Is there any benefit in exercise if you are still eating badly/too much?
cyaneverfat
Posts: 527 Member
Cause sometimes it seems pointless, or like you shouldn't do it if you aren't fueling your body properly, you know?
0
Replies
-
in my opinion, im no expert, but i would imagine that "exercise and not so great diet" would be better than "no exercise and not so great diet" i meean youve gotta start somewhere and i would imagine exercise would be a good gateway to want to eat better and start fueling your body properly to see better results. but then again its just my opinion19
-
Exercise is good for your body, so you just do it anyway. What do you eat for example and how much over are you on your calories?6
-
L1zardQueen wrote: »Exercise is good for your body, so you just do it anyway. What do you eat for example and how much over are you on your calories?
Just a hypothetical0 -
Its still better than not doing it at all. Lots of people are overweight, and eat a lot, but have a healthy heart and are strong as hell because of exercise.4
-
cyaneverfat wrote: »L1zardQueen wrote: »Exercise is good for your body, so you just do it anyway. What do you eat for example and how much over are you on your calories?
Just a hypothetical
Then you need to properly define the parameters of the hypothetical situation.
Firstly what is your goal? What are you trying to achieve? Performance or weight loss?
How much is 'eating too much' and what do you mean by 'eating badly'? If you're overeating by 500cals per day then you're almost certainly not going to be able to burn that off via exercise so you'll continue to gain, or at least maintain weight. You may see some fitness/health benefits but depending on your current level of fitness you may not be able to work out effectively enough to see much improvement. And depending on your size the choice of exercise you can do safely without risking injury will be limited.
How much exercise is involved and how does your appetite react to working out? It's all well and good to smash out a massive gym session and burn a few hundred calories but that's not going to help you lose weight if you're so hungry afterwards that you end up eating more calories than you burned. On the flip side if you scale back the intensity/amount of exercise to a level that doesn't increase your appetite then there's a chance the number of calories you're burning is very unlikely to overcome even a modest amount of over eating.
You're far better off keeping the two things separate. Eat to lose weight and workout to get fit.11 -
If you're trying to lose weight, then you won't lose weight if you're eating more than you're burning. That being said, like other people have mentioned above, moving and doing exercise is better than not moving so there is still a benefit healthwise even if the weight loss benefit is probably negated by the poor/overeating. Plus if you're eating only the wrong foods, you're going to run out of steam pretty quickly in terms of exercise.1
-
Weight is mostly about what you eat, and health/shape is mostly about exercise, so yes, of course.4
-
Being successful means at least a little discipline. You figure out what you really want and the sacrifices needed to get there. It has to be worth it to you. However, you don't say your age, but sooner or later you have to pay the piper. Better to create good habits when you're younger. Good luck.1
-
Are you sure your head is really in the game OP?
To be blunt your question is coming across as looking for an excuse.
Assuming you wish to be healthier than you are now how can not exercising be a good idea?8 -
It sounds like the hypothetical situation may be reflective of the cognitive bias/distortion "all or nothing thinking".
The thinking goes something like, "I'm not doing everything I can, so why bother doing anything."
I can relate to this thought. It's the thought that keeps me from going to the doctor for preventative care because I'm not taking very good care of myself sometimes. It's the same thought that says, "I can't work out the way I want to on the schedule I prefer, so I won't do any of it." It's the thought that says, "You've already messed up your day with that lemon donut from the coffee stand, so you might as well eat the cake in the break room."
There are significant benefits to exercise that have nothing to do with weight loss: decreased stress, increased resting metabolic rate, increased bone density, improved immune function, mood improvement, better sleep, decreased risk for a BUNCH of diseases including stroke, hypertension, type 2 diabetes, arthritis, depression, etc.
Of course you'll see more health benefits from getting to and maintaing a healthy weight while also being physically active.
And if you're a perfectionist or type A kind of person, learning to embrace the imperfect and doing what you can on any given day while also recognizing the definition of "what you can" will change from day to day depending on other variables probably serve you better in the long run than getting the "f*** its" and spending long stretches of time doing little or nothing to support your health.7 -
NuggetLovesEdie wrote: »It sounds like the hypothetical situation may be reflective of the cognitive bias/distortion "all or nothing thinking".
The thinking goes something like, "I'm not doing everything I can, so why bother doing anything."
