squats

meerkat70
meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
edited October 4 in Fitness and Exercise
I'm really struggling with squats. My knees are always crunchy, and getting into a deep squat, even without a weight, can hurt. Shallow squats don't seem to do anything much for me. In addition, I have a rotator cuff injury, which makes squats with a bar with narrow grip very painful at the shoulder.

I find the stance for a squat unnatural and uncomfortable.

What are the alternatives? How can I make this work for me? I've read articles suggesting 'if you're not doing squats, you're not training', but are there ways round this?

Replies

  • rjones21986
    rjones21986 Posts: 2 Member
    Try doing leg press on a machine. It takes a lot of stress off your lower back and you don't have to bend your knees as much. Plus you can use both of your hands to support your legs during your press if you find yourself struggling. I would also try lunges with dumbells in each hand.
  • engineman312
    engineman312 Posts: 3,450 Member
    try lunges and box jumps for other quad exercises.

    the form for a squat should basically look like you're trying to sit down.
  • brookepenni
    brookepenni Posts: 787 Member
    I do squats a lot wider (legs further apart) than most people, because it is the most comfortable and hurts my knees less. Whould that help?
  • I do squats a lot wider (legs further apart) than most people, because it is the most comfortable and hurts my knees less. Whould that help?

    I do the same thing. Also I've noticed doing a leg together squat (idk what the proper term is, but I do it in Zumba) also is easier. It seems like the middle area is when my knees start to hurt!
  • kir911
    kir911 Posts: 228 Member
    I would first work on your form with body weight squats, trying widening your stance and kinda pointing your toes out a little, it takes a little bit of the stress off your back. It is also helpful to put something behind you to kind of sit down onto. Like a weight bench or something that you have to make contact with and then come up again. Lightly touch it, don't actually rest or loose the resistance, and come back up. Work on that first and then progress to adding weight. Your form is half the battle!
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    Thanks everyone. :-)

    I do do seated leg press - pushing 85 kg on there (about 190lb). Do you think if I continue to build strength with that kind of move, the squats will eventually get easier?

    I find lunges tough for the same kind of reason - will shallow lunges do, or are there the same problems with shallow lunges and knee strain that there are with squats?

    I'll look up box jumps - not sure what they are.

    I wonder about the wider squat position - maybe I'll give that a go and see.

    Thanks everyone, this has been helpful.
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    I would first work on your form with body weight squats, trying widening your stance and kinda pointing your toes out a little, it takes a little bit of the stress off your back. It is also helpful to put something behind you to kind of sit down onto. Like a weight bench or something that you have to make contact with and then come up again. Lightly touch it, don't actually rest or loose the resistance, and come back up. Work on that first and then progress to adding weight. Your form is half the battle!

    I'll try this too. I don't feel i have the form right, but at my gym there isn't really anyone to help with that. The bench idea sounds good. I think part of the problem is that this exercise more than any other makes me feel incredibly self conscious. I think I'll try your suggestion at home - practising at home just to get the stance and form right might make me feel less of a twonk.
  • If you have a large stability ball, try doing squats with the ball in your lower back area against a wall. It really helped me when I first started doing squats and had the same problem. Once my overall strength increased, regular squats became more "comfortable."

    This also really helps you use proper form.
  • MsFitnFabulous
    MsFitnFabulous Posts: 432 Member
    I too squat with my legs wide.


    I'd suggest you mention your pain during your next Dr visit as well.
  • dexters_dexterity
    dexters_dexterity Posts: 342 Member
    I'm really struggling with squats. My knees are always crunchy, and getting into a deep squat, even without a weight, can hurt. Shallow squats don't seem to do anything much for me. In addition, I have a rotator cuff injury, which makes squats with a bar with narrow grip very painful at the shoulder. I find the stance for a squat unnatural and uncomfortable. What are the alternatives? How can I make this work for me? I've read articles suggesting 'if you're not doing squats, you're not training', but are there ways round this?
    facing the same problem these day. I was very depressed then someone suggested leslie sansone walk away the pounds i started with 1 mile and came upto 4 just in 1 week. then for a change i did winsor pilates and found tht it really burns glutes and thighs without a hint of stress on knees. i can PM u the link of winsor on net

    if u r just concerned about squats the support idea is gr8 second can be that to make sure that ur knee is just over ur ankle. i always thought i do squats right. its just that it is very difficult that my knees hurt and i quit. then i watched myself in mirror sideways while doing it, now i know i push my knees too forward and keep my back prependicular,
    but actaully to work on legs u r supposed to push ur buns back and knees over ankles
  • kir911
    kir911 Posts: 228 Member

    I find lunges tough for the same kind of reason - will shallow lunges do, or are there the same problems with shallow lunges and knee strain that there are with squats?

    I'll look up box jumps - not sure what they are.

    If your knees are giving you issues I would wait on lunges or Box jumps, those are more advanced moves. I would focus on getting your form right on squats first. You most definately can do this at home. I would recommend it!
  • chefgorman
    chefgorman Posts: 45 Member
    my trainer has been using an exercise ball against the wall while I'm doing squats. I also use a wider stance as well.
  • GorillaNJ
    GorillaNJ Posts: 4,024 Member
    Be sure to push your knees out as you squat down... and do not try to lift more then you can do a full range of motion with.

    Personally i think that leg press machine is horrible, it gives your back no where to go and can lead to injury. Especially for someone who is looking to get into better shape. It has a place for the bodybuilders... but is far inferior to a squat.

    Look up goblet squats, do it with a dumbell held infront of your chest, it might help you with the form
  • instructor03
    instructor03 Posts: 56 Member
    Proper form is so important. While squatting, your butt leads the way back and down like sitting in a chair. Put almost all of the weight in the heels of your feet. Tip: lift your big toes OFF of the floor and start the squat. Big toes off of the floor will force you to sit back. Take a peek at your knees. You should be able to see your toes as you squat, showing you that you are keeping your knees BEHIND the toes. It may feel awkward at first and feel like you are going to fall over so use your own body weight until you feel comfortable with the movement and get the range of motion.
    If you have a full length mirror, turn to the side and do your squat. See if your knees remain mostly over your ankles(they will slide forward slightly) but should NOT go passed your toes.
  • stubbysticks
    stubbysticks Posts: 1,275 Member
    This is a good site that I reference for form all the time because it has animations: http://www.exrx.net/WeightExercises/GluteusMaximus/BBSquat.html

    I used to have crunchy knees - I know you've been running - but it seems that as I've gotten more accustomed to running that's gotten better. By all means keep up the leg workouts, but maybe an additional thing you could do is arrange your workouts differently. I don't know how frequently you run & if your runs are structured at all, but when I was doing a split-body routine I'd make sure to schedule my leg workout before my distance run & not the other way around. Putting as much time as you can between runs & your leg workout will help minimize any knee tenderness, maybe do your leg workout after your rest day.

    Stick with the squats...your butt will be awesome!
  • czechsmate
    czechsmate Posts: 556 Member
    I do squats a lot wider (legs further apart) than most people, because it is the most comfortable and hurts my knees less. Whould that help?

    I do both...but I do this one too, legs further out as much as possible and toes pointed out...you can feel it in your inner thighs a lot too!
  • czechsmate
    czechsmate Posts: 556 Member
    Proper form is so important. While squatting, your butt leads the way back and down like sitting in a chair. Put almost all of the weight in the heels of your feet. Tip: lift your big toes OFF of the floor and start the squat. Big toes off of the floor will force you to sit back. Take a peek at your knees. You should be able to see your toes as you squat, showing you that you are keeping your knees BEHIND the toes. It may feel awkward at first and feel like you are going to fall over so use your own body weight until you feel comfortable with the movement and get the range of motion.
    If you have a full length mirror, turn to the side and do your squat. See if your knees remain mostly over your ankles(they will slide forward slightly) but should NOT go passed your toes.

    Bump!
  • findingfit23
    findingfit23 Posts: 845 Member
    Sometimes I use the exercise ball against the wall, you can do it with your back to the wall or your chest. For the chest you have to stand forward on an angle. Ill look to see if I can find a video.
  • steffiejoe
    steffiejoe Posts: 313 Member
    How do you log squats in MFP?
  • livnlite
    livnlite Posts: 520
    Form and technique are very important when working on any weight bearing joint. If you are doing dynamic jumps .. even moreso.

    I used to be an instructor (years ago, mind you) .. training techniques change over the years, so what I know .. or used to know, might not be as relevant anymore ..

    But, it was typically suggested that you never go over a 90 degree angle when doing squats. ..especially when carrying a 'load' like in weight training. Anything over 90 degrees is really hard on the knee joint. You'd be surprised at how much even shallow squats can do for your quads .. Remember it's your quads you are focusing on working .. not the joint. Keep your toes in line with your knee cap. NEVER turned to the side .. Alignment is key!

    As you squat, your feet may develop a tendency to pronate, or "cave in" toward the inner side. When this happens, the knees are also forced inward, leading to a constant strain on the medial collateral ligaments, excessive shear force on the meniscus, and improper patellar tracking, which in turn can lead to chondromalacia. Having good solid shoes is a must.

    If your feet tend to pronate anyway, or if you're prone to being "knock kneed" (and these two conditions are very often associated with one another), it becomes even more important to select good training shoes.

    Stretches and no weight bearing exercises are slightly different because of less compromising 'load'.

    I have very bad knees and hips .. and have started taking a supplement with Glucosamine .. and what a difference! At least for me .. I even give my dogs the canine version. This stuff is short of miraculous! A definite suggestion to anyone with joint problems.
  • Azdak
    Azdak Posts: 8,281 Member
    Proper form is so important. While squatting, your butt leads the way back and down like sitting in a chair. Put almost all of the weight in the heels of your feet. Tip: lift your big toes OFF of the floor and start the squat. Big toes off of the floor will force you to sit back. Take a peek at your knees. You should be able to see your toes as you squat, showing you that you are keeping your knees BEHIND the toes. It may feel awkward at first and feel like you are going to fall over so use your own body weight until you feel comfortable with the movement and get the range of motion.
    If you have a full length mirror, turn to the side and do your squat. See if your knees remain mostly over your ankles(they will slide forward slightly) but should NOT go passed your toes.

    The "keep the knees behind the toes" is somewhat outdated information. It is more important to follow a "figure 4" position in which the angles of the back and the angle of the tibia are parallel than it is to slavishly keep the knees behind the toes. For some people, depending on their skeletal dimensions and flexibility, that means the toes may go out a little farther than was recommended in the past.
  • musclebuilder
    musclebuilder Posts: 324 Member
    Thanks everyone. :-)

    I do do seated leg press - pushing 85 kg on there (about 190lb). Do you think if I continue to build strength with that kind of move, the squats will eventually get easier?

    I find lunges tough for the same kind of reason - will shallow lunges do, or are there the same problems with shallow lunges and knee strain that there are with squats?

    I'll look up box jumps - not sure what they are.

    I wonder about the wider squat position - maybe I'll give that a go and see.

    Thanks everyone, this has been helpful.

    And if you end up injured you realy may not be training. You can look to find an exercise or exercises that allow you took work the same muscles minus upsetting the knee. See if over time this allows your knee issues to improve. Make sure you put the same effort into the disciplines of warming up/stretching ect..as you do your training. Also you may want to look into a front squat. This squat will keep you back and more upright..This should place less stress on your knees..It can have a positive influence on back squat technique..And for somebody who has reduced flexibility in their shoulder joint and has pain and discomfort when gripping the bar during back squats as you mentioned, this can be an answer to that issue as well.

    A poster above mentioned placing a bench under you for squats "box squats" These may be doable for you as well as this puts the majority of the weight on the hamstring/glutes/heels and does not put pressure on the knee or patella tendon..The key with these exercises like any is doing them properly. Practice technique with no weight..Read,study video ect..so you do them right from the start.

    You mentioned you can currently do leg press..A great bodybuilder created a leg training program when he could no longer squat due to injury. A friend of mine who recently had another knee surgery of several he has had for both knees was in the same situation. He cannot squat without severe pain. Somebody suggested he look up Francisco "Wheels from Hell" training program..And yes, it is a training routine from hell.lol My friend did and has been following it for several months now without knee pain or discomfort and he is making significant progress once again..If you're interested in giving it a go, here is the link..

    http://anabolicminds.com/forum/genomyx/159450-wheels-hell-article.html
This discussion has been closed.