What are your PMS cravings/hunger like?
oat_bran
Posts: 370 Member
Most of the people I talk to about PMS say they mostly crave junk food and sweets when they are PMSing and also say that eating the foods they crave usually satisfies the craving. Am I the only one for whom PMS doesn't really cause cravings for particular foods? it makes me crave everything. It's insane some months! I literally want to just eat non-stop and it doesn't really matter what. Everything that isn't nailed down and a few things that are. I mean, sweet and starchy foods sound particularly tempting but anything goes really. And it's not just cravings, I feel RAVENOUS pretty much non-stop. And no matter how much I eat there's always lingering feeling of hunger. It's like I just ate a huge meal, and I can feel it still in my stomach and yet, there's this uncomfortable hollow-like sensation in my stomach like I'm still starving. I swear, there were days where I let myself eat thousands of calories and it was still there. I feel like I can't get full no matter how much I eat. I mean, even before eating I can already feel that I won't be able to satisfy it no matter how much i eat, if it makes sense? And still I can't really stop eating, it's almost a compulsive drive. I wake up several times throughout the night because i feel hungry and I wake up starving in the morning even if I ate at night! It drives me crazy. All I can think is food! The usual "just eat at maintenance", "drink more watre", "eat more portein/fat/fiber/more frequantly" etc. make me want to both laugh and cry at the same time... I hate how hormones can control our life so much...
Please tell me I'm not the only one like that! It's not only about the fact ruins my progress every time, but I just literally can't focus on anything besides food for several days, 2 weeks straight sometimes, it's so frustrating!
Please tell me I'm not the only one like that! It's not only about the fact ruins my progress every time, but I just literally can't focus on anything besides food for several days, 2 weeks straight sometimes, it's so frustrating!
4
Replies
-
You're not the only one. I get insanely hungry a few days before my period. Usually, I'll just up my workout for that time (take an extra long hike or bike ride) and eat whatever I want. I used to just crave fast food but for the last year or so it's been Chinese food. I'll binge on crab rangoon like they're going off the market. It doesn't have to ruin your progress though. That might be more psychological than reality. Are you counting what you're eating? Is it really thousands of calories or do you just feel as if it is? If you really feel as if you're out of control then start taking back control. Only eat one meal where you eat whatever you want and stick to your goals the other 2. It'll be hard at first but you can do it.3
-
Try taking magnesium for PMS cravings. Also maybe try IF? If eating more is making you more hungry then maybe eating more is not the solution? If it’s that bad I would also look at ghrelin/leptin. Maybe your sleep is disturbed and that can make hunger worse and pms worse too. I get this too and focusing on sleep has helped me as well as magnesium.2
-
Other than waking up at night after falling asleep, totally me!!!! So frustrating. Defeating.1
-
Oh I should add. I can eat up to 9000-10,000 calories. Forget eating at maintainence !2
-
Some women are more sensitive to hormonal fluctuations than others. Sometimes, this sensitivity can result in compulsive overeating and/or binge eating behaviors. Since not every woman experiences it, oftentimes they may advise you to do the usual 3 things that you listed.
The only thing that resolved my food issues was to get my hormonal issues under control. After that was done, I no longer have food cravings. Sometimes, I may have a slight uptick in appetite in that my normal meals don't satisfy me. When that happens, I'll just put a tiny bit of L-glutamine powder on a spoon and take that. Then I'm fine. That may not work for you.0 -
Ovulating y Period times are big food craving moments for women.Im Perimenopause so it’s worse just like I’m a teenager again! I know the issues now read articles on it so looking at the calendar so I have a heads up that it’s coming start building the willpower! It’s helping a lot being aware stepping back with a bag of sweets in hand saying will We regret this at the end of the week? Yes sigh* puts it back healthy options ..peanut butter ,dark chocolate bits,cereal healthy only,y almond milk with a dash of honey.I adjust my meal calories to what fills me up but low calories. At the end of the day stay on track but excersice suffers. -After the water weight poofs I’m less or same as before.Then wait for the next battle like a soldier seeing dust on the horizon.
Usually your 1st 3days after that your back to yourself0 -
Lol yes I ask the question out loud in my mom tone like I would to my kids. Family gives me a Moms losing it stare but I ignore that lol0
-
Oh this app syncs with GLOW app gals! It’s a period/ovulation tracker0
-
Of course I am lucky and only have 1-3 days, immediately preceding my menstruation, that this increased pseudo-hunger signalling occurs.
What I've learned through lots of trial and error works for me? It stops when I stop snacking in response to it and instead eat an entire extra, real, bonafide sit-down meal when it hits. I also make sure my fat intake isn't below 30% of my total calories for the day and protein is as high as I can comfortably fit based on the amount of carbs I eat those days. Yes, this will push me up to, or a bit above, my estimated maintenance amount of calories. But far better in the long run to eat 2-2,500 than 5-10,000 kcals on those days as a result of planning for and meeting the (tongue firmly planted in cheek) enemy head on.1 -
grinning_chick wrote: »Of course I am lucky and only have 1-3 days, immediately preceding my menstruation, that this increased pseudo-hunger signalling occurs.
What I've learned through lots of trial and error works for me? It stops when I stop snacking in response to it and instead eat an entire extra, real, bonafide sit-down meal when it hits. I also make sure my fat intake isn't below 30% of my total calories for the day and protein is as high as I can comfortably fit based on the amount of carbs I eat those days. Yes, this will push me up to, or a bit above, my estimated maintenance amount of calories. But far better in the long run to eat 2-2,500 than 5-10,000 kcals on those days as a result of planning for and meeting the (tongue firmly planted in cheek) enemy head on.
Yes, I used to go down the snacking, pizza, and Ben & Jerry's route and eat thousands of calories extra but learned just eating an extra (balanced) snack and a bigger dinner would do the trick. Getting adequate protein is key for me. (I've never had a problem meeting my fat goal
)
Increased hunger is the first and sometimes only sign I'm premenstrual. I'm hungrier for lunch earlier and so will eat it earlier, and have an afternoon snack and a bigger dinner.0 -
My PMS is a beast. My diet barely survived it last month, cravings never hit me so hard.
I'm liking the idea of meeting it head on and taking on some kind of compensational deficit so you can splurge a little more on the bad days. I might have to try it this month if things get dicey again.1 -
I struggle with this too, I crave seeet & salty for like a week before my cycle. I noticed if I amp up my workouts it helps with the hormonal imbalance.0
-
I go through the same and found this post today going through here. I'm going to try some of the remedies mentioned. I also get insane fatigue like a week before its crazy how tired I get.0
-
https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/is-pms-sabotaging-your-diet
One of the articles about our issue it explains a lot about it even what to do or avoid0 -
JRsLateInLifeMom wrote: »https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/is-pms-sabotaging-your-diet
One of the articles about our issue it explains a lot about it even what to do or avoid
I find this one very helpful:
Tackle Food Cravings With Exercise
Any physical activity, from swimming to running, that gets the heart going will raise serotonin and lower cortisol levels, Peeke says. Though most experts recommend working out for 30 minutes, four to six times a week, even a 10-minute walk will put a serious dent in your cravings, she says.
Plus, if you sweat a lot, you'll get rid of water and feel less bloated, Wurtman says. And once you get going, anger dissipates, "so you may not feel like murdering your colleagues."
Some studies suggest that mind-body activities such as yoga and tai chi can help calm a woman while lowering cortisol and increasing serotonin levels, Peeke says. And a massage by an experienced therapist evokes the same benefits. "That's also why a good massage makes you so sleepy."
https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/is-pms-sabotaging-your-diet#13 -
One word: NUTELLA4
-
Amen! Nutella for me too! With peanut butter filled pretzels.1
-
Ugh, I thought it was just me, you've just described my last couple of days (apart from waking from sleep). Anything and everything, no particular craving, gimme FOOD!! It's this constant hollow unsatisfied feeling, even after I've just ate and can feel I'm full! I'm getting better at not destroying myself at this time, but its so distracting.1
-
I don't really have PMS cravings for whatever reason (never have) BUT I find my appetite is a lot stronger when I am ovulating and it's the only time of the month that I find myself wanting evening snacks like an egg and toast at 10 pm (usually I don't eat anything after dinner at 6).
I'm more of a stress eater so I crave chocolate and fast food, etc, when something is going on in my life that is what I'd call "medium stressful". Like a fight with a friend or broken appliance. Then I am like "eff my long term awesome progress, give me some cheese sticks or all of the Oreos".1 -
https://www.healthyway.com/content/real-misconceptions-that-men-have-had-about-menstruation/
Lol a fun read of how clueless men/sons are about periods. Fix my grandma discovered has passed down stop being secretive about it! No really they become sweet more understanding! Shower you with shampoo to chocolate 🍫 hide from you instead of being jerks. Do it for the Daughter in laws,Daughters, y Grandkids train a dragon later start with training the men in your life. How we do it stop flushing to hiding pads being ashamed. My hubby bus pads in bulk! My Dad too! My Grandpa did too! My Uncles do too Plus one tossed his granddaughter 9 who started early a private party 🎈 made her feel it wasn’t a bad thing. She hugged him the pictures were cute! Toss them bloody pads upright in the trash can. Say uggh cramps...Where’s the heating pad loudly! Forget to flush every blue moon. Complain darn stomach got diarrhea again can’t wait for this period to be over. Announcement time I’m in my period hun thought I’d give you the heads up...by the way so is our daughter we NEED Chocolate say it in an evil will hurt you tone like your cravings consuming you...without chocolate be a grump when they ask what’s wrong say I don’t know cry say I don’t know what I’m feeling I just want a hug ,chocolate,y YOU you hot thang! They will pass on the thang but come back with bags 💼 of chocolate to pads y gal shampoos to smell goods. Don’t shower for on the heavy days unless you got work let them smell the iron. Leave panties soaking in shout on top of the washer or bathroom sink.They break pretty fast then you can tone it down just leave a pad every blue moon upright announce your cramps in your period lol. Their trained magic.0 -
Most of the people I talk to about PMS say they mostly crave junk food and sweets when they are PMSing and also say that eating the foods they crave usually satisfies the craving. Am I the only one for whom PMS doesn't really cause cravings for particular foods? it makes me crave everything. It's insane some months! I literally want to just eat non-stop and it doesn't really matter what. Everything that isn't nailed down and a few things that are. I mean, sweet and starchy foods sound particularly tempting but anything goes really. And it's not just cravings, I feel RAVENOUS pretty much non-stop. And no matter how much I eat there's always lingering feeling of hunger. It's like I just ate a huge meal, and I can feel it still in my stomach and yet, there's this uncomfortable hollow-like sensation in my stomach like I'm still starving. I swear, there were days where I let myself eat thousands of calories and it was still there. I feel like I can't get full no matter how much I eat. I mean, even before eating I can already feel that I won't be able to satisfy it no matter how much i eat, if it makes sense? And still I can't really stop eating, it's almost a compulsive drive. I wake up several times throughout the night because i feel hungry and I wake up starving in the morning even if I ate at night! It drives me crazy. All I can think is food! The usual "just eat at maintenance", "drink more watre", "eat more portein/fat/fiber/more frequantly" etc. make me want to both laugh and cry at the same time... I hate how hormones can control our life so much...
Please tell me I'm not the only one like that! It's not only about the fact ruins my progress every time, but I just literally can't focus on anything besides food for several days, 2 weeks straight sometimes, it's so frustrating!
Nope - you're not the only one. I get more tired, more hungry and far more lazy one-to-two weeks before Aunt Flo arrives. I gain at least 1.5kg of water weight and my chest feel like two boulders. I have upped my protein intake, and it has helped my cycle cravings significantly (they were really low!), but for the most part - the cravings are still there and cause my angst. I have increased my calories slighty (roughly 150-200 cal) so I can satisfy my craving.
But it is a guessing game, and my hormonal cravings are different month to month. I just remind myself that any gain is just temporary and will disappear as soon as Aunt Flo arrives.0 -
I tend to crave chocolate, fatty foods and extremely salty foods. The week of my menses, I have no appetite so it normally evens out.0
-
Yep, I swear there is no food out there that will actually make me feel full.0
-
leejoyce31 wrote: »Some women are more sensitive to hormonal fluctuations than others. Sometimes, this sensitivity can result in compulsive overeating and/or binge eating behaviors. Since not every woman experiences it, oftentimes they may advise you to do the usual 3 things that you listed.
The only thing that resolved my food issues was to get my hormonal issues under control. After that was done, I no longer have food cravings. Sometimes, I may have a slight uptick in appetite in that my normal meals don't satisfy me. When that happens, I'll just put a tiny bit of L-glutamine powder on a spoon and take that. Then I'm fine. That may not work for you.
Thanks for your advice, @leejoyce31 How did you manage to get your hormonal issues under control, if you don't mind me asking? I tried bringing it up with my GP and gyno the last time, but they both didn't seem too concerned and said the usual "eat more balanced meals/more protein/fiber/avoid sweets", which left me frustrated and made me fish I didn't bring it up at all.
It's interesting what you're saying actually, because I've struggled with binge eating pretty much since puberty. At some point it turned into a binge-restrict cycle. For the longest time I thought, I was binging simply because I had no self-control or because I was too hungry from restricting my intake. Then when I realized that my eating patterns were disordered, I started thinking that the urges to binge were mostly psychological. When I finally broke the binge-restrict cycle and started to eat normally, I realized that it's definitely very physical and also isn't caused by undereating and that there's a certain pattern to it. But I was on the pill at that time and didn't think I could have a cycle or PMS since I wasn't ovulating. It took me a long time to connect it to hormones, because of the pill and because its pattern was never very regular. I had month where I didn't experience these bottomless-pit days and then other months it was almost non-stop, other times it would last for 4-5 days every 2-4 weeks etc. But this irregularity may be a symptoms of some hormonal issues, like you said.
I went off the pill 6 months ago, had what appeared like 3 normal cycles (but probably was just withdrawal bleeding) and since then no period (no chance of pregnancy). At first the bottomless-pit days were gone so I thought they might have been caused by the pill. But then they came back in full force, if not worse!
If my period doesn't come back soon, I will go see a gyno again, but not sure how to bring up the hunger issue... I feel somewhat ashamed talking about it, especially when people almost always say something along the lines of "yeah, most women have it! stop exaggerating, stop complaining, woman up and learn some self-control!". I'm expecting my gyno won't even be really concerned with me missing my period for so long as from what I've heard /read it's very common and doctors usually say to just wait it out.
Most tips on the internet and books about stabilizing your hormones post-pill is about getting in proper nutrition and taking magnesium, B vitamins, Omega-3's and iron supplements. Tried all of this, no luck. Some advice herbs like Vitex Agnus, but from what I've read it seems like a powerful herb and I'm afraid to mess up my hormones even more with it. Not sure what else I can try...0 -
kshama2001 wrote: »
I find this one very helpful:
Tackle Food Cravings With Exercise
Any physical activity, from swimming to running, that gets the heart going will raise serotonin and lower cortisol levels, Peeke says. Though most experts recommend working out for 30 minutes, four to six times a week, even a 10-minute walk will put a serious dent in your cravings, she says.
Plus, if you sweat a lot, you'll get rid of water and feel less bloated, Wurtman says. And once you get going, anger dissipates, "so you may not feel like murdering your colleagues."
Some studies suggest that mind-body activities such as yoga and tai chi can help calm a woman while lowering cortisol and increasing serotonin levels, Peeke says. And a massage by an experienced therapist evokes the same benefits. "That's also why a good massage makes you so sleepy."
https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/is-pms-sabotaging-your-diet#1
I usually feel very weak and fatigued on top of the cravings and hunger, but still I exercise and then end up even hungrier most of the time...
But this article mentions eating carbs to up serotonin and it made me think of another article I found somewhat helpful. It recommends eating a snack containing 30-35g of starchy or sweet carbs (no fruit or fructose, less than 2g of protein and as little fat as possible) on an empty stomach. I can't say it's a magical solution, but it seems to work sometimes to take the edge off of the cravings. Thought the ravenous hunger and hollow sensation in my stomach is still there...
1 -
My PMS cravings are intense, I want to eat everything in sight! I have found going for a run helps and also making sure to have a high protein/high fat snack as carbs just don't satiate me in the slightest
0 -
Mine are pretty bad. I mostly crave starchy carbs - potatoes, pasta, breads. But even above that, I just want to eat everything. It's similar for me to being on prednisone, if you ever have been put on that. Nothing will help satisfy me either. I do tend to try to distract myself a lot, but for a few days at least my cramps are so bad, i'm incredibly bloated and swollen and i'm so tired and irritated with the world I just want to lay around and watch tv with my cat LOL.
I have tried several birth controls, and now I have an IUD, but nothing has ever been able to curb my PMS. It was worse being on nothing, so I am thankful at least for some improvement....but you are not alone.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions