Leg extension machine

tmbg1
tmbg1 Posts: 1,701 Member

When I use this the regular way, it hurts my knee even on low weight. However, when I do short pulses at the top of the exercise, I really feel it in my quads without any knee pain. Is it OK to just do the pulses? Asking because I don't see anyone else doing it that way. Thanks for any input.

Replies

  • Retroguy2000
    Retroguy2000 Posts: 2,169 Member

    It depends how short that short pulse is. At the top, with your knee at zero degrees, you're getting the most tension in the muscle, and keeping that tension on the whole time is completely fine, if you go down some of the way then contract again. That's actually a good thing, and a totally valid training technique which people use for lateral raises and other exercises. However, you still want some range of motion there, say 45 degrees. It doesn't have to be 90 degrees. If the ROM is very minimal then it's basically an isometric which doesn't build much muscle.

    If you can, lean backwards to about 45 degrees. This stretches the rectus femoris at the hip, which is the main quad muscle the leg extension works which squats don't.

    This random article I found seems quite informative, may be helpful.

    https://ironbullstrength.com/blogs/sports-injury-prevention/leg-extension-knee-pain

  • nossmf
    nossmf Posts: 15,572 Member

    Not mentioned above, but I would double-check your knee placement in relation to the pivot point of the machine. Just an inch or two forwards or back from the actual pivot point can have a world of impact on stress placed upon the knee. Simply placing the end of the seat at the back of your leg is not necessarily a perfect placement for everybody.

  • tmbg1
    tmbg1 Posts: 1,701 Member

    @Retroguy2000 @nossmf Thank you for the info - very helpful! I've been using the gym only since last summer and I appreciate learning ways to keep it sustainable and not painful!

  • I2k4
    I2k4 Posts: 217 Member
    edited October 18

    Just to add a bit of sauce, I'll suggest maybe Job 1 is NOT to build quads while knees just keep on a-hurtin', but (very dependent on medical diagnosis) to fix up those knees. Ordinary knee pain (e.g. patellar tendonitis) can be effectively addressed with targeted and usually overlooked hip and knee exercises and, while isometric holds (or your pulses) are not the best muscle builders they can be better and less painful than dynamic movement for building joint tissue, that typically requires significantly more time. Kneecap problems that plagued me just walking around ten years ago have been addressed to pain-free workout status after some months focusing on pilates-type mobility and isometric holds using straps, and good nutrition. I'd suggest reconsidering personal priorities and research into joint repair.

  • tmbg1
    tmbg1 Posts: 1,701 Member
  • AnnPT77
    AnnPT77 Posts: 38,099 Community Helper

    I endorse checking that out. It's individual.

    Bystanders and a lot of articles talk about increase quad strength to reduce knee pain. They told me that, too, but I was skeptical. (In my case, I'd been doing things for a long time that tend to give good quad strength.) Sure enough, when I got referred for physical therapy, my therapist assessed me and said quad strength was fine - the problem was elsewhere.

    That may apply to you, it may not apply to you . . . and if your quad strength is OK, there are diverse other variables that can be triggering knee pain, which is one reason I'm not saying what my issues turned out to be. Yours would almost certainly be different. Quad strength is a common issue, but far from the only possibility.

  • Retroguy2000
    Retroguy2000 Posts: 2,169 Member
    edited October 19