Weight training makes me look bigger :/
UmaMageswarymfp
Posts: 280 Member
I’ve been struggling to lose weight since young. I used to weigh 130kg I weigh 113 now. I lost about 17 kg but the thing is I’m not seeing much difference on my body. I’ve been doing a lot of weight training and my coach said that’s helping me lose weight but my concern I stay looking big and not much difference. My shoulders looks so broad to me compared to last time and there was one time throughout the journey I stopped training for 2 weeks. No lifting and out of no where everyone started saying I lost SO much weight. It’s as if only if I stop weight training people notice the difference. Does lifting actually makes one look bigger? I’m a girl btw and my shoulders v broad and I hate it. Should o continue training or stop training and do cardio only? Help pls
2
Replies
-
Here’s a lil difference8 -
Your shoulders look bigger because your waist is smaller. You look great to me.19
-
Thank you but would you recommend me to continue to build muscle or stop to look thinnerquiksylver296 wrote: »Your shoulders look bigger because your waist is smaller. You look great to me.
0 -
Congrats on the loss, I think you look great! There’s a huge difference, maybe you/your coworkers just haven’t noticed much because they see you every day. Your shoulders might seem broader to you because you are standing with better posture and your waist is so much smaller. It also looks like there’s less weight around your arms. I don’t know much about weights but it looks like it has been helping you so far6
-
Congrats on the loss, I think you look great! There’s a huge difference, maybe you/your coworkers just haven’t noticed much because they see you every day. Your shoulders might seem broader to you because you are standing with better posture and your waist is so much smaller. It also looks like there’s less weight around your arms. I don’t know much about weights but it looks like it has been helping you so far
Aww thank you so much 💜
0 -
I think there is an immense difference, pretty much in all body parts. Are you taking measurements?
You see yourself every day, so you are less apt to notice the differences. It's also REALLY hard to be objective about ourselves. In my opinion, whatever you're doing, KEEP DOING IT!4 -
You look smaller and have a healthier looking body composition.
There is well established evidence on the benefits of lifting. Quality and longer life being two important ones.
Discuss with your coach your concerns and long term plans.
Your doing extremely well!4 -
Keep doing what you’re doing you look great! Congratulations on your weight loss 🤗0
-
UmaMageswarymfp wrote: »Thank you but would you recommend me to continue to build muscle or stop to look thinnerquiksylver296 wrote: »Your shoulders look bigger because your waist is smaller. You look great to me.
It is impossible to build muscle while in a calorie deficit. You can however build strength and lose fat which make the muscles you have visible. To build muscle you need a calorie surplus and a lot of weight training. It's also a lot more difficult for women to build muscle than men because of our lower levels of testosterone.
For three years I was the same weight and lifted as heavy as I could and dropped 4 sizes and a lot of inches. People were shocked that I weighed as much as I did because I didn't look it.
I agree that your shoulders look broader because your waist is a lot smaller and that taking measurements will give you a better gauge of your body than visual comparison.
There is the possibility that the reason people noticed your loss "suddenly" when you had a week off is because the body holds water in muscles for repair after the stress of lifting. That is how muscles grow stronger. Every time I have a week off lifting or a lift significantly lighter (a deload week) I drop 4-5 pounds. When I start lifting again that weight comes back gradually so I don't see loss for 2-3 weeks. Everyone's body holds a different amount of water weight for repair.
I would also encourage you to consider the health benefits of weight training. You are preserving/ strengthening bones so you won't break bones as easily when you age. Weight training builds new neural pathways in our brains. This helps reduce dementia, Alzheimer's etc etc. Strength is functional. I love being able to bring in all my groceries in one trip. Pick up my nephew, deadlift more than my bodyweight, etc etc.
Lastly you look great! Keep lifting!5 -
Thank you so much , alright I’ll continue lifting and hope to see more results6
-
I think you’re just developing a great hourglass figure and your smaller waist is making you think your shoulders are bigger. Keep lifting - you won’t build muscle in a hurry I promise - and you’ll get toned and fit as well as building healthy strong bones.4
-
UmaMageswarymfp wrote: »Thank you but would you recommend me to continue to build muscle or stop to look thinnerquiksylver296 wrote: »Your shoulders look bigger because your waist is smaller. You look great to me.
Not sure you want my opinion, because my goal is gaining ALL DA MUSCLE!!!
Below is an old thread, and some of the photo links are broken, but there are some awesome examples of the effects of weight lifting on females.
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/977538/halp-heavy-lifting-made-me-supah-bulky/p15 -
mochapygmy wrote: »UmaMageswarymfp wrote: »Thank you but would you recommend me to continue to build muscle or stop to look thinnerquiksylver296 wrote: »Your shoulders look bigger because your waist is smaller. You look great to me.
It is impossible to build muscle while in a calorie deficit.
Lastly you look great! Keep lifting!
The first line is absolute nonsense.
The second line is good advice.9 -
I think you look fab in picture 2.0
-
I think you look much fitter in the second picture and are no where close to being overly muscular.
Have you been taking measurements? As I lift weights and lose weight, my lying eyes have told me my biceps are bigger, but the tape measure says otherwise.
It takes quite a bit of effort for women to put on significant muscle. I won't say it's impossible to do so in a calorie deficit, but just really, really difficult.1 -
I echo others , you look really good! keep up the good work!0
-
You look fantastic! Well done!0
-
Keep going! Keep lifting!
You look fantastic0 -
Your waist, your hips, arms, very noticeably smaller. Congratulations, great progress!
0 -
You look much better in the second picture0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions