Cheat Days
bjkoziara
Posts: 158 Member
I am sure many people have shared their sentiments on "cheat days", but I wanted to get something off my chest.
I struggle(d) with disordered eating. Not an eating disorder - there is a difference - but a disordered thought pattern surrounding food, and a very unhealthy relationship with it.
There were a lot of different ways that these thoughts presented themselves; but the biggest part of it for me (and by far the most disturbingly normalized part) was assigning value to foods, which came along with failed attempts at cutting out entire food groups that I deemed to have a negative value, and feeling guilt, shame, and embarrassment when I would "cheat".
But cheat on what, exactly? A healthier lifestyle? A healthy lifestyle can (and should) include all kinds of food! Sure, there are some foods that have more to offer nutritionally, but something I am working every day to remember is that food is not inherently "good" or "bad". If I have a donut for breakfast, I'm not "being bad" or having a "cheat" meal, but simply enjoying a donut for breakfast.
It took me a long time and a lot of failed attempts at losing weight before this all clicked for me. I worked through some of it and still deal with my binging problem. It's been more than a month since my last binge, and I found this article particularly helpful in bringing me back down to Earth. I'm working to identify some of the triggers that cause me to binge, and one of the biggest ones was labeling foods as "bad". That always lead to guilt, and before I knew it, feeling guilty about having that one "cheat" donut turned into shame-eating an entire box of them.
I'm not implying that anyone who uses the term cheat day or cheat meal has an eating disorder, or even that they struggle with any sort of disordered eating. What I am saying is that it's a far too normalized way of thinking about food in general, and can certainly contribute or lead to some potentially dangerous ways of thinking about food.
I struggle(d) with disordered eating. Not an eating disorder - there is a difference - but a disordered thought pattern surrounding food, and a very unhealthy relationship with it.
There were a lot of different ways that these thoughts presented themselves; but the biggest part of it for me (and by far the most disturbingly normalized part) was assigning value to foods, which came along with failed attempts at cutting out entire food groups that I deemed to have a negative value, and feeling guilt, shame, and embarrassment when I would "cheat".
But cheat on what, exactly? A healthier lifestyle? A healthy lifestyle can (and should) include all kinds of food! Sure, there are some foods that have more to offer nutritionally, but something I am working every day to remember is that food is not inherently "good" or "bad". If I have a donut for breakfast, I'm not "being bad" or having a "cheat" meal, but simply enjoying a donut for breakfast.
It took me a long time and a lot of failed attempts at losing weight before this all clicked for me. I worked through some of it and still deal with my binging problem. It's been more than a month since my last binge, and I found this article particularly helpful in bringing me back down to Earth. I'm working to identify some of the triggers that cause me to binge, and one of the biggest ones was labeling foods as "bad". That always lead to guilt, and before I knew it, feeling guilty about having that one "cheat" donut turned into shame-eating an entire box of them.
I'm not implying that anyone who uses the term cheat day or cheat meal has an eating disorder, or even that they struggle with any sort of disordered eating. What I am saying is that it's a far too normalized way of thinking about food in general, and can certainly contribute or lead to some potentially dangerous ways of thinking about food.
28
Replies
-
Sounds like you are well on your way to developing a healthier relationship with foods, congrats for that! I agree with you. Rather than having a cheat meal or day, I prefer to work foods, and meals, that some may consider cheating, into my daily calorie budget. It seems a logical conclusion for losing, and hopefully someday, maintaining a healthy weight.3
-
I grew up in a very controlled home. In many weight loss attempts I confused cheating with an immoral act and once the act was committed the seal was broken and I just went to town. If you are going to feel guilty you might as well have A LOT to feel guilty about.
I have noticed in my time here for some people the idea of cheating adds to their pleasure. They want to feel "naughty". I don't know how many of those people went on to be successful. I assume some probably did.
I don't cheat. Ever. I live my life and that means that a select number of days have more calories in them than others. My plan allows for everything from mistakes to overfeeding on vacation... it is just life.
I believe once you figure out how to eat a healthy number of calories and not be hungry weight loss is almost entirely mental. If I need a day off I take one. It is just me managing myself not cheating.9 -
Your article link doesn't work for me.0
-
Your article link doesn't work for me.
Funny enough, when I was searching for it on Google, a thread on MFP that @MikePTY posted recently came up.
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10748201/four-terms-that-make-dietitians-cringe-why-we-say-what-we-do-on-these-boards/p11 -
I don't cheat. Ever. I live my life and that means that a select number of days have more calories in them than others. My plan allows for everything from mistakes to overfeeding on vacation... it is just life.
I believe once you figure out how to eat a healthy number of calories and not be hungry weight loss is almost entirely mental. If I need a day off I take one. It is just me managing myself not cheating.
Absolutely. What many call "cheating", and what I used to as well, I now think of as living my life.
I also used to struggle with "falling of the wagon". I would have a day where I went over on calories, feel guilt and shame again, and then think that I'd already set myself back, so what's the point of continuing?
Now, it's just life. I try not to have emotions associated with food anymore. Even good ones. Emotional eating is how I got to be 360 pounds, so not attaching those feelings to food anymore has been successful. Now I try to think of it as an energy source instead.
3 -
I don't cheat. Ever. I live my life and that means that a select number of days have more calories in them than others. My plan allows for everything from mistakes to overfeeding on vacation... it is just life.
I believe once you figure out how to eat a healthy number of calories and not be hungry weight loss is almost entirely mental. If I need a day off I take one. It is just me managing myself not cheating.
Absolutely. What many call "cheating", and what I used to as well, I now think of as living my life.
I also used to struggle with "falling of the wagon". I would have a day where I went over on calories, feel guilt and shame again, and then think that I'd already set myself back, so what's the point of continuing?
Now, it's just life. I try not to have emotions associated with food anymore. Even good ones. Emotional eating is how I got to be 360 pounds, so not attaching those feelings to food anymore has been successful. Now I try to think of it as an energy source instead.
I like reading things like this because I am as positive as I possibly can be that I will make it all the way to wherever I intend to shift into maintenance. When I see this I believe that you will too. The main thing that changed for me was a shift in mindset. It has made it all easier. Not easy but easier.
2 -
Your article link doesn't work for me.
Funny enough, when I was searching for it on Google, a thread on MFP that @MikePTY posted recently came up.
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10748201/four-terms-that-make-dietitians-cringe-why-we-say-what-we-do-on-these-boards/p1
That was a good find by @MikePTY.1 -
I don't cheat. Ever. I live my life and that means that a select number of days have more calories in them than others. My plan allows for everything from mistakes to overfeeding on vacation... it is just life.
I believe once you figure out how to eat a healthy number of calories and not be hungry weight loss is almost entirely mental. If I need a day off I take one. It is just me managing myself not cheating.
Absolutely. What many call "cheating", and what I used to as well, I now think of as living my life.
I also used to struggle with "falling of the wagon". I would have a day where I went over on calories, feel guilt and shame again, and then think that I'd already set myself back, so what's the point of continuing?
Now, it's just life. I try not to have emotions associated with food anymore. Even good ones. Emotional eating is how I got to be 360 pounds, so not attaching those feelings to food anymore has been successful. Now I try to think of it as an energy source instead.
I like reading things like this because I am as positive as I possibly can be that I will make it all the way to wherever I intend to shift into maintenance. When I see this I believe that you will too. The main thing that changed for me was a shift in mindset. It has made it all easier. Not easy but easier.
Thank you. I'm really glad it's working for you and I know you will definitely get to that point. I used to think to lose weight I had to hate myself enough, but this time around it's because I love myself enough. I just started but I am already sure that I'll get to the point of maintaining2 -
I am struggling to stay on track and thought the prospect of incorporating a planned "cheat day" might help me. Unfortunately, you reminded me of my own unhealthy attitudes toward food. Refined sugars and flour only leave me craving more. Cheat days might work for some people, but I think I'm better off not to indulge.0
-
Thank you so much for sharing this! No such things as good and bad foods. Just moderation.0
-
@bjkorovka This was exactly what I needed to read today. I am horrible about this. Anytime I eat anything not on my 'approved list of foods' I feel like a failure. It is a mindset. I need balance and to not think of food as the enemy. Thanks for your wisdom.1
-
I am also trying to learn not to be afraid of food. I am working on recovering from anorexia. This post has been very inspiring0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions