Paula Deen on the Today Show - what's your opinion?

Options
2456718

Replies

  • NayaP
    NayaP Posts: 46
    Options
    I didn't see the show but overall, she never professed to be a go-to source for healthy eating or living. People have to take personal responsibility...if they couldn't figure out that her recipies weren't exactly healthy while watching the show - I mean adding sticks of butter to everything shoulda clued them in - then that sadly is on them. And if those same people are now (after she's been publicly diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes) willing to follow her advice on how to get healthy, that is is sadly on them. I place no real blame on Paula Dean...she strikes me as an old school cook who doesn't want to diet-down her cooking because of the times we live in; which honestly, I understand. Eating those foods every now and then is not a crime and no one should be made to feel like it is. Again, each person is responsible for their own health choices.
  • xjackie83
    xjackie83 Posts: 23 Member
    Options
    I've never really cared for her. I think it's kind of shameful for her to sit there as a person with diabetes and say that it's ok to eat the meals she cooks as long as it's in moderation. Having a donut maybe once a month is eating something in moderation. Having a donut hamburger with a side of mac and cheese and one of her gooey cakes for dessert is not moderation.

    Also if she only eats her high calorie/fat/sugar foods in moderation what is she eating the rest of the time? Why isn't she showing Americans how to make those foods?
  • Grokette
    Grokette Posts: 3,330 Member
    Options
    I think she is a fat-sugar-starch pusher, who should atone for her sins. She is harming people by giving everyone the idea that feast foods should be everyday foods. We have enough of that message from greedy corporations who don't care if they throw us under a bus, as long as they get our money.

    She should do FREE public service messages, and if she teaches anyone about food, it should be how to make delectable foods that nourish us and sustain our health.

    She's made enough money off the fat of the land.

    It is not the fat that is bad for us. Butter is actually healthy as it is a natural occurring fat. The sugar, flour and starch in her foods is what is killing her and many others.

    And she needs to stop smoking
  • gdaykatie
    Options
    I'm loving all these responses, and I do agree with points on both sides of the camps.

    I do, however, think that when one assumes a public role, as she did, they must think of the repercussions of their actions. Sure, you and I might realize that these foods can lead to a very dangerous health problem if consumed regularly (Obviously, we're all on MFP for one reason or another), but there are those people who either A) Don't realize that or B) Realize it but don't care.

    I'm just saying, she could have been more tactful in how she's reaching out to her audience instead of yet another celebrity endorsement of a pill. Again, just my opinion. :)
  • mixmastermolly
    Options
    I think it's her body, her health, and our responsibility to educate ourselves on what is healthy. Sure it would be great for someone in the public eye to be a good representative of good health but she certainly isn't the only celebrity making poor choices. I never was much of a fan and it's a constant joke about Paula Deen and her butter so people know the health risks from her food and continue making/eating them.
  • skinnywithin
    skinnywithin Posts: 1,392 Member
    Options
    HER MEDICAL ISSUES ARE JUST THAT..HERS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She doesnt need to report to any of us what her medical charts look like..Just becasue she is a celebrity she should still have the same respect that we give each other..PRIVACY !!!!!!!!

    It is her issue weither or not she wants to take prescriptions to handle her issues..at her age she can do or NOT do what ever the heck she wants. ..She is a big girl she knows right from wrong just as we all do......DID you or would you like it is someone said OH DONT EAT THAT YOU TO HEAVY or YOU KNOW THATS BAD FOR YOU RIGHT??? It takes our own inner self to make the proper changes that we need to.

    You see....this is whats wrong with people today...always pointing the finger at someone else..Im sure there are changes WE ALL NEED TO MAKE within !!!!!!!!!!! Sorry rant over........and YEA like Paula I LOVE BUTTER !!!!!!!!!
  • Savyna
    Savyna Posts: 789 Member
    Options
    I think some people are just too quick to let celebrities/people on the screen make decisions for you. I personally know that I can't really eat the food Ms. Deen cooks because its waaaay too heavy for me. Of course it looks tasty though and I might have a bite of it but I wouldn't go home and make it everyday and night because she did. Yes if she did know she had diabetes she should have been more cautious of what she was cooking, but then again we only see what she cooks in the studio, maybe in her home she was more careful, I'm not quite sure. I just hope that now that she knows for real and that the public knows along with her that she'll feel more pressure to think of healthier choices in her kitchen and eating lifestyle, that she could change that first and see how that can help with the drugs she might be taking, because in the end you can't just depend on the drugs you need to do your part too, and doctors tell you that when they say you have high cholesterol or diabetes, they tell you that you're going to have to exercise more, cut back on certain things etc. There are no miracle drugs.
  • Lesa_Sass
    Lesa_Sass Posts: 2,213 Member
    Options
    I like Paula Deen. I did not see the show today but
    I think she may just be uneducated on how important diet and exerise is. Knowledge is power!

    I hope she realizes this soon.


    I am assuming you did not see her on Dr Oz either? Trust me, she knows, she refuses!!
  • BobbyDaniel
    BobbyDaniel Posts: 1,460 Member
    Options
    As a life long southerner...sorry, I cannot say anything bad about Ms. Paula. To do so would result in a visit by some large guys wearing bib overalls all named Bubba, who would then take me for a ride into the woods escorted by their baseball bats and a mostly empty bottle of Jim Beam.
    And now, for some reason, I'm craving a stick of butter....
  • Manda_H
    Manda_H Posts: 80
    Options
    As long as she pushes the meds, people will keep eating her food and buying her books. For her to admit it was a terribly unhealthyw ay to live, she wouldn't make any money. This way she can burn her candle from both ends.
  • Grokette
    Grokette Posts: 3,330 Member
    Options
    Hmmmmm, maybe this is why her son Bobby is trying to play up her recipes and make them more healthy.

    No she does not have to be held responsible to her audience, but honesty to her audience would have been nice. How convenient for a public figure to not speak up about a condition that affects millions until you get an endorsement.

    However from what I see, his food is not that much healthy.

    Making something low fat definitely doesn't make it healthy - only more processed, which in my book is the BIGGEST NO NO of them all.

    Reducing the sugar and flour a small bit doesn't making something healthier either...............

    I would rather stick to the basics.

    Fat - Coconut Oil, animal fats, olive oil, some nut and seed oils
    Protein - From a variety of wild, pastured, free roaming sources
    Carbs - From locally sources farmers markets, CSA and Coop. Growing my own when it is growing season and getting as much organic as I can afford.
  • myranda16
    Options
    I didn't see it but ill stand up for paula dean any day I love her!!! .. I probably need to see if some how i can watch it...
  • mallorybriann
    mallorybriann Posts: 1,380 Member
    Options
    it's irresponsible of the public to not educate themselves.
    Just because someone famous supports it, doesn't mean you should jump on the bandwagon.
    Do research, be INFORMED and EDUCATED.
    She is basically advocating drugs (and getting compensated by a pharmaceutical company) over lifestyle changes to help type 2 diabetes. It's irresponsible....
    she has a public responsibility with that damn cooking show of hers, and she's just exacerbating something that she could be helping.
  • firesoforion
    firesoforion Posts: 1,017 Member
    Options
    As for the unhealthiness of her food, I don't particularly care. She doesn't say it's healthy she almost treats it as a joke that you don't really do this but oh hah hah hah it's so goooood. Meh. She's an entertainment person and 99% of the time, entertainment people either consciously or unknowingly promote lifestyle changes in their viewers, and the viewers really shouldn't put all that stock in an entertainment show.

    The thing that really bothers me is that I've watched her on Next Food Network Star, and for someone who claims to come from a background of troubles and hardships and overcoming adversity, she had absolutely no compassion towards the contestants on her show. I watched her straight up tell a person their food was terrible and not even be apologetic about it. On national tv. Granted that still doesn't make her as bad as Ina Garten and not letting a kid with cancer come meet her (after making him wait months to hear the answer), but I saw her treat the contestants that way and I was pretty much done with her.
  • Elleinnz
    Elleinnz Posts: 1,661 Member
    Options
    I cringe every time I watch one of her shows - her show must be by far the unhealthiest of the US celebrity cook show hosts!!
    She has obviously made truck loads of money peddling unhealthy eating, and what a shame she is not using this opportunity to show people a new way!
  • Missnurse89
    Options
    I USED to love Paula Deen... but after hearing about this I have a completely changed opinion.

    According to different newsites she has had diabetes for approx 3 years. That means for 3 years she has continued to make high sugar high carb foods that trigger blood sugar spikes in diabetes patients while she herself was suffering. So only now, when she is being paid to represent a medication, she comes out and tells America... You want to make money? How about pitch a show about cooking for people who have diabetes??

    Type 2 diabetes can be CONTROLLED and in some cases REVERSED with DIET alone!!!

    Tsk, tsk Paula. You say you dont know if the way you ate had anything to do with your diabetes? Of course it did, you cant eat high carb high sugar foods for years and expect your pancreas to just be able to keep up. Lets own up to this. I do not blame her for cooking those types of foods on TV, people have complete control over what is put in their mouths, only for lying about it and acting like she has no clue why this happened to her.
  • noiva
    noiva Posts: 94
    Options
    Is it irresponsible for a public figure to advocate drugs over healthy lifestyle? Yes. But she is a brand and has worked herself up from absolutely nothing to, well, a lot. And this will be her millionth endorsement deal, so it really doesn't surprise me.

    As for her waiting three years to tell, it's no one's business what disease any public figure or celebrity has. Her body and health is her business.
  • samatalma
    samatalma Posts: 197
    Options
    I'm sorry, but if unless she forced people to cook and consume everything on her show, she has no responsiblity to her audience. They are responsible for what they purchase, prepare and consume.


    This. Honestly, if you seriously thought this woman who cooks and eats the way she does has NO health problems at all, you're delusional. Seriously.
  • jonetpwhite
    jonetpwhite Posts: 4 Member
    Options
    Paula Deen has a responsibility to herself. If she wants to continue to be in the public eye while still smoking, eating fried foods on a regular basis and advocating pills as a means to control weight and cronic disease, then she is the one who is suffering.

    I like some of her foods but in moderation and on special occasions. If she didn't think she was doing anything wrong she wouldn't even go on Dr. Oz or the Today show and have fingers pointed at her.

    If you think she has a responsibility to improve the quality of food she is cooking then you have a responsibility to tell her so as well. You are an accessory after the fact, by sitting there and watching, you are promoting the bad behaviour as well.