can teas/splenda be counted as your water intake

Options
i drink a lot of tea and i have heard you can count it as you water intake and i have heard you cant. i was wondering if i can count drinking tea or not? i dont use sugar but i do use a lot of splenda
«1

Replies

  • sleepy7
    sleepy7 Posts: 104
    Options
    i would count it. it's just better to know
  • SamiSamiBoBlammy
    SamiSamiBoBlammy Posts: 868 Member
    Options
    No. water is water. if you add something to it - it becomes something else.

    ONLY count water toward your daily goal of 8
  • katheern
    katheern Posts: 213 Member
    Options
    I only count decaffeinated tea and water of course. Nothing with splenda or caffeine.
  • perduec
    perduec Posts: 3
    Options
    Tea is mostly water so yes. I took a nutrition class a while ago and the instructor told us milk counts as well.
  • brendalyne
    brendalyne Posts: 497
    Options
    I personally only count water as water. I keep a 32 oz insulated mug with me at all times and drink 3 of them a day. It's my understanding that tea can be a diuretic...that's why I don't count it when I do drink it.
  • katheern
    katheern Posts: 213 Member
    Options
    I personally only count water as water. I keep a 32 oz insulated mug with me at all times and drink 3 of them a day. It's my understanding that tea can be a diuretic...that's why I don't count it when I do drink it.

    Only tea with caffeine because caffeine is a diuretic. Decaf is fine.
  • ProTFitness
    ProTFitness Posts: 1,379 Member
    Options
    Splenda is worse then sugar! Research it! All artifical sweetners cause more healthy problem then people realize
  • Misslissa16
    Options
    Anything with caffeine actually acts as a diuretic so i would say if its caffinated then no.
  • perduec
    perduec Posts: 3
    Options
    No. water is water. if you add something to it - it becomes something else.

    ONLY count water toward your daily goal of 8

    The point is just to stay hydrated, so I don't think flavoring the water with tea or anything else changes the fact that it is keeping you hydrated.
  • TourThePast
    TourThePast Posts: 1,753 Member
    Options
    No. water is water. if you add something to it - it becomes something else.
    Poppycock. What if you drink water at the same time as eating something? It all gets churned together in your stomach, there's nothing magical about pure water.

    Obviously alcohol which is dehydrating should not be counted and don't drink exclusively drinks which are mildly diuretic such as tea or coffee, but even food with a high water content counts.

    By the way, the eight glasses a day thing is an average requirement and is highly dependent on factors such as activity level, size and climate; the research that figure came from was never designed to create a suggested intake of water.

    If you are peeing several times a day, and your pee is a light straw colour, you're drinking enough. Though, of course, drinking more might help you feel full and stop you overeating, but that's a different matter.

    Don't take my word for it, google reporting of research papers.
  • ProTFitness
    ProTFitness Posts: 1,379 Member
    Options
    Why Artificial Sweeteners are Bad For You and the Planet
    If you ingest these sweeteners without a second thought, it might be time to think again.

    Trying to keep your weight down and trying to be healthy can be totally different things. There was a time in my life when I believed that sugar-free foods and drinks were actually good for me. I was drinking sugar-free Red Bulls and dumping Splenda into my morning coffee like my life depended on it. I'm a little embarrassed to admit that I considered myself healthy then.

    I always heard negative things about artificial sweeteners in passing, but dodged conversations about it and pretended like I didn't hear or read anything knocking the merit of the products. What can I say? I was addicted to caffeine and totally uninterested in ditching my habit. (And who doesn't love a low-calorie caffeine fix?)

    But after learning a thing or two about artificial sweeteners, I've left my sugar-free energy drink toting days behind me.

    Some facts about artificial sweeteners that made me change my mind:

    1.They are chemicals or natural compounds that replace the sweetness of sugar, without all of the calories. But sometimes the label 'sugar-free' masks calories present in the food or drink. Of course you can always read the product's label, but believe it or not, there are a whole lot of people out there who think that sugar-free or fat-free means low-calorie. On top of that, there are some recent studies that have shown that artificial sweeteners can actually increase your appetite. And then there are sugar-free products with ingredients that can raise your blood sugar dramatically—like the white flour in sugar-free cookies. All in all, 'sugar-free' doesn't always mean 'diet-friendly'.



    2.Aspartame (NutraSweet, Equal, NatraSweet, Canderel, Spoonfuls, DiabetiSweet) is a common chemical sweetener with possible side effects that sound like they're out of a horror movie. From hallucinations to seizures to brain tumors, it is hardly worth consuming for the sake of saved calories.




    3.Sucralose (Otherwise known as Splenda, my past-sweetener of choice), is scary. Recent research suggests that Splenda can enlarge both the liver and kidneys and shrink the thymus glands. Sucralose breaks down into small amounts of dichlorofructose, which has not been tested adequately tested in humans. Splenda reportedly can cause skin rashes, panic, diarrhea, headaches, bladder issues, stomach pain, and those side effects don't even sum it up.



    Think this sounds bad? Do some further research. Most artificial sweeteners on store shelves are accompanied by numerous side-effect stories. (Some recent studies suggest they cause cancer. Should something as serious as cancer really be overlooked?) Research also suggests that they actually cause overeating among consumers.




    In addition to all of this, consider the waste involved in the industry of artificially sweetening. Ever stepped into a coffee shop and noticed a mound of sugar substitute packets building on the counter or in the trash? We've been wasting one of our most precious resources for the sake of a sweetener that can harm our bodies and prevent weight loss. It sounds unfathomable, but true nonetheless.

    What you can do instead to get your sugar fix:

    Turn to natural sweeteners for your drinks and food alike. Honey, organic maple syrup, molasses, date sugar, brown rice syrup, and stevia are just a few natural sweeteners you can turn to. Not only will they wreak less havoc on your body, but your support of these sweeteners instead will, eventually, help to slow the production of toxic artificial sweeteners--which are significantly less delicious in my opinion anyway
  • MJLavaty
    MJLavaty Posts: 72 Member
    Options
    I count tea towards it but I always get over 8 even with my 2 glasses.
  • NicoleLyn1818
    Options
    Tea is mostly water so yes. I took a nutrition class a while ago and the instructor told us milk counts as well.

    Milk should not count as water intake....it has calories, carbs, sugar and whatnot in it. That is not water.
  • Hope228
    Hope228 Posts: 340 Member
    Options
    Splenda is worse then sugar! Research it! All artifical sweetners cause more healthy problem then people realize



    I agree. As a brain tumor survivor, my Neurologist made me get rid of all sugar substitutes!
  • SimplyDeLish
    Options
    The idea is to stay hydrated.. While MFP suggests 8, 8 oz glasses of water a day - that is not a magical number. Some of us need more, some less. If you prefer tea to water drink it!

    You know what works for you!
  • plainjoe81
    plainjoe81 Posts: 53 Member
    Options
    I give you permission to count it as water.
  • SamiSamiBoBlammy
    SamiSamiBoBlammy Posts: 868 Member
    Options
    No. water is water. if you add something to it - it becomes something else.
    Poppycock. What if you drink water at the same time as eating something? It all gets churned together in your stomach, there's nothing magical about pure water.

    Obviously alcohol which is dehydrating should not be counted and don't drink exclusively drinks which are mildly diuretic such as tea or coffee, but even food with a high water content counts.

    By the way, the eight glasses a day thing is an average requirement and is highly dependent on factors such as activity level, size and climate; the research that figure came from was never designed to create a suggested intake of water.

    If you are peeing several times a day, and your pee is a light straw colour, you're drinking enough. Though, of course, drinking more might help you feel full and stop you overeating, but that's a different matter.

    Don't take my word for it, google reporting of research papers.

    I agree, research it.

    8 is not a magic number (nor is 1200 calories) but it's a standard goal for many people. Those research papers are not saying drink *8 glasses of liquid*, they are saying drink *8 glasses of WATER*

    Plus your pee should not be a light straw color - it should be practically clear.
  • NoAdditives
    NoAdditives Posts: 4,251 Member
    Options
    Personally, I only count plain water in my water count. But, all beverages and a lot of foods do have water in them and that water does help keep you hydrated. Whether or not you want to count it is up to you. I have two glasses of homemade decaf/herbal tea in my food diary today that I could count as water, but I won't. I put them in my meals instead because my tea is lightly sweetened and I won't count them in both places, just as I wouldn't count juice or a soda twice.

    And I also agree that artificial sweeteners are terrible for your health. Cane sugar isn't great but at least it's natural and in moderation it isn't a big deal health wise. But artificial sweeteners are chemical compounds that aren't natural and our bodies don't react well to exposure from them. Aspartame is actually on the EPA's list of most dangerous chemicals. Splenda is a chlorocarbon that is dangerous for our bodies. Stevia comes from a plant and other countries have been using it in small quantities for decades, but I can't stand the taste. You're better off cutting out sweetened foods and beverages from your diet as much as possible and enjoying them as treats once in a while.
  • fudgebudget
    fudgebudget Posts: 198 Member
    Options
    Milk should not count as water intake....it has calories, carbs, sugar and whatnot in it. That is not water.

    Milk is a hydrating liquid, therefore it can count as one of your glasses of water as long as you also log it with the rest of your calories and don't consider it a freebie. The point of the 8 glasses of water is to ensure that you're not getting dehydrated.
  • anitademonte
    anitademonte Posts: 1 Member
    Options
    If it is a caffeinated, you are dehydrating; so no. In fact, for every 8 ounces of a caffeinated drink, you have to drink 12 ounces of water to offset it. That is in addition to the water you should be drinking daily. As a veteran sports and health enthusiast, this is gospel truth.