I can relate to this thought. It's the thought that keeps me from going to the doctor for preventative care because I'm not taking very good care of myself sometimes. It's the same thought that says, "I can't work out the way I want to on the schedule I prefer, so I won't do any of it." It's the thought that says, "You've already messed up your day with that lemon donut from the coffee stand, so you might as well eat the cake in the break room."
There are significant benefits to exercise that have nothing to do with weight loss: decreased stress, increased resting metabolic rate, increased bone density, improved immune function, mood improvement, better sleep, decreased risk for a BUNCH of diseases including stroke, hypertension, type 2 diabetes, arthritis, depression, etc.
Of course you'll see more health benefits from getting to and maintaing a healthy weight while also being physically active.
And if you're a perfectionist or type A kind of person, learning to embrace the imperfect and doing what you can on any given day while also recognizing the definition of "what you can" will change from day to day depending on other variables probably serve you better in the long run than getting the "f*** its" and spending long stretches of time doing little or nothing to support your health.
Brilliant thank you. The kind of answer I needed.0 -
-
cyaneverfat wrote: »
As someone who regrets staying fat for 20 years (fat but fit as it happens) I would say that getting my head straight and realising I was using an excuse for not taking full responsibility for my actions (or inaction) were the most important steps in the whole process of losing my excess weight, keeping it off and getting far healthier and fitter.8 -
I hope you do "get there" but it is a process.
Four surprising benefits to me when I started getting regular exercise were:
1. I could eat a bit more. If you are using Myfitnesspal and you exercise, the way the calculations work, you can eat a little more on those days.
2. When I exercise it makes it easier to stay in goal (calorie wise.) I'm not as hungry and I've also taken an hour to do something enjoyable and good for me.
3. When I exercise, I tend to want to get other things accomplished AND I tend to want to eat better and with better nutrition. It's a snowball effect of doing the right thing and the healthy thing for myself.
4. I sleep so much better and have much less anxiety on days I exercise. This in itself makes exercise worth it.4 -
Exercise is beneficial regardless but you will have more energy and feel better eating healthier choices.1
-
riffraff2112 wrote: »Its still better than not doing it at all. Lots of people are overweight, and eat a lot, but have a healthy heart and are strong as hell because of exercise.
This.
When I was obese (for 20 years) I was always RELATIVELY healthy for my weight and I think getting exercise and eating somewhat healthy food (but too much of it) was a big part of that, along with genetics.1 -
Absolutely! In my experience when people make drastic changes to their diet without exercising it rarely ever sticks. Lifting can help you retain muscle and burn more calories long term and any cardio/conditioning work will help burn some extra calories while conditioning your energy systems (metabolism).1
-
For well over a decade, I was very active (even competing as an athlete in a short-endurance sport - not a star, but "in the pack" in performance results with others of my age, many of whom were not obese).
Comparing myself to peers (i.e., friends and relatives, so people I actually know) of similar weight, there were numerous advantages to being relatively fit while fat, versus fat and unfit. I was stronger, had better endurance, my resting heart rate was lower, and more.
Still, I wasn't "healthy": My blood pressure was high-normal, my cholesterol/triglycerides were high, I experienced some health issues that are normally correlated with obesity (even though non-obese people can experience them, too) such as cancer and gallbladder adenomyomatosis.
I agree with others above that getting one's head in the game, figuring out ways for your current self to be happy and satisfied but still give your future self better odds of the same, avoiding the trap of all or nothing thinking, taking control of the things you can personally control or influence to make change . . . those are really important.
But I think it's fine to start with the things that are easiest for you, personally, and proceed from there. If exercise is easier for you than diet, it's a fine on-ramp to improved health. Just gradually keep heading up onto the health highway.2 -
Every activity carries a benefit and harm. Thinking of exercise and diet as two sides of an equation - moderate exercise certainly isn't going to hurt, but serves as a great mitigator with several other benefits outside of CICO.
Comparing two subjects:
Subject A eats 2000 kcals/day and burns 300 kcals through exercise. If their BMR is 1500 this amounts to a 200 kcal surplus.
Subject B east 2000 kcals/day and doesn't exercise. If their BMR is 1500 this amounts to a 500 kcal surplus.1 -
cyaneverfat wrote: »Cause sometimes it seems pointless, or like you shouldn't do it if you aren't fueling your body properly, you know?
Exercise is good for you regardless. I'm a former competitive athlete and I can tell you my nutrition was nowhere near optimal...I still was very fit and kicked *kitten*.
There are numerous health benefits from regular exercise outside of weight loss or weight management. Regular exercise is one of the single best things you can do for your body.1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions