Very confused about the calorie intake.
Jennifernellwebb
Posts: 209 Member
This week, I am more alert as to the fruits and veggies in my diet opposed to last week... ( I gained almost 2 lbs. last week just staying UNDER the calories for the day ) but I cut out almost all my fruits and vegetables. I basically just added anything and everything until it got close to my goal and then I stopped, not really paying any attention to WHAT I was eating. So, this week, I put the fruits and veggies.... and whole wheat, back in to my diet and I seem to go in the negative on my protein, but after working out, it says that I am GETTING TOO FEW CALORIES, and I am starving myself. I just don't get it!! My meals for today.....
Breakfast : oatmeal w/ 1 piece of 100% double fiber and a smoothie that had 1cup of 2% milk , 1/2 cup of oranges, 1/2 large banana, and 4 strawberries.
Lunch : 1/2 cup of V~8 juice ( regular ) and a 1/2 cup of crab meat
Dinner : 1 piece of chicken breast from my crock pot... simmered in salsa, 1/2 cup of french style green beans, and a small salad w/ fat free vinegrette.
I drink nothing but water so I go well over my 8 cups a day, especially when I work out. ( I add a little sobe lifewater for flavoring ) but I add that in my daily totals as well. 15 carbs. I think in it. no sugars or anything like that though. At the end of today, it said that I needed to eat more calories!!! I was at my limit on protein...actually went over by 1 , I think. All my others were in the green. So, what am I missing here??? Please, anyone.... if you can tell me where I am going wrong, I would really appreciate it. I gained last week, I want to go the opposite direction.... :sad:
Breakfast : oatmeal w/ 1 piece of 100% double fiber and a smoothie that had 1cup of 2% milk , 1/2 cup of oranges, 1/2 large banana, and 4 strawberries.
Lunch : 1/2 cup of V~8 juice ( regular ) and a 1/2 cup of crab meat
Dinner : 1 piece of chicken breast from my crock pot... simmered in salsa, 1/2 cup of french style green beans, and a small salad w/ fat free vinegrette.
I drink nothing but water so I go well over my 8 cups a day, especially when I work out. ( I add a little sobe lifewater for flavoring ) but I add that in my daily totals as well. 15 carbs. I think in it. no sugars or anything like that though. At the end of today, it said that I needed to eat more calories!!! I was at my limit on protein...actually went over by 1 , I think. All my others were in the green. So, what am I missing here??? Please, anyone.... if you can tell me where I am going wrong, I would really appreciate it. I gained last week, I want to go the opposite direction.... :sad:
0
Replies
-
From many things I have heard and agree with, MFP underestimates protein. My suggestion... don't look at the protein, you need a lot of it so that your muscles will repair themselves if you are working out hard. You should eat more protein than MFP says, the main thing you are trying to keep under are the calories, sugar, fat, and sodium.0
-
This program will tell you, and many people have different opinions about it, to eat the calories you are allotted AND the calories you burn during exercise. The reason is the program has already put in a deficit for you. I personally eat back part of my exercise calories but, like I said there are many opinions on it.0
-
just be patient. at first your body is hanging onto weight to keep a balance. in a couple of weeks you'll see some changes.0
-
Going over on protein is really not that big of a deal, especially if you are working out. You are supposed to eat back your exercise calories because the way this website is designed, it gives you a deficit to lose without exercise, so eat those back (this is a HUGE debate on here.) It takes a lot more healthy foods to get to your calorie goals than it does junk food. The only areas I really worry about going over is sodium, carbs (I subtract my fruits and veggies from this number) and my calories though I try and get as close as possible, including eating my exercise calories. I hope this helps. I feel like I am all over the place but I just had a date with the devil (Jillian) and am still trying to recover!!! Good luck.0
-
Yes, the protein is defaulted very low here, especially if you are working out. So you may want to increase to a higher percentage. As far as the calories, as someone else mentioned this is highly debated but MFP is set up to eat back your exercise calories (I do) You need to fuel your body!! If you do want to eat back your exercise calories try adding a snack during the day -- things like nuts, walnuts, almonds or seeds are full of nutrients and have about 300 calories per serving.0
-
Hey Jennifer...I've been on a great diet and reading everything I could get my hands on as to nutrition. I've lost about 75 pounds in the past 10 months. I've done so through better nutrition, excercise and calorie counting to insure I have a calorie deficit each day. As a man, I shoot for around 1500 to 1700 calories per day. Two suggestions I would make to your eating. First, there is a lot of recent evidence that eating protein earlier in the day leaves you feeling more full. I typically start my day with eggs and whole wheat toast. Second is watching out for the fruit. Not that it isn't healthy and all, but it typically includes a great deal of natural sugar. If you eat a bunch of fruit and aren't actively burning the sugar (energy) your body will turn it to fat. People often refer to "Fruits and Veggies" as one and the same. Actually, you can eat pounds of veggies and add only health and very few calories to your body. Fruit on the other hand should be eaten sparingly and preferably, just prior to the point in the day when your activity is at its highest. This allows the sugar in the fruit to fuel your muscles, rather than pad your butt...:0) I've found best results in not only considering what I eat, but when I eat it. Jus tsome food for thought. Hope I haven't rambled on too long. Best of luck to you in your journey.
Cheers, Jeff0 -
Sodium is a big one, and i fully agree with the protien being to low on MFP
I eat tons of protien0 -
if that is all you are eating, then yes indeed you are eating nowhere near enough food. you shoudl be eating about triple what you are eating right now. Take a look at my diary to see how much i eat and i'm usually around 1350 cals. yesterday i ate a lot, i ate back my exercise caloris and today i had crepes as a treat. i lose on average of 2 lbs a week.
your lunch especially needs to be much much bigger.0 -
Protein is often too low, especially if you are doing any resistance training.
You could have gained [most likely] water weight from what you ate the other day[high sodium?] .
Or you may be starting to gain muscle tissue[not as likely].0 -
Are you counting calories correctly? or portions? Breakfast seemed a little heavy to me. Other than that I would not worry if it tells me i am not eating enough, as long as you are not hungry. and you have exercised. other than that, keep on doing what you are doing! you will reap if you faint not!0
-
Your net is what counts. On your homepage, where it says NET, it should say 1200 or higher. If you're exercising, you have to eat some of those calories back to "net" 1200 so you're in a healthy range and getting enough nutrients. Try adding in little snacks here and there for 100 calories or so. Peanut butter, string cheese with your fruit, etc.0
-
In my opinion, going over in protein isn't a bad thing, especially if you are doing any sort of weight lifting at the gym... your muscles need the protein, so don't fret if you go over there. Worry about the Calories, Fat, Carbs, and Fiber. You want to be sure to limit the 1st three and you want to make sure to get enough fiber. Again with fiber, I'm not really sure going over is something you should be worrying about!
Judging by what you wrote down for your diet and assuming you burn around 400-600 calories when you work out, you probably aren't eating enough calories. As someone else already said, this program is already putting you at a calorie deficit so that you can lose weight at a safe and healthy rate. If you are allotted 1500 calories per day, try to eat around 1500 calories a day! If you burn 500 calories at the gym, try to eat the calories you burned! For me, I enjoy working out... it gives me more energy and it of course increases my appetite from all the calories burned. You have to give your body those calories back! It's almost a nice reward for a hard workout to have a big hearty, healthy meal. Obviously it's not best to fill the calories burned with empty calories, but it's also okay to treat yourself to a bowl of ice cream on occasion! It's important for you to try to change your mindset about eating while on a diet like this. Eating lots of veggies, fruit and water is absolutely the right thing to do, so keep doing that. But just make sure you're eating enough!
I think you will find in the long run that you continually go in an extreme deficit to what is recommended to you, you will gain weight back much easier if you go off the diet. Been there, done that, and really really trying to change my lifestyle for good this go around...0 -
Try adding in little snacks here and there for 100 calories or so. Peanut butter, string cheese with your fruit, etc.
Absolutely agreed! Space your food out... it's to have more smaller meals/snacks throughout the day!0 -
I don't know what exercise you are doing. But you could be gaining muscles. It sounds like you are eating healthy. I try to eat 1200 calories and 20 fat grams a day. And walk, I start out 2 miles and work my way up to 3 miles a day. Good Luck!0
-
Hi, newbie here too. I don't understand why people are saying when you exercise you need to give your body back the calories it burned? I thought the whole idea was to be getting rid of calories and burning off fat! If you exercise then eat extra isn't it defeating the purpose?0
-
Thank you all so much. I appreciate everything you have told me and I will keep a mental note, no doubt!! I still don't, and probably will never understand the "eating back your calories" thing........it is just so hard to stick anything in my mouth after an hour on my ironman treadmill!! I burn almost 300 calories doing that along w/ 100 crunches on my Abcoaster ( not sure what I burn there ) and the thought of putting anything in after trying to get it off just doesn't sit well w/ me. I try to do my workout in the evening after all meals. I just figure that if I have unburned calories, I can tackle them then and I might eventually lose weight. I really don't feel the need to replace the burned calories in the evening when I will, in just a few hours, go to bed. I am a stay at home wife so I really don't get much exercise, outside of what I actually WORK OFF on the treadmill. The sodium thing.......I have to look in to that!!! I notice that almost everything I eat has it in it!! Just when I think I get one thing balanced, I get thrown off on something else. I will get it eventually though, I really want this!!!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions