Carbs carbs carbs!

nllee456
Posts: 9 Member
Evening,
I’ve had a plan written out for me and my carb intake is at 286g a day for maintaining weight and gaining some womanly muscle. I’m struggling to get them all in?!
Am I doing something wrong??!!
I’ve had a plan written out for me and my carb intake is at 286g a day for maintaining weight and gaining some womanly muscle. I’m struggling to get them all in?!
Am I doing something wrong??!!
0
Replies
-
If your goal is 286 grams a day and you're not meeting it, the only thing you're doing "wrong" is eating more protein and fat. Have you tried looking at your diary, to identify where you're going over your personal goals for protein and fat and eating less of those things?
Or maybe having someone else write out a plan isn't the best thing for you. Do you *want* 286 grams of carbohydrates a day? You can maintain weight or gain muscle while eating more protein and fat.4 -
What's your calorie goal? Is it hard to hit your calorie goal, or does your macro split feel unbalanced? What are you eating? What do you like to eat?1
-
I can get close to my calorie goal. But seem to have a lot of carbs left over.
I’ve been eating porridge, egg in wrap for lunch. nuts, rice cake with peanut butter on or fruit for snacks. Dinner is meat, seeet potato mash and veg or rice instead of mash....0 -
Calorie goal is just over 1600**0
-
I can get close to my calorie goal. But seem to have a lot of carbs left over.
I’ve been eating porridge, egg in wrap for lunch. nuts, rice cake with peanut butter on or fruit for snacks. Dinner is meat, seeet potato mash and veg or rice instead of mash....
Assuming everything is calculated and logged correctly, if you're close on your calories but short on carbohydrates it is because you're going over your needs for protein or fat (or both). So if you identify where you are going over, you can eat less of the foods that are rich in those macronutrients and more of the foods that are higher in carbohydrates. Your diary is closed, so we can't see what you're eating to be more specific than that.
0 -
I can get close to my calorie goal. But seem to have a lot of carbs left over.Calorie goal is just over 1600**
You won't likely gain on 1600 calories.
I really hope you didn't pay for that plan.3 -
kommodevaran wrote: »I can get close to my calorie goal. But seem to have a lot of carbs left over.Calorie goal is just over 1600**
You won't likely gain on 1600 calories.
I really hope you didn't pay for that plan.
OP, @kommodevaran is right. Something is off with this plan. I'm not sure who you paid for it, but you might want to try a more sustainable (and probably more pleasant) set of macro goals. 28% total for fat and protein combined . . . why?1 -
I can get close to my calorie goal. But seem to have a lot of carbs left over.
I’ve been eating porridge, egg in wrap for lunch. nuts, rice cake with peanut butter on or fruit for snacks. Dinner is meat, seeet potato mash and veg or rice instead of mash....
How close to your calorie goal? How many carbs left over? Are you over on fats and protein?
Your macros make up your calories...4 calories per gram of carbohydrate, 4 calories per gram of protein, 9 calories per gram of fat. If you're coming close to your calories, that would suggest you're going over...possibly significantly over on protein and fat and/or you are using erroneous entries from the database.
All that said, I've never understood all the hand wringing people do over their macros...0 -
Are you sure it's not 186 grams of carbs? That's 46% of a 1600 calorie diet, and very normal and balanced.1
-
-
It’s all gone abit over my head if I’m honest. I need to get in the swing of things but can’t understand where I’m going so wrong with the fats and carbs.0
-
Pic attached...
Who put this plan together...18 grams of dietary fat is no bueno. Protein looks ok, but I don't know how much you weigh. You could drop the carbs...I don't see any reason to to 286 grams of carbs on a 1600 calorie diet.
Your macro breakdown is pretty wacky.
I mean 18 grams of fat is like hardly any fat...like you wouldn't be eating peanut butter, nuts, eggs, dairy, etc...all of that is primarily dietary fat. But like I said, 18 grams of dietary fat is ridiculously low if not bordering on unhealthy...10% of your diet in dietary fat is extremely low fat.2 -
-
Get a refund.3
-
kommodevaran wrote: »
I've seen some body builders do that ratio...it's a pretty miserable from what I've seen...basically butt loads of chicken and white fish, egg whites rice, pasta, potatoes, veg, etc...but no sauces or much use of oils so veggies are usually steamed, potatoes boiled, etc. Everything is pretty bland and boring.
The guys I know who do it are competitive bodybuilders...and in reality, they eat like robots...food brings little to no joy...it's just fuel.
Your average everyday gym goer trying to get a little fitness on and maintain a nice physique is going to have a pretty tough go of this...especially if they like their food to taste good.0 -
I weigh7 and a half stone so my plan was looking at toning the body really. Adding abit of muscle but maintain my weight.
Do I need to lower carbs and up fat?? I’ve eaten healthy today no junk atal and outdone my fat by mid afternoon0 -
I weigh7 and a half stone so my plan was looking at toning the body really. Adding abit of muscle but maintain my weight.
Do I need to lower carbs and up fat?? I’ve eaten healthy today no junk atal and outdone my fat by mid afternoon
You don't have to eat junk food to get dietary fat...you mentioned eggs, nuts, peanut butter...all of that is largely dietary fat...healthy fat, but fat none the less. 1 lousy tablespoon of peanut butter has 8 grams of dietary fat...so you're like halfway there with just a tiny little dollop of peanut butter.
18 grams of fat is basically nothing...you are going to have a very flavorless and boring diet with 18 grams of fat. There is not magical ratio of macros for "toning"...0 -
Well that explains how I managed to be over by midday! I can’t live like that haha.
0 -
I’ve got the figure there with 21% body fat so it is all about toning for me. The protein I will make sure I get the right amount in daily but I am seriously struggling to get the carbs in and then not go over on the fat.
I suppose we all start learning from somewhere I just hope I can get on track soon and work out a way I can fit everything in...0 -
for fat - .4-.6 per lb of goal lean muscle mass; protein - 8.-1.2g per goal lean muscle and the let carbs fill in where they fall0
-
deannalfisher wrote: »for fat - .4-.6 per lb of goal lean muscle mass; protein - 8.-1.2g per goal lean muscle and the let carbs fill in where they fall
Yup...0 -
kommodevaran wrote: »I can get close to my calorie goal. But seem to have a lot of carbs left over.Calorie goal is just over 1600**
You won't likely gain on 1600 calories.
I really hope you didn't pay for that plan.I weigh7 and a half stone so my plan was looking at toning the body really. Adding abit of muscle but maintain my weight.
Do I need to lower carbs and up fat?? I’ve eaten healthy today no junk atal and outdone my fat by mid afternoon0 -
II am seriously struggling to get the carbs in and then not go over on the fat.
I just hope I can get on track soon and work out a way I can fit everything in...1 -
5ft 20
-
You need to reconfigure those macros. OMGoodness.... check your protein needs first - VITAL! https://bodybuilding.com/fun/calpro.htm
There is a minimum health requirement for fat intake as well.
https://bodybuilding.com/fun/fats_calculator.htm
As for carbs....The 'Recommended Dietary Allowance' set by the Institute of Medicine (IoM) of the National Academies, a U.S. government body, is 130g/day although they state: " Dietary Reference Intakes (the DRI), Chapter 6, “Dietary Carbohydrates: Sugars and Starches”. The quotes below are taken directly from this chapter. My irreverent comments are in italics.
From the summary:“The primary role of carbohydrates (sugars and starches) is to provide energy to cells in the body, particularly the brain, which is the only carbohydrate-dependent organ in the body.”
The DRI later points out that the brain does not require ANY ingested (exogenous) carbohydrate – it can get ALL the carbohydrate it needs from conversion of ingested fat and protein (endogenous carbohydrate).
“Gluconeogenesis. Glucose can be synthesized via gluconeogenesis, a metabolic pathway that requires energy. Gluconeogenesis in the liver and renal cortex is inhibited via insulin following the consumption of carbohydrates and is activated during fasting, allowing the liver to continue to release glucose to maintain adequate blood glucose concentrations.”
Glucose is formed from protein and fat through gluconeogenesis.
“Clinical Effects of Inadequate Intake”
“The lower limit of dietary carbohydrate compatible with life apparently is zero."1 -
-
Evening,
I’ve had a plan written out for me and my carb intake is at 286g a day for maintaining weight and gaining some womanly muscle. I’m struggling to get them all in?!
Am I doing something wrong??!!
Increasing your carbs is easy, eat bread, dried fruits, fruit juice or soda, rice, candies, chocolate milk, rice cakes, fruits, veggies....You incorporate those into your diet and you will hit your carbs easily. I have to eat over 350 carbs, so you could imagine how difficult it can be when you don't know what carb source to take.0 -
That seems like a LOT of carbs for your height and weight. That being said, have you considered drinking them? Go to regular pop, fruit juices, chocolate milk. When my bf is bulking he drinks a lot of cals.0
-
I guess it's not that much if your protein is prob around 100g and you're small so fats are probably lower than mine. Disregard my comment on your macros haha0
-
I weigh7 and a half stone so my plan was looking at toning the body really. Adding abit of muscle but maintain my weight.
Do I need to lower carbs and up fat?? I’ve eaten healthy today no junk atal and outdone my fat by mid afternoon
You don't have to do anything... but I'd highly suggest you get your arms around what is and what isn't reasonably sustainable for you (this can take some time and trial/error, so I don't mean to make it sound like a quick and easy decision).
Most people here will suggest you increase fats and decrease carbs, but there are some very respected people who suggest cutting fat, not carbs. I won't say which is better as I think that requires a bit more conversation. But ultimately, your diet isn't very balanced and you're struggling to maintain the imbalance. I assume you can't ask the person who designed the plan what you should do?1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 398.2K Introduce Yourself
- 44.6K Getting Started
- 261K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.4K Food and Nutrition
- 47.7K Recipes
- 233K Fitness and Exercise
- 462 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.7K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.5K Motivation and Support
- 8.4K Challenges
- 1.4K Debate Club
- 96.5K Chit-Chat
- 2.6K Fun and Games
- 4.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 20 MyFitnessPal Academy
- 1.5K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 3.1K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions