Constantly eating over my calories and struggling to maintain a deficit. What do you guys do?! Help!
zichroni
Posts: 4 Member
Hello people of MFP. I could use input on what I can do to maintain my calories or see if I'm doing something wrong.
About me: 28F, SW:181, CW:173, GW:150. My daily limit is 1400 cals/day but I'm averaging 1700 - and often eat closer to 2000. I do light jogging twice a week and on other days I walk an hour a day and do 30m pilates or barre workouts. At this point, I'm just eating back the calories I burn and then some.
What am I doing wrong?! How do you all maintain deficit without feeling like you're starving yourselves?
ETA: I'm 5'3"
About me: 28F, SW:181, CW:173, GW:150. My daily limit is 1400 cals/day but I'm averaging 1700 - and often eat closer to 2000. I do light jogging twice a week and on other days I walk an hour a day and do 30m pilates or barre workouts. At this point, I'm just eating back the calories I burn and then some.
What am I doing wrong?! How do you all maintain deficit without feeling like you're starving yourselves?
ETA: I'm 5'3"
6
Replies
-
2000 might be what you need. Maybe it's 1850...no way for us to know given the amount of info.
With 23 pounds to lose, it's going to be slow and you'll need to dial in those numbers pretty closely. Log food as accurately as you can, set your goal on here to "Lightly Active" and "Lose 1/2 pound per week." Log your purposeful exercise and eat more to fuel that.
Then collect your data for 4-6 weeks and adjust at the end of that time.
Good luck, the last 20 are the hard ones. Patience is required.
Logging tips:
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1234699/logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide/p111 -
I really sympathise and don't have a huge amount of advice that common sense probably hasn't already told you
It's really hard! But just in case you haven't already heard these...
Try eating foods which are large in volume but low in calories. They take up space in your stomach and make you feel full.
Also high protein foods will fill you up for longer. Try porridge or cereal with some protein powder added to the milk.
Another thing to mention... How much do you think you ate before you were doing this?
If you were eating 2000 a day before and you now aim for 1700, that's going to be a step in the right direction! I really think that part of the reason people fail with this is because they just aim too low. Set yourself a realistic target. 1400 calories won't keep many people full!4 -
I agree about the volume of food, and that 1,400 calories is not much. Try eating more vegetables at each meal or maybe try some soup to feel full.
Set a timer and slow down your eating. I often eat so fast that I take a 2nd helping before I think. I'm always amazed at eating in a fancy restaurant and sometimes the portions look small but when you have several courses over say 30 minutes you fill up.
Also are you weighing and measuring everything? Especially high caloric foods like peanutbutter, chips and cheese.
Also are you waiting until you're famished to eat? I tend to overeat on those days.
Good luck. Stay the course. It works.4 -
Thank you all for the responses! I appreciate your inputs! Cmriverside, thank you for the logging tips! That's really helpful.
I know I was eating well over 2000 calories before starting, and I've been at this for a few months. I will try upping my calories. I think I need to pare down slowly, so that's a good point. I also try to wait until I'm hungry to eat and *do* eat fast. I've been working on taking more water breaks as I'm eating, but it's definitely something I can improve on.
I don't weigh my food, but am considering a small scale, because I'm either over or under-estimating things and that's not doing me any favors. Thank you spyro88 and babeisfit!2 -
What is throwing you over your deficit target? Sweets? Snacks? Portion size? Night eating? Why are you waiting until you are hungry to eat? A regular meal schedule may serve you better.
An accurate food scale is a must. Please get one ASAP. Maybe try narrowing the time window in which you eat... perhaps nothing after 7PM. Are you pre-planning your foods or deciding as you walk into the kitchen? Are you logging after each meal or waiting until the end of the day?
I've found pre-logging to be a major help. For example, tonight I made a delicious shrimp stir-fry over rice, ate half and will have the rest tomorrow. Pre-logging tomorrow's dinner lets me know exactly how many calories I have for front half the day - no Sunday pancakes for me! 😁4 -
Open your diary?0
-
What is throwing you over your deficit target? Sweets? Snacks? Portion size? Night eating? Why are you waiting until you are hungry to eat? A regular meal schedule may serve you better.
An accurate food scale is a must. Please get one ASAP. Maybe try narrowing the time window in which you eat... perhaps nothing after 7PM. Are you pre-planning your foods or deciding as you walk into the kitchen? Are you logging after each meal or waiting until the end of the day?
I've found pre-logging to be a major help. For example, tonight I made a delicious shrimp stir-fry over rice, ate half and will have the rest tomorrow. Pre-logging tomorrow's dinner lets me know exactly how many calories I have for front half the day - no Sunday pancakes for me! 😁
I will say a regular meal schedule, prelogging, and a food scale have all helped me enormously and would recommend them. Even if I end up adjusting the amounts later, having a rough idea of what I'm eating, and how much of it, ahead of time makes it much less likely that I will overeat. For meals I can't plan, say if I eat at a friend's, I budget about 800 calories (a typical lunch or dinner for me is about 600.)
For me, at least, the cold hard reality is that when I let my wants direct my eating, I eat too much. Maybe that will shift for me once I reach maintenance and what I'm inclined to do will match up better. But for now, I log, ahead of time, and precisely.5 -
Penguinmama, I think you're right. I'm letting my wants direct my eating. I get hungry and start snacking, which racks up my calories for the day. I plan my meals weekly, so I will give pre-logging a try and just stick to that as best as possible. Thank you! And thank you MsCzar! Very helpful advice5
-
What works for me is meal planning. I've just discovered it this past year, trying to figure out how I could make it grocery shopping just once every 3-4 weeks instead of 2or 3 times per week. It has saved me a lot of money, too! I plan for 1200-1300 calories(5'1.5 here), and so even if I have an extra snack or dessert I hardly ever go over enough to gain weight.2
-
There are a few things that helped my hunger. 1. Volume foods, 2. Lots of protein and 3. Ketogenic.
If you do a carb based diet, i have to include a lot of low calorie plants and lean meats. Things like dark leafy greens, low sugar fruits (berries, watermelon, kiwi, plums) and lean proteins, especially red meat like sirloin, chicken, rack of lamb and then i throw in lots of low fat dairy.
When i do keto, i have to keep it rather clean and get my new carbs around 25g.
Both methods are helpful to me for getting lean.1 -
Thank you all for the responses! I appreciate your inputs! Cmriverside, thank you for the logging tips! That's really helpful.
I know I was eating well over 2000 calories before starting, and I've been at this for a few months. I will try upping my calories. I think I need to pare down slowly, so that's a good point. I also try to wait until I'm hungry to eat and *do* eat fast. I've been working on taking more water breaks as I'm eating, but it's definitely something I can improve on.
To the bolded: If you figured out that that's best for you by experimenting with it, I wouldn't suggest doing otherwise.
However, if it just seemed like a good idea, you might experiment. People are very individual, and some of us (me!) can even be weird. If I start to feel a little hungry and have a small snack (usually a protein-y one), it turns out I arrive at the next meal not feeling so ravenous, and this makes portion control easier for me.
What you eat can be important for satiation (which macros, what specific foods, overall sound nutrition), and so can the timing of eating. Much of satiation is *very* individual: I've seen people here who say they do best on anything from one meal a day (OMAD) to pretty much all-day snack-sized grazing, as an eating strategy. Whatever schedule is sating for you, and practical, is a good eating schedule. Within the boundaries of decent overall nutrition, whatever foods/macros keep you full is a good way to eat.I don't weigh my food, but am considering a small scale, because I'm either over or under-estimating things and that's not doing me any favors. Thank you spyro88 and babeisfit!
Bonus: If you've been using cups/spoons, weighing food can also be quicker and easier. (And if just eyeballing, I'm reasonably confident using a food scale will be less fussy and time-consuming than you may be thinking.) Also, a scale is inexpensive, usually available for $20 or less. This thread (despite the joking clickbait title) has tips for using a food scale efficiently/quickly, for people who've decided to use that approach:
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10498882/weighing-food-takes-too-long-and-is-obsessive#latest
Best wishes!3 -
I have pretty good results from pre-logging and focusing on the foods that I know from experience help me feel satisfied. Another thing that really helps me is NOT waiting until I'm really hungry to eat. I know it's harder to control myself when I get that hungry and I also usually have to eat more overall to be satisfied.7
-
I had to play "this for that". Essentially it's an easy substitution game to maximize the use of your calorie allowance. So instead of 2eggo waffles and log cabin syrup I choose 1 gluten free Van's brand of waffle, 2eggs no additives like milk for scrambling and 90% less calorie log cabin syrup. The goal is reduced inflamation, better use of the calories you have and better hydration. It gets easier with practice. I also found it easier to up my allowance to 1720 calories and walk 5miles a day without eating back my exercise calories. Most days I eat under now that I'm used to maximizing my food volume. I also rarely consume liquid calories aside from protein drink meal replacement.4
-
I used a TDEE calculator to calculate your total daily energy expenditure (I used 'sedentary' as the lifestyle multiplier since IDK what your job/activity is like).....and to maintain your weight you would need to eat ~1780 cals/day (estimate).
So...if you are eating 1400...it just sounds like your deficit is just too high - especially if you are adding in intentional exercise burning calories. That would make your deficit even bigger.
So, if I were you - I'd bump up your daily net goal to like 1550/1600, be sure to measure/weigh your food (until you get a better idea of what amounts are what...then you can transition into more intuitive eating), and log your cardio exercise and eat back like between 50-100% of those cals.
This *should lead to fairly consistent (but maybe slow) weight loss. But it'll be easier and you won't blow your daily calorie goal bc you won't be so hungry all the time.1 -
I found going low carb really helpful at reducing my appetite. I don’t go as low as keto. Just between 99 and 120 grams a day. Eating this way I rarely go over my calorie goal because I’m just not hungry. Most days I struggle to eat enough! I hope you find something that works for you!2
-
my advice would be to stop seeing your calories as a daily thing and seeing it as weekly total. Cycle your calories. If you are hungry on a wednesday log it and eat less on the thursday and friday. if you stay in a deficit over the course of 7 days you'll still meet your weekly goal.3
-
Maybe you could also try fasting as well. That way you have a smaller window to eat your calories and may not eat as much.1
-
Estimating serving sizes has never been accurate for me. When the hubs and I were doing WW, I told him that even though some foods were zero points that he should weigh out ONE serving to eat. It’s amazing how measuring that out I such an eye opener. As in, a “serving” of cereal is NOT a full bowl. 🙂 (He’s still following WW and maintaining his 120 lb loss.)
Also, one other piece of advice sticks in my mind… Your stomach holds the same size no matter how hungry you are. So even if you are “starving”, only eat ONE serving. It seems we typically grab this, that, and the other to scarf down… but you really only need the “this” to take away the hunger.5 -
I decide what I am eating for the whole day and track it. I do not eat anything else that day that is not tract and I also weigh amounts.
0 -
One thing I do when recalculating my calories and lower them is I use natural appetite suppressants. Apple cider vinagar, cinnamon and ginger are my go to. Apple cider vinegar in the morning before teeth brushing. Tea with added ginger at lunch. Then hot cocoa 2 cups with water and 2 scoops of ovaltine and added cinnamon. For suppressing appetite hot beverages work better for me than cold ones.1
-
Your experience of course maybe different, but I think your calorie count is too low for sustainability. My (former) weight and activity level were virtually identical to yours. I consistently lost 1/2 to 1 pounds per week eating 1800 calories daily. It was sustainable and steady. I also ate at the same time everyday, including a planned am and pm snack, so I was never famished.1
-
If you switch to maintenance, how many calories do you get? Starting out I set my goal to high, realized I wasn't going to eat 1200 calories a day and set my goal to maintenance and aimed to eat 300 calories below that, but the real goal was not go above it.0
-
DeterminedDivaMN wrote: »Also, one other piece of advice sticks in my mind… Your stomach holds the same size no matter how hungry you are. So even if you are “starving”, only eat ONE serving. It seems we typically grab this, that, and the other to scarf down… but you really only need the “this” to take away the hunger.
I love this. It's so obvious, and yet I'd never thought of it before.0 -
The sensation of fullness while or after eating is different among people. This is like landing an airplane with a poorly made altimeter. It says you are 50 feet in the air but you just hit the runway. If you are guided by your feeling of fullness you will always overeat. You are not starving. You only feel like you are starving.
Learn to accept the feeling and not act on it. Its your only hope.5 -
I like to feel full. For me, I've found time restricted eating to be the most helpful tool I've found this go round. I only eat from 3-10 pm most days, but I get to eat a lot in those hours! I know it seems counter intuitive to what we've been taught our whole lives about eating, but for me it works and It may work for you. Its easier for me to not eat a little while and then eat more than to eat little meals all day long. Maybe start with just skipping one meal? It's an idea. It may not be right for you, but its right for me.3
-
Sometimes it's just making sure you save your calories for habitual eating. I habitual eat at night between 9pm and 11pm. So I make sure I save calories for that time. I'm NOT a big morning eater at all so I don't worry about eating in the am and normally don't feel hungry at all.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
3 -
This is a habit of logging and truly resisting certain temptations for me. I stopped logging for a while and realized that when I did start logging just how much I was overeating in calories for my goals. When I get hungry and I have goals in mind that I want to meet, lately I have been having cucumbers with dijon mustard. I have something low in calories, high in snack value for me. I have been staying away from sugary and processed stuff as snacks. I agree with others on measuring out stuff. For example, although a scoop is provided with protein powder, they also give grams per scoop. I find that many times it will either be over or under, so measuring is important.
I make sure that I have enough lean protein with each meal, as protein keeps you fuller longer.3 -
Beverly2Hansen wrote: »One thing I do when recalculating my calories and lower them is I use natural appetite suppressants. Apple cider vinagar, cinnamon and ginger are my go to. Apple cider vinegar in the morning before teeth brushing. Tea with added ginger at lunch. Then hot cocoa 2 cups with water and 2 scoops of ovaltine and added cinnamon. For suppressing appetite hot beverages work better for me than cold ones.
Just because someone mentions the dreaded ACV doesn’t mean they’re proposing it as a diet plan.
Absolutely hot beverages work for me, too, regardless of weather.
I enjoy two spicy chai lattes, with lovely mounds of frothed skim milk, liberally doused in cinnamon every afternoon. 37 calories apiece. These luxurious, satisfying treats are a very important element in holding my appetite off between snacks or before bedtime.
Hot drinks can’t be drunk quickly, so being forced to slow down and savor them is very effective.
Btw, I love ginger, too. I put a cube of thawed Dorot frozen ginger cubes (available at Trader Joe’s and Lidl) in my pumpkin pudding every night, along with a shedload of regular powdered ginger. It really amps up the flavor.2 -
springlering62 wrote: »Beverly2Hansen wrote: »One thing I do when recalculating my calories and lower them is I use natural appetite suppressants. Apple cider vinagar, cinnamon and ginger are my go to. Apple cider vinegar in the morning before teeth brushing. Tea with added ginger at lunch. Then hot cocoa 2 cups with water and 2 scoops of ovaltine and added cinnamon. For suppressing appetite hot beverages work better for me than cold ones.
Just because someone mentions the dreaded ACV doesn’t mean they’re proposing it as a diet plan.
Absolutely hot beverages work for me, too, regardless of weather.
I enjoy two spicy chai lattes, with lovely mounds of frothed skim milk, liberally doused in cinnamon every afternoon. 37 calories apiece. These luxurious, satisfying treats are a very important element in holding my appetite off between snacks or before bedtime.
Hot drinks can’t be drunk quickly, so being forced to slow down and savor them is very effective.
Btw, I love ginger, too. I put a cube of thawed Dorot frozen ginger cubes (available at Trader Joe’s and Lidl) in my pumpkin pudding every night, along with a shedload of regular powdered ginger. It really amps up the flavor.
I appreciate that you didn't jump to assumptions. I am an emotional eater and I struggle with binge eating. To adjust to 1720 calories after I've been not logging my food and eating say 3,000+ calories is very hard the first 2 weeks. I studied both mental health resources like weightloss meditation and appetite suppressants that are safe as tools to stop food addiction behavior and form healthy habits. I do not aim to lose more than 7lbs per month and sometimes only lose 4lbs. There are times I start to slip into bad behaviors of over eating and recommit using audio weightloss meditation and safe appetite suppressants. I do not go below 1500calories because I'm active and don't eat exercise calories back. Some of us need extra tools to break food addiction behavior or poor impulse control especially in the beginning 2 weeks of a deficit. Writing a diary helps a lot of people too. Yes people with disordered eating can abuse natural appetite suppressants but they are many cultures utilize these things to promote health and most people use them in moderation in a way that doesn't hinder their health at all. I can say my physical, mental and emotional health are improved by these things.2 -
Beverly2Hansen wrote: »springlering62 wrote: »Beverly2Hansen wrote: »One thing I do when recalculating my calories and lower them is I use natural appetite suppressants. Apple cider vinagar, cinnamon and ginger are my go to. Apple cider vinegar in the morning before teeth brushing. Tea with added ginger at lunch. Then hot cocoa 2 cups with water and 2 scoops of ovaltine and added cinnamon. For suppressing appetite hot beverages work better for me than cold ones.
Just because someone mentions the dreaded ACV doesn’t mean they’re proposing it as a diet plan.
Absolutely hot beverages work for me, too, regardless of weather.
I enjoy two spicy chai lattes, with lovely mounds of frothed skim milk, liberally doused in cinnamon every afternoon. 37 calories apiece. These luxurious, satisfying treats are a very important element in holding my appetite off between snacks or before bedtime.
Hot drinks can’t be drunk quickly, so being forced to slow down and savor them is very effective.
Btw, I love ginger, too. I put a cube of thawed Dorot frozen ginger cubes (available at Trader Joe’s and Lidl) in my pumpkin pudding every night, along with a shedload of regular powdered ginger. It really amps up the flavor.
I appreciate that you didn't jump to assumptions. I am an emotional eater and I struggle with binge eating. To adjust to 1720 calories after I've been not logging my food and eating say 3,000+ calories is very hard the first 2 weeks. I studied both mental health resources like weightloss meditation and appetite suppressants that are safe as tools to stop food addiction behavior and form healthy habits. I do not aim to lose more than 7lbs per month and sometimes only lose 4lbs. There are times I start to slip into bad behaviors of over eating and recommit using audio weightloss meditation and safe appetite suppressants. I do not go below 1500calories because I'm active and don't eat exercise calories back. Some of us need extra tools to break food addiction behavior or poor impulse control especially in the beginning 2 weeks of a deficit. Writing a diary helps a lot of people too. Yes people with disordered eating can abuse natural appetite suppressants but they are many cultures utilize these things to promote health and most people use them in moderation in a way that doesn't hinder their health at all. I can say my physical, mental and emotional health are improved by these things.
I think you are doing what I did. I started here at 1470. I don’t even know where I got that number. It just “sounded good”. The weight fell off, but several months in, my dietician recommended increasing it.
It is hard to increase. My “reward center” responded so positively to the weight coming off, and I was terrified of stalling out or even gaining. I had to force myself to add a couple hundred calories. You get used to it really quick, though.
Three months after that I started with a personal trainer and the first thing she did was insist I bump it up yet again. Rinse and repeat with the mental handwringing.
Same as you, I stuck with a flat calorie plan slightly above TDEE, and didn't eat my exercise calories back. It was just easier mentally for me to have a line in the sand. I also eat the same foods over and over, because I enjoy them, am a bit OCD, and because I can be more confident in knowing where my calories stand at any point in the day by doing quick math in my head.
I still don’t eat my exercise “back”. I try to stick with a daily of 2200, giving me room once every week or so to have some cookies, extra pizza, or that unexpected pack of graham crackers I scarfed down the other night. I’m currently averaging about 2500 per day.
I think by “safe appetite suppressants” you’re referring to are the natural ones you mention like the ACV, and ginger products? For me, it’s hot drinks. If I have a two or three hour gap between meals or snacks, I fill it with chai. That’s my suppressant. It’s meditative to make, too hot to be swilled down quickly, and tastes wonderful, of course. Plus it forces me to sit down with a book, magazine or MFP and relax fir a few minutes mid day, which I no longer do otherwise.
Interesting you mention diarying. I’ve only done it once, during a thirty day yoga challenge, and to my utter and complete amazement I broke two deeply held lifelong habits. For me, it worked crazy well, and led to permanent change. I think that posting here on the boards has fulfilled some of the same function as the diary and kept me out of trouble with food.
You’re not under eating, you’re exercising, you’ve researched and got a handle on this. I can only compare to my very similar trajectory, but FWIW I think you’re doing great. You do what works for you, and much success to you. Hope you’ll be a long-hauler. I plan to be!1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions