What can I add to Slim Fast to fill me up?
red_hatorade
Posts: 166
i am substituting slim fast in place of a traditional lunch, and I wanted to know if there is anything I can add to it so that I will feel more full. I have heard of whey protein, but I don't think that is appropriate for me. Any ideas?
0
Replies
-
YES, whey protein is a much better meal replacement. Slim Fast is full of sugar and has very little protein and it is protein that keeps you fuller longer.2
-
some sort of food.3
-
If you add something to slim-fast, it then becomes a weight-gaining supplement. In the hospital I work at, we give slim-fast and vegetables to people who need to gain weight (AIDS patients, cancer patients, etc.).
My younger brother couldn't put weight on when he was a child, and the doctors then also recommended he drink a slim-fast with a normal meal.
Moral of the story: Slim-Fast + Food = weight GAIN.
My advice? Skip the slim-fast, and just eat a well-balanced meal.1 -
I dont think slim fast makes u full...Everytime I drink the protein I am hungry in 2 hours0
-
I would defnately supplement it with a traditional lunch. Unless you enjoy starving.0
-
some sort of food.
Must agree with this, I was going to say a sandwich.
Sorry, I just find the whole idea of replacing food with chemical and sugars to be odd.1 -
some sort of food.
well said , no short cuts when it comes to your health and weight
0 -
Excellent advice...My advice? Skip the slim-fast, and just eat a well-balanced meal.0 -
YES, whey protein is a much better meal replacement. Slim Fast is full of sugar and has very little protein and it is protein that keeps you fuller longer.
soooooooooo true!!
two scoops of protein in 800 mL of water (or ~16oz) tastes surprisingly good (one scoop tastes really chalky)
I like isofemme - formulated for women, but it's not high quality protein like whey isolate, it's just soy protein isolate. Which works fine, becaue im not a body builder
0 -
If you add something to slim-fast, it then becomes a weight-gaining supplement. In the hospital I work at, we give slim-fast and vegetables to people who need to gain weight (AIDS patients, cancer patients, etc.).
My younger brother couldn't put weight on when he was a child, and the doctors then also recommended he drink a slim-fast with a normal meal.
Moral of the story: Slim-Fast + Food = weight GAIN.
My advice? Skip the slim-fast, and just eat a well-balanced meal.
Agree, Sorry sweety but you would be better off kicking the slim fast and eating a nutritious lunch. 0 -
I found that SlimFast not only didn't help me lose weight, but made me feel more hungry than I would have if I had eaten the same number of calories of real food. The sugar is ridiculous, and leaves you with a fantastic afternoon crash.
Try instead to learn how to eat balanced, portion-controlled meals four to six times per day within your calorie goal, and you'll do much better.0 -
Slimfast makes me moody - I need no extra help there...:explode:
Eat food, your body will be very happy with you.0 -
Have a sandwich with ham or cheese and loads of salad.. Drink a few glasses of water before and you will feel full and it'll only be about 400 cals (if you use low fat cheese and marg). You could always have a fat free yoghurt afterwards or a rice cake?0
-
This ^^^ Just don't use it as your beverage.some sort of food.0 -
Don't add to slim fast, actually dont use slim fast at all. There are far superior products out there, including real food. Let's break it down, for 190 calroies you can have a slim fast with 10 g of protein and aside from 18 g of sugar and some added vitamins and minerals, add to it my protein powder for example and you've upped your calories to 250 with 22 g of protein.
Or you can have ground turkey tacos and a multiviatmin
99% lean Ground turkey, 4 oz: 120 calories 27g of fat
1 cup spinach (like 6 c)
2 x 4.5 inch corn tortillas (90 c)
salsa 2 TBSP 10 c
sprinkling of 2% cheddar1 -
I had much success on the former Slim-Fast Optima program. With that one you ate food along with your shake or meal bar for lunch or supper. I lost consistently. I have kept the weight off for almost 4 years now. I left SF when they started the 3.2.1 program because I felt it was not a good way to lose weight or maintain weight loss anymore (very different from their old way of thinking). I think I would starve on the current program.
With the Optima I had a hard time eating everything in my day's menu, but the SF dieticians said to try to eat as much as I could. I was always satisfied when I was on this program.
I would add a 1/2 sandwich (ex. 2 oz. turkey breast, 1 tsp. low fat or fat free mayo, lettuce, tomato along with a shake or meal bar) or grilled chicken breast or turkey breast salad. I would also add a serving of fruit to this. I always aimed for 200 calories at breakfast, 400 calories for lunch and 500 cal. for supper, with 3 snacks in between. Depending on how much weight you have to lose for your height and current weight and how active you are, the calories and nutrients you need everyday vary widely. I have alot of my old SF menus from that program along with some good recipes. Altho, you can go to Ali at SF and request some of the old recipes from the Optima program. Good luck!!0 -
I'm not one to drink my calories - at least not on a regular basis, but you could easily add a banana to chocolate SF or other berries to some of the other flavors.0
-
Go back to eating real food.1
-
I GAINED weight on slim fast. I NEVER felt full and I would often eat lots later... plus tons of sugar, not good for insulin, etc. If you need want a meal replacement.. I know its a bit more expensive.. but shakelogy is GREAT. (Chocolate.. the green one is nasty)0
-
I am also doing slim fast.... i have the shake for breakfast and I have an equate meal bar at lunch... and I have healthy snacks during the day along with my dinner with the family.
is it really bad? am I hurting my plan to loose weight??
I am confused now...0 -
I am also doing slim fast.... i have the shake for breakfast and I have an equate meal bar at lunch... and I have healthy snacks during the day along with my dinner with the family.
is it really bad? am I hurting my plan to loose weight??
I am confused now...
After I did slim fast and GAINED weight.. I did much research and yes, I believe that it is bad. Basically you are getting sugar, chemicals.. none which are helpful if you want to lose weight. The thing that has helped me is eating food that is low on the glycemic index..and I have a tiny piece of chocolate every night. I dont feel deprived at all0 -
Maybe I worded my question wrong. I guess I was trying to see if there was something like whey protein but that was formulated for losing weight. Most things I have read about whey protein have said they are for building mass. I thought maybe adding something to my Slim Fast would work, but if it is something by itself i am up to try that too. I only have been drinking Slim Fast because I got it on sale and I am so busy that cooking lunch isn't an option for me.0
-
Everyone has their own opinion, of course, but I think the 3.2.1 plan isn't enough food.
I saw your post after I posted this, but I posted this for arynamber that said she is confused about SF now. Sorry.0 -
It may help you lose the weight (seems the jury is still out on that one), but it won't retrain you in knowing how to eat to keep the weight off and maintain a healthy balance. Do you plan on consuming artificially flavored shakes and bars for two meals a day for the rest of your life? Probably not. MyFitnessPal is brilliant at helping you know the caloric and nutritional content of real food. In just over a week, it has been eye opening for me to know exactly how many calories I was chowing down. I was eating good foods, just FAR too much of them. I am now conscious of portion sizes and paying more attention to the nutritional content of my foods over the course of a week. Once I train myself in this approach, I know it's something I will be able to stick with long-term, in any setting. Can't say that about meal replacement products.I am also doing slim fast.... i have the shake for breakfast and I have an equate meal bar at lunch... and I have healthy snacks during the day along with my dinner with the family.
is it really bad? am I hurting my plan to loose weight??
I am confused now...0 -
Thanks,
so what is a typical breakfast or lunch and how much calories should one be consuming for these meals if hoping to loose weight?0 -
ive always used slim fast as part of my weight loss..never have had a problem with it. in fact im currently sittin here adding my calories for my slim fast meal bar...i use slim fast for the extra vitamins, fiber, and the low calories...i didnt realize so many people were against slim fast..is there anyone who is for it besides me??0
-
I am..I don't rely soley on SF products and never did. When I belonged to SF they gave you options other than eating or drinking thier products, so I don't see that I was dependant on them. They are convenient. I have used them for bout 4 years now, but like I said not soley. I have learned how to eat healthy on my own, with the help of the SF dieticians back when I was on the Optima program. I can see, tho, how people get dependant on them. It takes a long time to learn to eat right and it's a constant learning experience, like any major lifestyle change. I had learned alot thru the old SF plan, but also have learned to experiment and look at alot of other sources for information. This worked for me.0
-
I am very busy in the morning and have a severe egg allergy, Oatmeal causes majoy carb crashes for me...the ONLY thing I have found that leaves me not starving for the three hours between breakfast and my snack is Slim-Fast. I only use it in the morning, I've lost 37 pounds doing this....0
-
I persnally love a scoop of %100 Whey Protein Powder, half of a banana or a few berries, ice and 8-10oz of vanilla soy milk for a meal replacement.
I buy bananas and strawberries in bulk, cut them up and freeze them so they're ready for my shakes.0 -
I agree with most of the group. Whey protein is the way to go!!! I use GNC wheybolic with fat free milk. Try it, it's delish!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions