Losing Body Fat Questions
linusidom
Posts: 5 Member
I’ve been trying to lose body fat % but clearly I’m doing something wrong so I thought I would ask for some advice
I’ve been eating very clean and healthy for about 1.5 months now, no cheat meals no protein shakes, no sweets, etc.
My body type breakdown
Endomorph: 30%
Mesomorph: 60%
Ectomorph: 10%
What I’ve been eating daily (not at once but throughout the day)
250 grams of Mung Beans
500 grams of chicken breast
4 oz of peanuts
4 oz raisins
1 lb of guava fruit
4 large eggs
About 2100 calories
This works out to about 200 grams of protein, 220 grams of carbs and 40 grams of fat
Essentially 40-50% protein/carbs and <10% fats
My workout is about 500 calories burned (cardio and weights)
BMR is about 1750
The problem: I’m losing lean muscle and gaining fat. My weight has stayed the same however I can lift more than I could before the diet. The scale has shown 18% to 20% body fat and 39kg of muscle down to 36kg. Yet I’m stronger now and look thinner
I’m guessing I need to up the carbs because my body might have gone into starvation mode holding onto the fat due to the drop in calories but not sure if I should mix up intake %’s based on my body type.
Any advice is welcome.
Thanks in advance
I’ve been eating very clean and healthy for about 1.5 months now, no cheat meals no protein shakes, no sweets, etc.
My body type breakdown
Endomorph: 30%
Mesomorph: 60%
Ectomorph: 10%
What I’ve been eating daily (not at once but throughout the day)
250 grams of Mung Beans
500 grams of chicken breast
4 oz of peanuts
4 oz raisins
1 lb of guava fruit
4 large eggs
About 2100 calories
This works out to about 200 grams of protein, 220 grams of carbs and 40 grams of fat
Essentially 40-50% protein/carbs and <10% fats
My workout is about 500 calories burned (cardio and weights)
BMR is about 1750
The problem: I’m losing lean muscle and gaining fat. My weight has stayed the same however I can lift more than I could before the diet. The scale has shown 18% to 20% body fat and 39kg of muscle down to 36kg. Yet I’m stronger now and look thinner
I’m guessing I need to up the carbs because my body might have gone into starvation mode holding onto the fat due to the drop in calories but not sure if I should mix up intake %’s based on my body type.
Any advice is welcome.
Thanks in advance
23
Replies
-
First off, both somotypes and starvation mode are irrelevant. Somotypes have been long debunked and starvation mode doesn't exist the way you are using it.
What are you using to measure your body fat vs muscle? If one of those home scales, those are really inaccurate for the most part.
What has your weight been doing? Are you losing?15 -
I'm using a weight scale at the gym that measures quite a few metrics including Total Body Water, Left/Right Arm/Leg Fat/Muscle, Protein, Minerals, etc. I figure even though it may not be accurate, it's at least consistent in it's inaccuracy Calipers would probably be best but I don't have them and my gym doesn't know how to use them...
My weight has been the exact same. Hasn't gone up, hasn't gone down, which is what I actually want It's the fat content going up and muscle content going down...according to the scale anyway2 -
I'm using a weight scale at the gym that measures quite a few metrics including Total Body Water, Left/Right Arm/Leg Fat/Muscle, Protein, Minerals, etc. I figure even though it may not be accurate, it's at least consistent in it's inaccuracy Calipers would probably be best but I don't have them and my gym doesn't know how to use them...
My weight has been the exact same. Hasn't gone up, hasn't gone down, which is what I actually want It's the fat content going up and muscle content going down...according to the scale anyway
I use one at my gym too, a BodyTrax unit.
Generally it gives a believable trend over time but like all BIA scales prone to weird and wonderful fluctuations.
Apparently I lost 6lbs of muscle one week and surprise, surprise gained it back the next week.
Always keep in mind it can't MEASURE your body composition, it only measures your electrical resistance and makes assumptions.
Be consistent when you use it and you may get less odd readings - same time of day, same eating/drinking routine (they are very prone to odd results from differences in hydration), not after your workout - not even after a hard workout the previous day, not after a large or salty meal the previous day....
Use a tape measure and track over time, take progress pictures (same lighting, posture etc.)
Put everything together and you will have a better idea of progress.
PS -
Eating clean is subjective and pretty much irrelevant, somatotypes are absolute twaddle and completely irrelevant, starvation mode is twaddle.
What drives your body composition changes is a good training program - without that your progress will be sub optimal.15 -
Why so little fat?4
-
TavistockToad wrote: »Why so little fat?
Good spot.
But with the peanuts and eggs it's probably inaccurate logging.
Hopefully anyway as 40g would be inadequate unless OP is about 100lbs.6 -
TavistockToad wrote: »Why so little fat?
Good spot.
But with the peanuts and eggs it's probably inaccurate logging.
Hopefully anyway as 40g would be inadequate unless OP is about 100lbs.
Google tells me that 4oz is 113g so that many peanuts and eggs is no way 40g of fat.
So very inaccurate logging!8 -
Good call on the fat...I’m using the verified foods from MFP and that’s where I’m pulling my intake numbers from. I’ll rework the numbers and update with what I find.
Thanks for the help.1 -
Good call on the body fat, took a look at the numbers and the inputs and corrected (images attached).
I'm 180, 5'8, BMR ~1750, Ideal goal is the maintain mass but lose body fat, but I'm willing to lose the mass to lose the body fat.
My workout plan is a combination
- HIIT (20 minutes, burns ~200 calories)
- followed by either Calisthenics, Heavy Weights or Volume Weights depending on the day of the week and direction (push vs pull) for 30-45 minutes. Calisthenics and volume days my HR I try and keep my heart rate at a base of 130-140 and up to 160-170. Weight days it's probably closer to 110.
-RHR is 65-70
Any glaring issues with my intake?0 -
Good call on the body fat, took a look at the numbers and the inputs and corrected (images attached).
I'm 180, 5'8, BMR ~1750, Ideal goal is the maintain mass but lose body fat, but I'm willing to lose the mass to lose the body fat.
My workout plan is a combination
- HIIT (20 minutes, burns ~200 calories)
- followed by either Calisthenics, Heavy Weights or Volume Weights depending on the day of the week and direction (push vs pull) for 30-45 minutes. Calisthenics and volume days my HR I try and keep my heart rate at a base of 130-140 and up to 160-170. Weight days it's probably closer to 110.
-RHR is 65-70
Any glaring issues with my intake?
Yes. You need to weigh your food on a digital scale.5 -
a more accurate food guide in terms of nutrient composition is at the USDA food composition site0
-
For body fat loss what should be the target numbers/%’s to aim for? What’s a good guide to follow?
There’s a lot out there which makes it all the more confusing...
Thanks!1 -
Where are your vegetables?2
-
-
If you are lifting and you are looking smaller then you are not losing muscle -- the scale is goofy. I would stay the course, possibly reduce overall calorie intake by 200 hundred or so. You only need .8 grams of protein per pound of current weight in order to grow muscle.0
-
My body type breakdown
Endomorph: 30%
Mesomorph: 60%
Ectomorph: 10%
This is not a thing, disregard completely.
Fat % scales are useless, not accurate at all.
Weigh your food, all of it. I even weigh the milk in my tea.
Also, saying you are "eating clean and healthy", there is no "clean food" you can eat sweet treats as part of weight loss and a healthy diet. Depriving yourself of things you like and labeling food as "clean" is a surefire way to fail long term. As long as you are in a deficit overall, that's all you need to lose fat.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions