Cardio&Strength - Together or Separate?

CheetoBandoto
CheetoBandoto Posts: 67
edited October 3 in Fitness and Exercise
Good evening pals! I've got a simple question. Is it better to do intense cardio and strength training together or separately? As in, is it better to do a really good 500+ calorie burning cardio session then immediately follow it up with weights or calisthenics or is it better to focus on cardio one day and strength the next?

I ask because I typically do my intense cardio, allow myself a short break to rehydrate and collect and then immediately jump into my strength. Tonight, I decided to give just strength a try (with a little 5 minute cardio before just to warm up) and it feels to me like my muscles feel more worked. It was also much easier to keep form since I wasn't worn down from running or jump rope.

Replies

  • Most of the stuff I've read suggests doing them different days. As you indicated, you probably get a better strength training workout if you are well rested and ready to pump some iron.
  • rosebarnalice
    rosebarnalice Posts: 3,488 Member
    Well, as a swimmer, I sorta do both together!
  • keep em seperate. you don't want to over work your body and keeping them seperate allows you to focus on certain muscles. But just my opinion.... I've had better results this way.
  • sarah44254
    sarah44254 Posts: 3,078 Member
    I like to keep them separate

    or at the very least, do my weight work first :)
  • Nikki_is_Knotty
    Nikki_is_Knotty Posts: 248 Member
    I have heard a lot of people suggest (if you do both in the same session) to do lifting then cardio.
  • neurochamp
    neurochamp Posts: 261 Member
    If you normally do weights AFTER intense cardio you're more likely to fatigue faster and lose proper form more quickly during weightlifting. You're going to get more from your weightlifting sessions if you maintain proper form, and you simply can't do that if you're already fatigued from intense cardio. If you're going to do them on the same day, I think you should do weights first, THEN cardio (short/5min cardio warmup before weights is fine).

    Otherwise I see no reason to split them up unless you need or want a rest day from one or the other.
  • sc1572
    sc1572 Posts: 2,309 Member
    Hmmm, interesting question! I personally do cardio, cool off a bit and stretch, do conditioning/strengthening, and then stretch some more. I've heard different things from different people, but I can't do it the opposite way!
  • trud72
    trud72 Posts: 1,912 Member
    i do cardio EVERYDAY and strength 3 x a week! :drinker:
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,990 Member
    Good evening pals! I've got a simple question. Is it better to do intense cardio and strength training together or separately? As in, is it better to do a really good 500+ calorie burning cardio session then immediately follow it up with weights or calisthenics or is it better to focus on cardio one day and strength the next?

    I ask because I typically do my intense cardio, allow myself a short break to rehydrate and collect and then immediately jump into my strength. Tonight, I decided to give just strength a try (with a little 5 minute cardio before just to warm up) and it feels to me like my muscles feel more worked. It was also much easier to keep form since I wasn't worn down from running or jump rope.
    Well if you do intense cardio first, you're depleting your glycogen stores and by the time you lift, the energy required is usually taken from the break down of lean tissue to amino acids.
    Since you had more glycogen to lift today, the workout was much more effective.
    You can do weights and cardio on the same day, but lift first then do cardio.
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 48,990 Member
    Hmmm, interesting question! I personally do cardio, cool off a bit and stretch, do conditioning/strengthening, and then stretch some more. I've heard different things from different people, but I can't do it the opposite way!
    How about if you found out that you could be catabolizing lean muscle tissue doing it the way you are now which would lead to a lower resting metabolic rate more quickly and leading to a stall or plateau much faster?
  • dreambig_gohome
    dreambig_gohome Posts: 194 Member
    Hmmm...I usually do both but i change the focus of my routine daily. If I do a heavier cardio day, i relax on some strength training and focus mostly on free weights and arm/chest [as my cardio usually fatigues the leg muscles]. If I'm going to focus more on strength training I limit my cardio sessions to 20 minutes max depending on how Im feeling. I always do stretching and crunches [working my core] in between the two. Sometimes if my body isnt feeling up to it I do a short intense workout with fifteen mins cardio and fifteen mins strength and that usually works well. I generally try to listen to my body and how much fatigue Im feeling. I'm trying to lose weight so I have a more cardio-centric focus but since I dance and snowboard I also need to rely on my body's strength ability, so it works for me to do both. I usually keep my regimen rations [cardio-core-strength] at about 70-10-20 for a cardio day and 20-20-60 for a strength-training day. Hope that helps!
  • crux
    crux Posts: 454 Member
    I never lift after cardio. From personal experience it's a waste of my time.

    I some times do Lifting and cardio the same day, but then the cardio is done hours later after the lifting and it's a really tough day for your body to recover from.
  • Dragongrl
    Dragongrl Posts: 186 Member
    The only way to build muscle is to let them recover. I think it's overkill to do both on the same day.
  • I think doing both is fine, but I would always do strength before cardio :-)

    Lisa :flowerforyou:
  • crux
    crux Posts: 454 Member
    The only way to build muscle is to let them recover. I think it's overkill to do both on the same day.

    I agree with this!

    So as always depends on your goals, if you are primarily working on gaining strength & muscle then eat right, lift and recover.

    If you working on some kind of hybrid general fitness, then still better to do them separate days if you can. recovery is king in any exercise routine!

    If your aim is to work up to some kind of cardio endurance event, then still lift if you can! but maybe twice a week would work better in this scenario.
  • JamesBurkes
    JamesBurkes Posts: 382 Member
    I generally keep them separate, but I try to do one workout a week that's a mix (such as the Asylum "Strength" workout, BodyPump, or two levels of 30DS one after the other).

    If I was going to do them one after the other, I would definitely do weights first - you need to be relatively fresh to really push yourself with the iron!

    Personally, after a weight workout I can't imagine doing anything else, but some low intensity cardio after weights seems to be the preferred option for many. (Good luck trying to do HIIT after weights, unless you want to say hello to your breakfast again!).
  • Enforcer25
    Enforcer25 Posts: 350 Member
    I keep them separate. I lift 3days a week and do cardio 3 days a week, I feel this way I can give my max at each. Good luck.
  • Wow! Thanks a ton for the great feedback guys! :D Since yesterday was my first strength only day I made today my first only cardio day. I'm gonna try the alternating days and see how it feels for me!
This discussion has been closed.