Do you prefer cardio or strength training and why?
Fitwithsci
Posts: 69 Member
Alright MFP, I want to know who prefers cardio and who prefers strength training and why. I would also like to know what type of cardio/strength training you are doing. Cardio: steady state, HIIT, etc. running, biking, swimming, or something really cool that I don't even know about? Strength training: Body Building, power lifting, Olympic lifting, etc. I am sure there are many MFP'ers who enjoy both modes of training, if so feel free to talk about why you like both and what sorts of activities you enjoy doing.
1
Replies
-
I am a strength guy. I really enjoy lifting heavy weights and trying to hit new PR's. I usually start my day with some Olympic lifts, and then move into multi-joint exercises focusing on upper/lower body push-pull movements. I also occasionally do crossfit-style circuits following the same general format with lighter weights and I try to complete the workout as quickly as possible. I suppose this could be considered to be somewhere in the middle of the cardio/strength spectrum. I do cardio on my off days but the only thing that I have found that I really enjoy in terms of cardio is swimming and my gym does not have a pool so this requires a little extra effort.
If I seem like someone you might want to be friends with, feel free to add me.6 -
When in my groove I like to run and my gym is on the way so I can walk out my front door and do both. I have gotten hurt lifting so I just do an easy Nautilus set for fitness. I have really grown to love running.4
-
I like both, but the gym is a big time suck so I usually only lift 2x per week...if I happen to get in 3x per week it's gravy, but that usually means I have to give up a road ride. My program is flexible as my trainer gave me a template that lists different types of movements that can be accomplished with a variety of different lift variations. I also don't live in any one rep range. My programming is centered around all around fitness rather than any specific strength or aesthetic goals.
Cardio is mostly cycling and I like participating in a few endurance cycling events every year. I recently purchased an indoor rower for my house to break up the monotony of being on my indoor bike trainer in the winter and on super windy spring days. I'm also hoping that it will provide some benefit for my back issues I have due to sitting at a desk hunched over a computer all day. I also do a bit of top rope and enjoy hiking in the mountains.2 -
I do low intensity cardio, with 2 5 minute sprints a week on a bike, with low intensity yoga, but I am a strength guy.1
-
No preference. They are both valuable tools to achieve health and fitness goals. Enjoy them both.2
-
I like lifting the most.. mostly hypertrophy (bodybuilding), some strength work. Why, because of how it makes me look and feel. Cardio is ok (plyos, kickboxing, interval training), I also enjoy yoga1
-
I have become a cardio junky. Lately, it's been spinning. I get such a massive high from it!
Yoga, Zumba, swimming are my other faves and I occasionally lift because I feel like I should but it's not something that I'm super into,.2 -
Both for me. Strength and bodybuilding, being older I aim to maintain muscle and losing less of it during the aging process and also for aesthetics. I body build many months of the year and recomp the others or with a little cutting of fat.
Cardio is steady state, long distance running. I also cross train with elliptical and stationary bike. My running becomes a main focus (I have several events I participate in) end of winter/spring and my lifting is more to support my running, maintain muscle. I am usually cutting some in the summer and do both to support that.0 -
Personally I don't let preference play a role in my decision to do a given type of exercise. I wish to achieve a goal so I implement the techniques that will help me achieve that goal. If I want to build strength I choose weightlifting, if I want to build endurance I choose cardio. Personal preference enters at the point of deciding the type of cardio or the type of weightlifting I do.
I guess what I am saying is what I like is related to my goals and my goals aren't to exercise, exercise is just what enables my goals to be achieved. They are a means to an end, not the purpose.0 -
I lift 4 days a week with one accessory work. I walk a lot 6-10 miles a day to and from the subway to work, kids school, the gym etc. but for fun not meaningful exercise as I love walking. I run in the summer too and ride my bike. I prefer cardio, but get the results I want with strength training.0
-
I do PHUL 4x/week and I walk 15k steps every day (so steady state cardio)
I don't prefer one over the other but they are both valuable and necessary for my goals (looking good naked)1 -
I lift 3X a week and do cardio 3X as well. I love cardio more, probably because I've been doing it for longer. It took me a while to learn to like lifting, but I really enjoy it as well.0
-
I lift because I think I should. I run because I'm enjoying it.1
-
Tbh I hate questions like this. The obvious answer is to love BOTH. I do as much weights as I do cardio, except for my rest days.1
-
I enjoy lifting weights and tolerate (barely) interval training at the end of my workout as well as a 10-15 minute warm-up dreadmill stint. I am following the Strong (Schuler & Cosgrove) program (full body workouts) and go 2-3 times a week. When I am just re-starting the program after a layoff, I can manage 3x a week and as the weights get heavier as stages progress, I often allow this aged body a bit more recovery time and have alternating weeks with 2 x gym stints. I like swimming outdoors, ocean or lake, but am not a big fan of pools either in or out.0
-
They're both valuable and a lot depends on your goals. I've trended more toward strength. I started with a goal of weight loss, which morphed into fitness (by that I mean the ability to do stuff - both picking up and putting down heavy things, and endurance enough to move myself around as required).
Having never lifted before, at age 54, I've found myself continually amazed at what lifting progressively and heavy does, and how much better it helps my cardio - and body composition too. I did do a fair amount of cardio at the start (last Feb through September). But after the weights got heavy, my occasional distance runs improved dramatically.
Now I lift 2x per week and do HIIT 1-2x per week. I augment that with a fair amount of walking or a 4-5 mile run every couple of weeks.2 -
I play roller derby, a bit of a mix of strength and cardio, in intervals. When I'm not playing/training I prefer lifting, but run (steady state) for cardio (mostly because my endurance sucks!). Both lifting and cardio are to help improve my roller derbying.1
-
I honestly enjoy both and tend to alternate between them on a daily basis.
My "cardio" of choice is cycling and it's hard to beat being outdoors in nice weather and riding in beautiful countryside. Very wide range from an hour in the gym to all day long distance events.
But there's times when both weights and cardio are just plain hard work rather than being enjoyable and it's training towards a goal or outcome that keeps me going. I've been training too long (40+ years!) and gathered too many injuries to be hitting strength lifetime PRs but "recent PRs" still give me a buzz same as the simple "that was a good session" feeling.
Indoor cycling generally bores me but I love the fitness results of the more technical training you can do under controlled conditions.
As I'm a latecomer to cycling I still can hit PRs once in a while and that's how I celebrated my 58th birthday - fastest ever indoor 40km/25 miles.1 -
I'm not a fan of cardio but I do a little (mostly because it gives me more calories ).
I enjoy lifting. Right now I'm doing SL 5x5 and adding accessories. I enjoy yoga too. I do yoga 2x a week, SL 3x a week, and a HIIT/strength interval class 2x a week.0 -
I genuinely enjoy cardio and do it because I enjoy it. I might tweak it here or there for fitness reasons, but ultimately I do it because I like to. My primary activities are cycling (both road and mountain), running (both road and trail), hiking, and playing basketball.
Strength training I get exactly zero enjoyment from, so I ONLY do it for the strength/stability benefits, but I don't do it as regularly as I should. It is solely a means to an end for me. I do either bodyweight work or free weights. I rarely use machines.1 -
Cardio hands down. Way more bang for my buck re: cals burned, and requires minimal equipment. Plus, I’m a distance runner and endurance junkie. I lift too, but I dislike it a lot. I just know it’s good for me.1
-
Lifting is the bees knees. Anything else is just torture. I'm currently doing SL 5x5. I lift because I like the mental aspect along with the physical. Also it helps me hit the long ball.1
-
I enjoy running because it gets me out of the house, gives me energy (and a few extra calories!) for the rest of my day, helps balance my moods, and because I love that zen feeling I get when everything just clicks. After I started running I could go up a flight of stairs without getting winded and jog short distances without breaking a sweat, both handy in day-to-day life. Other forms of cardio haven't really clicked for me, especially stuff that I have to drive to get to or do with other people. Intervals and circuits are fun though.
I've enjoyed body-weight strength training because I enjoy the challenge of doing a range of things, for the increases in strength, balance and endurance, and because it also gives me energy for the rest of my day. My husband says I carry myself more confidently, which I'm cool with. After I started doing regular body-weight workouts I noticed I'm a lot steadier on my feet and don't make groaning and grunting noises when I get up or bend over, plus I can lift heavier things than I could before. I'm a little sad to be putting the body-weight workouts mostly on hold as I transition to a progressive lifting program, but I'm excited about the challenge and benefits of lifting heavy things.0 -
I much prefer strength training to cardio, although there are forms of exercise/activities that fall under "cardio" that I love - martial arts, horseback riding (hunter/jumper), I enjoy zumba, etc.
That being said, what I DO is all geared towards helping me in my sport (motorcycle road racing, which is far more physical than most people realize unless they've done it).
I do a rotating workout plan that includes strength/lifting (max weight with lower reps); muscle endurance/cardio (similar to P90X); CrossFit inspired workouts (ST and cardio); and some steady state cardio. Today, during my deload week, I did a HIIT session with rowing as the base cardio (I can't run due to an 'old' injury) after a warm up on the stationary bike.
I'm open to a lot of different workouts, and I need variety to keep me interested, but I also need to target things that will help with the sport and improve my weaknesses as well.0 -
I need a 50/50 balance of both. Too much of one or the other is not healthy for me. About 4 years ago I was ALL cardio though. Now I'd be very unhappy with that. I tend to get more cardio once the winter weather lifts, but I still ensure I take advantage of the good days out there when I can.0
-
I run because I enjoy the out of doors and it keeps my head clear and moods even. I enjoy strength training but need someone with experience with me at all times to keep me in check regarding form and doing it properly. I lack coordination and if left to my own devices, end up hurting myself.0
-
I like both, but it depends on the exercise. A bit of background: I've got some motor coordination issues and was never very athletic. When I was in CEGEP (in Quebec, that's an education level with a community college/tech-vocational track or a pre-university track) phys ed was mandatory each semester, but there were a wide range of offerings. I pointedly avoided team sports and other activities where my being a klutz would impact more people than just me.
My main cardio is walking, and I go around 3.3-3.5 mph and shoot for 2 hours a day. If that doesn't work, I've got a GazelleEdge glider and do 70 minutes. I like the machine, but it doesn't elevate heart-rate much.
My strength training is primarily dumbbells and body-weight, with a couple of medicine balls, a stability ball, and some ankle weights in the mix. I don't have a reliable spotter and I am just getting to the point where lifting heavy might be an option. In other words, the heaviest thing I lift right now are a pair of 17.5lb dumbbells on seated lat rows on the stability ball, and on front and side squats. This Sunday, I'm phasing in 20lbs on the lat rows. (Squats a week later).
Honestly, it's hard for me to say whether I find either exercise enjoyable in and of itself, or if it's more of the, "Whoa. I think I just shaved 5 minutes off the time to do this route!" or "Hey, I just picked up a 20lb weight in each hand and I remember when I needed both hands to pick up 15!" or "Hang on a second. There. In the mirror... is that my deltoid?" I definitely love the feeling after the workout when I can stop. And I love seeing the results of both cardio and strength training. As for the actual exercise, some days I'm more into one than the other. Sometimes I have to push myself, because I'm afraid that if I take a (non-rest) day off, one day will become two and then more and I'll just quit doing it. Sometimes I love it. Sometimes I'm meh. But I don't do exercises I hate. And the meh passes.1 -
I prefer cardio because it's more fun (for me anyway). I do spin class and run.
For strength training I prefer body weight work, specifically yoga. I typically choose fast flow vinyasa type classes. This is not because I am afraid of getting bulky from heavy weights but because I have a lot more fun doing yoga as opposed to lifting. I feel at this point that I am too old to spend time on workouts I don't really enjoy when there are so many exercise types I do really enjoy.1 -
I prefer strength, but do both. 2-3 days are geared more to strength, there is usually some sort of Crossfit type work in there that gets my heart rate up...AMRAPs and EMOM, I enjoy those, but the majority is more just strength. Then 2-3 days a week I do kickboxing. I count that as my all cardio days. I do enjoy that for cardio. I had to look and try a bunch of different things to find cardio that I really enjoy.0
-
I genuinely enjoy both. At different times over my life I've done varying extremes of each, as well as a more balanced program. I'm currently in a more balanced place, with cardio volume undulating as needed depending on time of year and how many races I'm entered in.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions