We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

elliptical question

noeys
noeys Posts: 56
edited October 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
Is the elliptical a good workout? I know "they say" that you burn more calories on the elliptical than the treadmill, but when I do the elliptical, versus jogging on the treadmill I dont feel like Im working out as much. IE on the treadmill Im huffing and puffing and cant catch my breath, but on the elliptical Im just gliding along.... Am I really getting a good workout???

Replies

  • nkziv
    nkziv Posts: 161 Member
    It's only better if you amp up the resistance! Try putting it on one of the preset workouts. I like 'hills' and 'aerobic trainer.' That usually gets my HR up into the 180's for a good 40 minutes.
  • NoAdditives
    NoAdditives Posts: 4,251 Member
    Elliptical machines do give a great workout and it's more of a full body workout. I find I use my back and abdominal muscles much more when I'm on the elliptical, as well as my arms.
  • mochalovies
    mochalovies Posts: 192 Member
    hmm elliptical is my *default* workout. You can get some good intervals going and even focus on different muscles. Whether you are going backwards, pulling/pushing with upper body, squat all the way down, on your toes, on your heels, things like that. I also grab a medicine ball or dumbells and it helps keep my HR up while getting a good burn. I get a pretty good workout when I have a *FACE OFF* with the treadmill, but the elliptical is more of a controlled workout for me.
  • risefromruin
    risefromruin Posts: 483 Member
    The best way to know the answer to this is to buy a heart rate monitor! I always felt like I got the best workout on the arc trainer, but as it turns out, the best workout for me is on the elliptical. If I jog on the treadmill I'm huffing and puffing but I'm not actually burning much more than the elliptical. It could be way different for you though.
  • noeys
    noeys Posts: 56
    It's only better if you amp up the resistance! Try putting it on one of the preset workouts. I like 'hills' and 'aerobic trainer.' That usually gets my HR up into the 180's for a good 40 minutes.

    I have been doing the "total body" workout that is preset in my elliptical machine.
  • noeys
    noeys Posts: 56
    The best way to know the answer to this is to buy a heart rate monitor! I always felt like I got the best workout on the arc trainer, but as it turns out, the best workout for me is on the elliptical. If I jog on the treadmill I'm huffing and puffing but I'm not actually burning much more than the elliptical. It could be way different for you though.

    hmmm. ok.
    Yeah I had the body bugg, and know what Im burning on the elliptical, but IM returning it, and havent used it for the treadmill. I just assumed huffing and puffing meant burning more calories, but maybe not LOL!
  • renku
    renku Posts: 182 Member
    If nothing elseI enjoy my elliptical for the feeling that maybe when I shed a few more pounds, I'll be able to run.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories