We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

At what point will you switch your calories to maintenance?

Iamfit4life
Iamfit4life Posts: 3,095 Member
edited October 2024 in Chit-Chat
I keep going back and forth!

Replies

  • rjbrowne82
    rjbrowne82 Posts: 198 Member
    I would think when u reach where you want to be weight wise.
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    is this a trick question?! i did it when i got to my goal weight....
  • Iamfit4life
    Iamfit4life Posts: 3,095 Member
    is this a trick question?! i did it when i got to my goal weight....

    Not a trick question... I'm where I need to be and happy. But i get so nervous having it set there.
  • blunderwhere
    blunderwhere Posts: 24 Member
    For what it's worth, I started with so-called maintenance. I don't want to "diet" again, because it has been a repeated abysmal failure for me, so instead of dieting, I have simply started eating "normally" which, of course, will never be normal for me and will always require my vigilance.

    I want to start my "maintenance" now because it will take everything I have to make consistent and permanent changes in how I live a day at a time. I don't need to learn how to diet, I need to learn how to live and eat daily. So, I am eating and living as I hope to eat and live today as I hope to for the rest of my life.

    Because it requires more calories to walk around at my current weight than it would if I was, say, 130 lbs, though, I eat more now than I will when I weight 130, so I carefully monitor how rapidly I am losing and using the BMR and BMI tools, I periodically and gradually reduce my caloric intake as I become lighter.

    Best of luck.
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    is this a trick question?! i did it when i got to my goal weight....

    Not a trick question... I'm where I need to be and happy. But i get so nervous having it set there.

    nervous about what?
  • sleepytexan
    sleepytexan Posts: 3,138 Member
    I have not been able to get to my goal! I needed to lose 15 lbs. and I lost 13 lbs. in 2 months at a 500-cal deficit. Then I plateaued for a month.

    I work out hard 16 or more hours a week, and eating too few calories is what had caused my weight gain in the first place, so with 2 lbs. to go, it didn't make sense to eat any fewer calories. So I upped my cals to a 250 defiicit . . . and stayed the same for another month. Then I upped my cals to maintenance for the past 3 weeks and have stayed the same.

    So, I am now confounded bc I started maintaining my weight 3 mos ago at a 500 cal deficit and continued to maintain even up to a 0 defiicit. What have I learned? Ha, I don't know, other than that I may as well eat at maintenance instead of 500 cal deficit if I'm going to stay the same anyway.

    Some would say, "why do you need to lose 2 more pounds?" I guess I don't. I would just like to, that's all. It's not unreasonable. It's possible I'm not losing bc I'm training so hard right now for a century ride in 2 weeks. I'm not really able to take a break--I know that sounds bizarre, but I am committed to some of my exercise bc I teach fitness classes and am under contract to perform with a dance company. I can't back down the training rides or I won't be able to complete the century. Maybe after it's over when I cut my weekly rides back down to 35 miles and I'm taking October off of dance performances, maybe then I'll be able to drop a few pounds.

    Anyway, when I first went to maintenance, my weight crept up for the first 2 weeks by a total of 2 lbs, but I had committed to trying it for 3 weeks. Then it went back down the last week, so here I am again.

    Since I don't know what else to do now, I put my deficit back down to 500 yesterday and I am trying a 2x BMR spike day once a week before a big workout day. I'm riding 80 miles tomorrow, and will burn about 3500 cals, so today is my first spike day.

    So how's that for a whole lotta stuff without any answer to your question?

    blessings.
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    For what it's worth, I started with so-called maintenance. I don't want to "diet" again, because it has been a repeated abysmal failure for me, so instead of dieting, I have simply started eating "normally" which, of course, will never be normal for me and will always require my vigilance.

    I want to start my "maintenance" now because it will take everything I have to make consistent and permanent changes in how I live a day at a time. I don't need to learn how to diet, I need to learn how to live and eat daily. So, I am eating and living as I hope to eat and live today as I hope to for the rest of my life.

    Because it requires more calories to walk around at my current weight than it would if I was, say, 130 lbs, though, I eat more now than I will when I weight 130, so I carefully monitor how rapidly I am losing and using the BMR and BMI tools, I periodically and gradually reduce my caloric intake as I become lighter.

    Best of luck.

    if you are at maintenance, why are you reducing your calories?
  • blunderwhere
    blunderwhere Posts: 24 Member
    Good question, Tav. Because, at my weight, maintenance is what a person of 130 lbs would need to maintain that weight, plus an additional amount because I carry around a significant load 24 hrs per day. In other words, the simple fact that I weight more than 100lbs more than I should means that I naturally burn more calories than a person of an average weight.

    Imagine that a 130 lb person strapped on a backpack weighing 100lbs everyday and carried it around everywhere, never taking it off, even slept in it. That person would burn x amount of calories more than someone who doesn't carry that backpack. Therefore, I must add on a specific amount to account for my "load" then subtract a small portion to make sure that I am in a "calorie deficit" without throwing my body into starvation mode by losing too fast.

    If I simply ate the number of calories a 130 lb person should eat to maintain that weight, I would have too large a calorie deficit and therefore my body would slow down its metabolism to protect me from impending starvation.

    I eat more than 2000 calories daily right now and lose consistently, but when I started I was eating 2350 and losing. So, I will continue to very gradually descend in weight and calorie consumption until I reach my weight goal and appropriate calorie intake for that weight.

    I believe the traditional calorie deficit followed by an "increase" for so-called maintenance simply feeds into the diet yo yo that so many of us have experience. At least it has for me.
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Good question, Tav. Because, at my weight, maintenance is what a person of 130 lbs would need to maintain that weight, plus an additional amount because I carry around a significant load 24 hrs per day. In other words, the simple fact that I weight more than 100lbs more than I should means that I naturally burn more calories than a person of an average weight.

    Imagine that a 130 lb person strapped on a backpack weighing 100lbs everyday and carried it around everywhere, never taking it off, even slept in it. That person would burn x amount of calories more than someone who doesn't carry that backpack. Therefore, I must add on a specific amount to account for my "load" then subtract a small portion to make sure that I am in a "calorie deficit" without throwing my body into starvation mode by losing too fast.

    If I simply ate the number of calories a 130 lb person should eat to maintain that weight, I would have too large a calorie deficit and therefore my body would slow down its metabolism to protect me from impending starvation.

    I eat more than 2000 calories daily right now and lose consistently, but when I started I was eating 2350 and losing. So, I will continue to very gradually descend in weight and calorie consumption until I reach my weight goal and appropriate calorie intake for that weight.

    I believe the traditional calorie deficit followed by an "increase" for so-called maintenance simply feeds into the diet yo yo that so many of us have experience. At least it has for me.

    aaaaaah, i see. sounds like you have found a way to lose weight healthily that works for you & from the looks for your ticker you're doing a great job! x
  • Iamfit4life
    Iamfit4life Posts: 3,095 Member
    I have not been able to get to my goal! I needed to lose 15 lbs. and I lost 13 lbs. in 2 months at a 500-cal deficit. Then I plateaued for a month.

    I work out hard 16 or more hours a week, and eating too few calories is what had caused my weight gain in the first place, so with 2 lbs. to go, it didn't make sense to eat any fewer calories. So I upped my cals to a 250 defiicit . . . and stayed the same for another month. Then I upped my cals to maintenance for the past 3 weeks and have stayed the same.

    So, I am now confounded bc I started maintaining my weight 3 mos ago at a 500 cal deficit and continued to maintain even up to a 0 defiicit. What have I learned? Ha, I don't know, other than that I may as well eat at maintenance instead of 500 cal deficit if I'm going to stay the same anyway.

    Some would say, "why do you need to lose 2 more pounds?" I guess I don't. I would just like to, that's all. It's not unreasonable. It's possible I'm not losing bc I'm training so hard right now for a century ride in 2 weeks. I'm not really able to take a break--I know that sounds bizarre, but I am committed to some of my exercise bc I teach fitness classes and am under contract to perform with a dance company. I can't back down the training rides or I won't be able to complete the century. Maybe after it's over when I cut my weekly rides back down to 35 miles and I'm taking October off of dance performances, maybe then I'll be able to drop a few pounds.

    Anyway, when I first went to maintenance, my weight crept up for the first 2 weeks by a total of 2 lbs, but I had committed to trying it for 3 weeks. Then it went back down the last week, so here I am again.

    Since I don't know what else to do now, I put my deficit back down to 500 yesterday and I am trying a 2x BMR spike day once a week before a big workout day. I'm riding 80 miles tomorrow, and will burn about 3500 cals, so today is my first spike day.

    So how's that for a whole lotta stuff without any answer to your question?

    blessings.

    lol it makes you sound a whole lot me. I'm going to try it for a few weeks. I just fear waking up one day and being 70lbs heavier.
    Which is, stupid... But it's just my weird body stuff.
  • stampede55
    stampede55 Posts: 474
    As soon as I can see my abs!
This discussion has been closed.

Categories