Not sure if anyone will ever notice...

Hi Tracy. For me, it took a loss of about 30 lbs before I got the first comment on my losing weight, so hang in there! Are you doing any strength training? Adding some muscle tone will give you a more fit look once you shed the extra pounds. Keep at it - you're heading in the right direction!

I don't like it when people say, "Oh, you've lost weight!" It makes me feel self-conscious. Since I don't like it, I don't do it to others. Most of my friends don't talk about others' weight either for fear of making someone uncomfortable. Maybe those in your life are the same way. It could be that they notice but don't want to make you feel self-conscious.

Are you wearing clothes that fit? Nothing clingy or skintight, just well-fitted? If you're wearing balloony peasant tops or roomy sweaters, it might be hard for people to see you. My weight fluctuates (independently of anything I'm doing, it seems), so sometimes I put on something only to realize it's pretty loose. Since I don't have a full-length mirror at home, sometimes I don't figure it out until I catch my full reflection sometime during the day. Is it possible that you might also be wearing bigger clothes than you realize?

I'm envious of your 5'7''! I'm 5'3'' on a good day. Almost everything has to be hemmed; even my leggings and gym pants.

It sounds as if you are being too hard on yourself. True it is nice if someone notices you are looking better, (healthier) but you're not doing it for anyone other than yourself. I wonder where you are on your bmi range. I know there is a great variance in what is considered a good weight. I would love your extra 4 inches in height. I'd not expect to ever be a size 12 (UK), even at 5.3 but I'm on the older end of things.

You cam make it different this time using mfp, once you have achieved your right chosen weight, you will be able to use the system to maintain, you will learn what you need to do to keep within 7 lbs or, which ever number you permit yourself to be, of your chosen weight, keeping yourself in line. Please concentrate on nutrition rather than just being thin. Thin very often is not that healthy as one may think because nutrition is lacking. Achieving the best, healthiest you is in my view where you need to be.

All the very best You can and will be able to do it this time.

I’m 5’8” and only a couple of people noticed when I lost 30 lbs. I’m a yo-yo dieter so I’m always up and down. So I pretty much look the same to people. It sounds like you may be the same.

Everyone noticed when I lost 60 lbs. When I tell people how much I’ve lost they don’t believe me. They think it was 20-30 lbs. I show them my before picture and they are shocked I’ve changed so much.

I totally understand the feeling of not being good enough. I can wear a 8-10 pant and 12 dress and I should be thrilled after starting at 18 pant and 14W dress (which is like a 20). I think my after picture looks like some people’s before picture. So that can be disappointing. I will never be skinny.

I think I can maintain where I am now (still want to lose 5 lbs), so that’s what’s important to me. I can walk 5 miles and don’t feel like I’m going to die. My feet no longer hurt. I also don’t snore anymore. I can go clothes shopping and actually find things that look good on me. I went yesterday and tried on size 8 pants just to see is they would fit. I bought a few, some were still snug in the waist. Sales clerks say “can I help you”. They were showing me new arrivals. That never happened when I was heavier.

Just keep reminding yourself where you started. Look at your before picture. Where you are is a lot better. No one is perfect. You just need to be the best version of you and still have a happy life. Trying to be perfect and skinny will not give you a happy life.

BTW...I’m saying all this to myself too.

Sometimes people don't comment. I notice people who have lost weight, but usually don't say anything because I know some people don't want anything said about it. If they were to talk about it and tell me "hey I have been dieting and lost ___" I would say wow awesome I can tell congratulations. Some people just won't say anything because they know weight is a sensitive topic and don't want to offend one way or another.