How to Cut Carbs/Adjust diet for faster weight loss
rydanip
Posts: 62 Member
Hello All,
When I went to the doctor in August for my yearly physical I was just under 20 lbs heavier than I am now. I remember I had been stuck at a plateau for like 6 months and was really discouraged, and she told me to cut my carbs to like 45g a day. I joined MYP and have lost at a steady pace but its been really slow. Now I never cut carbs like she said I just tracked calories.But I have read that cutting carb intake speeds up weight loss and really helps with bellyfat which is my arch nemesis! Have any of you cut carbs significantly? What happens If I start eating them at the recommended daily amount again? Are Carbs the enemy? Very confused but would like to shake things up a bit!
When I went to the doctor in August for my yearly physical I was just under 20 lbs heavier than I am now. I remember I had been stuck at a plateau for like 6 months and was really discouraged, and she told me to cut my carbs to like 45g a day. I joined MYP and have lost at a steady pace but its been really slow. Now I never cut carbs like she said I just tracked calories.But I have read that cutting carb intake speeds up weight loss and really helps with bellyfat which is my arch nemesis! Have any of you cut carbs significantly? What happens If I start eating them at the recommended daily amount again? Are Carbs the enemy? Very confused but would like to shake things up a bit!
0
Replies
-
Hey rydanip.. I'm going to point you to one of my favorite websites reddit.com.. they have a FAQ on something called ketogentic. It sounds just like what the dr is trying to get you to do..
http://www.reddit.com/help/faqs/keto
here is an exerpt..
What is keto?
The ketogenic diet is a high-fat, adequate-protein, low-carbohydrate diet. The diet mimics aspects of starvation by forcing the body to burn fats rather than carbohydrates. Normally, the carbohydrates contained in food are converted into glucose, which is then transported around the body and is particularly important in fueling brain function. However, if there is very little carbohydrate in the diet, the liver converts fat into fatty acids and ketone bodies. The ketone bodies pass into the brain and replace glucose as an energy source. Ketosis is the state characterized by elevated levels of ketone bodies in the blood. Very simply put ketosis is when your body stops using glucose for energy and instead uses fat broken down into ketones.0 -
You need to do some research. Cut the unhealthy carbs. Fruit, veggies, avocado, whole wheat, just to name a few , are good for you, IN PORTION CONTROL!
Belly fat is cardio. You cannot spot reduce. Exercise and healthy eating will eventually help with excess fat.0 -
I tried low carb once. Fainted on my way home from my nightly run. That was scary.
When you go low carb you will drop a lot of --> water <-- weight. You don't always lose fat faster. And yes, when you add in carbs you gain this water weight back.
Carbs are not the enemy. A surplus of calories is the cause0 -
My suggestion would be to cut the processed sugars from your diet.0
-
I eat Lean meat and green vegetables whenever possible, and I have string cheese and fruits that don't have a lot of sugar as snacks. I stay away from corn, bread, and sugar at all costs!!! I've lost 41 pounds in like 2 months so cutting carbs really works well!0
-
OH and also I work out like it's crack (most of the time) Cardio cardio cardio!0
-
Bump.0
-
I eat Lean meat and green vegetables whenever possible, and I have string cheese and fruits that don't have a lot of sugar as snacks. I stay away from corn, bread, and sugar at all costs!!! I've lost 41 pounds in like 2 months so cutting carbs really works well!
Are you saying that you lost weight because you cut carbs? Because if you are in a calorie deficit you WILL lose weight.
If it fits into your macros....om nom nom0 -
I don't know what kind of carbs you eat (your diary isn't public), but if you're eating 'white' carbs like white bread, rice, refined sugar, then maybe you should just try to eat more whole grain breads, brown rice, etc.0
-
You need to do some research. Cut the unhealthy carbs. Fruit, veggies, avocado, whole wheat, just to name a few , are good for you, IN PORTION CONTROL!
Belly fat is cardio. You cannot spot reduce. Exercise and healthy eating will eventually help with excess fat.
There is not a healthy/unhealthy carb and cardio does not target belly fat.
Eat all your carbs in the evening in a short window and adjust down to around 100gms a day and you will see benefit.0 -
But I have read that cutting carb intake speeds up weight loss and really helps with bellyfat which is my arch nemesis! Have any of you cut carbs significantly? What happens If I start eating them at the recommended daily amount again? Are Carbs the enemy? Very confused but would like to shake things up a bit!0
-
Carbs cover a lot of territory. My enemy is starches -- even the "good" ones. I followed the 17-Day Diet for 3 months, which in the first phase eliminates all starches while retaining light fruits and vegetables, lean meats, non-fat dairy, and eggs. I have lost and maintained the loss of 30 pounds since then. I eat some starches now, but I still eliminate then from my regular routine and just use them for treats.
Weight loss from restricting carbs is NOT water weight loss. Only at first, as the fiber (filled with water) moves through your system.
The whole purpose of a reducing diet is to force your body to burn its stored fat. As long as carbohydrate energy is flowing through your system freely and regularly, your body will not turn to fat for energy. Thus, the reduction in carb intake.
At least, this has been completely true for me. On a routine basis, my carb count hovers around 75-80g per day. And yes, I do work out. I'm a dancer and a backpacker and I lift weights.0 -
rydanip, I was on the ketogenetic diet 30 years ago. I changed to a wholesome diet. Over the years, I needed to work on my own nutrition. So I researched foods that I would eat along with the their nutritional contents and designed my own nutrition plan around it. Mhotch is right on - cardio will help burn off belly fat, but I'd like to add to it. Weight training will build lean muscle, and the cardio will burn off the fat. Working your legs in cardio will burn fat on the lower part of your body.
Eating the right food is like putting good fuel in a car. With good fuel, the car runs. When a car has bad fuel, it doesn't run well. Same is true for your body. Lean proteins, fruit, vegetables are important.
Everyone is different. You have to find what works with you and be consistent about it. If you need help, let me know. I'll be happy to help.0 -
Low-carb works for me. I've never felt faint or light headed and I work out with a personal trainer four days a week.
The key is what carbs you eat. Obviously, if you low-carb or not, cut out all white flour products, white rice, white pasta, sugar and sugary syrups, cakes, cookies,etc. This is smart no matter what.
When I low-carb, I turn my habitual American eating habits on their head - breakfast is my heaviest meal of the day, usually accounting for 40% of my overall calorie intake. Dinner is my lightest meal of the day, rarely accounting for more than 20% of my daily calories. Someone said it best & I don't know who, but a good rule is, "Eat like a King at breakfast, a Prince at lunch, and a pauper at dinner.
Good luck!0 -
Carbs are not the enemy. Just like fat wasn't the enemy back a few years ago. In moderation, NOTHING is the "enemy". It is over indulging in anything that is the enemy to weight loss. Plain and simple.
That being said, different people respond differently. For me, cutting carbs makes me feel terrible. I am sluggish. All I want to to is sleep. Also, I tend to gain weight when I drop my carbs very low. I've spoken to a doctor about it and she said that everyone's body responds differently to different things and to do what works for me.
Figure out what works for YOU and YOUR BODY. Don't base your decisions on what works for anyone else. I truly believe that the key to success in this journey is learning about your body. To listen to it. To try and understand it.0 -
I went low carb/gluten free... at first very strictly only salad. veg with meat or fish for meals and some fruits. I missed my toast so I found some gluten free bread and allowed it once a week, but i had to burn at least 500 extra cals that day and never had more than 1 carb item in one day.. so couldnt have toast at breakfast AND a small jacket potato for tea.
I love my chocolate brownies and that was always gonna be my major weakness but found a gluten free one. Only thing I couldn't cut out was my yorkshire puds as I'm a yorkshire lass and been having them every sunday for over 40years! .. but I reduced it to a mini one and replace the potatoes with either parsnips or turnip cut into roast potato shapes or carrot/swede mash instead of mashed potato.. I do a workout sunday morning.
All other meals in week don't contain carbs I replace them with butternut squash, parsnip chips, etc.. I allow sweet potato once a week.
My water retention greatly improved and after experimenting it seems I only pile it back on more or less instantly if the carb is heavy portion of wheat based carbs (ie pasta, regular bread) and more than 1 day in a row.
I will re-introduce more carbs more frequently as I get closer to my goal weight but will probably stick with gluten free bread rather than going back to regular bread.. and maybe allow 1 meal a week with carbs so can have chips, jacket spud or a curry and rice if I fancy it as an occasional treat.
I found that if i have small portion of carbs midweek or weekend and the days at either side I stick to diet strictly I don't put on any extra water weight... currently only putting on an extra 1lb a day by bedtime.. if I eat carbs more than 2 days in a row it goes up by 3-5lbs again.0 -
*sigh*
OP: Did you have a fasting blood glucose test done and do you have diabetes or are you insulin resistant?
I would find out the above, or at the very least, find out why your doctor is recommending a reduced carb intake. This is important.
If your doctor provides you with a medical reason to avoid/reduce them, then you should probably avoid/reduce them and disregard this thread entirely.
If your doctor is suggesting you reduce carbs because carbs make you fat, you should find a new doctor immediately.0 -
In response to ketosis I was on the HCG diet about a year ago which is extreme though I did lose a significant amount of weight and have only fluctuated 10 pounds give or take above what I lost. If any of you know what that is your body is def in ketosis because its in starvation mode. While it helped me shed weight fast, I also shed hair, and ENERGY. I couldn't exercise if you paid me to while I was doing that, and that's my biggest concern with going really low. But I also have PCOS which is a metabolic disorder, and it causes insulin to spike. I don't eat White Carbs except potatoes. My bread and pastas and rice are all whole grain (100% wheat). I eat yogurt with fruit (chobani) often and I eat about 2-3 fruit servings per day. I also eat oatmeal which keeps me pretty full, more so than eggs and turkey sausage. I just don't want to feel hungry because that's when I mess up, just being honest. I'm doing 1500 cal a day on MYP0
-
*sigh*
OP: Did you have a fasting blood glucose test done and do you have diabetes or are you insulin resistant?
I would find out the above, or at the very least, find out why your doctor is recommending a reduced carb intake. This is important.
If your doctor provides you with a medical reason to avoid/reduce them, then you should probably avoid/reduce them and disregard this thread entirely.
If your doctor is suggesting you reduce carbs because carbs make you fat, you should find a new doctor immediately.
Bingo. I have PCOS which makes me Insulin Resistant0 -
Bingo. I have PCOS which makes me Insulin Resistant
That being the case, I would absolutely listen to your doctor and reduce carbs per her advice. Give it a good two weeks or so as it may take time to adjust in terms of how you feel on a low carb diet.0 -
*sigh*
OP: Did you have a fasting blood glucose test done and do you have diabetes or are you insulin resistant?
I would find out the above, or at the very least, find out why your doctor is recommending a reduced carb intake. This is important.
If your doctor provides you with a medical reason to avoid/reduce them, then you should probably avoid/reduce them and disregard this thread entirely.
If your doctor is suggesting you reduce carbs because carbs make you fat, you should find a new doctor immediately.
Also she didnt say "carbs make you fat" but she said "you dont really need carbs" :-/0 -
Cardio doesn't reduce "Belly" fat, in fact cardio itself doesn't reduce fat, being in a caloric deficit reduces fat as body fat % goes down so will your belly fat or leg fat or where ever it is that your body likes to hold on to it. Cardio just makes it easier to reach a caloric deficit that causes you to reduce fat.0
-
Also she didnt say "carbs make you fat" but she said "you dont really need carbs" :-/
For the most part she is correct.0 -
Unless you have a disease that affects how your body processes carbe, they are not the enemy.
You will lose weight by reducing the amount of calories you consume and/or increasing the amount you burn (exercise)
One certain food group does not "target" belly fat. Belly fat will decrease along with other fat.
If you stop eating carbs and then reintroduce them, you will gain the weight back unless you decrease something else in your diet to compensate for the carb calories. In a healthy person, weight loss is all about calories in vs. calories out.0 -
Bingo. I have PCOS which makes me Insulin Resistant
That being the case, I would absolutely listen to your doctor and reduce carbs per her advice. Give it a good two weeks or so as it may take time to adjust in terms of how you feel on a low carb diet.
There ya go :]
Try to get most of your carbs from veggies! filling and good for ya :]
berries are pretty low in carbs too. raspberries especially
good luck to you!0 -
PCOS which is a metabolic disorder, and it causes insulin to spike. I
Sorry but PCOS is NOT a metabolic disorder. PCOS is an Endocrine/GYN related diagnosis. The symptoms common with PCOS are Insulin-resistance(Endo), hyperglycemia(Endo), reproductive issues (GYN & Endo), in many cases male-pattern hair loss and growth (Derma and Endo)...
PCOS even itself has different variables as well as far as being diagnosed with it...
Ive worked for physicians and specialists not only as one of their staff, but also as their patient as well... I also have the culinary side where Ive worked with the staff with other patients, as well as worked with the staff AS their patient also.0 -
As far as the OP:
I would, like other posters have mentioned, do some research and run it by your Endocrinologist to see if going low-carb is right for your PCOS case. If your Endo has the special training dietary-speaking, then go with the guidelines of your Endo. If not, request you see a registered dietician that specializes in PCOS patients with low-carb dietary plans.
Unfortunately, even moderation of the regular 'white' food categories still can cause problems for us. I have a severe metabolic disorder where if I consume any more potatoes, rice, processed flours, bleached flours, most pastas, my insulin is no longer controlled by the prescriptions and I go into Insulin Shock.... Its happened to me once. It also affected my liver to the point I was almost quarantined.... I dont want that to happen ever again!
Run the research by your Endo and make sure they are well-knowledged in addition to any advice they give you. I only wish you had the same Endo as I do - she has studied in five countries and has a large background in dietary changes for her patients... and that means one less trip to another facility (and less copay too!)... and with her help, I have not only lost alot of weight, but, with new and updated tests, I may find out more where others have simply said "take this and call me in the morning"...0 -
PCOS is classified as a metabolic disorder by some physicians, the endocrinologist i saw even said that, but thats neither here nor there. I think I will see a dietician who specializes in insulin resistance. Then they can tell me exactly what will make my insulin spike and what won't. You guys gave me some great advice. I also want to know if any of you are insulin resistant or have pcos and what your diet is like0
-
PCOS is classified as a metabolic disorder by some physicians, the endocrinologist i saw even said that, but thats neither here nor there. I think I will see a dietician who specializes in insulin resistance. Then they can tell me exactly what will make my insulin spike and what won't. You guys gave me some great advice. I also want to know if any of you are insulin resistant or have pcos and what your diet is like
And speaking on over 14 years experience working IN the medical field, and credentialing physicians, specialists and surgeons and also an advanced medical biller for 26 specialities, I do know what Im talking about..
Good luck to you0 -
PCOS is classified as a metabolic disorder by some physicians, the endocrinologist i saw even said that, but thats neither here nor there. I think I will see a dietician who specializes in insulin resistance. Then they can tell me exactly what will make my insulin spike and what won't. You guys gave me some great advice. I also want to know if any of you are insulin resistant or have pcos and what your diet is like
And speaking on over 14 years experience working IN the medical field, and credentialing physicians, specialists and surgeons and also an advanced medical biller for 26 specialities, I do know what Im talking about..
Good luck to you
LOL no one is discounting your credentials. I'm just repeating what was told to me by doctors I've seen. No need to argue about the specifics, its not a battle. Appreciate your input nonetheless0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions