We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Does losing more than 1 lb/wk hurt you at maintenance?

ice1200s
ice1200s Posts: 237 Member
edited October 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
My current schedule is to lose 2 lbs./wk. I have a friend that has been doing one of the meeting type places for quite a while,and says that much loss puts your body in the starvation mode, and makes it next to impossible to not regain weight when you finally make it to the maintainance phase. Does anyone know anything about this? TIA

Replies

  • Sallycinnimon
    Sallycinnimon Posts: 102 Member
    bump... need it for my info too =) Thanks for posting this.
  • Sidesteal
    Sidesteal Posts: 5,510 Member
    My current schedule is to lose 2 lbs./wk. I have a friend that has been doing one of the meeting type places for quite a while,and says that much loss puts your body in the starvation mode, and makes it next to impossible to not regain weight when you finally make it to the maintainance phase. Does anyone know anything about this? TIA

    It largely depends on how much you have to lose. As a general rule (this is a generalization and not universally true) heavier people will have higher maintenance intakes and more pounds to lose. This allows them more room to create larger caloric deficits than a slender person.

    Conversely, someone with a very low maintenance intake might not even want to lose 1lb/week, because a 500 calorie deficit is too large of a percentage of their maintenance. For example, a 105lb person losing 3lb/week is absurd, but a 500lb person losing 3/week is within reasonable.

    Lastly, starvation mode isn't nearly as literal as people make it sound. You don't suddenly store fat. As you endure long periods of caloric deficit you will slow production of a few thyroid hormones and this lowers your metabolic rate. Having a few higher calorie days offsets this, which is one benefit of incorporating a few days at maintenance during long term diets.

    that's what I've read about the subject anyways.
  • maidentl
    maidentl Posts: 3,203 Member
    I don't think it's a matter of too much loss but how many calories you take in. If you starve yourself to lose the weight, then your metabolism slows down accordingly and thus if you try to eat "normally" again you will gain weight. You will have to eat less calories to maintain your weight.

    Hope that made sense?
  • maryd523
    maryd523 Posts: 661 Member
    I hope that isn't true. I have my goals set as 2 pounds per week, even though I am a normal weight. I would like to know why it might be bad.
  • liftingbro
    liftingbro Posts: 2,029 Member
    Starvation mode is a myth.

    If you eat too few calories over a long period of time your metabolism will slow (partially due to being a smaller person, partially do to metabolic adaptation) but it will not stop.

    Most people should not encounter slowing metabolism losing 2 pounds per week but that depends on how much fat you have. The more obese you are the less effect. If you have 100+ pounds to lose you can probably lose 5 pounds per week in the beginning and not effect your metabolism. If you are already a male at 12% BF and trying to lose 15 pounds at 2 per week you'll probably have issues.

    Most people on this site that are overweight shouldn't encounter this problem.
  • TK421NotAtPost
    TK421NotAtPost Posts: 512 Member
    My current schedule is to lose 2 lbs./wk. I have a friend that has been doing one of the meeting type places for quite a while,and says that much loss puts your body in the starvation mode, and makes it next to impossible to not regain weight when you finally make it to the maintainance phase. Does anyone know anything about this? TIA

    Metabolic slow-down is not an all-or-nothing thing. Any time you diet or maintain a caloric deficit, your body will always fight back to some degree. But like the previous poster mentioned, as long as 2 lbs per week isn't a large caloric deficit, you shouldn't notice much metabolic slow-down.

    As an example, if your daily maintenance level with exercise is 4,000 calories and you consume 3,000 calories daily for a weekly 2 lbs loss, we are talking about a moderate to a moderately high deficit (25% below maintenance).

    If you are worried about regaining when transitioning to maintenance, consider narrowing the deficit for a week prior to moving to maintenance.
  • ice1200s
    ice1200s Posts: 237 Member
    A stepped approach to maintenance sounds like a great idea! Thanx
  • ice1200s
    ice1200s Posts: 237 Member
    Yes it did. I'm hoping to never eat "normal", aka gorging like I used to, again. Thanx.
This discussion has been closed.