What the chicken breast?

brittaniao
brittaniao Posts: 5 Member
edited November 2024 in Food and Nutrition
I am hoping someone can clarify a chicken question for me!

I often find myself eating boneless skinless Chicken breasts. It shows as "breast, boneless, skinless, baked" and "chicken 6oz" below it worth 276 calories. I recently put in the exact brand I use (Kirkland from Costco - also baked) and it says that 6oz is only 165 calories. I see multiple Kirkland chicken brands for 165 cals and multiple unnamed brands worth the 276. Can different brands of chicken breasts really vary that much in calories? Which number is more accurate?

Thanks!

Replies

  • DragonHasTheSapphire
    DragonHasTheSapphire Posts: 184 Member
    Can you see the nutrition facts on the bag of chicken you buy? Generally, what I'll do is put in the exact brand name (like you did), and view the nutrition facts in the entry and compare them to the physical nutrition facts on the bag of chicken sitting beside me.

    If I see too many conflicting numbers, I just click an entry and say the information is inaccurate, then edit the entry to the exact facts on the actual bag of chicken I purchased. I then will just weigh my chicken to the serving size on the bag and use my own entry. I'd avoid generic brands, some are accurate but most aren't. I also don't choose the cooked entries, but I could imagine there is some accurate ones out there, but I couldn't tell you which ones.
  • DragonHasTheSapphire
    DragonHasTheSapphire Posts: 184 Member
    To kinda add on to that, I would stick to the named brands. Some unnamed brands claim that an item has a ridiculous amount of calories when it really doesn't.
  • brittaniao
    brittaniao Posts: 5 Member
    That's helpful. I'll check once I get home. I didn't know something as generic as chicken breast could very so much in calories! Is there a specific reason I should avoid putting the cooked entries?
  • RoxieDawn
    RoxieDawn Posts: 15,487 Member
    edited April 2018
    brittaniao wrote: »
    That's helpful. I'll check once I get home. I didn't know something as generic as chicken breast could very so much in calories! Is there a specific reason I should avoid putting the cooked entries?

    Is your chicken already cooked or raw in the package? If your chicken has a label use that and weigh it accordingly. If your chicken breast package is per grams or ounces enter the weight of the chicken upon selection of the proper database entry.

    Just be aware entries are made from other MFP members and not always correct. Always good to double check the one you use. On new foods I enter sometimes I have do multiple searches but usually there is an entry, I use USDA entries as well.

    eta: maybe this guide will you help out on logging accuracy.

    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1234699/logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide/p1
  • DragonHasTheSapphire
    DragonHasTheSapphire Posts: 184 Member
    brittaniao wrote: »
    That's helpful. I'll check once I get home. I didn't know something as generic as chicken breast could very so much in calories! Is there a specific reason I should avoid putting the cooked entries?

    Just to add on to the advice above, I avoid them because some cooked entries say that a cooked chicken that is 4 oz skinless is 120 calories or so, but it shrinks after you cook it. It should be weighed 4 or so ounces (most serving sizes say it for the raw meat) So after you cooked 4 oz, it should only be around 2.5 oz.. kinda a difference there. The same calories, just less water. So if I were to weigh 4 oz of cooked chicken, it could've been 8 oz raw so I'd have to double calories. That's just my personal chicken I buy though :) I always double check, and the USDA entries I second agree
  • brittaniao
    brittaniao Posts: 5 Member
    brittaniao wrote: »
    That's helpful. I'll check once I get home. I didn't know something as generic as chicken breast could very so much in calories! Is there a specific reason I should avoid putting the cooked entries?

    Just to add on to the advice above, I avoid them because some cooked entries say that a cooked chicken that is 4 oz skinless is 120 calories or so, but it shrinks after you cook it. It should be weighed 4 or so ounces (most serving sizes say it for the raw meat) So after you cooked 4 oz, it should only be around 2.5 oz.. kinda a difference there. The same calories, just less water. So if I were to weigh 4 oz of cooked chicken, it could've been 8 oz raw so I'd have to double calories. That's just my personal chicken I buy though :) I always double check, and the USDA entries I second agree

    So for your example above, are you saying you would log 8oz or 4oz of unspecified chicken breast? I usually bake in bulk then weight it out and divide after it's cooked. I specify "baked" as I would assumed if your were to fry it for example, it would be more calories. Thanks for your help!
  • brittaniao
    brittaniao Posts: 5 Member
    RoxieDawn wrote: »
    brittaniao wrote: »
    That's helpful. I'll check once I get home. I didn't know something as generic as chicken breast could very so much in calories! Is there a specific reason I should avoid putting the cooked entries?

    Is your chicken already cooked or raw in the package? If your chicken has a label use that and weigh it accordingly. If your chicken breast package is per grams or ounces enter the weight of the chicken upon selection of the proper database entry.

    Just be aware entries are made from other MFP members and not always correct. Always good to double check the one you use. On new foods I enter sometimes I have do multiple searches but usually there is an entry, I use USDA entries as well.

    eta: maybe this guide will you help out on logging accuracy.

    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1234699/logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide/p1

    Very helpful but still confused on how I should log lol. The chicken breasts come raw and I bake them. Do I put chicken breast raw with the raw weight, or do an entry that says baked with the oz after its baked? Thanks!
  • RoxieDawn
    RoxieDawn Posts: 15,487 Member
    brittaniao wrote: »
    RoxieDawn wrote: »
    brittaniao wrote: »
    That's helpful. I'll check once I get home. I didn't know something as generic as chicken breast could very so much in calories! Is there a specific reason I should avoid putting the cooked entries?

    Is your chicken already cooked or raw in the package? If your chicken has a label use that and weigh it accordingly. If your chicken breast package is per grams or ounces enter the weight of the chicken upon selection of the proper database entry.

    Just be aware entries are made from other MFP members and not always correct. Always good to double check the one you use. On new foods I enter sometimes I have do multiple searches but usually there is an entry, I use USDA entries as well.

    eta: maybe this guide will you help out on logging accuracy.

    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1234699/logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide/p1

    Very helpful but still confused on how I should log lol. The chicken breasts come raw and I bake them. Do I put chicken breast raw with the raw weight, or do an entry that says baked with the oz after its baked? Thanks!

    Weigh the chicken raw enter the raw weight on your diary. Only use baked entries if the chicken you bought is baked/pre-cooked and use the entry based on your label. .
  • DragonHasTheSapphire
    DragonHasTheSapphire Posts: 184 Member
    brittaniao wrote: »
    brittaniao wrote: »
    That's helpful. I'll check once I get home. I didn't know something as generic as chicken breast could very so much in calories! Is there a specific reason I should avoid putting the cooked entries?

    Just to add on to the advice above, I avoid them because some cooked entries say that a cooked chicken that is 4 oz skinless is 120 calories or so, but it shrinks after you cook it. It should be weighed 4 or so ounces (most serving sizes say it for the raw meat) So after you cooked 4 oz, it should only be around 2.5 oz.. kinda a difference there. The same calories, just less water. So if I were to weigh 4 oz of cooked chicken, it could've been 8 oz raw so I'd have to double calories. That's just my personal chicken I buy though :) I always double check, and the USDA entries I second agree

    So for your example above, are you saying you would log 8oz or 4oz of unspecified chicken breast? I usually bake in bulk then weight it out and divide after it's cooked. I specify "baked" as I would assumed if your were to fry it for example, it would be more calories. Thanks for your help!

    No problem :)! What I was meaning was that it would be best to weigh your chicken raw before it's cooked. So, if I were to have an 8 oz chicken and pop it in the oven, it would shrink to 4 oz. Many people would assume that's the correct portion, but the chicken should weigh to be 4 oz before it's cooked, and usually 2 or 3 ounces once it's done. No need to stress though, calories don't technically evaporate. Only use baked or cooked entires (whether it's specified or not), if you purchased the chicken already cooked. I made the mistake by weighing chicken after it was cooked, and didn't realize that the serving size on my chicken bag was referring to weighing the chicken raw, then you bake it and get your correct serving size. Most raw chicken breasts are 8-12 ounces when you buy them, so a scale is a go-to for me.
  • brittaniao
    brittaniao Posts: 5 Member
    Ah okay... thank you guys! I just got home and looked on the package and it does match the entry (110 cals per 4oz).
This discussion has been closed.