avoiding the scales, don't want to be disappointed,

alltalk199
alltalk199 Posts: 275
edited October 2024 in Introduce Yourself
Hi, I am new to my fitness pal, started last week, great site, great info, great bunch of people, any ideas on weighing in? Is Weekly ok?

Replies

  • eyemadreamer
    eyemadreamer Posts: 41 Member
    I would suggest weekly, it gives you a more accurate idea of how much you've lost/what your current weight is.
  • jenbusick
    jenbusick Posts: 528 Member
    Lots of people weigh in weekly and it works just fine for them.

    When I first started, I weighed in every morning and every night, and I learned a lot about how what I ate was affecting my weight. I don't do that anymore, because I don't need to.

    Good luck on your journey!
  • NyxDominique
    NyxDominique Posts: 271 Member
    I offically weigh-in for the website once a week on friday. Right after I wake up.

    Though I normally check the scale daily just to keep myself encouraged
  • sarah44254
    sarah44254 Posts: 3,078 Member
    weekly is great :)

    one thing I would like to suggest is considering logging gains. Sometimes you do well, really well! then you have a snag and you gain a little. It helps me to log these gains so that months later when it happens again, I see it in my check in history and tell myself 'well, I got through that gain and lost more afterwards! I will log this gain too and look forward to getting rid of it quickly like the other time'
  • city_of_frogs
    city_of_frogs Posts: 101 Member
    weekly is great :)

    one thing I would like to suggest is considering logging gains. Sometimes you do well, really well! then you have a snag and you gain a little. It helps me to log these gains so that months later when it happens again, I see it in my check in history and tell myself 'well, I got through that gain and lost more afterwards! I will log this gain too and look forward to getting rid of it quickly like the other time'
    thats a great idea :) I will to :D

    I recommend weekly. Daily can be discouraging as your body fluctuates, but it does tell you about how your body reacts to different things. Sodium, for example, causes water retention. Water weight is great at adding that little bit of weight back on you :S I feel any longer between weighs can be bad. You don't have as much control, and can't react to a "gain" as quickly as one would like.

    Good luck with everything :)
  • littlemili
    littlemili Posts: 625 Member
    Weekly is fine. But be prepared to be disappointed for a whole week if you eat a high sodium meal within a couple of days of weigh-in day. To me, the fact that a whole week's worth of work can be skewed by something that stupid put me off ever weighing weekly, and the idea of being able to understand my daily fluctuations and understand why x days before TOM my weight goes up, how long it stays up after alcohol/heavy exercise/sodium makes it ok when I see a higher number randomly for a day. So I would actually say that unless you don't mind seeing a higher unexplained number, weigh whenever you like and get used to understanding your body. It is a healthier way of doing it. Eg imagine if this happened over 2 weeks

    Mon 150
    Tue 149.5
    Wed 149.5
    Thu 149.5
    Fri 149
    Sat 149 (have a Saturday night takeaway high in sodium)
    Sun 152
    Mon 151 <- looks like you have gained, but you're on a downward trend
    Tue 149
    Wed 148
    Thu 148
    Fri 148 (TOM hits you)
    Sat 151
    Sun 152
    Mon 151 <- looks like you haven't lost, but ditto downward trend

    Actually here you probably lost 3lb over 2 weeks but you would think you gained 1lb. I hope that makes sense.
  • OfficerFuzzy
    OfficerFuzzy Posts: 222 Member
    I'm thinking about doing it twice a week.
    On Wednesdays and Sundays.
  • robin52077
    robin52077 Posts: 4,383 Member
    Weekly is fine. But be prepared to be disappointed for a whole week if you eat a high sodium meal within a couple of days of weigh-in day. To me, the fact that a whole week's worth of work can be skewed by something that stupid put me off ever weighing weekly, and the idea of being able to understand my daily fluctuations and understand why x days before TOM my weight goes up, how long it stays up after alcohol/heavy exercise/sodium makes it ok when I see a higher number randomly for a day. So I would actually say that unless you don't mind seeing a higher unexplained number, weigh whenever you like and get used to understanding your body. It is a healthier way of doing it. Eg imagine if this happened over 2 weeks

    Mon 150
    Tue 149.5
    Wed 149.5
    Thu 149.5
    Fri 149
    Sat 149 (have a Saturday night takeaway high in sodium)
    Sun 152
    Mon 151 <- looks like you have gained, but you're on a downward trend
    Tue 149
    Wed 148
    Thu 148
    Fri 148 (TOM hits you)
    Sat 151
    Sun 152
    Mon 151 <- looks like you haven't lost, but ditto downward trend

    Actually here you probably lost 3lb over 2 weeks but you would think you gained 1lb. I hope that makes sense.

    This is why I weigh daily.
    I like to see the gains and losses. It really helps to understand your body, and what one day of high sodium or high sugar can do. Also helps to track TOM because the weight goes up right before for no reason.
    As long as you don't beat yourself up over higher numbers and learn from them as a natural fluctuation of water and waste, then it's fine.
    Only people who obsess about it and will starve themselves if they see a higher number should avoid this tactic, for them it's not healthy. They should do once a month.
  • myofibril
    myofibril Posts: 4,500 Member
    As long as you don't beat yourself up over higher numbers and learn from them as a natural fluctuation of water and waste, then it's fine.
    Only people who obsess about it and will starve themselves if they see a higher number should avoid this tactic, for them it's not healthy. They should do once a month.

    Pretty much this. It depends on what your emotional reaction is to the numbers and how that then prompts you to act. Words like "disappointed" "upset" "angry" "hate" indicate a emotional response which in itself is not a bad thing. It can inspire you to tighten up your diet, spur you on in your training, focus your mindset.

    However, if it causes you to think "no matter what I do I can't lose weight" or "I am different" or "I may as well shovel a boatload of twinkies down my gullet" then leave it a few weeks between weighing. Personally, I weighh myself a couple of times a year at most. As a measue of success the scale is far down on my list.
  • city_of_frogs
    city_of_frogs Posts: 101 Member
    Also helps to track TOM...

    what is TOM??? :)
  • anu_6986
    anu_6986 Posts: 702 Member
    I used to weigh weekly, but right now, I don't really bother. I check it once a while. I am happy as long as I get my workout in!
  • Qarol
    Qarol Posts: 6,171 Member
    Weekly is perfectly acceptable. But I don't allow myself not to weigh for fear I'll be disappointed. That's how I gained all this weight in the first place. I didn't want to see that higher number. Yet I deluded myself into believing it wasn't really all that high. Until I finally did weigh, and it was. No more. But that's what works for me. Some people are better off weekly or maybe even monthly.
  • Also helps to track TOM...

    what is TOM??? :)

    TIME OF MONTH
  • JUST REMEMBER, the scale is just ONE (1) gauge of how you're doing

    and it can be VERY PMSy, so DON'T allow it to dictate your mood/feelings if it's UP

    How you're feeling, how your clothes are fitting, and if you can keep track of your body fat/BMI

    as well as lab work for improved blood work ( IF things like Total cholesterol/triglycerides/blood sugar, etc. might be factors too?)

    are ALSO gauges- and give you the OVERALL picture of what's going on w/ your health.

    ( I keep preaching that to myself ;) cuz I get discouraged too sometimes if the scales UP one week)

    GOOD idea to weigh yourself approx same time each week, in the AM, before you eat and after you use the bathroom w/ little or no clothes on.
This discussion has been closed.