Is running good for heavy people? I am 211lbs

24

Replies

  • damifogg
    damifogg Posts: 26 Member
    Not sure I've got a great response for you, but I got a response at least.

    RUN JOHNNY!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    When I was at 265lbs I ran a 10km race (not fast, but run them), and a few 5km races a few years back.

    I'm back to the same weight, give or take the odd pound, and have just started the C25k thing. My knees are always a bit of a concern, but so far, because I've been building up slowly and allowing myself plenty of rest, it's been going fine. I'm up to week 5 now so running like 8 minutes each time. Nothing to be excited about, but I can do it comfortably and nothing is aching / breaking.

    Not running over 200lbs is utter bollocks. Just don't expect to be doing any marathons anytime soon.
    Running at our weight is one of the best ways to burn calories, and yes it's high impact, but I'm sure someone smarter than me can explain why that's a very good thing to prevent osteoarthritis and all that.

    My advice. Get out there and do it. Find a programme that is progressive and does the run/walk thing for several weeks. Let your body get used to it, and watch the weight fall off.

    My 2 pence worth anyway.

    Good luck! :-)
  • shellyb2017
    shellyb2017 Posts: 119 Member
    I weigh around 200 and run 3-4 times a week. I ran a half marathon in October 2011 - slowly. I am not a fast runner so I don't think the joint impact is as damaging. I've seen some people walk faster than I run :-)

    My advice (for what it is worth) is to start out by walking, build up to being able to walk briskly, then walk/run - try Galloway's method. If you feel like running after you have conditioned your body, then I think you should do it!

    Just like with dieting, running is something you condition your body to do little by little over time. I used to run marathons, but over the years my weight and lack of motivation has kept me from doing what I love. I am looking foward to losing weight and enjoying life again! I just joined Fitness Pal this week!

    See you on the roads ...
  • lawson305
    lawson305 Posts: 103
    I weigh 248, and am starting the 8th week of C25K tomorrow. I have no joint pain or issues with stamina, and I think if it feels good, do it. C25K is a great way to start! Good luck
  • Stoicus
    Stoicus Posts: 34 Member
    I started Couch to 5K when I was 200lbs+, I'm now 185. I started slow, in fact I'm still pretty slow but I am still overweight. I use a treadmill predominantly which is easier on the joints. I don't run outside at the moment, but I have run on concrete and I can tell you it really hurt after. I've read that a lot of overweight people start on treadmills or grass, and I can see why. If your knee hurts, you should get some advice from your doctor and look into some knee strengthening exercises. And if you want a virtual buddy to run with, feel free to add me :)
  • 6mimi
    6mimi Posts: 1,432 Member
    I'm 207lbs, took it slow 3 weeks ago on Couch to 5k program. By the end of the second week I got unmanageable pain in both knees and the sides of my calves so I had to stop. I'm going to give it another when a) the pain goes away and b) when I'm less heavy. I'm thinking another 14lbs and I'll see how it goes.

    That happened to me too. Running is really hard on the joints. I am not giving up on the running, but going to wait until I lose a little more weight and start again even slower. I read on one web site that most of the time people start a running program without building muscle in their legs first. I also think that it will vary from person to person just depending on their genetic leg/foot structure. I know my high arches cause me problems sometimes. I tend to do better on the elliptical and it is still a great burn.
  • Lorie66
    Lorie66 Posts: 66
    If you can walk 30 mins without effort start out walking 4 mins and running one untill you can graduate to walking 3 mins and running 2....and SLOWLY build your mileage ...this is how a coach teaches it....your weight will start to drop as you gradually build your mins as long as you are on a healthy eating plan....always go slow to prevent injury..if you start having pain stop and rest that day and if you are ready the next day with no pian start back.Listen to your body and you will be loosing weight and running in no time.. :)
  • Eaglesfanintn
    Eaglesfanintn Posts: 813 Member
    I started running 18 months ago, at 279 lbs. I'm still over 200, but have run 3 marathons in that time.
    I will say that I'm lucky to not have major joint problems. I have suffered with some other problems - but nothing that other, thinner runners don't get - shin splints, IT band pain, etc.
    I started off slowly - my first run was about a mile and took me about 14 minutes. I added on time at first - about a minute every day and then 2 minutes on day 6 - took day 7 off. Then started at that time the next week. In a few weeks, I was running for 30 minutes. Then, I started to work on speed.
    Others have recommended C25K - I didn't use it, but know some people that did with really good results.
  • Articeluvsmemphis
    Articeluvsmemphis Posts: 1,987 Member
    you don't HAVE to run. but that's crazy someone recommended not doing it over 200lbs. I started "running" more like jogging since I started at 300lbs, on the treadmill. anyhow, just find something lower impact to do if it hurts. exercise should be effective, not painful
  • I started running at about 250 pounds (I think I was about 26-ish). At around 235 pounds, I ran my frist 5K, and then ran a 10K at around 195 pounds. So, the moral of the story is, it can be done! I lost a TON of weight running, but I also was careful to mix in some cross training every week as well, such as using the eliptical and another running-esque machine that's kinda like the gazelle that used to be advertised on TV.

    There are many exercises you can do to increase the strength of your knees. I did have some knee pain during the time I was running, but it was almost never actually WHILE I was running. It was mostly after when I would go down stairs, or have to get up from a kneeling position. I just made sure to take ibuprophen when necessary, and ice and rest appropriately. (And also not do too much running, as I said, cross training with low-impact exercises was important for me!)

    Now, I play roller derby, and my knees are in GREAT shape (knock on wood)! I have recently started running again, and I'm hoping to run a 5K in March! Good luck with your running endeavors!
  • FunRun08
    FunRun08 Posts: 203 Member
    I was over 200lbs when I started running, I bought shoe inserts to help protect my knees. If you have issues with your joints the elliptical is a nice low impact alternative to running.
  • brandimacleod
    brandimacleod Posts: 368 Member
    I started jogging in the 270's but my knees are great. So while I would hate to steer you wrong with knee issues, I say if it doesnt hurt, and you have great shoes, do it!
  • blueyegrl
    blueyegrl Posts: 248 Member
    I just started the C25K training, got through week 1 with no problems, but at the start of week 2 my knees started to hurt, so I went back to week 1 and will stay there until I lose some more weight.

    I should note, I'm currently 215.8lbs, 35 years old and have NEVER jogged in my life, even back in high school I was the one who walked behind everyone else because unless there is a zombie coming after me, I don't jog! lol I started doing the training on my treadmill at home. Let me tell you, I am having the time of my life. I LOVE it. Even if it is 1 minute intervals of jogging, I think it's the best thing I've ever done. I just bought some "real" running shoes though, because I think that's part of why my knees hurt. Also my weight. I am hoping as the pounds keep dropping I'll be able to keep going on with the training. But I say start slow and give it a try, and be sure to stretch!!!! So important, I didn't think it was, but I learned the hard way how important it really really is! Good luck! And feel free to add me as a friend if you need additional jogging support! :happy:
  • gaelbrady
    gaelbrady Posts: 68 Member
    Always check with your doctor before taking up running or any high-intensity activity...but for motivation, I point you to this video:

    http://youtu.be/8SbXgQqbOoU

    Enjoy! And good luck!
  • jrich1
    jrich1 Posts: 2,408 Member
    The key again.. invest in a pair of Running shoes. this will help with joint and knee pain.. not a pair of shoes you get at walmart on sale for $29.. go to a running store and spend some money and get a good pair of shoes that works for you..
  • eayal002
    eayal002 Posts: 186
    It starts with the proper shoe, if it doesn't provide enough support for you it can create problems. I wouldn't start trying to run 5 miles at first, concrete is hard on the knees regardless if you are 100lbs or 300lbs I prefer to run on trails or a track (have no idea of the name of the material) that is not a hard surface. If you find a good track, run 1/2 or a 1/4 of the track and walk same distance the repeat and gradually increase the distance you run lessening the distance you walk.

    Small steps at a time, first few weeks walk a faster pace start building up to it. Don't get discouraged if running at first hurts your knees build up to it. Nothing wrong with starting with a walk.
  • summertime_girl
    summertime_girl Posts: 3,945 Member
    I started running at 219. Running got me to 169 and counting. Look into ChiRunning, as well as minimalist shoes that help you stay on your forefoot/midfoot while running. That'll mitigate knee pain.
  • philOHIO
    philOHIO Posts: 520 Member
    It is important to stretch and warmup before AND after, regardless of weight. I have ran since high school, but I also love good food. Wife, family, life, back problems from lifting, restaurant food put this weight on. I used to run 15 mile stretches, and then go for a bike ride. I am all original parts. I can still run! Just much slower and smaller stints. I highly recommend it... one of the best ways to lose weight.
    MUST READ: START A C25K program!!!!!!!! and follow it.
  • jdavis193
    jdavis193 Posts: 972 Member
    I had to take an exercise science class in college and she said for anyone exercising before they should run they should beable to walk 2 miles straight before they should run.
  • For me I have found inclines to be more helpful than speed. Like I power walk often at a speed of 2.5 on an incline of 8 or 9 onthe treadmill. Its harder but not faster, and I find it to be a slower burn my body handles easier.Hope this helps!
  • pupcamper
    pupcamper Posts: 410 Member
    I tried running/walking intervals when I was over 200 pounds and it resulted in knee troubles for me too. My Doctor gave me some leg excercises to do to build up the muscles behind my knee cap. I would love to tell you that it solved my problems but unfortuantely I broke my ankle and I think my running days are over - on the plus side I walk on the treadmill on a high incline and I seem to burn off more calories that I would if I ran! Go talk to your Doctor I'm sure you'll get your best advice from there!
  • jjlees
    jjlees Posts: 2 Member
    I think moderation and a slow ramp-up is key. And, I wouldn't run every day. Probably every third day to start.

    I started running when I was 38 as part of a weight loss program. I didn't start running until I had gotten down to 250lbs. approximately. That was in May 2008. I raced my first half marathon on Thanksgiving 2008. And my first marathon on Thanksgiving 2009. I have since completed two Ironman races and am doing my third this summer. I now weigh just under 200lbs. (205 just last week--thank you holidays!) So, I am not far from 211.

    I mention the above to make sure you know that YOU can do it! That first mile in May 2008 was harder than the last mile of my first marathon! From that first mile, it took me probably 6 weeks to work up to 3 miles. And, it wasn't until I could comfortably run 10+ miles that I truly began to enjoy running. Now, on my biggest run weeks, I will do 40-60miles/week. YOU will get there! The hardest part is that first mile.

    It is tough to draw that line between the minor aches and pains that come with pushing yourself and the aches and pains of injuring yourself. If you have to err, err on the side of caution. There will always be a next run to go harder--as long as you don't hurt yourself. Once you get more and more miles behind you, you will get a better and better feel of the difference between pushing and injuring.

    Enjoy the journey!

    -John
  • I dropped most of my initial weight running. Went from 235 to about 215 on a treadmill. Find one with a shock absorber (most gym ones have them now) and listen to your body.
  • Mariposa7
    Mariposa7 Posts: 74 Member
    Sure you can! Ease into it, listen to you body...but still push yourself. I'm 214 and I can run 4 miles w/out a walking break. I have a 10K, a 10 mile and half marathon planned for this year! Don't give up, its hard, and you'll probably moan & groan at first, but you'll feel great once you've finished! Good Luck and Happy Trails!
  • ritzglitz
    ritzglitz Posts: 7 Member
    Absolutely. I've been running since I was 260. Start slow though and listen to you body. I'm around you weight right now(207) and I run a 10min mile. I had to train myself to get my endurance and speed up through interval work. My new goal is to be able to run for 30min straight at a 5.5mph pace. I'm pretty sure you can do some research online and find a running plan that works for you and slowly progress from there.
  • hpsnickers1
    hpsnickers1 Posts: 2,783 Member
    I'd say with anything to start slowly. I am 209 and ran 1.5 miles yesterday with my Xbox fitness game and it hurt my hips. I am not a runner and am slowly starting to try to get out of my comfort level as far as exercise goes and try new things. I don't see myself being a runner per se but it is a great burn. No other advice but I'm sure others will have some great advice for you. Good luck!!

    I agree. Start slowly. There will be a lot more impact on your joints then someone who is "skinny" (I hate that word). A brisk walk will do just as much for your health as running - personally I think it's a whole lot healthier than running - just my opinion. Then maybe move on to jogging intervals during your walk. But be careful because a whole lot of cardio is really good at eating up your lean muscle mass and putting unneeded stress on your body. (the body sees too much exercise as stress and proceeds to try and "protect" itself from that stress).

    Google "chronic cardio" and see what you find.
  • csparon
    csparon Posts: 200 Member
    I would say walking is good, running may be hard on your knees. I was a cross country runner in high school and I am about 20lbs heavier than I was back then and it kills me sometimes. I stick with the elliptical because it's low-impact on the knees but still amazing cardio. Once I get closer to the range I was in high school I will work on running more.
  • icemaiden17_uk
    icemaiden17_uk Posts: 463 Member
    I am 231lb! I was 240ish when I started running! It is hard and I did hurt my shin but I love it so I just rested and am ready to get back to it! If you listen to your body and don't overdo it I don't see why it would be a problem! Just be careful and make sure your fitness level is ok to start running! Try using a program like couch to 5 k as a starting point!

    Good luck!

    Wanted to add that I do my running using proper running shoes to support my feet and knees and on a treadmill!
  • jcstanton
    jcstanton Posts: 1,849 Member
    I am 35 and I weigh 255lbs. I ran last Saturday and again on Monday, but I didn't run nonstop. I warmed up with a brisk five minute walk, ran for 90sec, walked for 60sec, ran for 90sec, and back to walking for 60sec, and so on for about twenty minutes. I didn't have any pain in my knees, but my calves and ankles were pretty sore the next day. I have noticed in the past, though, that if I am retaining water I tend to have more knee pain when I run. I think the excess fluid puts pressure on the joint, causing extra stress. Maybe try reducing your sodium intake, and drink extra water the day before you plan to do any running to get rid of excess fluid in your body. I have set a goal to run an entire 5K in May, so I started training now to give myself plenty of time to work up to it. Also, doing some extra strength training for your legs wouldn't hurt either (i.e. leg extensions, leg curls, leg press, squats, lunges, calf raises, etc...).
  • PhatAv8r
    PhatAv8r Posts: 150 Member
    I don't run as fast, and I have to do the walk/run thing, but I am evidence that HEAVY (nice way to say it there) people can run. In fact, they should, but again, in a controlled manner to protect their knees.

    I weight 340, trust me, it can be done. I walk more than I run, but I do C25K and am back on Week 2. Three years ago, I started at 342, and dropped to 308.. at that point, I ran a 5K in 42:16, so again, a HEAVY person can run..

    just be sure to ICE your knees if you feel pain, each knee for about 10 to 15 minutes... you can freeze dixie cups of water and then peel the top back to reveal about 1/4 inch of ice, then just move it around over the knee for a few minutes.

    The other thing is use ibuprofen to manage the inflammation and prevent tendonitis.

    Finally, STRETCH, STRETCH, STRETCH.. why did I write that THREE times, BEFORE, DURING, AFTER

    Always walk and warm up for 300-400 yards, then stretch your calves, hammies, groin, and quads. Also your hips. Then go ahead and start your run. If you feel a little cramping along the way, STOP, and stretch with a LONG HOLD (no bouncing) of 20-30 seconds, and then continue your run by walking for a bit, then moving into your run. If you get tight again, stretch again... and when you are done... STRETCH, and this should take 5-10 minutes, moving through different stretches that you hold for 20-30 seconds, release, then repeat. Each stretch a minimum of TWO times. Again, calves, hammy, quad, and groin.

    If you'll do that, you'll avoid not only pain, but a lot of the acid build up you feel a day or so later.

    Good luck.
  • As a certified Health Fitness Specialist through the America College of Sports medicine, and a Division-1 cross-country and track runner if you can run comfortably and without pain do it because it is one fo the best ways for losing weight. You burn about 100 calories per mile that you run which is awesome! There is more stress on your knees and ankles if you run while being overweight but if it is tolerable then go for it. The best way to approach it would be by walking and then progressing into running, and you're not out to set any world records so just take it nice and easy. As for running and aerobic training, it does not inhibit or decrease muscles mass so you can run all you want and still be gaining muscle if you are lfting weights. I hope this was helpful to you.
This discussion has been closed.