diet soda? Yay or nay?
hollieponine
Posts: 14 Member
Let’s talk diet soda.....
I feel like I drink too much of it.
My husband thinks I need to completely stop.
Does anyone think it’s okay?
Does anyone think it’s terrible?
And.... go!
I feel like I drink too much of it.
My husband thinks I need to completely stop.
Does anyone think it’s okay?
Does anyone think it’s terrible?
And.... go!
0
Replies
-
I don't drink coffee. I rarely drink tea. I'm a night owl who gets up early. If it weren't for diet cola, I'd have no caffeine at all.1
-
This is a very "danger, Will Robinson" topic on these boards.10
-
i started drinking it when i started losing weight. helps keep me full.3
-
Not a problem at all.
I’ve been drinking Diet Pepsi for almost 50 years, and I’m still living with no diseases and on no prescription medications. I tend to drink more water now days, but I still bought 4-12 packs of Diet Pepsi on sale this week for $10 for the 4th of July. It always goes on sale for holidays where I shop.3 -
How much of it do you think is 'too much'? Why is it too much? What is it that you think is wrong with it? Is it causing you some kind of health problem?1
-
How much of it do you think is 'too much'? Why is it too much? What is it that you think is wrong with it? Is it causing you some kind of health problem?
I just hear horror stories over it and then hear that it’s okay and not sure which is best for me. Personally, it dehydrates me if I drink too much of it. I was on IV fluids a couple of weeks ago due to being dehydrated and I think diet soda and no water may have been the culprit.
7 -
The only downsides to diet soda
- if you drink caffeinated sodas and suddenly stop. Caffeine withdrawals are horrible.
- A very small number of people (less than 1%) may have an allergic reaction to one or more artificial sweeteners.
- There is growing evidence that too much phosphoric acid (an additive in ALL soda, especially cola) can leech calcium from the bones leading to early osteoporosis
In other words, too much soda in general may not be good for you. Unless you have a sensitivity or allergy to artificial sweeteners there is nothing inherently bad about diet soda.
If you think you may be drinking too much (personally I would think that more than a 2 liter, 6 cans, or 3 bottles per day is too much, but that is IMHO) try substituting something like still water or seltzer for some of it. Only you can determine if you are drinking too much.1 -
I would think it'd be okay in moderation. So long as your soda levels don't exceed how much water you drink.10
-
There’s no reason not to drink it unless you have an allergy or other health problem related to ingredient(s) in the soda.4
-
I agree this is a touchy subject on MFP for whatever reason. I usually get a ton of "woos" no matter what I say about it, which is kinda funny to me.
I like the taste & carbonation of diet soda especially with certain foods like homemade pizza. I always have some in the fridge. I'd say I go through a 12 pack in a month, usually. I am maintaining a loss of about 130 lb for years.
I also drink stuff like Bubly and La Croix, though less often...and honestly, I don't find those to be a good substitute for Diet Pepsi and Diet Dr. Pepper...to me they're totally different. Some really like that substitution though and find it satisfactory when trying to cut out specific sweeteners.
In the past (before using MFP), I drank almost exclusively diet soda. I would have a can with lunch and dinner, coffee with breakfast, and typically drank no other water or beverage at all. I think that was not a great thing and I needed more hydration and sometimes snacked or had lattes etc, because I was thirsty rather than hungry...just didn't realize it. Everyone's a little different with stuff like this, but that's my .02 on diet soda...I think it's fine, but am careful not to get in the habit of drinking it 24/7 instead of water.4 -
seltzermint555 wrote: »I agree this is a touchy subject on MFP for whatever reason. I usually get a ton of "woos" no matter what I say about it, which is kinda funny to me.
I like the taste & carbonation of diet soda especially with certain foods like homemade pizza. I always have some in the fridge. I'd say I go through a 12 pack in a month, usually. I am maintaining a loss of about 130 lb for years.
I also drink stuff like Bubly and La Croix, though less often...and honestly, I don't find those to be a good substitute for Diet Pepsi and Diet Dr. Pepper...to me they're totally different. Some really like that substitution though and find it satisfactory when trying to cut out specific sweeteners.
In the past (before using MFP), I drank almost exclusively diet soda. I would have a can with lunch and dinner, coffee with breakfast, and typically drank no other water or beverage at all. I think that was not a great thing and I needed more hydration and sometimes snacked or had lattes etc, because I was thirsty rather than hungry...just didn't realize it. Everyone's a little different with stuff like this, but that's my .02 on diet soda...I think it's fine, but am careful not to get in the habit of drinking it 24/7 instead of water.
It is touchy, yes.
And I totally agree about not letting myself get in the habit of drinking it 24/7 instead of water.
2 -
I rarely drink soft drinks, but when I do I drink diet if my calories can't support regular; and regular if my calories can support it.
Edit: I never developed the "taste" for sodas, so when I say I rarely have one, I mean once every 3-4 months. I do like Topo Chico as a change from plain water and have one of those every few weeks.0 -
I think if you’re asking the question, you know the answer.
If it wasn’t bothering you in some way, why would you ask?3 -
corinasue1143 wrote: »I think if you’re asking the question, you know the answer.
If it wasn’t bothering you in some way, why would you ask?
Maybe looking for points about it being really horrible/unhealthy that she hadn't heard? That is my guess.4 -
hollieponine wrote: »How much of it do you think is 'too much'? Why is it too much? What is it that you think is wrong with it? Is it causing you some kind of health problem?
I just hear horror stories over it and then hear that it’s okay and not sure which is best for me. Personally, it dehydrates me if I drink too much of it. I was on IV fluids a couple of weeks ago due to being dehydrated and I think diet soda and no water may have been the culprit.
It has a net hydration effect slightly higher than water though, right? I'm not sure how it would dehydrate you?
I'm also a big fan of this thread for one of the sweeteners common in diet soda: https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1308408/why-aspartame-isnt-scary/p114 -
hollieponine wrote: »How much of it do you think is 'too much'? Why is it too much? What is it that you think is wrong with it? Is it causing you some kind of health problem?
I just hear horror stories over it and then hear that it’s okay and not sure which is best for me. Personally, it dehydrates me if I drink too much of it. I was on IV fluids a couple of weeks ago due to being dehydrated and I think diet soda and no water may have been the culprit.
Why do you think they dehydrate you? A diet soda is like 99% a glass of water
Artificial sweeteners are some of the most studied food additives in human history. The horror stories come from research where they basically marinate rats with insane amounts of the sweetener to get something scary to happen.
Some people say they have some kind of reaction to a specific artificial sweetener, trouble digesting them, or that they can be migraine trigger.
Too much carbonation can be an issue for some people's digestion, so they might have to watch how much of any bubbly beverage they consume.
If for whatever reason you feel like you drink "too much" then cut back, it's not necessary for you to drink a lot. But if you enjoy it, don't feel like you need to cut it out, there's nothing wrong with it, and there's no proof behind the fear mongering. I drink a can a day usually, and there are women in my family who have been drinking diet soda daily since the 60s with no ill effects!6 -
Everything in moderation is fine IMO. Could it negative health consequences over years and years and years? Maybe. Does it effect different people differently? Probably.
I think it’s just like everything in the world. If you enjoy it enough just do it in moderation and be smart about it.
I drink diet soda on a daily basis. Don’t really notice any effects day to day. I do notice though that if I stop for a couple days for whatever reason, I do feel a slight reduction in water retention for me personally. I don’t drink insane amounts, maybe a cup or two a day.
If it’s causing you problems, or you’re concerned about it, then try stopping. I’d say for 95% of people it’s a habit and maybe a slight addiction, but once broken I don’t think it would really be missed much.0 -
I drink Diet Coke and Pepsi Max every single day. I might have around 4x330ml cans and I’ll pour myself around 3 or 4 glasses from the bottle. It hasn’t stopped me losing any weight as I’ve lost 40lbs since February. Prior to losing weight, I would drink the same amount of full sugar soda but I’ve not had any for around 6 months now.0
-
Studies have shown that for some people, artificial sweeteners increase appetite. However, many users on MFP have said that this is not true for them.
I avoid artificial sweeteners because to me they taste nasty.
If you want to stop diet soda but not caffeine, alternatives are coffee, tea, or caffeine pills.0 -
I don't drink soda anymore. I never really drank much but once I saw the complete lack of nutrition in it, I didn't feel it was worth it at all.2
-
100 yays.
I don’t keep it in the house but when I go out diet sodas that’s my go to.
Why does your hubby want you to stop?
0 -
I like diet soda and drink it occasionally (mainly Diet Coke and diet ginger ales, occasional diet root beer or cream soda). I limit it because I love coffee and don't really need more caffeine in my life. I also like plain water (ideally cold), sparkling water, LaCroix, homemade iced tea (I tend to use fruity or herbal teas).
I find diet soda (as with other beverages) tend to make me less hungry, not more, and I sometimes went through periods where I drank no soda and at other times drank more (I took a break from coffee at one point), and it made 0 difference for me.1 -
I hear nothing good about it - what it's doing to our brains and bodies and still drink it. I intend to wean myself off - or at least cut it down to where it's a treat...looking for something with some actual health benefits which is does not have.15
-
I love diet coke, and have drank it for years. I think one per day is fine.0
-
jfeather01 wrote: »I hear nothing good about it - what it's doing to our brains and bodies and still drink it. I intend to wean myself off - or at least cut it down to where it's a treat...looking for something with some actual health benefits which is does not have.
Then you're listening to the wrong people
I don't feel like it's necessary to get health benefits from every single thing I consume every day, and I think the enjoyment I get is more than enough benefit. Besides, there is water in diet soda, so I'm getting the health benefits of hydration. And it often subs for an unnecessary snack, so it helps me keep my calories down!15 -
I enjoy drinking the equivalent of about 3 cans of diet soda per week.
I like it and it has no ill effects for me - although I do take the point about osteporosus risk ( with all sodas,not just diet ones!)
Given I am not in a high risk group and 3 cans per week is moderation in any language, that seems ok to me.1 -
Diet soda is essentially just carbonated water with some artificial flavourings (which have no additional nutritional value) added to it. Even when it contains caffeine, which is slightly diuretic, it can't dehydrate you. So if you were dehydrated while drinking it, there was definitely something else going on there to cause dehydration - either you were drinking less than you needed or you were sweating more, or something else.
Some people get stomach pain from drinking too many carbonated drinks. Some people say it makes them crave sweet foods. Neither of those have ever been true for me personally, but if they're true for you then obviously you might want to think about stopping. Personally, I find it curbs any sugar cravings I might have, but we're all different.
I know some people are convinced that the artificial sweeteners in diet drinks are bad for you, but personally, I don't think any of the studies stand up to scrutiny. Again, if you feel differently, stop drinking it - but don't stop based on being nagged by someone else. Decide for yourself rather than letting your husband dictate what you do and don't eat or drink. It isn't his choice.
2 -
I drink an epic kitten ton of water so I allow myself a Diet Coke when my soul yearns for one. They're still a pleasure in this dark, critical world of ours and you can pry the occasional fountain beverage from my cold, dead hands.4
-
And it is perfectly okay to eat/drink things from time to time that have no benefit other than you just really freakin' like the taste of them.6
-
This content has been removed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions