Logging Housework as Exercise??
Replies
-
Of course you can class it as exercise (so long as you are building up a sweat and putting more effort in than normal) I would agree and say you need to up your daily activity staus though, Try taking one thing upstairs at a time rather than all at once, and really scrubbing things harder than the normal, put 110% into anything you do and yes it is excercise. Excercise is defined: Activity requiring physical effort, carried out esp. to sustain or improve health and fitness.
So yes it can be exercise!!!
Just not classed as exercise if your doing a light dust and some washing up haha!
0 -
unless i am dripping in sweat i would not log housework i see it more as a daily activity0
-
I do it so I'm curious how many other people do it0
-
I've only logged it once. I told my teenager to clean his room and I ended up in there for over 6 hours taking everything out and scrubbing the entire room, including the closet. This was outside of my normal activity and I logged 60 minutes. If it is a normal activity then you shouldn't include it.0
-
If I am mopping or doing something that takes effort then I will log it. I often make an effort when mopping to make a "workout" out of it. Trust me, it can be a workout.0
-
LOL thanks for the morning laugh to the person who said it is not exercise.
I log mine only when I do deep cleaning, like rearranging furniture, climbing chairs to clean corners, on top of cabinets, etc. Stuff like that. I also drag the vacuum up 3 flights of stairs, scrub floors, tubs..... I get some of my best burns during deep cleans because they last for HOURS. Sometimes I am more exhausted from them than doing typical cardio. I wear my HRM and pedometer while deep cleaning.
If I am just dusting or lightly picking up, I don't log it.0 -
when you clean are you moving? you already know that you burn calories when you clean so why not log it? i am a mom of 4 so i clean my house a few times a day, if i am moving and burning calories i dont really give 2 hoots what it is i am doing i am def logging it. someone said it was ppls way of excusing them from a real workout or real cardio or whatever which is BS, i also do other workingout not just cleaning so that cant be true for all of us!
if you are burning the calories then LOG THEM!!!!!
Agreed!0 -
I guess you'd have to know their personal situation/fitness level before you should judge. Some people were not doing housework on a daily basis before, and it depends where they are in their weight loss & fitness journey.*sigh* who cares what OTHERS are doing....
i was meerly asking a question as i wondered if i should log as had seen others logging it when it came up on my feed.... it doesnt bother me what other people do or why.
i WANT to lose weight but i know that if im not eating enough i wont...so if i think ive eaten the 1200 cals that im meant to have for that day but have actually burnt of 2100 my body could go in starvation mode couldnt it.... just going by what ive read on here!
I thought this forum was about helping each other!
Myself, no, I don't log housework, or even heavy-duty yardwork (I consider it a bonus and basically only log exercise that meets my own definition of intentional cardio). I'm sure there are some people who take advantage of this and only log housework to justify eating more calories, but again, you shouldn't assume everyone is at the same point in this process as you are.
This is just something to consider!0 -
I fell into this trap a few years back, but I also included my ymca workouts, and in order to get every calorie burned in there, I added housework too, but it didnt really make a difference, and the typing I did prob added up to more calories burned. Dont fall into that trap,
However if it makes YOU feel better, then by all means log it. It is your decision, your choice, your log...I dont think that logging it will be detrimental at all (spell check on detrimental, its early)
I hope your having a great day, good luck today on another day of your journey and remember every little bit helps.
Mary0 -
Forums raging so early..
I wouldn't But thats opinion.
Have a great day!:happy:0 -
Since I have my settings at Sedentary to start with, if I plan on cleaning like a mad woman (this happens once a week for me usually) I will log it. Simply because I do eat my exercise calories back, and I can burn over 600 calories for a couple of hours of hard cleaning- and YES I wear my HRM. Im talking hands and knees scrubbing, carpet steaming, up and down stairs laundry type cleaning. This being said, I do not log the every day vacuuming and such.
You will have people tell you that you dont burn any extra calories cleaning and I say I would hate to see their house........ :laugh:0 -
You're damn right I log cleaning and vacuuming. Not the daily run of the mill dusting and picking up, I do that several times a day.
If I vacuum the house from top to bottom; three bedrooms, bathroom, landing, stairs, hall, living room and kitchen (mopping) - yes, I WILL log it. It involves a lot of picking up, putting away, moving furniture, as well as the actual vacuuming.
I'm pouring with sweat by the time I've finished. Why SHOULDN'T I log it?0 -
I absolutely log housework as exercise, but only when I do something truly active (Vacuuming and kitchen floors etc...) with two toddlers under 3 and a dog and cat, this is nearly every other day, haha. I also work out/run almost daily but cleaning my house definitely burns calories and I feel comfortable logging it! I believe I use- 'Cleaning- Light, Moderate Effort- Good luck!
I am the same, when I get on all fours to scrub the kitchen floor, hoover the stairs and rest of house, lift loads of washing up and down the 2 flights of stairs in big bundles, squatting, bending, lifting etc....how is this not a form of exercise? I definitely log it. If I hadn't bothered to exercise on that day but know I have burned a couple hundred calories just from doing that, it makes me feel less guilty. It is not a cop out. I log all activity and why not? It's simply just a lighter form of exrcise.0 -
I log my housework if i clean the whole house. moppng the floors dusting etc. I also work in a sports bar in a casino here in Ont. ON concert nights i am running around that resturant with no stop for at least 3hrs. I am a busser (the only one ina resturant taht can hold 200). I log those calories for sure. since i am running around for 7 hrs cleaning i only log 3 hrs of it. Non concert nihgt i log one hr. I also put it under light housework i hope that helps0
-
I have mine set to sedentary and am a housewife. I clean pretty much everyday but on days where I'm spending hours of serious cleaning or moving moving stuff up and down the stairs I count it. I count it because its important to eat back exercise calories so if I'm burning several hundred extra calories cleaning then its significant enough to log. People that say cleaning is not exercise obviously don't really clean themselves. My husband doesn't think cleaning is hard work but then again he doesn't even know how to turn on the dishwasher. Also I saw someone complain about counting shopping. I do that too because what do you do when you shop? WALK. So if I'm out on a shopping trip for 6 hours I will log about 4 hours of leisurely walking. If you don't agree then that is your business but you shouldn't put others down who do it. I would understand if I had my activity set to active and then counted them but I don't so I'm not trying to "cheat". We're supposed to be a support system not a judgmental group.0
-
*sigh* who cares what OTHERS are doing....
i was meerly asking a question as i wondered if i should log as had seen others logging it when it came up on my feed.... it doesnt bother me what other people do or why.
i WANT to lose weight but i know that if im not eating enough i wont...so if i think ive eaten the 1200 cals that im meant to have for that day but have actually burnt of 2100 my body could go in starvation mode couldnt it.... just going by what ive read on here!
I thought this forum was about helping each other!
This forum is about helping people. Some people however have to start an argument on every forum. Sorry!
I would tell you that if it is something out of your norm log it. I spent an entire day one day rearranging furniture, building furniture and cleaning, I logged that. But I don't log my daily cleaning.0 -
It is in the databasse for a reason. I am generally sedentary, but yesterday I packed up all the Christmas stuff, that involved a lot of reaching and squatting. Lifted and carried heavy boxes up and down stairs, and did an extra extra thorough, very unusual, vaccuum, mopping of the living room to get rid of the pine needles. I burned calories that needed to be logged. I use the cleaning light, moderate as a sort of compromise between planned exercise, but I definately got a work out and I hurt today.
In the old days people didn't use the gym, they did daily chores.
You have to be a personal judge. If you are listed as sedentary, and break a sweat ... list the calories. Your body needs them.0 -
Boy someone needs to learn being a ***** doesn't burn calories huh? I agree with everyone else...I set my lifestyle to light active and only log anything out of the norm ... like cleaning the boys play room..UGH..should have list THAT under archaeological dig!! Best of Luck on the weight loss!! Don't be put off using the boards...99% of people as wonderful and supportive...I couldn't have got this far without them!! xxx0
-
I do not log everyday housework (dshes, vacuuming, laundry, dusting, etc), but if I am doing something that is out of the ordinary, I sure do. For example, our house has a lot of windows and to get to the upper ones, I need to drag out the ladder (both inside and outside) and it will take several hours of work ad constant movement, so I am going to log it. Other things I might log, organizing closets, garage, basement... Again, out of the ordinary and includes lifting, stretching, bending, etc. I always log it as 'light' or 'general' housework, even if I am sore the following day.0
-
Thanks everyone have changed my settings
Am going to feel guilty sitting on my *kitten* in front of the PC now so going to have to go clean up0 -
I agree with most other posters. I personally would not log it, unless you did some down and dirty housecleaning. If I am not sweating I dont feel like I had a good workout. and personally I dont sweat when I am doing housework.
I had one friend that would nearly everyday log 3 hours of housecleaning...c/mon how dirty is your house? After maybe 6 hours in a week my house would be spotless. And she would complain about not losing weight and how she cheated and fell off the wagon and needed to leave for awhile..clearly she did not have her heart in it. But if logging her housecleaning made her feel better well then I guess that is her perocative. To each their own.0 -
unless i am dripping in sweat i would not log housework i see it more as a daily activity
I often work up a sweat when I do housework, and without the central heating on - I must be doing my job(s) well then :laugh:0 -
Depends what I am doing .. if I am scrubbing floors, washing the car (by hand), washing the plane , cleaning windows and I am actually working up a sweat and getting a bit out of puff then I will log it.
If I am washing up , ironing , cooking .. or walking around the shops doing the weekly shop that isn't exercise thats just life :laugh:0 -
I log my vigorous housework. Polishing 1600 sqft. of wood floor on your hands and knees isn't exactly feather dusting. Oh no! What will other people think of me?! Will they think I'm a fatty and being lazy?! The SHAME!
Keep in mind that there are few truly sedentary people. Sedentary means on your butt, little effort, ALL day. If you run after kids and do chores everyday, I'd set your activity to lightly active or active.
People need to stop being so judgmental of what others log as exercise. If you are over 300lbs, just walking around or mopping IS exercise. Maybe they feel discouraged a little more every day when they find someone making fun of their "exercise."0 -
In the old days people didn't use the gym, they did daily chores.
You have to be a personal judge. If you are listed as sedentary, and break a sweat ... list the calories. Your body needs them.
absolutely agree, well said!0 -
I thought this forum was about helping each other!
Whenever you post a question on here be prepared for a mixed bag of responses - and ignore the ones that are not particularly helpful. There are lots of lovely people on here willing to share what they have done, and what has worked for them - almost always they show up too and respond. Those are the ones to listen to.
You've got some good answers here - I'm with those who suggest changing your settings to lightly active. I personally don't track anything other than workouts, and I see the rest as a bonus, but equally I know I have done the work and if I do go slightly over my calories that day I don't let it worry me.
Good Luck!0 -
It's not exercise.Im pretty new to this (first week) and i have noticed that some people log housework as Exercise....
Im a stay-at-home-mum and spend a majority of my day doing some sort of housework i put my settings as doing the lowest level of activity some days im flat out doing housework and running round after the children & my partner other days i sit on the computer or watching tv..... so should i be logging the hoovering...bathroom and kitchen floor scrubbing as "exercise" or not.
I dont personally see it as exercise although i know it burns calories.... am a little confused
People log this in as a handy excuse not to have to do real cardio.
It's more an activity than a workout. Don't do it!
Uhm Negatory Ghostrider.................... I log it occasionally(not the daily version, but the serious cleaning type) AND I just ran 4 miles AFTER I did 40 minutes of strength....... I dont need an excuse because Im no stranger to cardio. But what I do need is to eat enough based on the calories I ACTUALLY burn on that day...........................0 -
here is what I do. I log my cardio (running/circuit training) and then on days when I find I have spent hours doing a major cleaing - moving furniture, washing floors, etc I log that too. I try to under count my hours though so for example, if i do a major 6 hour cleaning I will most likely log 4 hours worth. For me this tends to be my Sat "house cleaning day".
This exactly.
I under-count too, as I think MFP can sometimes overestimate calories burned. I don't ever log my day-to-day cleaning / housework, as that is just part of daily life, but above and beyond (like the above poster said) is perfectly reasonable.
Just don't use it as an excuse not to do other exercise - it's a bonus, not a workout.
As other posters have said, you need to change to lightly active if you're a SAHM, as there's no way you'll be Sedentary!
I hope that helps. Good luck, and add me if you like... always happy to make new friends :flowerforyou:0 -
It's not exercise.Im pretty new to this (first week) and i have noticed that some people log housework as Exercise....
Im a stay-at-home-mum and spend a majority of my day doing some sort of housework i put my settings as doing the lowest level of activity some days im flat out doing housework and running round after the children & my partner other days i sit on the computer or watching tv..... so should i be logging the hoovering...bathroom and kitchen floor scrubbing as "exercise" or not.
I dont personally see it as exercise although i know it burns calories.... am a little confused
People log this in as a handy excuse not to have to do real cardio.
It's more an activity than a workout. Don't do it!
keep your nose out of other people's business. WTF cares cause it won't show up on YOUR scale...so butt out.
A bit harsh.....0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions