Numbers
sh2640
Posts: 7 Member
I set my goals for the calories, protein, etc. But the app keeps raising them. It also says I'm not meeting the proper nutrition for my body but I'm eating mostly veggies, fruit, and proteins. Am I supposed to eat more even though I am meeting the goals I placed even though they keep going up?
0
Replies
-
Is your overall daily calorie goal set to less than 1200 if you’re female? Or 1500 if you’re male? Those are the minimum daily calorie goals according to MFP.1
-
I'm a female but I set my goal at 1,000cals a day. It let me change that goal but then every time I exercise, it raises that number.0
-
Why eat so little? Please eat more than this tiny amount6
-
It raises your calorie allowance when you’ve exercised because that’s how this app is designed to work.
Think of your 1200 (yes, I KNOW you said a different number, but it’s lower than the “floor” for safe eating…) as your standard ordinary day allowance. It reflects your normal non-exercise day to day calorie burn minus an amount to achieve weight loss at the rate you put in with the set-up.
So, for me 43 F, 59kg / 130lb, set at sedentary, at target weight so my “minus” is 0, this number is 1580.
BUT I do a whole bunch of exercise most days which varies wildly in amount and intensity. So I add in (log - but mine is pushed from FitBit) those calories too. Because if I didn’t, I would be massively undereating and lose when I don’t need to (or in your case lose too fast and endanger my health).
Take Thursday.
Base calories 1580
Exercise calories 1219
So I got to eat up to 2799 calories.
If I had stuck with the original 1580, and not “eaten back” my exercise I would have only given my system 361 calories to run itself for 24hrs which is clearly far too little.
You want to keep (base+exercise) - food BIGGER than 1200 or you’re going to run into trouble longer term.
Does that make sense?
(Edited for typos, imperial weight conversion)8 -
Consider this. If you are severely under eating - which you are- you will begin to lose muscle.
You realize your heart is a muscle?
Undereating can cause heart damage, hair loss, and more. There are horror stories here on MFP of people who started out undereating and suffered permanent damage.
Not to mention, it leads to cycles of binging and cutting.
Instead of punishing yourself, and your body by default, make this sustainable. So what if it takes you a few months longer.
Learn habits that will keep the weight off.
Stop buying into the Women’s Magazine and clickbait fantasy of “I lost it all in thirty days”.
I have found my weight loss via simple CICO was actually enjoyable when I got past those headline “expectations” my eyeballs had been trained to acknowledge for decades.7 -
I set my goals for the calories, protein, etc. But the app keeps raising them. It also says I'm not meeting the proper nutrition for my body but I'm eating mostly veggies, fruit, and proteins. Am I supposed to eat more even though I am meeting the goals I placed even though they keep going up?
Yes.2 -
Yes, 1000 calories is too low. There are some cases where a doctor will recommend that amount for morbidly obese patients under close medical supervision, but that’s the only exception I am aware of.
You will lose weight with a higher calorie allowance. Don’t worry about that. There are some TDEE calculators you can look at for free online that will give you a pretty good idea of where to set your calorie goals. Just Google TDEE and they will come up.1 -
https://www.calculators.tech/tdee-calculator
Let’s see if I can post a link to a simple one. It’s better/more accurate if you know your current % body fat, but I just checked my numbers with this one and it was bang on.0 -
Very low calorie diet is any diet plan under 1200calories for women and 1500 for men. Very low calorie diets are not safe without medical supervision and this app has fail safes to discourage dangerously understating. Gal stones, heart attacks, hair loss, fainting and mood swings are the most common side effects of very low calorie diets. When you exercise you burn more calories so if you're under eating to produce fast results you're not just eating super low calories you're risking health. You can also damage your metabolism the longer you eat that little causing long term harm to your weightloss goals. You can raise your calories to 1500 choose not to log your exercise or customize it to 1calorie burn and you will then bypass the fail safe and have a less dangerous plan if you're not exercising an insane amount.0
-
Why eat so little? Please eat more than this tiny amount
Iam actually eating a lot. I've been eating lots of veggies, cups of fruit, some protein, ect. I once got so full on a meal but it came out to under 500 cals. All that was in my bowl was cups of Spinach, a cup of rice Cauliflower, 2 cups of fruit, 1 cup of carrots, some lite Italian dressing, 2 Oatmeal raisin cookies, and a Mozzarella stick. And I had more to eat for dinner. So I am definitely eating, just not things that are high in calories.0 -
I am actually eating a lot. I've been eating lots of veggies, cups of fruit, some protein, ect. I once got so full on a meal but it came out to under 500 cals. All that was in my bowl was cups of Spinach, a cup of rice Cauliflower, 2 cups of fruit, 1 cup of carrots, some lite Italian dressing, 2 Oatmeal raisin cookies, and a Mozzarella stick. And I had more to eat for dinner. So I am definitely eating, just not things that are high in calories. Sorry if this comes up 2x, I'm still learning how to use this app.0
-
Why eat so little? Please eat more than this tiny amount
Iam actually eating a lot. I've been eating lots of veggies, cups of fruit, some protein, ect. I once got so full on a meal but it came out to under 500 cals. All that was in my bowl was cups of Spinach, a cup of rice Cauliflower, 2 cups of fruit, 1 cup of carrots, some lite Italian dressing, 2 Oatmeal raisin cookies, and a Mozzarella stick. And I had more to eat for dinner. So I am definitely eating, just not things that are high in calories.
Your body is a car and food is the fuel. It doesn't matter where you buy your fuel (food) from, you still need to top off the tank (calories) to get to where you're going without finding yourself stalled with no gas in the middle of the desert in 102 degree heat.
Go eat a snickers bar.3 -
Seriously, eat more! You're doing harm to your body if you don't. You might feel great now, but damage builds up over time. Think hair loss, heart damage, loss of muscles and increased risk of ostheoporosis, loss of menstruation. If you think what you're eating is normal then you really should talk to your doctor. Oh, and eat things higher in calorie.1
-
Thanks everyone. Heard your advice, am looking into it more.1
-
It is quite common that if you massively change your eating habits from higher calorie foods to very low calorie items (such as your salad bowl listed above), that you get full quickly on what turns out to be very low calories. Veggies / salad / fruit tend to be high volume, low calorie items. I love massive salads but there’s no way I could possibly eat enough to keep me fuelled. I’d need a washing-up bowl full, rather than a plate!!
What’s needed is to find a happy medium between how you have been eating, and this that enables you to get enough calories in and still feel like you’ve had enough to eat.
It doesn’t all have to be “healthy” stuff.2 -
It is quite common that if you massively change your eating habits from higher calorie foods to very low calorie items (such as your salad bowl listed above), that you get full quickly on what turns out to be very low calories. Veggies / salad / fruit tend to be high volume, low calorie items. I love massive salads but there’s no way I could possibly eat enough to keep me fuelled. I’d need a washing-up bowl full, rather than a plate!!
What’s needed is to find a happy medium between how you have been eating, and this that enables you to get enough calories in and still feel like you’ve had enough to eat.
It doesn’t all have to be “healthy” stuff.
This.
Op, sounds like you're still in the weight-loss honeymoon phase, where you've made big changes to your way of eating and are temporarily feeling full on lower calorie foods (in part because all those veggies have fiber and high water content). I actually went through this a few days ago, when I started a weight-loss phase, to lose some maintenance weight creep. Started eating large salads everyday, fruit, whole grain bread etc and was feeling really good on a lower calorie intake. But, it only lasted a few days and as my food diary shows-I've really started having trouble keeping my calories in check. Now it gets real
OP, just enter your info into MFP and let it do the math work for you. Follow it's recommendations and enjoy the calories it gives you.0 -
Why eat so little? Please eat more than this tiny amount
Iam actually eating a lot. I've been eating lots of veggies, cups of fruit, some protein, ect. I once got so full on a meal but it came out to under 500 cals. All that was in my bowl was cups of Spinach, a cup of rice Cauliflower, 2 cups of fruit, 1 cup of carrots, some lite Italian dressing, 2 Oatmeal raisin cookies, and a Mozzarella stick. And I had more to eat for dinner. So I am definitely eating, just not things that are high in calories.
If this what you like there are ways to make this higher in calories so that you get both the nutrition from the veg and it includes more to reach your goals.
So for example you could include avocado, toasted nuts and/or seeds, croutons, olive oil, quinoa/bulghar wheat, some feta or goats cheese, a chopped boiled egg. Or some lovely fresh bread to dip into olive oil and balsamic vinegar or hummous.
Mmm, hungry now1 -
littlegreenparrot1 wrote: »Why eat so little? Please eat more than this tiny amount
Iam actually eating a lot. I've been eating lots of veggies, cups of fruit, some protein, ect. I once got so full on a meal but it came out to under 500 cals. All that was in my bowl was cups of Spinach, a cup of rice Cauliflower, 2 cups of fruit, 1 cup of carrots, some lite Italian dressing, 2 Oatmeal raisin cookies, and a Mozzarella stick. And I had more to eat for dinner. So I am definitely eating, just not things that are high in calories.
If this what you like there are ways to make this higher in calories so that you get both the nutrition from the veg and it includes more to reach your goals.
So for example you could include avocado, toasted nuts and/or seeds, croutons, olive oil, quinoa/bulghar wheat, some feta or goats cheese, a chopped boiled egg. Or some lovely fresh bread to dip into olive oil and balsamic vinegar or hummous.
Mmm, hungry now
I did add an entire egg to boost my calories one day and that did the trick. I also bought some potatoes (I love them) and air fried them into Curly fries. That also helped.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions