breakfast or not to breakfast
Replies
-
If you're not hungry in the morning, it could be because you ate too soon before you went to sleep the night before. Honestly, I hate a lot of breakfast foods, but there are sooooooo many out there. Research new foods to have for breakfast and you should be good! And unfortunately, skipping meals will slow down your metabolism. So eat yo wheaties! (;0
-
I started drinking green smoothies for breakfast and it's usually just enough to get me through the day. I find I'm not as cranky if I eat breakfast, and I'm also more focused.
Green smoothies for me include a really ripe banana for texture, spinach or kale, and berries. Add water to make blending easier, and call it good. It's light and is just enough.0 -
Anyone interested in actual science and not perpetuated myths passed from person to person, on meal timing, frequency and it's effects on your metabolism, please see this site...
http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debunked.html0 -
Coffee is my breakfast. Are you a coffee drinker?0
-
Gotta eat breakfast!!!
It kicks the metabolism into gear!0 -
I have two pieces of advice.
1. Eat when you are hungry, it does not have to be as soon as you wake up, but about an hour after is pretty good. If you eat breakfast it will help keep you from going crazy overeating on snacks and meals later in the day.
2. In the event that you are not a fan of breakfast foods, then eat whatever you feel like. I am constantly eating leftovers from dinner for breakfast or a half breakfast half lunch meal of a bagel thin with fat free cream cheese, sliced turkey and spinach with raspberries.0 -
I know eating breakfast starts your metabolism for the day. I tend to eat a bag of cereal or a hard boiled egg. The egg keeps you feeling full longer... sometimes, I do not even eat it till 9:00 or so. My coffee fills me up in the morning, but I do know it is great to get your metabolism going as soon as possible!!!!!!!:drinker:0
-
I'm no health expert but I don't force food down my throat when I am not hungry. Just doesn't make sense to me. I can't differentiate when I do that in the morning to "boredom snacking." What I mean is: If I make myself eat when I am not hungry in the morning just so I can say "I ate Breakfast during normal breakfast hours" then when I am bored sitting in front of the t.v I think, well I see food so I am going to eat. just doesn't make sense to me to eat when I am not hungry.0
-
Studies show eating breakfast not only makes u smarter and more alert; but makes u less likely to overeat later in the day
0 -
Studies show eating breakfast not only makes u smarter and more alert; but makes u less likely to overeat later in the day
WooHoo!
0 -
Studies show eating breakfast not only makes u smarter and more alert; but makes u less likely to overeat later in the day
WooHoo!
Hahahaha... I'm convinced!0 -
I know breakfast is the most important meal... But I'm bot a huge breakfast fan... I'm also seeing that as I get my hunger under control... I don't wake up starving. Or hungry at all for that matter. So the question is... Does anyone else have this problem? Should I be forcing breakfast anyway? Just don't want to be hurting my weight loss efforts by not eating a meal.
If you're not hungry, don't eat breakfast. There is no metabolic advantage to increased meal frequency, so it will not hurt your weight loss efforts by skipping breakfast.
I personally haven't eaten within hrs of waking in months
This!!0 -
There's no evidence to show that eating within a certain time of waking up is any different from eating the same foods later.
Personally though, I do eat breakfast because if I do not I feel hungry and consequently make poor choices. Not everyone will find that though, for some people eating breakfast before they're hungry is a waste of calories.0 -
Actually i agree with you with the breakfast. I find if i eat breakfast forcefully, i am actually even more hungry during the day. When i don't eat breakfast i have no hungry all day.If you read that book Eat for your blood type, it actually makes sense depending on your blood type some people need to eat breakfast while others do much better without breakfast.0
-
I know breakfast is the most important meal... But I'm bot a huge breakfast fan... I'm also seeing that as I get my hunger under control... I don't wake up starving. Or hungry at all for that matter. So the question is... Does anyone else have this problem? Should I be forcing breakfast anyway? Just don't want to be hurting my weight loss efforts by not eating a meal.
If you're not hungry, don't eat breakfast. There is no metabolic advantage to increased meal frequency, so it will not hurt your weight loss efforts by skipping breakfast.
I personally haven't eaten within hrs of waking in months
The evidence does not support your claim. Breakfast intake has been shown to improve not only overall nutrition intake, but lower overall caloric intake through the day, decrease blood sugar spiking, and improve cognitive function.
A) Breakfast has shown to lower blood sugar levels throughout the day, avoiding sugar spikes/insulin releases http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/016882279290017L
Breakfast has shown fairly consistently to correlate with healthy body types, as well as increased mental function (meta study)
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002822305001513
C) Children who eat breakfast at home have shown to eat less througout the day - http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/000282239391527W
D) Another study showing that obese children tend to have bad/no breakfasts - http://ukpmc.ac.uk/abstract/MED/9565828/reload=0;jsessionid=VT5NxCT991u1JUbnCRqZ.94
E) Not consuming breakfast leads to significant deficiencies in assential nutrients - http://www.jacn.org/content/5/6/551.short
F) Another study suggesting a link between school/cognitive performance and eating breakfast
http://archpedi.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/143/10/1234
There's just too much evidence out there to not eat it. Anecdotal experience aside. Many more studies are available, just check google scholar (scholar.google.com).
A) Breakfast has shown to lower blood sugar levels throughout the day, avoiding sugar spikes/insulin releases http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/016882279290017L
In diabetes patients Breakfast has shown fairly consistently to correlate with healthy body types, as well as increased mental function (meta study)
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002822305001513
Meta review of epidemiological studies, correlation =/= causation
C) Children who eat breakfast at home have shown to eat less througout the day - http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/000282239391527W
Epidemiological study, correlation =/= causation
D) Another study showing that obese children tend to have bad/no breakfasts - http://ukpmc.ac.uk/abstract/MED/9565828/reload=0;jsessionid=VT5NxCT991u1JUbnCRqZ.94
Correlation =/= causation, also relies on self reported data
See a pattern here?
Provide studies that actually show eating breakfast has a metabolic advantage over not eating it
Specific to high-protein diets, but supports it still. http://www.jacn.org/content/23/suppl_6/631S.full
Another study:
http://www.ajcn.org/content/88/5/1396.abstract
Sadly I cannot find more atm, I'm not connected to any university library where I would have access to more scholarly journals.0 -
I start eating, at about 11 am, I guess it could be still considered breakfast!!0
-
dont eat if you're not hungry. seriously, listen to your body. breakfast will not kickstart your metabolism. i'm a senior in biomedical sciences and i've taken enough biochemistry/nutrition classes to know this to be true. and i've lost 85 lbs without eating breakfast normally.0
-
To me, it's breakfast all the way. I need to eat something with some substance, because I do wake up hungry and eating breakfast keeps my hunger and cravings in check. I'm no expert, but that's one of the things you need to know yourself for. The most important thing is to eat properly throughout the day, according to your hunger and timing, I guess.0
-
I wake up hungry in the morning....especially when I don't eat late at night. I look forward to breakfast!0
-
Dont eat breakfast if you dont feel like it......do you think cavemen ate within X amount of minutes of waking every day. I think there is way to much emphaisis put on meal timing. People say "dont fast it will destroy the metabolism" but you fast every night when you sleep.....just my opinion.0
-
Keep it small...5 almonds, half a banana or other fruit, 6 oz OJ...breakfast does not have to be big...not at all.0
-
I'm shocked by the number of people suggesting that you force yourself to eat when you aren't hungry. I don't know about you, but that's part of why I'm fat.0
-
Could this be because eating actually does rev up the metabolism, which causes the body to burn energy and, therefore, need more nourishment? As opposed to remaining in "sleep mode" due to not eating. It is a fact that the metabolism slows down somewhat when we don't eat in order to preserve what energy and nutrients it can. Now whether or not it's a typical breakfast meal is a whole other issue... no one says it has to be. Fruit is fine, smoothies are fine, toast and peanut butter is fine, etc. - as long as its healthy and nourishing. If it is, it will sustain you for a good 2.5 to 3 hours or so, at which time you may begin to feel hungry. Grab some water and a light snack (fruit & nuts, yogurt & berries, etc.) to carry you through to lunch. There's no shame in feeling hungry. That's our signal that the body has used up the food we gave it and it's time to replenish.
Here's another way to look at it. You wouldn't drive your care without refueling would you? What would happen if you knew you needed gas but didn't stop to get any? Eventually it would sputter and run out of gas leaving you stuck with no options for fuel or that only gas station in sight is the one that you know for a fact makes your car run like crap...the one that has you sputtering and coughing all the way up the road. Then you'll be wishing that you stopped and got at least a gallon's worth of the stuff you know your car likes.0 -
Actually i agree with you with the breakfast. I find if i eat breakfast forcefully, i am actually even more hungry during the day. When i don't eat breakfast i have no hungry all day.If you read that book Eat for your blood type, it actually makes sense depending on your blood type some people need to eat breakfast while others do much better without breakfast.
Could this be because eating actually does rev up the metabolism, which causes the body to burn energy and, therefore, need more nourishment? As opposed to remaining in "sleep mode" due to not eating. It is a fact that the metabolism slows down somewhat when we don't eat in order to preserve what energy and nutrients it can. Now whether or not it's a typical breakfast meal is a whole other issue... no one says it has to be. Fruit is fine, smoothies are fine, toast and peanut butter is fine, etc. - as long as its healthy and nourishing. If it is, it will sustain you for a good 2.5 to 3 hours or so, at which time you may begin to feel hungry. Grab some water and a light snack (fruit & nuts, yogurt & berries, etc.) to carry you through to lunch. There's no shame in feeling hungry. That's our signal that the body has used up the food we gave it and it's time to replenish.
Here's another way to look at it. You wouldn't drive your car without refueling would you? What would happen if you knew you needed gas but didn't stop to get any? Eventually it would sputter and run out of gas leaving you stuck with no options for fuel or that only gas station in sight is the one that you know for a fact makes your car run like crap...the one that has you sputtering and coughing all the way up the road. Then you'll be wishing that you stopped and got at least a gallon's worth of the stuff you know your car likes.0 -
Eat when you are hungry. Get in touch with your body, so only eat when you TRUELY hungry, not for food craving or emotion eating or because its' TIME to eat. When you want to eat, ask yourself this "Would I eat an apple right now?" if the answer is No, then you know what to do.
I gained weight because I DID NOT listen to my body. Why you think people who had gastric (sp?) surgery and then stretch their stomach out again like the famous country singer? We have to find out what's reason that makes us overweight, solve it
before the healing progress-lose weight! This is the reason why at least 80% of people who lose weight, gain them back again in a year!
I've been eating 2 meals a day. It's so easy for me to stay in my calorie range. I hardly eat breakfast. Sometimes I got up and feel starving then I eat big breakfast. I noticed once I start eating and my digestion system started the chewing process, I would get hungry more often.0 -
Specific to high-protein diets, but supports it still. http://www.jacn.org/content/23/suppl_6/631S.full
Another study:
http://www.ajcn.org/content/88/5/1396.abstract
Sadly I cannot find more atm, I'm not connected to any university library where I would have access to more scholarly journals.
Specific to high-protein diets, but supports it still. http://www.jacn.org/content/23/suppl_6/631S.full
it does not support that eating breakfast has a metabolic advantage.
http://www.ajcn.org/content/88/5/1396.abstract
Correlation =/= causation
Since you can't provide any studies showing a metabolic advantage to breakfast, how about you explain why you think there is one?0 -
Could this be because eating actually does rev up the metabolism, which causes the body to burn energy and, therefore, need more nourishment? As opposed to remaining in "sleep mode" due to not eating. It is a fact that the metabolism slows down somewhat when we don't eat in order to preserve what energy and nutrients it can. Now whether or not it's a typical breakfast meal is a whole other issue... no one says it has to be. Fruit is fine, smoothies are fine, toast and peanut butter is fine, etc. - as long as its healthy and nourishing. If it is, it will sustain you for a good 2.5 to 3 hours or so, at which time you may begin to feel hungry. Grab some water and a light snack (fruit & nuts, yogurt & berries, etc.) to carry you through to lunch. There's no shame in feeling hungry. That's our signal that the body has used up the food we gave it and it's time to replenish.
The myth of increased meal frequency = greater metabolism is from the thought of a more frequent boost from TEF, from lyle mcdonald to easily explain itEat more frequently and metabolic rate goes up more, right? Because you’re stimulating TEF more often. Well, no. Here’s why:
Say we have two people, both eating the same 3000 calories per day from identical macronutrients. One eats 6 meals of 500 calories/meal while the other eats 3 meals of 1000 calories/meal and we’ll assume a TEF of 10%. So the first will have a TEF of 50 calories (10% of 500) 6 times/day. The second will have a TEF of 100 calories (10% of 1000 calories) 3 times/day. Well, 6X50 = 300 calories/day and 3X100 = 300 calories/day. There’s no difference.0 -
Specific to high-protein diets, but supports it still. http://www.jacn.org/content/23/suppl_6/631S.full
Another study:
http://www.ajcn.org/content/88/5/1396.abstract
Sadly I cannot find more atm, I'm not connected to any university library where I would have access to more scholarly journals.
Specific to high-protein diets, but supports it still. http://www.jacn.org/content/23/suppl_6/631S.full
it does not support that eating breakfast has a metabolic advantage.
http://www.ajcn.org/content/88/5/1396.abstract
Correlation =/= causation
Since you can't provide any studies showing a metabolic advantage to breakfast, how about you explain why you think there is one?
Sadly at this time I can't. I have no access to a university network to start browsing for more scholarly journals.
However, I think your understanding of statistics is slightly flawed. While causation!=correlation, consistent correlation shows that there is some type of link (causitive or otherwise), we simply don't understand its nature.
A link which constantly appears most likely does exist, see the law of large numbers.
I'll take the huge risk and continue eating breakfast. It seems to have worked for the first 140 pounds I lost pretty well. For now the studies showing improved satiation alone are enough for me.0 -
Sadly at this time I can't. I have no access to a university network to start browsing for more scholarly journals.
However, I think your understanding of statistics is slightly flawed. While causation!=correlation, consistent correlation shows that there is some type of link (causitive or otherwise), we simply don't understand its nature. See the law of large numbers.
I'll take the huge risk and continue eating breakfast. It seems to have worked for the first 140 pounds I lost pretty well.
Might eating breakfast be correlated to greater weight loss not due to a metabolic advantage, but due to people that tend to skip breakfast have crappy eating habits in general?
Studies on meal frequency show no metabolic advantage and i posted above why people tend to still beleive that there is one (TEF mostly)
And you can continue to eat breakfast, it's a personal preference, but again yields no metabolic advantage to not eating it0 -
If I fuel up my car at night, I don't need to do it again in the morning.Here's another way to look at it. You wouldn't drive your care without refueling would you? What would happen if you knew you needed gas but didn't stop to get any? Eventually it would sputter and run out of gas leaving you stuck with no options for fuel or that only gas station in sight is the one that you know for a fact makes your car run like crap...the one that has you sputtering and coughing all the way up the road. Then you'll be wishing that you stopped and got at least a gallon's worth of the stuff you know your car likes.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions