Budget healthy...can it be done?

2»

Replies

  • Thr33N1N3
    Thr33N1N3 Posts: 39 Member
    OMAD
  • J72FIT
    J72FIT Posts: 6,009 Member
    IMO, eating healthy becomes budget friendly once you stop falling for the over-hyped and over-priced "health" foods...
  • toxikon
    toxikon Posts: 2,383 Member
    Thr33N1N3 wrote: »
    OMAD

    How does eating all your calories in one meal make it cheaper? :|
  • BeeColvin
    BeeColvin Posts: 1 Member
    Eating healthy, tasty and cheap can be done, easy, if you're willing to work with some parameters.

    You have to look at your diet as a whole, and in connection with need. When you stop working out, you may experience that you need fewer calories, aka less food. But one car instead of two means that you'll be walking more, so maybe you can't cut down on food. Cars and gyms cost money, walking is free. It could take more time to get things done, but maybe it doesn't make a negative impact, maybe it just "steals" time from watching excessive TV.

    You have to consider value, not just cost. Ramen noodles and bananas offer a different range of nutrients. A human needs a wide range of nutrients every day, and an appropriate amount of calories. A variety of foods will provide you with what you need. The main challenge in our world, is to not eat too much. We are often tempted to eat or buy too much, and that's why you have to think about what you get for your money, not just what it costs in dollars.

    Cooking from scratch using simple single food ingredients can be easy and cheap, but you have to know how to cook, how to plan and not be fussy. You have to balance your meals so they are appealing and nutritious. Low carb and high protein will be expensive, not just boring. You can't rely on vegetables for calories. Use oil, grains, potatoes to get enough calories, add fruit and vegetables for vitamins, and meat and fish for variety and supplementing protein. Buy cheap foods often and in larger amounts, buy more expensive items more occasionally and in smaller amounts. This has the unexpected but wonderful side effect that you'll appreciate all food more.

    Other tips, or expanding on this, is to plan meals you want to eat, and eat up everything. Buy just what you can store, store it properly, and eat it before it spoils. Mostly stick to what you know you like, but try new things occasionally too. Buy store brand and in season. Buy the cheapest alternative of otherwise equal items. Don't pay extra for things you don't need. Rotate and alternate. Learn to cook and free yourself from recipes. Peruse sales and stock up, but don't be fooled, look at price per pound and compare with other package sizes and brands.

    Most of this is about attitude. If you don't want to change the way you're eating, you can just tell yourself that "healthy eating is boring, difficult and expensive".

    Thank you for posting this! I found it both informative and inspiring! My goal this year is to eat more whole/natural foods in smaller portions. This is MY year to achieve!
  • Thr33N1N3
    Thr33N1N3 Posts: 39 Member
    toxikon wrote: »
    Thr33N1N3 wrote: »
    OMAD

    How does eating all your calories in one meal make it cheaper? :|

    Easier to plan. You can stick to your budget easier and have less waste. You can't eat the same bulk you do in 3 meals, so you will be forced to eat less.
  • jennybearlv
    jennybearlv Posts: 1,519 Member
    $10.99 for two is fine dining at my house. Cook from scratch whenever possible. Staples like dry beans, grains, and flour, seasonal produce, and on-sale whole cuts of meat are cheap. Stop filling the freezer with convenience foods and make room for frozen veggies and that meat you bought on sale. If you are busy with work crockpots and bread machines are good time savers.
  • toxikon
    toxikon Posts: 2,383 Member
    Thr33N1N3 wrote: »
    toxikon wrote: »
    Thr33N1N3 wrote: »
    OMAD

    How does eating all your calories in one meal make it cheaper? :|

    Easier to plan. You can stick to your budget easier and have less waste. You can't eat the same bulk you do in 3 meals, so you will be forced to eat less.

    I found OMAD more expensive because I'd be so ravenous by the time I was leaving work that I'd often just grab fast food or quick ready-to-eat meals instead of cooking. But of course, it's different for everyone. I just don't see the inherent savings in different meal timing/frequency choices.
  • Thr33N1N3
    Thr33N1N3 Posts: 39 Member
    edited January 2018
    toxikon wrote: »
    Thr33N1N3 wrote: »
    toxikon wrote: »
    Thr33N1N3 wrote: »
    OMAD

    How does eating all your calories in one meal make it cheaper? :|

    Easier to plan. You can stick to your budget easier and have less waste. You can't eat the same bulk you do in 3 meals, so you will be forced to eat less.

    I found OMAD more expensive because I'd be so ravenous by the time I was leaving work that I'd often just grab fast food or quick ready-to-eat meals instead of cooking. But of course, it's different for everyone. I just don't see the inherent savings in different meal timing/frequency choices.

    Sorry for hijacking thread..
    I should of mentioned eating healthier options and grocery shopping for meals you prepare at home. I'm not sure why you got extremely hungry, because hearsay is most people do not get hungry fasting. I don't either.
    I got a pork loin for $8 at the store and a $1 bag of broccoli yesterday. Fed me and my girlfriend, and still have at least another 2 meals on the pork.
  • Laruto
    Laruto Posts: 23 Member
    We live in a world where raman noodles cost less than 4 bananas. A place where fast food establishments offer 2 can dine for 10.99. Over a year ago I joined weight watchers and lost 50 pounds using the program. I kept it off. Due to budget constraints I had to leave the program. I have not gained any weight since but have not continued to lose either. My diet has had increased carbs, fats and sugars and decreased vitamins and proteins.

    So here is a little more info...I work as an LPN and make reasonable money. That is when I work full time hours. I have been a casual for many years and often have to work a different position for a lot less money just to make ends meet. My husband left his high paying specialty trades job to go back to school 6 months ago. We have all the usual bills, rent insurance, car payments ect. Money has been tight and we have had to stick to a specific budget just to get by. We made a lot of lifestyle changes such as only using one vehicle. In this time I also cut out my gym pass. Our food budget went from being virtually non existent to extremely tight. I now have a full time nursing line but we have to stick to a similar budget to pay back the debt we have had the last few months.

    I am going to try to not eat fast food, reduce my carbs and increase the amount of vegetables and proteins we eat. All on a budget of 300 dollars a month (canadian). I am open to suggestions from anyone on ways to save. My biggest one right now. Buy unprocessed beans...takes a long time but high in protein. I am making chilli tomorrow. Another is to use frozen vegetables instead of raw.
    Please brainstorm with each other on recipies and ways to save.

    I will post further as I learn.

    Veggie curry can be made relatively inexpensively in large batches and so many diff types of curries. Mostly veg meals would help cut some costs. Is growing anything at home an option? Youtube has vids on growing celery etc from the butt ends. Congrats on getting a full time line! That will come in handy for sick and vacay days to avoid further budget strain.
  • srpotts1212
    srpotts1212 Posts: 12 Member
    Laruto wrote: »
    We live in a world where raman noodles cost less than 4 bananas. A place where fast food establishments offer 2 can dine for 10.99. Over a year ago I joined weight watchers and lost 50 pounds using the program. I kept it off. Due to budget constraints I had to leave the program. I have not gained any weight since but have not continued to lose either. My diet has had increased carbs, fats and sugars and decreased vitamins and proteins.

    So here is a little more info...I work as an LPN and make reasonable money. That is when I work full time hours. I have been a casual for many years and often have to work a different position for a lot less money just to make ends meet. My husband left his high paying specialty trades job to go back to school 6 months ago. We have all the usual bills, rent insurance, car payments ect. Money has been tight and we have had to stick to a specific budget just to get by. We made a lot of lifestyle changes such as only using one vehicle. In this time I also cut out my gym pass. Our food budget went from being virtually non existent to extremely tight. I now have a full time nursing line but we have to stick to a similar budget to pay back the debt we have had the last few months.

    I am going to try to not eat fast food, reduce my carbs and increase the amount of vegetables and proteins we eat. All on a budget of 300 dollars a month (canadian). I am open to suggestions from anyone on ways to save. My biggest one right now. Buy unprocessed beans...takes a long time but high in protein. I am making chilli tomorrow. Another is to use frozen vegetables instead of raw.
    Please brainstorm with each other on recipies and ways to save.

    I will post further as I learn.

    Veggie curry can be made relatively inexpensively in large batches and so many diff types of curries. Mostly veg meals would help cut some costs. Is growing anything at home an option? Youtube has vids on growing celery etc from the butt ends. Congrats on getting a full time line! That will come in handy for sick and vacay days to avoid further budget strain.

    In the summer I grow celery, green onions and tomatoes but I have a small balcony so that is all. I love home grown veggies wish I could all year
  • srpotts1212
    srpotts1212 Posts: 12 Member
    mackau wrote: »
    Sure.

    Beef Mince. Chicken. Fish. Beans. Rice. Eggs. Onion. Potato. Tomato. Fill out meals with cheap frozen vegetables (Broccoli, Cauliflower, Carrot, Peas, Corn). "Snacks" become apples, pears, oranges etc (cheap fruit).

    One point when on a "budget" healthy diet would be worry less about carb/protein/fat macros, and worry more about getting specific with your portions & weights, because the majority of a budget meal will be Beans, Potato or Rice. If those 3 are not the basis for most of the meals (and you aren't cheating) then you're unlikely to get enough calories, or you're going to be having large quantities of meat (which is expensive).

    Also get used to using different spices & herbs. It can be easier to take the same ingredients every day when day 1 is an Italian herb flavour, day 2 is an coriander & cumin Indian curry flavour, day 3 is a lemon pepper salt flavour, day 4 is a tex-mex cayenne pepper flavour, day 5 is a French onion & garlic parsley flavour and day 6 Asian five spice and day 7 is a middle eastern thyme/sumac/sesame mix.

    A final point would be what sort of online shopping places do you have around? Many people have the biggest problems with "budgeting" because they just go around a shop buying anything that catches the eye and not sticking to a list. If you have a shop that is online and is reputable you are completely taking yourself out of the environment that Grocery stores have spent millions upon millions researching the best ways to get people to buy stuff.

    Hence why the cooked chickens are in the far left corner, the frozen food is in the top right corner and the milk & bread at the back of the store and to get straight to them you're probably going to be walking past a chocolate aisle.

    It's much easier to stick to a list when you're just typing only the items you want into a search bar.

    We don't have much for online shopping, however living in a small community we drive to all 3 grocery places to find the best prices.
  • srpotts1212
    srpotts1212 Posts: 12 Member
    J72FIT wrote: »
    IMO, eating healthy becomes budget friendly once you stop falling for the over-hyped and over-priced "health" foods...

    I don't eat health foods. I like fruits and vegetables and meats. A few carbs and potatoes but I don't eat anything fancy.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    I don't know about you, but bananas don't grow anywhere close to where I live (midwest US). I think they're very affordable considering how far they have to travel and how many people have to work to get them to me.

    I generally have no problem eating affordably and hitting my nutritional/calorie goals when I focus my diet on staple foods and foods that are in season.
This discussion has been closed.