Do Naturally Thin Skinny Girls really exist???

I've not read the book but my BFF (truly, since we were 15 and we're now 48) has always been thin. She has to workout hard to have any shape to her body, HAD to get the girls done (she didn't have any) and was the one who asked "does this make me look too skinny?". She eats regular food and her family is all normal sized (no obesity, no anorexia). So yes, naturally thin, skinny girls DO exist.

yes, I know one.

I was once in a previous life.....

Then I had my son and came back again as fat mama

my daughter is very thin. She eats anything she likes (in fact, eats out mostly) and drinks alcohol 4 or 5 days a week. She picks up about 5lbs in winter but takes it right off in spring before bikini weather. Don't ask me HOW she does it, I do not know. I have never been thin. I know she was a very tiny child; in fact, she never got out of the #2 diapers.
so yes, they exist

can anybody tell me if they have had sucsess with this diet and actually have maintained it???/

I once worked with a girl who hated her body because she was so skinny. She wouldn't wear skirts or shorts because her legs were so skinny. She tried so hard to put on weight but couldn't (her grandmother was very skinny, too. It was all genetics).

There is a girl in my office who is a natural size 6 (UK) and I've never seen her eat anything other than crap in the 2 years she's worked for us. During a day she will eat a tube of pringles or a bag of crisps, a family sized bag of skittles, and then other sweets and crisps: her desk is always piled high with them, its a running joke in the office. If she does have "food" for lunch is lasagne, potato and cheese or curry.

I don't understand how she doesn't have scurvy!

My best friend since we've been 4 years old, is 5'1 and 92lbs. She eats fast food, pizza, drinks soda every single day. Has a desk job, doesn't excercise, loves to sit on the couch and watch tv...etc. She wants to gain weight but has never been able too

One of my cousins is extremely thin. She's had 5 babies already and doesn't look like she was ever pregnant. Even when she was pregnant she never got that big.

My 10 year old daughter, who is just like her Great Grandmother, is super skinny and has to eat constantly. In fact she is underweight and I have to feed her high carb and protein foods to help her try and gain weight. At almost 4'8" she only weighs 64 pounds with her clothes on! She takes after her Great Grandmother and as long as I have known my Grandmother she has been super skinny and can eat anything she wants. It's only been since she turned 70 that she has had to change what she eats.

I tell you what trying to find clothes for my daughter is like pulling teeth on a alligator, because finding size 12 pants in super skinny is hard! So yes naturally thin people do exist and for some it's not as easy as some might think. For me being pleasantly plump it's never been hard for me to eat but for my daughter is hard for her to eat enough so she doesn't get sick. Seems like she is constantly tired and she eats all day. We have gone to protein shakes but being allergic to everything and lactose intolerant makes it really hard to find protein powders. Sometimes is just exhausting for both of us trying to find enough food thats right for her to eat an keep her energy levels high and her feeling 100%.

My old roommate at 39 years old once told me she maintained her six pack by eating peanut butter. She doesn't exercise, drinks a lot, and eats constantly. She does fitness modeling as a hobby. Her mom is the same way. I wish I had her genetics. Never read the book.

There was something on Fox news this am about being naturally skinny...it is a "mutated" chromosome on the 16th one ( I think that is what they said). Heidi Klume has this "mutation", which is why she is so skinny...

They exist until they have babies lol unless you have money to get all removed. I was very small intil I had my daughter and have never been able to get back there

i beg to disagree. my cousins wife was thin before she had her kids, and shes even thinner now. And she eats like a freakin cow! im jealous. lol

that was me up until about a year ago when I finally was able to put weight back on

There was something on Fox news this am about being naturally skinny...it is a "mutated" chromosome on the 16th one ( I think that is what they said). Heidi Klume has this "mutation", which is why she is so skinny...

Where can I sign up for gene therapy for this mutation!?

I once worked with a girl who hated her body because she was so skinny. She wouldn't wear skirts or shorts because her legs were so skinny. She tried so hard to put on weight but couldn't (her grandmother was very skinny, too. It was all genetics).

I was like that in my teens. My father and his sisters are all very thin. My mother is 5'0" and weighs 110. At her "heaviest" she was 125. I was 95lbs up until I was 23. Its easy to get cocky and think one will always be thin so one eats like crap. I began to get saggy and skinny fat so I toned up and now I'm 102. And yes I still have breasts and curves lol.