Dinner eating!

oberon0124
oberon0124 Posts: 10,524 Member
edited October 2024 in Food and Nutrition
They say that i am doing this *kitten* backwards. Let me know what you think. I save and use most of my calories for the day for the evening meal. I usually eat almost half my calories at that time. Add to this the fact that I even eat a late dinner, usually after six pm.
Now everyone I talk to says that I should have my biggest meal in the morning. Here is my reasoning for what I do. I eat a late and large meal most every day to keep me out of the fridge!. If I eat a small meal or to early I always find myself hungry by 10 pm. Then i am grazing the fridge for something to eat. It also seems that I have no will power to resist at 10 pm also.

Any ideas on the matter or how to not be hungry at 10 pm would be appreciated. I have had great success doing what I am doing. I would also value any ideas that may improve my overall health and well being. Thnak you in advance!

Replies

  • tmm01
    tmm01 Posts: 137
    I often do the same. With work, it's not until the evening when I have a cooked meal. My recommendation would be try not to make it to carbohydrate heavy or a meal that will 'sit on your stomach'. If you can try to do some low intensity exercise about 30mins after the meal - just something light, this will make sure that your metabolism is working at a slightly higher rate for a few hours into the night.

    I often eat about 7pm, so it's not too bad.
  • BreakinTheChains
    BreakinTheChains Posts: 381 Member
    From what I have read and heard, it does not matter what time you consume the calories.. I'm a shift worker and I eat all hours .. With that said .. Most people consume more calories at dinner , if you look at diaries.. Also If it's not broke why fix.. You said this is working well for you and that you're seeing great results... :happy:
  • fromaquasar
    fromaquasar Posts: 811 Member
    It doesn't matter when you consume your calories or the bulk of your calories as long as you are maintaining a deficit you will lose weight. I regularly eat my last meal at 10 pm or later.
  • If it's working for you why screw with it?
  • Jxen
    Jxen Posts: 1
    What I have found to work for me is still eating that relatively large meal at dinner time (around 7-8pm), but cutting out some of the complex carbohydrates such as pasta, bread, rice, potatoes etc. or at least reducing them to less than 1/3rd of the calories for that meal. Later in the evening decaffeinated teas are my savior. If I am desperate for a nibble I always keep some low calorie, low sugar jello in the fridge as well.

    And hey ... at the end of the day you need to keep yourself happy - otherwise you won't stay on track! So don't feel too bad about the grazing. Just try and balance it out the next day with some extra exercise :)
  • Matttdvg
    Matttdvg Posts: 133 Member
    Eating a large meal in the morning does nothing for your metabolism. It's a myth. Eat whenever you want. Do whatever works for you. For a lot of people, a large meal in the morning helps prevent hunger throughout the day. Others don't have an issue with having a small or even no breakfast. It's down to personal preference. Your metabolism isn't effected by meal sizes at various times of the day.
  • Eating a large meal in the morning does nothing for your metabolism. It's a myth. Eat whenever you want. Do whatever works for you. For a lot of people, a large meal in the morning helps prevent hunger throughout the day. Others don't have an issue with having a small or even no breakfast. It's down to personal preference. Your metabolism isn't effected by meal sizes at various times of the day.

    This is completely true ^^

    This is the common myth/saying: Eat breakfast like a king, lunch a queen, dinner like a pauper

    And it is debunked here: http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debunked.html

    Here is a small portion of the article:

    Truth

    Also connected to this saying, is the belief that you should reduce carbs in the evening as they will be less likely to be stored as fat. While this might sound good on paper, there's nothing to support it and a lot that shows it to be wrong.

    The strongest argument against this are the numerous studies available on body composition and health after and during Ramadan fasting. This meal pattern of regular nightly feasts has a neutral or positive effect on body fat percentage and other health parameters. This is quite an extreme and telling example. People literally gorge on carbs and treats in the middle of the night to no ill effect. And yet, in the bizarre world of bodybuilding and fitness, people worry whether it's OK to eat 50 grams of carbs in their last meal.

    If the scientific data on Ramadan fasting aren't enough, there are plenty of other studies showing no effect on weight loss or weight gain from eating later in the day.

    In one study comparing two meal patterns, which involved one group eating more calories earlier in the day and one group eating most calories later in the day, more favorable results were found in the group eating large evening meals. While those who ate more in the AM lost more weight, the extra weight was in the form of muscle mass. The late evening eaters conserved muscle mass better, which resulted in a larger drop in body fat percentage.
  • ljbhill
    ljbhill Posts: 276 Member
    I used to be the same.

    The problem with this is that your stomach will never be able to shrink and you will always be needing that large meal to feel full! So when you're eating smaller in the day you are STARVING by night time.

    Try smaller meals more frequently through the day.

    Something along the lines of breaky, mid-morning snack, lunch, dinner, afternoon and after dinner snack! If you're constantly eating you wont feel deprived and need that massive night meal. It may take you about 3-5 days to get used to it but it works!
  • ljbhill
    ljbhill Posts: 276 Member
    I used to be the same. Dinner was my favourite (and biggest) meal of the day.

    The problem with this is that you're stomach never gets a chance to shrink. You eat sparingly through the day and are STARVING in the evening. For me this is the worst scenario because food is so much more accessable when I'm at home in the evenings!

    I'd eat smaller meals more frequently throughout the day, something along the lines of; breaky, mid morning snack, lunch, afternoon snack, dinner and after dinner snack! 2-3 hours between each meal. You're constantly eating so you don't feel deprived.

    It may take 3-5 days to get used to it but it teaches portion control and than you no longer need the big dinner meal!
  • CARNAT22
    CARNAT22 Posts: 764 Member
    My dinner is always my 'biggest' meal - I eat about 8 / 8.30pm and have been around my goal weight for months now.

    I do however eat little and often through-out the day to make sure I never feel 'starved'
  • HMonsterX
    HMonsterX Posts: 3,000 Member
    I skip breakfast, I'd rather have those calories later in the day when i actually want them! I have a small lunch, around 3-400 cals, then a big dinner around midnight every day, around 8-900 cals. Meal timing and size is irrelevant as long as you maintain that calorie deficit. :)
  • KimmieBrie
    KimmieBrie Posts: 825 Member
    As long as you don't exceed calorie requirements and aren't starving all day then all good.

    That's how I ate when I was younger and never had a weight issue.

    Now I'm sort of opposite...
    I do breakfast, lunch, and snacks at work and light dinner or snack instead of a big night meal.
    That's because work makes me hungry and nothing to distract me but more work. So it's easier to
    eat light at home and by then I'm not even that hungry.
This discussion has been closed.