do YOU eat your exercise calories?

BeautyFromPain
BeautyFromPain Posts: 4,952 Member
edited October 3 in Food and Nutrition
Hey all,

just wondering who eats their exercise calories, just want to find out what works for them :)

I eat back mine ... I didn't really when I was very obese but now I am very close to just being overweight I plateaued, and was feeling hungry and dizzy. I started eating more and it is working! :)
«1

Replies

  • rudegyal_b
    rudegyal_b Posts: 593 Member
    i eat to about my BMR, usually works out to about half my exercise cals, i feel better this way and get decent results
  • MarieNevada
    MarieNevada Posts: 395 Member
    Rarely. I eat about 1400 cals a day, sometimes 1500. I never eat back my exercise calories cause that's extra weight loss. I have never heard anyone say anything about eating them back until i joined MFP. The whole point of exercising is to increase your calorid deficit. starvation mode only happens if you consume less than 1200 calories. Consume. you can burn thousands of calories a day and not hit starvation mode. The contestants on Biggest Loser dont eat back their calories, nor do the participants on Extreme Makeover weight loss edition, or any other weight loss show i've ever seen. I've been losing weight steadily, rarely plateau, and have tons of energy. I read books about fat loss, not gimmick books but solid information books that talk about working hard and having to eat right, no easy ways to lose weight, and none of those ever say to eat back your exercise calories. If that's what works for people that's great but it's not what works for me.
  • It depends on the day for me. I usually try to stick to my original calorie goal, so I don't somehow prolong my weight loss, but If I'm still hungry and I burnt a lot of calories, I'll eat something. I've never eaten them all back though, usually like 200 or so.
  • koosdel
    koosdel Posts: 3,317 Member
    not eating exercise cals can put you in starvation mode which will stall your weight loss as will slow down your metabolism. i recently did an experiment of eating them back, check it out here if you'd like:http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/BeautyFromPain



    You would not run a car or no fuel would you?


    Also, if you do this and get very hungry, and get frustrated you may give up.



    Exercise is good for you so you do not become skinny fat, and this is how you truly change your body.


    "Exercise is the cheap man's plastic surgery."



    Also if you need more info, feel free to search the forums. There is a LOT of information around about exercise calories.
  • Hairhacker
    Hairhacker Posts: 174 Member
    The main reason I exercise is so I CAN eat more!! lol
  • amfmmama
    amfmmama Posts: 1,420 Member
    I use them as my safety net. Last night , I was going to dinner with friends, I did a zumbathon for brest cancer in the morning so I was able to enjoy myself, not worry about every calorie. I came home, logged and didn't even use them all. !
  • xSophia19
    xSophia19 Posts: 1,536 Member
    I dont eat mine back, im earning these excercise cals for a reason, im not going to eat them back :) i find i stay the same weight when i eat my excercise cals back.. And when i dont eat them back and i stick to my 1300 calorie goal, i loose 1 or 2 lbs every week or so.
  • SueGremlin
    SueGremlin Posts: 1,066 Member
    Yes!
  • ElleC
    ElleC Posts: 37
    I eat mine back, or I start feeling unwell. I work long shifts, so I need to make sure I can stay the course.

    This is the first diet where I dont feel exhausted. I have had two tired days in 6 weeks....and those days were after hard workouts at the gym, and not eating back all my cals.

    Everyone is so different on this. I think when I get lighter / hit a plateau / find a job that does not include 13 hour shifts - I might switch it up.
  • _eislek_
    _eislek_ Posts: 198 Member
    If I'm hungry I'll eat some of them back, if I'm not I won't.
  • I eat mine back.... I lost 50 pounds 5 years ago and I didn't eat them back at that point. All the weight is back! There is only so long a person can stay on such a low calorie diet unless you want to eat salads every meal the rest of your life. I learned from experience.
  • cloneme_losehalf
    cloneme_losehalf Posts: 356 Member
    If I'm hungry I'll eat some of them back, if I'm not I won't.


    same here!!! I let my body tell me whether I need to eat or not
  • yanicka
    yanicka Posts: 1,004 Member
    I eat my calories back. I am doing strenght training so I am doing my best to have no deficite
  • Jennyzfit
    Jennyzfit Posts: 175 Member
    I usually eat most of mine back because mfp has you at a lower calorie amount so your already losing.
  • jg627
    jg627 Posts: 1,221 Member
    I eat more before I go to the gym, so I have the extra calories to do the work. I train in the evening, so on my training days I eat more snacks or a bigger lunch. I still eat dinner afterwards though, but the 'extra' calories go in earlier. You can't really go by what MFP says for strength training, because it doesn't know how long your set rests are or the intensity of your workout. You have to gauge based on the difficulty. If your squats were too hard, then you probably didn't eat enough. If you're recounting the weight twice, because it feels light, then, if you didn't miscount, you ate plenty.
  • katkins3
    katkins3 Posts: 1,359 Member
    I eat my exercise calories back. I've lost 30 pounds, so far. I also do an intermittent fast one day a week.
  • jg627
    jg627 Posts: 1,221 Member
    I eat my exercise calories back. I've lost 30 pounds, so far. I also do an intermittent fast one day a week.

    I'm tempted to try IF, but I recently did a 1 1/2 day fast (required for a medical procedure) and the only way I could survive was doing weird things to take the edge off the hunger, like chugging a bottle of pure lemon juice from concentrate.
  • JamesonsMommy
    JamesonsMommy Posts: 771 Member
    Listen to you body.. if you are hungry EAT!! I don't eat mine back everyday but i try to eat at least some of them
  • Listen to you body.. if you are hungry EAT!! I don't eat mine back everyday but i try to eat at least some of them

    Exactly ^. If you're not hungry, then don't eat food just because you feel like you absolutely have to. If you are hungry, then of course eat! I try and eat back at least half of the calories I burn during work-outs. I've also found it takes away any lightheadedness if I eat a little something after a good work-out. I've been eating them back, and I've been doing pretty decently so far.
  • Rae6503
    Rae6503 Posts: 6,294 Member
    Yes I do.
  • tiedye
    tiedye Posts: 331 Member
    No, I don't. The times I do are when I am going out to a restaurant or there's a family party or something where I know without my exercise cals I'll be way over my daily limit.
  • If I'm hungry I'll eat some of them back, if I'm not I won't.

    This is how I see it. Since it's a lifestyle change, I need to let my body tell me when to eat, not my emotions.

    I lost 30 pounds at the beginning of the year with a strict 1200 calorie diet with exercise and it worked well for me. Like someone else mentioned I never heard or thought of "eating back" the exercise calories until I came on here. To me that's what you would do if you were maintaining your weight, which is not where I'm at yet.

    However, I do use them as a safety net, if I'm hungry I'm going to eat!
  • clubbybear
    clubbybear Posts: 30 Member
    Yes, I eat my exercise calories. Maybe not all of them, but most of them. I'm down 22 lbs in 9 weeks, so It's working for me.
  • sheepysaccount
    sheepysaccount Posts: 608 Member
    Just a few of them. I don't really exercise a lot so it's really not that many extra calories. But I use them to have something I shouldn't :P Like a little treat to reward me for actually doing something.
  • keola64
    keola64 Posts: 207 Member
    Aloha my friend,I have to say eating your exercise calories can variety due to different goals ,as I am trying now to gain lean mule mass I try to always eat my exercise calories,however when my goal was weight loss I didn't eat my exercise calories I usually used supplamental protein sources to force my body to have to use my excess fat as a fee/energy source without the side effect of loss of muscle mass as which is common with low calorie diets,by doing so I managed to lose close to 100 pounds in 7months ,the hard part is feeling the lack of motivation due to fatigue,but keeping a high level of protein will help all you need to do is push past the feeling of lack of energy and push through your exercise routine,keep your fats & sugar low ,keep hydrated,and get some protein powder,like whey isolate protein for pre & or after workouts,casein protein for slow releasing protein especially at nite to help prevent muscle loss so as your body burns calories even when asleep especially after a day of hard cardio only fat us lost,its a hard path I chose for my diet but if u can follow this it will work ....aloha Keola
  • kaetra
    kaetra Posts: 442 Member
    If I'm not hungry I don't eat my exercise calories. If I am hungry I will eat some, but I don't like to eat them all because exercise calories are super easy to over-estimate.

    I don't have a Heart Rate Monitor, and even if I did my heart rate is artificially lowered by blood pressure meds - so, an HRM that is guessing calories burned based on a heart rate would be guessing even more innaccurately for me.

    I refer to a couple different exercise calorie sources to try make my exercise calories as accurate as possible, but so much of excercise calories burned is pure guesswork that in the end I don't trust the exercise calorie number all that much.
  • Vegan_Chick
    Vegan_Chick Posts: 474 Member
    Rarely. I eat about 1400 cals a day, sometimes 1500. I never eat back my exercise calories cause that's extra weight loss. I have never heard anyone say anything about eating them back until i joined MFP. The whole point of exercising is to increase your calorid deficit. starvation mode only happens if you consume less than 1200 calories. Consume. you can burn thousands of calories a day and not hit starvation mode. The contestants on Biggest Loser dont eat back their calories, nor do the participants on Extreme Makeover weight loss edition, or any other weight loss show i've ever seen. I've been losing weight steadily, rarely plateau, and have tons of energy. I read books about fat loss, not gimmick books but solid information books that talk about working hard and having to eat right, no easy ways to lose weight, and none of those ever say to eat back your exercise calories. If that's what works for people that's great but it's not what works for me.
    I agree and I'm gonna stop entering my exercise because it makes me want to eat more
  • jchester71
    jchester71 Posts: 124 Member
    I never eat back exercise calories. I usually try to stick around 1200-1400 cal a day (below my MFP goal). I personally suspect the MFP net calorie calculation and eating back the calories has more to do with legal concerns than fitness ones. I briefly ran it past my wife's nutritionist/trainer/PT and he said its nonsense (which jives with the vast majority of what I have read).
  • jchester71
    jchester71 Posts: 124 Member
    not eating exercise cals can put you in starvation mode which will stall your weight loss as will slow down your metabolism. i recently did an experiment of eating them back, check it out here if you'd like:http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/BeautyFromPain

    Everybody should go through the exercise of asking an MD about "starvation mode" and see what they say. Very divergent from a lot of the MFP common wisdom.
  • i definitely do. I'm only 4'11 so I'd be eating 1200 calories a day if I didn't. I exercise like a beast to eat 2000 calories daily and maintain/lose really really slowly.
This discussion has been closed.