Eating Late--really detrimental?
Ilbrantdai
Posts: 58
Hey guys, I've heard eating after a certain hour of the night can be detrimental to weight loss. How true is this statement? I work during the day and go to school at night, so I usually end up eating later than I'd like. When do you guys generally have your last meal/snack?
0
Replies
-
Hey guys, I've heard eating after a certain hour of the night can be detrimental to weight loss. How true is this statement? I work during the day and go to school at night, so I usually end up eating later than I'd like. When do you guys generally have your last meal/snack?
Only if the late night eating causes you to exceed your total daily intake. (So basically, it doesn't matter).
I will eat until I run out of calories or fall asleep.0 -
Hey guys, I've heard eating after a certain hour of the night can be detrimental to weight loss. How true is this statement? I work during the day and go to school at night, so I usually end up eating later than I'd like. When do you guys generally have your last meal/snack?
It's not true at all. You can eat right up till you go to bed without it effecting your weight loss, assuming you are still in a caloric deficit0 -
I dont think so... as long as you dont eat something that will give you problems (heartburn, diarrhea, etc...)0
-
I eat bacon in bed, I'll spare you the other details.0
-
I have pretty severe acid reflux. I can't eat/drink a couple hours before I go to bed or else it comes back up. I'm usually eating/drinking up to that time though and you can see my weight loss below.0
-
Hey guys, I've heard eating after a certain hour of the night can be detrimental to weight loss. How true is this statement? I work during the day and go to school at night, so I usually end up eating later than I'd like. When do you guys generally have your last meal/snack?
I'd say the statement is very true, whenever I go to bed soon after eating I always gain the next day.
I'll usually have my last meal or snack at least 3-4 hours before bed, so about 7 or 8pm when I go to bed at 10 to 12.
If I must eat I try to make it something lite like a huge salad or fish (tuna), that way I'm at least getting as few calories as possible
they also say people will eat when they're really sleepy, the body tells them to eat more because the calories will give them energy to stay awake longer.0 -
I eat bacon in bed, I'll spare you the other details.
^ Coolest guy EVER. I LOVE bacon. I would marry bacon, but my wife would disapprove.0 -
I have a late meal after working out. Hasn't affected me one bit. ☺0
-
it´s a myth. The time when you eat has no impact on weight loss.0
-
Your body does not stop digesting food just because you're asleep. Your metabolism has to run around the clock to keep your body functioning. While it is true that your metabolism slows while you sleep, that is only because of the reduction in your body's requirements for energy. It is still hard at work building up tissues and keeping your bodily functions going. As long as you're hitting your daily calorie goals, when you eat those calories will have little effect on your weight loss/gain.0
-
I eat bacon in bed, I'll spare you the other details.
Doesn't everyone? It's a ***** when the syrup gets on the sheets tho0 -
The only reason people say not to is because your body isn't moving about so when you eat later at night they think that your body will not burn those calories. If you were to eat during the day you are up and moving more. If you are still in your calories then you should be fine. You need to eat when you are hungry no matter what time of day0
-
Time has nothing to do with it. Just keep your calorie goal.0
-
Hey guys, I've heard eating after a certain hour of the night can be detrimental to weight loss. How true is this statement? I work during the day and go to school at night, so I usually end up eating later than I'd like. When do you guys generally have your last meal/snack?
Usually 3-4 hours before bed
I was told no carbs after 6.. so really i dont eat after 6 anyways i get home from the gym at 9pm so i take a shower and off to bed.0 -
The problem is that if you eat late, and eat something high in carbohydrates and/or sugar you are less likely to be able to burn those carbohydrates off which can then be stored as fat. Eating earlier allows you more time to 'burn' the calories and carbs that you have eaten. That's the theory anyway. Whether it makes a difference, I don't know, I try to eat around 6.30-7.00 and then have something with either natural sugars like a little fruit (not a good enough choice for some I know) or something with protein, such as yoghurt or milk. Hope that helps!
There is also another thought to keep on mind. The body repairs itself when you're asleep and by eating late your body can't focus purely on healing as it has to digest. I find if I eat late my body won't digest food as well as it would if I had given it more awake time!
I don't personally think it's about a set time, I think it's more about the amount of time before you sleep, I think it's best to stop eating a couple of hours before bed(I'll have to try working on that!!!)0 -
I've never had an issue with late night eating, but on the flip side if I skip breakfast, I definitely feel it and crave items I'm trying to minimize.0
-
It doesn't affect weight loss, but if may affect how you feel (i.e. previous comment about acid reflux, or someone who doesn't sleep well on a full stomach). However, if you don't have any adverse effects like that, then you can eat whenever you like, as long as you keep to within your caloric and macronutrient range. I often eat a HUGE meal quite close to the end of the day, and I'll still show a loss in the morning.
Amy0 -
I agree with the last posts. I just read that it doesn't matter but people do tend to eat more calories in the evening to feel satisfied so just be careful not to exceed your daily goal!0
-
I eat bacon in bed, I'll spare you the other details.
Ha Ha. No, I eat until I'm full. If it's late I eat a small snack-last night I had a handful of almonds, the other night I had a "fun" sized candy.0 -
Eat whenever you want just as long as you stay with in your caloric intake... I head to bed with a Big Glass of 1% Chocolate Milk and a Bowl of Almonds every night. ( around 400 calories) gets me by til breakfast around 6:30..... Doesn't matter what time of the night it is, Food is fuel for the body, got to stoke the fire..... :-)0
-
It can affect how well you sleep but it has absolutely no impact on weight loss.0
-
I'll eat right up until bedtime if I'm hungry and I have the calories. As others have said, when you eat has no effect on weight loss. The reason you'll see the "never eat after X pm rule" is that many people eat snacks in front of the TV after dinner and those calories are usually above and beyond what they should be eating. For those people who aren't counting calories, not eating snacks after dinner is probably a good idea.0
-
I eat a light snack EVERY night within an hour of my bedtime and have lost pretty much everything I wanted to lose. A friend of mine (fitness competitor) told me that it's best to eat protein-rich snacks before bed. Carbs will cause a spike and subsequent crash in your blood sugar while you are sleeping and you'll wake up starving.
Your body is still burning energy while you are asleep, so keeping it fueled makes sense.0 -
I've never had any problems losing weight due to eating at different times. My usual supper time is around 8 to 9 pm, and I often have a cup of hot chocolate or a glass of milk within an hour of going to bed.0
-
I used to always eat as late as 9pm and if I am still hungry later and I have the calories to spare, I will snack on something. The only time I won't eat past 6-7 pm is when I'm doing a biggest loser challenge and need to step on the scale the next morning.0
-
Like most diet and nutrition-related questions, this depends on your particular metabolism & your own body's quirks.
As some people mentioned, some have trouble sleeping on a full stomach or suffer from acid reflux. If that doesn't apply to you, don't worry about it.
How carbohydrate-sensitive are you? One in four women has some level of carbohydrate-sensitivity and needs to be careful about how many carbs she eats in one sitting. Some (like me) actually need to eat a pretty restrictive low-carb diet in order to stay healthy. So IF you are carbohydrate-sensitive, then your body is more likely to end up storing carbs as fat (if you don't use them immediately). In that case, you would want to avoid eating carbs right before a rest period. Eating anything else would be fine: hard-boiled egg, cheese stick, anything with protein. I hate going to bed hungry, it makes it hard for me to sleep, so I generally have a protein shake about half an hour before bedtime and it works great for me.
But if you're not carbohydrate-sensitive, then again, I don't see any reason why you shouldn't eat whatever you want, whenever you want. Again, it just depends on YOUR body and what works for YOU.0 -
it depends on what you eat, dont eat anything that isnt beneficial such as candy, or drink sodas, the same thing u stay away from now...
if i wake up in the middle of the night and feel like snaking i will, i eat just about every 2 hours to keep my metabolism on fire.0 -
Im a firm believer that eating carbs after 7 will add some bodyweight. Your body will not process the carbs during the night as it does during the day. Therefore since they have no where to go, they attach to your fat cells, making them bigger.
When I cut, lose bodyfat, I have no carbs (breads, rice, sweet potatoes) after 3pm. If Im adding mass, I will eat carbs up to 7pm.
that is my two cents.0 -
Im a firm believer that eating carbs after 7 will add some bodyweight. Your body will not process the carbs during the night as it does during the day. Therefore since they have no where to go, they attach to your fat cells, making them bigger.
When I cut, lose bodyfat, I have no carbs (breads, rice, sweet potatoes) after 3pm. If Im adding mass, I will eat carbs up to 7pm.
that is my two cents.
They attach to your fat cells huh?0 -
if i wake up in the middle of the night and feel like snaking i will, i eat just about every 2 hours to keep my metabolism on fire.
meal frequency does nothing to boost metabolism...that is a myth0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions