We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

exercise calories different on my treadmill vs this site?

lin7604
lin7604 Posts: 2,951 Member
edited October 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
so which do i go by? when i enter my exercise eg) walking a brisk pace of 3.5 for 25 min it shows on here 101 calories, but my treadmill showed just over 200? that's a big difference.... which do i go by?

Replies

  • kegonzales
    kegonzales Posts: 75
    I would go by here. My elliptical gives enormous calorie burned numbers. The numbers here seem to be more in line with what I would expect.
  • juliep1974
    juliep1974 Posts: 222 Member
    The best thing to do would be to get a heart rate monitor and get your calories burned that way. Neither this site or the treadmill is going to be as accurate as a heart rate monitor. In the meantime, I'd split the difference and log something in between.
  • lmtrevin77
    lmtrevin77 Posts: 68 Member
    I go by the MFP calories because it actually uses your weight to determine the calories burned. I guess if you are entering that info into the treadmill you can use that, but if not then MFP would be more accurate. I never enter that info in the treadmill so I haven't compared. I know, it sucks that the treadmill gives you more of a burn.
  • Moonbeamlissie
    Moonbeamlissie Posts: 504 Member
    I think i would go down the middle... if its that important. i do not eat my calories back... or all of them anyway. I look at them as my buffer. If i'm hungry I eat if I am not then I don't. Thing is everything is a estimate... even HRM's which are more accurate than the machine or this site. If I had to choose which is more accurate the machine or this site I would go with the machine, unless... you did not enter your weight on the machine then I would go with this site, other wise the machine was there, it knows if you did an incline or not and how often and so and so. EDIT---- also when I enter my weight on the treadmill it usually will be pretty close to my HRM... however this is not true for any elliptical type device I have used.
  • lorihalsted
    lorihalsted Posts: 326 Member
    Were you using an incline on your treadmill? That would make a difference. Unless you have a treadmill that you enter your weight MFP is probably more accurate than your treadmill. Either way it's exercise!
  • LynneGG
    LynneGG Posts: 95 Member
    If the machine allows you to enter your weight I would go by that...that would be more accurate since it would be derterminng calories burned based on your weight versus a "standard" number which would apply to any weight
  • Maurey
    Maurey Posts: 44
    I would go by mfp, or even better invest in a HRM. Once I got my HRM i realized that my treadmill said I burned almost double of what I was actually burning.
  • onebigbutt
    onebigbutt Posts: 48
    This is interesting. I've always used my treadmill because of the incline.
  • Puffins1958
    Puffins1958 Posts: 614 Member
    The BEST thing I ever invested in since starting MFP was a HRM. I would get an accurate reading when I was on the treadmill, but that was it. It amazes me how many calories I burn when I'm doing the circuit training. If you could afford one, I would get a HRM. It will give you the MOST acurate readings once set up properly....

    12117749.png
    Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Calorie Counter
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    Everyone will tell you to buy a HRM so that your calorie burn is accurate. However, I lost all my weight going by the numbers on my treadmill. It asks for age, weight, etc - so I feel that it is pretty accurate (or close enough at least). I don't think a HRM is a necessity to lose weight and keep it off. :)

    That being said - does your treadmill ask for your age, weight, etc? If so, I would go by its numbers since it knows exactly what you're doing during the workout.
  • lin7604
    lin7604 Posts: 2,951 Member
    no my treadmill doesn't ask for age, weight, etc it also has incline but you don't know how high you are going as there is no numbers. I did have it on a bit of a incline for the last 10 of my 25 min workout but even without that i was over what it shows on here. I guess i will go by this site's info since it did ask for my weight and age.... how much can i expect to spend if i were to get a HRM?

    it just made me think tonight when i say the numbers and then went to log on my exercise for the day. I have been exercising for 1 month 5-6 days a week and haven't lost 1 lb yet... I didn't find this site until a week ago to log my calories, etc so i was wondering what i am doing wrong....
  • rileysowner
    rileysowner Posts: 8,354 Member
    so which do i go by? when i enter my exercise eg) walking a brisk pace of 3.5 for 25 min it shows on here 101 calories, but my treadmill showed just over 200? that's a big difference.... which do i go by?

    Use the lower of the two would be what I suggest.
  • lin7604
    lin7604 Posts: 2,951 Member
    thx i will do so, i'll just keep using this sites estimate!
  • Asher213
    Asher213 Posts: 46
    The calories burned reading on the treadmill/eliptical at my gym is always less then what mfp says so I go by the reading on the gym equipment.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories