Cardio with injured knee?
aimanj7
Posts: 7 Member
Hey guys,
As the title of this reveals, I have injured my knee! Nothing super serious, but my doctor suggests I stop running for at least 4 weeks so that my muscles heal.
Running on the elliptical/treadmill is very important during my workouts and it’s gonna be very hard to avoid that. Do you guys know of other ways to get in some cardio that doesn’t involve me using my knee? I’ve read that rowing machines help, but I don’t know of anything else.
Hope to hear your thoughts:)
As the title of this reveals, I have injured my knee! Nothing super serious, but my doctor suggests I stop running for at least 4 weeks so that my muscles heal.
Running on the elliptical/treadmill is very important during my workouts and it’s gonna be very hard to avoid that. Do you guys know of other ways to get in some cardio that doesn’t involve me using my knee? I’ve read that rowing machines help, but I don’t know of anything else.
Hope to hear your thoughts:)
0
Replies
-
Swimming?2
-
did you dr suggest biking?2
-
Depending on the knee injury, cycling could be great for you. Any place where cyclists gather, you'll find a lot of people who used to be runners until an injury sidelined them.3
-
If you choose cycling, make sure you have a proper bike-fit or you will experience pain from a bad setup. Check in with a bike club or better yet a bike shop before you start cycling. If doing an indoor spin class, again proper seat height is important. Your spin trainer should be able to advise on proper height for the seat. Don't just sit on any bike or spin bike. Good luck1
-
I’ve had 3 knee surgeries. So I feel your pain. Many of the recommendations above are great. Biking and swimming are fantastic low/no impact exercises.
I’d suggest adding some weight training to your workout regiment. Nothing protects the knee like strong muscles supporting the joint. In addition, you can burn more calaries by lifting than doing cardio.
I’d also suggest meeting with a personal trainer. Explain your goals and challenges. A good PT will be able to design a program for you. Most importantly, you will learn proper technique. That will prevent additional injury.
Good luck. Feel free to add me if you like.
Enjoy.1 -
Hey guys,
As the title of this reveals, I have injured my knee! Nothing super serious, but my doctor suggests I stop running for at least 4 weeks so that my muscles heal.
Running on the elliptical/treadmill is very important during my workouts and it’s gonna be very hard to avoid that. Do you guys know of other ways to get in some cardio that doesn’t involve me using my knee? I’ve read that rowing machines help, but I don’t know of anything else.
Hope to hear your thoughts:)
What is your injury specifically because this sounds a peculiar combination?
" I have injured my knee! Nothing super serious, but my doctor suggests I stop running for at least 4 weeks so that my muscles heal
I've injured bone, ligaments x3, meniscus x2 and bursitis but never a muscle in my knee.....
Rowing machines and most swimming strokes either involve load on your knees or put stress on them. You can swim without legs though (use a float).
Arm bike springs to mind as non leg cardio but I've not seen one in a gym for years.1 -
Hey guys,
As the title of this reveals, I have injured my knee! Nothing super serious, but my doctor suggests I stop running for at least 4 weeks so that my muscles heal.
Running on the elliptical/treadmill is very important during my workouts and it’s gonna be very hard to avoid that. Do you guys know of other ways to get in some cardio that doesn’t involve me using my knee? I’ve read that rowing machines help, but I don’t know of anything else.
Hope to hear your thoughts:)
What is your injury specifically because this sounds a peculiar combination?
" I have injured my knee! Nothing super serious, but my doctor suggests I stop running for at least 4 weeks so that my muscles heal
I've injured bone, ligaments x3, meniscus x2 and bursitis but never a muscle in my knee.....
Rowing machines and most swimming strokes either involve load on your knees or put stress on them. You can swim without legs though (use a float).
Arm bike springs to mind as non leg cardio but I've not seen one in a gym for years.
^ thanks for the reply! Wow, that’s a lot list of injuries
So I injured my IT belt and I’ve been using the RICE method. It’s been challenging though because it’s hard to ice my knee and keep it elevated when I’m at work/school. I asked my trainer about it and be recommended I use the bike or rowing machine.
I weight train regularly (x4 week) arms, back and glutes but I’ve had to take it easy the past few days because of my knee. I’m really tempted to go back into routine as soon as I feel a little better -BUT I don’t want to make things worse.0 -
Ah - the IT band. One of the few things that I haven't seriously injured!
It's not really a knee injury as such (or a muscle) but that's where the inflammation and pain commonly occurs.
Far more common in runners than cyclists, often an overuse injury in runners but more likely to occur from a bike fit problem in cycling. I wouldn't recommend switching to cycling when you already have problems as that may simply aggravate it in the same way as running would. Maybe after you have healed...
You do know the R in RICE means rest? That doesn't meaning switching to a different exercise while it's still inflamed.
Dr Google ("IT Band Syndrome") will allow you to find stretches and rehab exercises that may help with your recovery.0 -
Ah - the IT band. One of the few things that I haven't seriously injured!
It's not really a knee injury as such (or a muscle) but that's where the inflammation and pain commonly occurs.
Far more common in runners than cyclists, often an overuse injury in runners but more likely to occur from a bike fit problem in cycling. I wouldn't recommend switching to cycling when you already have problems as that may simply aggravate it in the same way as running would. Maybe after you have healed...
You do know the R in RICE means rest? That doesn't meaning switching to a different exercise while it's still inflamed.
Dr Google ("IT Band Syndrome") will allow you to find stretches and rehab exercises that may help with your recovery.
Lol, yes I am fully aware of the REST part. For the past 2 days I’ve been using RICE for 3-4 hours after coming home from work so it’s getting better.
I really don’t want to stop working out because of it
but you’re right, how else am I supposed to heal. I went to the gym last night and worked upper body for like 30 mins and then was done (not the most satisfying workout because I didn’t sweat from cardio).
Thanks for the suggestions, very much appreciated
2 -
The only "cardio" device that will NOT involve your knees (or lower body) to a significant degree is a SkiErg.
If you've never heard of or seen one, you can read about it here:
http://www.concept2.com/skierg
It's made by Concept2 (the company that's famous for the rowers it makes) and is designed to simulate the movements and work the muscles used in cross country skiing. They are sometimes used in Crossfit games.
You can find one to use located near you here:
http://www.concept2.com/skierg/finder
If you don't give up, you will sweat profusely and burn as much if not more doing any other form of cardio.
I was going to buy one to add to my collection of home gear until I tried one and found out how difficult it was.
It's brutal. Rowing and biking are much easier.
0 -
I would suggest swimming or biking0
-
Last time I hurt my leg, I started rowing. Swimming is also a good option as it removes a lot of the pressure gravity normally places on joints.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions