Trying to be half the person you used to be

Fredrigo
Fredrigo Posts: 134 Member
edited October 2 in Motivation and Support
I'm wondering how many other people have shared my realization that if they were literally cut in half (vertically down the middle) the BMI would still say each half was obese.

Replies

  • smithskiman06
    smithskiman06 Posts: 29 Member
    BMI is NOT a good weight to judge health. As always the current medical communities "status quo" is not up to date. BODY COMPOSITION is where it is at my friend

    Try getting under 20% bodyfat and say the heck with BMI.
  • shesblossoming
    shesblossoming Posts: 426
    Here. But if you were to cut me in half now, I would be normal. That just made me realize I have a long way to go.
  • jmikels67
    jmikels67 Posts: 116
    How would that be possible? You'd be the same height and weigh half as much right? For me, that would put me in a healthy range theoretically.
  • Gemini_at_36
    Gemini_at_36 Posts: 207
    The good news is that you only have to work as one person to give up the weight:flowerforyou:
  • jamie1888
    jamie1888 Posts: 1,704 Member
    It may seem like you have a long way to go now, but just stick with it and you WILL reach your goal! You CAN do this! Congratulate yourself for wanting to make a change! :flowerforyou:
  • SueInAz
    SueInAz Posts: 6,592 Member
    How would that be possible? You'd be the same height and weigh half as much right? For me, that would put me in a healthy range theoretically.
    I think what the OP is saying is that if he weighed half as much as he does right now, he'd still be classified as obese.

    I think BMI is a good tool when you're actually overweight. It makes it quite apparent where you stand in relation to where you should be. It becomes less useful as you get into the normal weight range for your height and are physically fit and then body fat is a better indicator of health and fitness.
  • _SusieQ_
    _SusieQ_ Posts: 2,964 Member
    If I were cut in half I would probably be on the high end of normal, MAYBE.

    Dude, that's just depressing. :P
  • jamie1888
    jamie1888 Posts: 1,704 Member
    How would that be possible? You'd be the same height and weigh half as much right? For me, that would put me in a healthy range theoretically.

    He has a bit more weight to lose than you do!
  • lynheff
    lynheff Posts: 393 Member
    A larger than average amount of muscle can make BMI numbers look bad. You doc can best advise you there. The stuff on-line is just an average or information guide. Good luck!
  • TheBigYin
    TheBigYin Posts: 5,686 Member
    I'm wondering how many other people have shared my realization that if they were literally cut in half (vertically down the middle) the BMI would still say each half was obese.

    Well - I started out at 398 lb and a BMI of 53.9 around 3 months ago, and I've lost 42lb and dropped to a BMI of 48.2. To be in the upper end of the normal range I need to hit 184lb, so yeah, I reckon I've got to loose a half-me :smile: Hope I'll still be smiling in another year and a half or so, when I'm still working on it....
  • moushtie
    moushtie Posts: 371 Member
    Yup, if I was cut in half now, I'm pretty sure I'd still be classed as obese. Definitely would've before I started losing!
  • Fredrigo
    Fredrigo Posts: 134 Member
    Personally I broke my "I'm 2 obese people" and I used it to set my next goal which is to be "less than 2 bmi "healthy" people".

    I kind of started this conversation to highlight how limited the BMI scale is and to find other people who are trying to be healthy while dealing with what can only be described as a large frame. I think we have challenges that are slightly different from other people trying to lose weight.

    To clarify yes at my top measured weight of 412lbs if cut in half each of my halves at 5'11" would be considered obese weighing 206 lbs each. This is regardless of the fact my waist measurement has always been at least 8 inches smaller than my chest and it's easy to feel my bones at all of my joints.

    I have a hard time ordering any type of fitted clothing even from specialty retailers. I just want to let others in a similar situation know they aren't alone.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories