What to do with a broken metabolism

2»

Replies

  • HHAEYOUNG73
    HHAEYOUNG73 Posts: 16 Member
    Yea no, I just enjoy walking and if you think about the subject, would you rather be bored sitting and most likely ruining posture and spine by slouching or be subconsciously burning some extra calories by walking and getting blood circulation. Nothing to brag about but college studies are a breeze for me. And the whole doctor thing, I'm pretty sure there's no "pedometer addiction" doctor. I know that this whole stepping this MIGHT appear to be an addiction, but in th3 end it's just burning some extra calories. If you think burning calories intentionally is a disorder, then I would direct you to every fitness individual or athletes who would probably burn more than me. So my problem as aforementioned, is my METABOLISM, not so much focused on if this is a disorder or something of the sort. I just wanted some THOUGHTS about this whole metabolism thing and not waste hundreds of dollars on some generic answer like "I dontnspecialize in this field and I'm pretty sure there's no such doctor who would specialize in such a subjective topic"(from 3 doctors I asked as a side note)
  • psychod787
    psychod787 Posts: 4,099 Member
    edited May 2020
    Ma'am, as someone stated above, your metabolism isnot broken. If you gained weight over a period of time not eating or drinking anything, then I would say yes. Actually there is some research where anorexics actually have hyper metabolism. (Will post upon request) The differences in most rmr studies is 80-120 calories as someone postd earlier. So, your rmr is most likely not that far off. As far a metabolism, the biggest difference seems to be NEAT. I am also coming to believe in the energy constraint model. Basically, the human body is only capable of burning so many calories before it down grades energy expenditure to help save itself. Something that is hinted to in a study by Herman Ponzer when dealing with the Hadza hunter gather groups. He measured their energy expenditure with doubly labeled water, be noted when lean mass was taken into account, they were burning no more energy than a semi-sedentary westerner. This was with them being over 2.5 times more active. We also see it in people who exercise too much. LH and testosterone drop in men and women lose their menstruation. Is AT real, yes, from the research I have seen out of Roosenbaums lab's. Though the drop in RMR is small, about 80 calories in his studies. The biggest drop is in muscle fuel efficiency. Basically the muscles burn less energy per contraction than prodicted. You weight train, so thins helps to mitigate this in some research. I was also someone who worried about metabolism for a long time, now not so much. Weight loss and maintenance mostly comes down to dietary adherence and activity adherence. Those two things are the LARGEST predictors of who loses and maintains. Best wishes.
  • PAV8888
    PAV8888 Posts: 14,254 Member
    @psychod787 hyper metabolic on refeed, not before, or did I fall asleep and miss that?
  • psychod787
    psychod787 Posts: 4,099 Member
    PAV8888 wrote: »
    @psychod787 hyper metabolic on refeed, not before, or did I fall asleep and miss that?

    Yes, there some research on re feeding post anorexia. Also, anecdotal remarks from people who work in centers where they are treated. Basically the body has to repair organs and bones before fat can be regained. About that time appetite seems to pick up quite a bit. Wonder if that is some of my problem. Not the time or place... lol
  • yirara
    yirara Posts: 9,943 Member
    It's certainly interesting that TO has not shown up here again.
  • HHAEYOUNG73
    HHAEYOUNG73 Posts: 16 Member
    OP you're a male, 5'11. Do you weigh 175lbs, 130lbs, or 160lbs? You threw out all these weights in your first post. I'd like clarification. However, any of those weights are low for a 5'11 male. How do I know? I'm a 5'11 female. So, you're underweight and walking all day, and worried about gaining weight. You know what that means--right? Yes. So get to a specialist ASAP before you ruin your health. Nobody wants you to come to harm.

    170s fluctuating
  • HHAEYOUNG73
    HHAEYOUNG73 Posts: 16 Member
    OP you're a male, 5'11. Do you weigh 175lbs, 130lbs, or 160lbs? You threw out all these weights in your first post. I'd like clarification. However, any of those weights are low for a 5'11 male. How do I know? I'm a 5'11 female. So, you're underweight and walking all day, and worried about gaining weight. You know what that means--right? Yes. So get to a specialist ASAP before you ruin your health. Nobody wants you to come to harm.

    Also I'm not worried about weight gain but the science of CICO and my metabolisms regards to that
  • HHAEYOUNG73
    HHAEYOUNG73 Posts: 16 Member
    psychod787 wrote: »
    PAV8888 wrote: »
    @psychod787 hyper metabolic on refeed, not before, or did I fall asleep and miss that?

    Yes, there some research on re feeding post anorexia. Also, anecdotal remarks from people who work in centers where they are treated. Basically the body has to repair organs and bones before fat can be regained. About that time appetite seems to pick up quite a bit. Wonder if that is some of my problem. Not the time or place... lol

    Thanks for the insight. Seems interesting, I'll look into it
  • HHAEYOUNG73
    HHAEYOUNG73 Posts: 16 Member
    hipari wrote: »
    1. Get a new pedometer
    2. See a doctor, not random internet strangers
    3. Stop eating a one-thing-only diet of chicken breast and sweet potatoes, that doesn't have enough nutrients and doesn't include all vitamins etc.

    Seriously, how many miles/kilometers does your pedometer say you walk? How many hours you walk per day? 60-70k would be 6-7 hours of just walking at a fast-ish pace, no breaks.

    I already saw a doctor for the disorder and RECOVERED, but I'm pretty sure I'm here because I already tried asking about steps metabolism and all that to drs

    What did your doctor say about your over exercising? Did you show them your pedometer?

    Just because you're not chewing and spitting anymore doesn't mean you're recovered.

    He just said there's no problem with my steps. And said there's no such thing as over walking. He gave Michael Phelps or military people as an example who burn way more than me but still aren't bodily damaged

    It isn't the walking that's the problem, it's the eating enough to sustain it. Phelps has a trainer, and I'm sure he has a nutritionist,..... all the bells and whistles. You?

    A trainer who tells him to shove down pizzas and Sugar filled monsters DAILY?
  • HHAEYOUNG73
    HHAEYOUNG73 Posts: 16 Member
    nooshi713 wrote: »
    I just want to mention as a healthcare provider that sometimes patients claim their doctor said something that they didn’t. I have seen patients do this in the ER where I work and they have done it to me. Either they are misinterpreting the meaning of what was said or they purposely twist the words in their mind to suit their own narrative. Also, all of the facts may not have been given to the healthcare provider.

    OP knows he is eating too little and working out too much.

    If this is the case, shouldn't I be losing weight?