Man advice needed!

jmgj27
jmgj27 Posts: 531 Member
edited September 30 in Chit-Chat
Hi guys

I have recently realised that I'm in love with a very good friend of mine. He's in a relationship and, although there is definitely a sexual attraction between us, he's been with his girl for over ten years and I would never break that up. To make matters worse we also work together. Sigh. We've known each other for 5 years and during that entire time he has been kind, loyal, funny and my protector in every workplace situation where I needed one. Couldn't have asked for a better friend basically.

I have to move on for my own sanity as much as anything else. I suspect he has feelings for me that stretch beyond the simple attraction, so I think that me moving on would be the best for both of us. The problem I have is that, because I see him every day, it's very difficult for me to put him out of my mind. I have been thinking (a lot) about this and I thought perhaps a good move would be to be completely honest with him (ok - almost completely honest - without using the word 'love'!) and just explain that because I have developed feelings for him, I think it best if we steer clear of each other for a while and give each other some breathing space.

What do you think? I desperately don't want to cut him out of my life but I simply can't see any other option. Damn it! Any and all advice gratefully received!

Replies

  • Carl01
    Carl01 Posts: 9,307 Member
    Tell him how you feel and be honest about not wanting to complicate his life while still being open to him wanting to be a part of yours.
    He may not be happy where he is right now and ready to move on from it,you never know.
    Once it is in the open and talked about between the two of you it will be easier for you to let those feelings go if that is what is meant to be.
  • IronSmasher
    IronSmasher Posts: 3,908 Member
    He may well know how you feel, and have feelings for you too, but he's trying to balance your friendship and his other relationship without hurting anyone. He might see you bringing it out in the open as an ultimatum, he might feel trapped and having to choose between you and her, risking losing your friendship either way
  • skinnywithin
    skinnywithin Posts: 1,392 Member
    Tell him how you feel and be honest about not wanting to complicate his life while still being open to him wanting to be a part of yours.
    He may not be happy where he is right now and ready to move on from it,you never know.
    Once it is in the open and talked about between the two of you it will be easier for you to let those feelings go if that is what is meant to be.



    well put Carl !!!!!! Girl I know I will hear **** over this but YOU MUST follow your heart, Ya see life is too short not to tell people how you truly feel and if he is loyal to his girlfriend and is a loyal friend to you he will be flattered by the interest but at the same time let you know that he is madly in love with his girlfriend and that the two of you can only be friends. THEN>>>>>>>YOU have to honor his integrity and move on.
  • IronSmasher
    IronSmasher Posts: 3,908 Member
    I guess it is a way to move on, if you're not happy
  • junipuni
    junipuni Posts: 264 Member
    Tell him how you feel and be honest about not wanting to complicate his life while still being open to him wanting to be a part of yours.
    He may not be happy where he is right now and ready to move on from it,you never know.
    Once it is in the open and talked about between the two of you it will be easier for you to let those feelings go if that is what is meant to be.
    I agree with this.
  • Trixtabella
    Trixtabella Posts: 471 Member
    Are you sure he actually likes you in this way? I agree it may be good to tell him how you are feeling but if he has been with his girlfriend for so long surley he must love her.

    I would tred very carefully, sometimes you can have good chemistry with someone but that doesn't mean they have intimate feelings for you anything beyond the friendship you already have.

    Also you need to be careful as you have said he is in a relationship and it is not only hyour feelings that could get hurt if it all came out in the open.
  • lannheue23
    lannheue23 Posts: 24 Member
    You also have to think that if you come out and tell the truth..is it going to be awkward between yall if he stays with his gurlfriend? Are you going to be able to just be friends with him after you tell him everything??
  • boomboom011
    boomboom011 Posts: 1,459
    i say keep your feelings to yourself until he is single. you dont want to be the reason he breaks up with her. besides, if you and the girlfriend get a long and you tell him how you feel and she finds out OH HECK NAW! Not good.

    Do NOT make your decisions based on your emotions. You will regret it. IMHO
  • This content has been removed.
  • jmgj27
    jmgj27 Posts: 531 Member
    You also have to think that if you come out and tell the truth..is it going to be awkward between yall if he stays with his gurlfriend? Are you going to be able to just be friends with him after you tell him everything??

    Yeah - quite possibly not. Whilst that makes me very sad, I think me having this relationship with him is preventing me moving on. I'm 99% sure that he has feelings for me because he's come out and said it on more than one occasion. I've always brushed it off but I think it's making me unhappy. Selfish though it may be, I think to tell him what I'm feeling would be more honest than simply disappearing off his radar, which will only serve to make both of us unhappy. At least if I tell him why I need not to be around him, I'll be the only one who suffers.

    Thanks to everybody for your good advice and thanks for not being judgy!
  • Kalrez
    Kalrez Posts: 655 Member
    You see this guy all the time. He's in a stable relationship with someone he's been with for a decade. Don't tell him your feelings. You said you don't want to break them up, so what's the point of even telling him how you feel. At best, you'll make him uncomfortable and potentially strain your friendship. At worst, he'll get upset with you for trying to come between him and his girlfriend.

    Switch jobs. Go on vacation. Get a new hobby. Find some different friends to hang out with. Something, anything to get your mind off this guy. I'm not saying that you never, ever see him again. But you need to seriously distance yourself from this guy before you do something stupid. Don't talk to him for a few months. Let your emotions cool off.

    Even if you don't think that telling him how you feel will ruin anything, don't do it. Just don't. Terrible idea. If he liked you "like that" then he wouldn't be with his girlfriend. It's not like he lacks free will to date whom he pleases.

    Don't be that friend. Don't be that girl.

    I wouldn't even tell him why you stop talking to him for a while. Just ... make yourself busy. "Sorry dude, can't chit chat, tons of work to do." "Oh, can't hang out after work, gotta hit the gym"
  • sunkisses
    sunkisses Posts: 2,365 Member
    Yeah, you need to cut that off. Whether you decide to say something or not is up to your own discretion. I have a personal rule about dealing with men who haven't taken some time between relationships to get themselves together, so I wouldn't say anything up front about it. I'd play the "I've been so busy" role with him for a while. Anyway, good luck to you. Your head is in the right place, for sure.
  • reactor25
    reactor25 Posts: 146 Member
    Only you can decide what's the right move for you but I would not tell him. If he has real feelings for you he should get out of the relationship he is in first and then address his feelings for you. He probably knows you're into him. Do you just want to tell him how you feel? Do you accept responsibility for the possibility of him leaving his girlfriend to be with you? (Not the end of the world--it just means he comes with baggage.) If you tell him then you can't just act like friends again. Friends love each other but don't want romantic relationships. You can't be just friends with this guy. I think it would be best to just start going out with other friends and date more.
    With that being said, if you feel in the bottom of your heart you have to declare you love him, I mean, who I am to stop you? I actually love a declaration of love. Like in the movie "Love Actually" and the guy shows up at Kiera Knightley door declaring his love for his best friends girl...hopeless and very romantic and sweet!!!!! (Yeah, I watch that movie every year during the holidays.)
    Anyway, I don't recommend it in general but maybe your situation is special.
    One question: If you think he might have feelings for you why has he not said anything or acted on them--girlfriend or not? Is he scared and the girlfriend is just a safety net?
  • nerdyandilikeit
    nerdyandilikeit Posts: 2,185 Member
    Worked out ok for Jim and Pam.

    :)
  • veganbaum
    veganbaum Posts: 1,865 Member
    You also have to think that if you come out and tell the truth..is it going to be awkward between yall if he stays with his gurlfriend? Are you going to be able to just be friends with him after you tell him everything??

    Yeah - quite possibly not. Whilst that makes me very sad, I think me having this relationship with him is preventing me moving on. I'm 99% sure that he has feelings for me because he's come out and said it on more than one occasion. I've always brushed it off but I think it's making me unhappy. Selfish though it may be, I think to tell him what I'm feeling would be more honest than simply disappearing off his radar, which will only serve to make both of us unhappy. At least if I tell him why I need not to be around him, I'll be the only one who suffers.

    Thanks to everybody for your good advice and thanks for not being judgy!

    What has he said? I think you're right - if he's said things, it probably is making you unhappy because you have feelings and know that he does, too, but neither of you are acting upon them. If he has real feelings for you, seems like he would have left his current girlfriend. If he still loves her, but has feelings for you, too - well, sorry buddy, but most people don't go for an open relationship - so that's putting you in a crappy position while he still gets to have his girlfriend and you're not moving on. I think you just need to try and spend less time with him, as others have suggested.
  • _beachgirl_
    _beachgirl_ Posts: 3,865 Member
    I don't think telling him that you have developed feelings for him is moving on. It's a backhanded way to let him know that you are interested.

    If you truly want to move on, do it. Do whatever you need to do for you to move on, if that's avoiding him do it, getting transferred to another department or finding a new job, just do it!
  • pinkgigi
    pinkgigi Posts: 693 Member
    Take it from someone who has a lot of crushes, it would be a disaster for you to tell him. It would hurt you and it has a very high risk of actually wrecking the friendship you have.

    I am a little annoyed at him, he gets to flirt and toy with you knowing it cannot go anywhere when he has a girlfriend, I'm sorry but I think he is being manipulative.

    I have a theory about crushing on people who are attainable, I think we do it when we are not fulfilling ourselves as we should. Go out and fill your life with positive wonderful experiences, and these hopeless cases will get dialled down to more manageable proportions. Well that's what I'm doing, with varying levels of success!

    GG
  • koosdel
    koosdel Posts: 3,317 Member
    "The truth shall set you free" and "There is a time and place for everything"
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,988 Member
    Hi guys

    I have recently realised that I'm in love with a very good friend of mine. He's in a relationship and, although there is definitely a sexual attraction between us, he's been with his girl for over ten years and I would never break that up. To make matters worse we also work together. Sigh. We've known each other for 5 years and during that entire time he has been kind, loyal, funny and my protector in every workplace situation where I needed one. Couldn't have asked for a better friend basically.

    I have to move on for my own sanity as much as anything else. I suspect he has feelings for me that stretch beyond the simple attraction, so I think that me moving on would be the best for both of us. The problem I have is that, because I see him every day, it's very difficult for me to put him out of my mind. I have been thinking (a lot) about this and I thought perhaps a good move would be to be completely honest with him (ok - almost completely honest - without using the word 'love'!) and just explain that because I have developed feelings for him, I think it best if we steer clear of each other for a while and give each other some breathing space.

    What do you think? I desperately don't want to cut him out of my life but I simply can't see any other option. Damn it! Any and all advice gratefully received!
    Holding back how you feel does nothing. Be up front. Though someone is with someone for 10 years, they may not have the ideal partnership. Why do you think the divorce rate is so high? Many stick around to just stick around. Worse that happens is that you stay friends and if you know that there's no interest it's also easier for you to move on.
  • Lisamariemlt
    Lisamariemlt Posts: 101 Member
    sorry here's the mom in me coming out

    I'd tell my daughter...................................respect, love, and loyalty

    be respectful to yourself----he's in a relationship and he's taken---find someone else
    love---love is not blind---he knows you are liking him, and as far as I am concerned it's his game-he's taken, he's letting you know and you say more than once he has--he's leading you on---if he's feeling anything and he's sharing it then he's not being loyal to the one he's with---and here's where the loyalty comes in
    if he's playing a game now and he's in a relationship
    he's gonna do it again if he gets bored
    or if he feels anyone else is into him

    sorry but the mom in me says move on, leave him behind and get over him
    if you have to write about it here and ask questions then you already know the answers you just need support
    you have to do what is right by you
    but
    like I said that's the mom in me
    and my daughter is much much younger than you and we have these talks already
    guess you could say I am trying to prepare her
    I don't want to see a claud like this hurt her ever
    hugs
  • Out of some personal experience here, I would probably say - Some feelings are better left unsaid. I strongly believe that if a guy wants to be with you, he will make it happen, no matter what. If he has the same strong feelings for you, I am sure that he would come way out of his comfort zone and let you know very openly and make it a serious conversation.

    Since he's your best buddy, it only makes things verry complicated for you. Trust me, I know how it feels. Good luck.

    P.S - Just know one thing, if it has to happen, it will, else there is definitely some else waiting to happen and who knows, its might just be better than the best.
  • AndrewTub
    AndrewTub Posts: 86 Member
    Don't say anything ! ! You could end up losing a good friend. Best thing to do would just be a good friend to him, maybe ask about how his gf is and how they are getting on. If he sounds really positive about them then you'll have to get over him. If he starts saying that it isn't going too well then just be there for him and things might just fall into place.
  • ziggy67
    ziggy67 Posts: 351
    I sympathise with you here as I have been there too....(many years ago mind!). I am no agony aunt but I only found peace of mind when I left my job and moved on. This is where you'll find out the true extent of this guys feelings for you because if he really cares about you (in the same way as you care about him) he will be so upset that you are leaving and will try and persuade you to stay. If he is indifferent you will know he only cared because you were a comaptible workmate that was there in his face every day.
    I too would never want to damage a relationship between two people so you have answered your own question I think.
    That reminds me.....Here's to all the guys I loved before...wherever you are!!! :ohwell:
  • ljd0693
    ljd0693 Posts: 289 Member
    If he's been with the same girl for over 10 years and hasn't married her then that relationship has big problems anyway.
  • BuffTexan
    BuffTexan Posts: 270
    Wow, a lot of good replies both FOR and AGAINST telling him. Here's my .02, FWIW (45 yrs old, been around a bit):

    This guy has a gf of 10 yrs and is intentionally flirting with you?? You said you're 99% sure he likes you beyond a basic friendship, right? RED FLAG! How would YOU feel if you were his gf of 10 yrs? Which brings me to my 2nd point: a gf for 10 yrs?!? Does this guy have commitment issues? At what point is he going to ask her to marry him? Or, is he keeping all options open?

    There's a chemical reaction in our brains when we go through this kind of love/infatuation thing. Feelings of "he's the one" or "I can't live without him" to "we'll always be in love." Those feelings are short-lived, trust me. Do you want to be his gf of 3 yrs only to find out he: #1 doesn't intend on marrying you and #2 is flirting with his co-workers?

    There are a lot of good men out there, but none are perfect. The one you're after is taken, he knows it and so do you.
  • katherines2230
    katherines2230 Posts: 276 Member
    I was in a very similar situation recently, except I was the one in the relationship and somehow developed feelings for a long time friend if mine. Turns out we both shared the same feelings for each other but weren't able to cope until we had openly talked about our feelings.
This discussion has been closed.