The importance of a "BMI Scale"
Options
Replies
-
Do body fat scales not give you an indication though? every measuring tool has a range of 'error' that is acceptable but surely it's better to have an 'idea' of your body fat reading if you can't access something like a bodypod?
Also, these scales have a terrible time trying to differentiate between water and fat. Your hydration level has a huge impact on the reading on these scales
And finally, Body Mass Index has absolutely nothing to do with body fat. Its just a ratio between height and weight, it doesn't take body composition into account at all, and has even been stated by the creator as being absolutely useless to an individual, it's only useful for the purpose it was designed, which is large population studies.0 -
My LBM is 174 pounds. I'm 5'7.0
-
So here is what I will do for you! I am FAT....not just overweight, but have given up my exercise due to a nasty divorce. Now I am at the point where I want....want...to take care of ME.
A experiment is just the thing I need to get my fat *kitten* off the couch.
Can you reccommend a scale under 50 bux? I will weigh in once a week, log my food and exercise here, and also let you know my 'scale' weight.
Will be interesting to see how it works. My BFP with the trainer and calipers (she admits she sux at the calipers) was *gulp* 44%. That will go down very quickly with exercise, weight lifting and eating foods good for my body.
Any suggestions for my experiment?0 -
So here is what I will do for you! I am FAT....not just overweight, but have given up my exercise due to a nasty divorce. Now I am at the point where I want....want...to take care of ME.
A experiment is just the thing I need to get my fat *kitten* off the couch.
Can you reccommend a scale under 50 bux? I will weigh in once a week, log my food and exercise here, and also let you know my 'scale' weight.
Will be interesting to see how it works. My BFP with the trainer and calipers (she admits she sux at the calipers) was *gulp* 44%. That will go down very quickly with exercise, weight lifting and eating foods good for my body.
Any suggestions for my experiment?0 -
Do body fat scales not give you an indication though? every measuring tool has a range of 'error' that is acceptable but surely it's better to have an 'idea' of your body fat reading if you can't access something like a bodypod?
Also, these scales have a terrible time trying to differentiate between water and fat. Your hydration level has a huge impact on the reading on these scales
And finally, Body Mass Index has absolutely nothing to do with body fat. Its just a ratio between height and weight, it doesn't take body composition into account at all, and has even been stated by the creator as being absolutely useless to an individual, it's only useful for the purpose it was designed, which is large population studies.
Well, calculate me. 175lbs, 5'7". My $93 craptastic bodyfat scale still can't tell me within any reasonable margin what my body fat percentage is...but for the most part it agrees with itself that I'm somewhere between 29% and 40%, during any given 5 minutes. They're a hoax. The only way they're even repeatable if you step on, then off again, is because the less expensive ones have a memory...so you think you got an accurate measurement. Mine varies as much as 11% from ONE measurement, step off...then step on for the NEXT measurement.
My calipers tell me I'm 18% right now...no matter how many times I measure. Matter of fact, the more times you measure, the closer to accurate my $8 calipers from Amazon will be once you've averaged the numbers.
Imagine that.
By the way...sorry for the absolutely blatant sarcasm...but this whole thread is full of misinformation...and you've repeatedly ignored anyone trying to tell you so in anything resembling a polite manner, while latching on to anyone who even remotely seems to be agreeing with you.
So I simply thought I'd try another angle.0 -
I would second the use of skinfold caliper. As long as you're consistent in where you are measuring, you'll know if you're making progress or not. As others mentioned, electronic scales aren't very accurate in measuring your body composition.0
-
Oh yeah, not only does my scale tell me my body fat percentage is 12% higher than every other test, it tells me I'm chronically dehydrated as well. My blood work and urinalysis disagrees with the scale. From what I've read, most of these scales are off by about 10-15%.
Oh, and $40 IS a cheap electronic scale. Top of the line models will run in the hundreds of dollars.0 -
Oh yeah, not only does my scale tell me my body fat percentage is 12% higher than every other test, it tells me I'm chronically dehydrated as well. My blood work and urinalysis disagrees with the scale. From what I've read, most of these scales are off by about 10-15%.
Oh, and $40 IS a cheap electronic scale. Top of the line models will run in the hundreds of dollars.
So, I'm sorry that your method did not work out for you. The caliper is also a good method, if you want to caliper every body part every week. I'll pass on that. My past tests and my scale look very comparable.
Have a good day. By the way. Write a article on your method. I'm sure people would love to hear more than mine is better. Details man....Details......0 -
Also reducing the reliability of this method is the variation between models of the BIA devices: for instance when comparing outputs from a Tanita scale to an Omron Body Logic handheld device the Tanita scale overestimated the percentage body fat in college-aged men by 40% and in college-aged women by 55%
I'm not talking anecdotal evidence. The method that the scales use is inaccurate, so the scales themselves, by default, are not accurate. That's the only point I'm trying to make. Most of these types of scales have trouble telling the difference between body fat and water. Also, sometimes they recognize some internal organs as fat. Like I said, my particular scale happens to measure my body fat 12% higher and my hydration level about 12% lower, so it's a wash. However, if my scale didn't give hydration numbers and just body fat, I'd never know that, and if I had never tested any other method, I'd have a very incorrect view of my body composition. Information is power, and more information is always better than less information.0 -
Caveat Emptor!
Just need to mention that the Tanita "electronic BFI" scale is total bulls---. It has these metal foot pads that are supposed to send a mild electric current through you to "measure body composition" and detect your BFI. It's a total scam - a cheap gimmick to sell the product.
As a simple b.s. test I did the following:
1) Weighed myself and let the scale "scan" me with it magic electric current. Weight = 190lbs (accurate), BFI = 24%
2) Picked up two 10lb dumbells and weighed myself again. This time "weight" = 210lbs (of course), but by some voodoo magic my BFI suddenly shot up to 31% !! Just because I was holding onto 20lbs of dumbells and the scale thought I was now 210lbs!
So, there is nothing special about the Tanita BFI scale. It just takes your gender, age, and height that you manually program into it, plus your weight reading and performs a simple mathematical calculation. No electronic 'scanning', no magic 'body composition' analysis. It just plugs in whatever your weight is into the built-in formula and spits out a BFI number.0 -
Aren't you confusing BMI with body fat percentage? Your BMI doesn't tell you anything about how much fat, LBM or bone you have. It just looks at your height and weight.0
-
servilia-
You are correct - my bad! I meant body fat percentage, not "BMI". Thanks for pointing that out.
However, I stand by my 'snake oil' assesment of the Tanita body fat scale. Those little foot electrode thingies do NOTHING to measure actual body fat percentage. If they did, I wouldn't be able to "fool" it by picking up a pair of dumbells and artificially increasing my weight reading. Afterall, my actual body fat percentage shouldn't have changed just because I'm holding a dumbell in each hand.0 -
servilia-
You are correct - my bad! I meant body fat percentage, not "BMI". Thanks for pointing that out.
However, I stand by my 'snake oil' assesment of the Tanita body fat scale. Those little foot electrode thingies do NOTHING to measure actual body fat percentage. If they did, I wouldn't be able to "fool" it by picking up a pair of dumbells and artificially increasing my weight reading. Afterall, my actual body fat percentage shouldn't have changed just because I'm holding a dumbell in each hand.
no I wasn't referring to yousorry - it was meant for the OP
0 -
servilia-
You are correct - my bad! I meant body fat percentage, not "BMI". Thanks for pointing that out.
However, I stand by my 'snake oil' assesment of the Tanita body fat scale. Those little foot electrode thingies do NOTHING to measure actual body fat percentage. If they did, I wouldn't be able to "fool" it by picking up a pair of dumbells and artificially increasing my weight reading. Afterall, my actual body fat percentage shouldn't have changed just because I'm holding a dumbell in each hand.
no I wasn't referring to yousorry - it was meant for the OP
No worries :-)0 -
I own a body fat scale and Omron body fat/bmi handheld monitor. Some scales you buy in the store gives you both your body fat percentage and bmi. Your bmi is simply a ratio between your height and weight. I can give you the formula to get your own bmi.
All body fat percentage method has error. Bodpod, even dunk test aren't 100% accurate. Caliper testing isn't 100% accurate.
I trust my scale and handheld monitor.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.1K Introduce Yourself
- 43.6K Getting Started
- 259.9K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.7K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 403 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.8K Motivation and Support
- 7.9K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.4K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 998 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.4K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions