Intermittent fasting?
irisannRN
Posts: 121 Member
So I have been reading about intermittent fasting and am interested in trying this to jump start a few more lbs of weight loss and shed some extra fat. The only information I can find is HOW to fast. I want to know why this works??? Say I use the lean gains approach (18 hours fasting, 6 of eating) .... I am still consuming the same amount of calories in a day as if I weren't fasting right (just in smaller window of time) ??? So why does it work?
0
Replies
-
I presume the picture is you? You look fantastic, you don't look like you need to lose anything!0
-
Hi there! If that profile picture is you, then I don't think you need to lose any more weight! :bigsmile:0
-
This content has been removed.
-
I really want to give it a go too. Are you doing the 16/8 plan? I was reading the 20/4 plan, but I like the idea of no food for a whole day better, from waking to sleeping. That would probably be more like 36 hours though, if I stop at dinner the night before. When are you starting? We could do it together
Yes, I am going to do the 16/8 plan or something very close to that (was reading infor about this on leangains.com. tons of info on there). I am starting today. I would love to work up to the 24 hour + fasting but I am going to attempt to ease into it !!!! So far I have gone 13 hours today and am breaking the fast at 1pm (total 15 hours). Very easy so far and makes me feel like I could do several more hours !!!! Let's definitely do it together ! Let me know what has worked for you after you try it !!!0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Intermittent fasting helps to burn fat through very simple biochemical principles. On the lean gains program, I believe you typically fast for 15 hours, have some BCAAs then do a one hour workout, and then have your first meal of the day, which should provide all the nutrition for your post-workout recovery. You can then eat the rest of your remaining calories whenever you like during your 8 hour eating window. This type of IF is usually referred to as a condensed eating window because you actually eat every day.
Your body constantly monitors blood glucose levels to ensure they are adequate to feed your brain. This is because your brain's primary source of energy is glucose. When glucose is abundant, your liver and muscles will store it as glycogen. Any remaining glucose will then be stored as fat. When you fast, the first thing your body does is begin to use up its glycogen stores in muscle and liver; this keeps your blood glucose levels stable, and fuels your brain. When your glycogen runs out, your body must produce its own glucose in order to continue fueling your brain. It does this by starting out with some precursor molecules (can be lactic acid or amino acids) and your liver performs gluconeogensis, which is the process of making glucose. This biochemical pathway requires energy, and that energy comes from the oxidation of fatty acids.
So, on the lean gains program, you fast for 15 hours, which is sufficient to work your way through your glycogen stores and get you into fat-oxidation mode, and then you supplement with branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs), which provides your body with the precursor molecules, then you workout, which causes your body to burn more fat to make more glucose (because you've only given it protein, no carbohydrates), and then when you're done working out, you break the fast and consume all the nutrients necessary to maintain your lean muscle mass. Incidentally, when you work out, you also produce lactic acid in your muscles which is recycled into glucose via the cori cycle, another fat-burner.
Other variations of IF are effective for fat loss as well. And as long as you eat enough protein to meet your nutritional needs when you are not fasting, you really shouldn't experience much in the way of lean mass loss while fasting.
Also of note, IF has been shown repeatedly to have positive long-term effects on overall health and lifespan extension. This is thought to be the result of a process called hormesis. Basically, denying your body of food for short periods of time places mild stress on your cells. This stress in turn causes your cells to initiate a number of protective mechanisms that help to increase their resistance to stress. Over time, periodically stressed cells become more robust and healthier. The concept is similar in some ways to weight lifting: you lift weights, which places stress on your muscles. Your muscles respond by becoming stronger, such that they can eventually tolerate more stress (lift more weight).
Some people may object to IF on the grounds of driving your body into "starvation mode". The truth is that starvation mode does not occur from one day of not eating. Period. It's a gradual change in your body that takes place over sustained periods of severely restricted caloric intake. If you were to drop your daily calories to 500 per day, and sustain that level for long periods of time, you would definitely see a reduction in BMR that could not be accounted for solely by changes in body composition. But that is not what you are doing with IF. You may choose to abstain from food entirely for 1-2 times per week and eat normally the other 5-6 days, or you may choose to consume all of your calories during a shorter period of time each day. Both methods increase the amount of time your body spends doing gluconeogensis and thus increase the amount of time you spend burning fat, but do not inexplicably decrease your BMR, as long as you are eating properly when not fasting.0 -
When I started 16/8 about 3 months ago I did a lot of research. Now I just remember a few basic things that stuck.
Basically our bodies produce insulin when we eat to store any excess calories as fat. When we fast our bodies naturally regulate insulin levels.
When we fast for more than 12 hours our bodies naturally up HGH (human growth hormone) to give us energy (to hunt). HGH is a hormone that we need to use stored fat.
Seriously if really read Martin's articles on Leangains.com he goes into a lot of detail on how it works. I also really like fitnessblackbook.com0 -
i don't know if it was IF or not but around when i started it did help me break through a plateau (there are mult other confounding factors though)
I like IF because i prefer bigger meals and it is more satiating for me0 -
I'd like to try this. So do most people start on the 16 hour fast? When I'm fasting can I have coffee/tea? or should I avoid everything except water all together? Any other tips would be greatly apprectiated0
-
I'd like to try this. So do most people start on the 16 hour fast? When I'm fasting can I have coffee/tea? or should I avoid everything except water all together? Any other tips would be greatly apprectiated
Some people dive right in on longer fasts. I started with 14 hours fasts and after a week switched to 16 cause it worked better with my schedule and I wasn't having any problems at 14. Now I occasionally throw in a 20-24 hour fast - especially on Mondays after a calorie heavy weekend. Usually I can tell when my body needs one.
I just do water but I don't like coffee or tea. I sometimes drink diet pop (very rare). As long as their aren't any calories (or very minimal) coffee/tea should be fine.0 -
I haven't decided to do intermittent fasting (partly because my current system is working well right now), but I read Eat Stop Eat in the last week and its a great read. That book explains, in pretty good detail, the benefits to intermittent fasting....about the fat burning response...about when it kicks in (its maximized at the 16 or 18 hour mark if I recall correctly)...about the reason 24 hour intermittent fasting is recommended rather than a longer or shorter period of time. for anyone considering intermittent fasting, I strongly recommend reading this book.0
-
I do IF but not the Leangains version. I do two 24-hour fasts per week (Tuesdays and Thursdays). Basically, I stop eating after dinner on Monday night and don't eat again until dinner on Tuesday night, then the same thing Wednesday night to Thursday night.
It took some getting used to, but it's not that difficult for me anymore. I read Eat. Stop. Eat. and am following those principles in terms of what you can and can't have while fasting. I can drink black coffee, tea, water, and diet soda, and I can chew sugar-free gum.
I've only been doing it for about a month, so I can't really speak about results so far. I can say it is nice not to have to worry about food for two days out of the week. I have lost inches and have more energy, but I am also doing a really intense kettlebell training program for fat loss and following a heavy protein/low carb diet at the moment, so it's probably a combination of all of the above for me.
ETA: I did some research on the effects of fasting on training days for people who do strength training, and there is some evidence to suggest that muscle damage occurs in people who fast immediately prior to strength workouts. Thus, I do not fast on training days.0 -
This sounds really interesting to try! But doesn't your stomach growl all day? I'd imagine that is a little uncomfortable if you're in class or at work and there are tons of people around. Does it eventually go away?0
-
Awesome, thank you!! I think I'm gonna try it starting tonight.0
-
My stomach does growl occasionally but not much. I did have "hunger headaches" the first few times I fasted, but I don't get them anymore.
My advice is drink a lot. It blunts the hunger, and it's good for you anyway.
Honestly, the whole thing has gotten easier for me since I started eating more of a Paleo/Primal type of diet. I don't do either of those programs specifically, I just have pretty strict macronutrient goals, and hitting those every day seems to require eating tons of whole foods and very little of anything processed. It has made fasting easier, in my opinion, because the food I am eating when I'm not fasting is of much higher quality than what I was eating before (i.e. too much refined sugar, bread, pasta, etc.). It seems to keep me better nourished so that I don't get so hungry that I can't function on my fast days.0 -
I'll agree with jq2122 - If I eat closer to paleo I'm way less hungry then when I don't. Last night I had salmon and a baked potato - no stomach growls this morning. Tonight I'm having pizza - I know I might have to deal with my stomach a bit tomorrow. I just think it's worth it for the pizza on occasion.
When I was first starting my stomach growled occasionally at normal meal times. It wasn't that I was actually hungry just that my stomach was trained to expect food then.0 -
I was planning to stop eating around 8pm which I did but then I went over to a friends for a movie night and I had a few veggies, pieces of cheese and at 11pm I had a small piece of brownie. So I guess my fast started officially at 11 so I'm trying my hardest to make it to 3pm today. It's only 9:30 here right now so wish me luck!0
-
Do you still workout during the 24 hour fast?0
-
You can. I do not because I fast on non-training days. I have read that you'll get more benefit from your workout if you do it while in a fasted state, but I've also read that strength training during a fast can cause muscle damage.0
-
Oh okay. I'm a little concerned about working out and feeling faint from not eating. But I'll try and see how it works. I fasted this week for about 2 days but I was a little apprehensive to exercise.0
-
The hunger is starting to kick in lol!! 4 hours and 10 minutes left!0
-
I made it 14 hours!! I guess it's not too bad for my first day!0
-
Give it a week and 14 hours won't be tough at all.0
-
yeah I was hoping to jump right into a 16 hour but I think I will keep going at 14 for a little while and go from there. Can anybody tell me about the results they've seen by doing this? I'm about 12-15lbs from my goal weight and I'm hoping this will help.0
-
I've lost 22lbs since I started IF at the end of June, but I'm still 12-15 lbs from goal. I can tell you I haven't had any plateaus while doing this. The weight has come off consistently at 1-2 lbs/week.0
-
Wow thats great. What kind of schedule are you on? do you fast daily or a few times a week?0
-
Pretty consistently on leangains 16/8. I eat between 1PM and 9 PM. I followed this pretty strictly the first month or so and now I use a little more flexibility. I'll go past 9 PM occasionally on weekends if I'm out with friends. Usually if I eat later one day I won't break my fast the following day until later - mostly cause my body is used to fasting for 16 hours.
I throw in a few 20-24 hour fasts a month. Usually after a bad weekend I'll eat Sunday dinner at 6:00 PM and won't eat again til Monday evening. I really don't think this is necessary - I just found the research on improved brain and body function on fasts intriging and figured it doesn't hurt to do a longer fast every once and awhile.0 -
I didn't do so great over the weekend....I went over my feeding time by a little bit and I ate pretty bad. Today is a new day! The last thing I ate was 10:30 last night so I'm trying to make it to 2:30 for 16 hours. I find its so much easier during the week when I'm at work then on the weekends when I'm out with friends and family.0
-
I didn't do so great over the weekend....I went over my feeding time by a little bit and I ate pretty bad. Today is a new day! The last thing I ate was 10:30 last night so I'm trying to make it to 2:30 for 16 hours. I find its so much easier during the week when I'm at work then on the weekends when I'm out with friends and family.
Totally agree. Monday thru Friday are pretty easy (I'm too tired to do anything late on Fridays). Saturday and Sunday are tough although I don't really have a problem waiting til 1:00 to eat, just stoping at 9:00 is more difficult and of course the foods consumed on weekends are much worse. I try to keep Monday as "clean" as possible to try to get back on track.
I will also say that I used to drink 5-6 cans of pop/day and no water. Now I drink water all day at work and then 1 can of pop at night. On Saturday I drank a lot of pop and woke up Sunday feeling so dehydrated! It's amazing how you can actually feel a difference when you start doing things right.0 -
You are so right. It's easy waiting till 1 pm but not eating late at night when you're around people that are eating bad is so difficult!! Well I just made it 12 hours and I'm pretty hungry. I hope I can make it the 16 but it might be another 14 day for me.
I've never been big into pop other then the occasional diet coke but I can just imagine how much better you feel switching it for water. I try and get 2-3 liters of water during the work day and then a glass or 2 at night but lately it's been hard to keep up with it.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions