Is running good for heavy people? I am 211lbs
Replies
-
I'm 306 and I occasionally jog during my walks. I had knee pain before I started this journey and have only been back to walking and fitness for a month, but I'm careful to take it slow and let my body be my guide. If my knee hurts, I'll swim at the gym or use the bike or elliptical. I don't walk every day, but I feel a natural need to bump it up a little when I do. Good luck!0
-
I do not think that running is best for everybody.
You might want to start out with some slow, low impact jogging or even fast walking.
When I was fat, I walked away my first 45 lbs before ever even attempting to jog.
And after losing 70lbs, my jog is barely a 12 minute mile.
Running may not be for everybody, but fitness surely is.
Find what works for you, and just do it.
All Is Possible!0 -
Hi! I am currently 221 and I run 2 miles straight and while I get a few shin splints they are usually gone after a quick massage and ice. I am training to run my first 5K this spring. Do things slowly and build up to them. You can do whatever you set your mind to. If you automatically tell yourself you can't then that will be the outcome.
Best of luck!0 -
Always check with your doctor before taking up running or any high-intensity activity...but for motivation, I point you to this video:
http://youtu.be/8SbXgQqbOoU
Enjoy! And good luck!
For what it's worth, Ben Davis (the guy in this video) was just interviewed and featured in Runner's World Magazine. And he's still not a "little" guy.
I was just coming back to post this. your right I think Ben is around 240 pounds right now. That video is amazing and is super inspiring0 -
I started running/jogging after I had worked out to strengthen my muscles for about 3 months before I started running. I was probably 220 when I started doing some running, more than 5 min at a time. I have tried running before and it was somewhat painful - I felt that my strength training leading up to it this time helped me start off on the right foot. I'm stil over 200 lbs and only 5'4", but am now able to run 2 miles without dying - so it can be done!
Good luck. Start slow and listen to your body!0 -
A good pair or trainers (sneakers) aand youll be fine, Im 230lbs and I run like a sprinter lol, youll be fine 0
-
There are a lot of people here who have run at over 200 pounds and have found success doing it. I think the best idea is to check with your doctor first to make sure you're not at risk of any health problems from running.
I'd recommend trying C25K (www.c25k.com) as a way to ease yourself back into running. It's a program designed to help people who have never been able to run before move from being a couch potato to being able to run a 5k in 9 weeks. The reason why you may have aggravated your knee is because you didn't ease back in to running and went too hard for your first time back.
THIS
I started out at 232. I began by walking and increasing my speed and distance. After a while, I found C25K and began that program. I agree that you need to start slowly and build up. From what I've read, many beginners start out doing too much, too fast, and injure themselves. Just go slow. Additionally, make sure you get fitted for a good pair of running shoes... that will also help,0 -
I started running at 220. I am a 5' 4" inch female and I started slow and set small goals. I would walk and then try to run one block without stopping, then one lap around the track, eventually one mile without stopping. I threw a party that day! I am slow and I jog more than I run but I haven't had any pain (besides soreness) or issues from running. 5 mos later I am down 60 lbs and have run 3 5ks and love running.
Get good running shoes... I had heel pain and my toes fell asleep until I got my asics gels.0 -
Don't run. Walk briskly. Don't use treadmills unless it's bad weather or too hot/cold. Natural walking is better than treadmills because treadmills make you walk in an unnatural gait. Also, treadmills cost money whereas walking outside is free.
Walk briskly every day for 10 minutes. The best time to walk is two hours after lunch. Usually, people feel a little sleepy two hours after lunch due to an insulin rush and crash. The best way to snap out of that malaise is to walk briskly for 10 minutes (56 calories). You need to walk fast enough to get your heart pumping but not too fast that you injure yourself. Wear proper footwear!
The reason that I'm able to maintain a daily walking routine is:
1. It's fun to take a 10 minute break from work
2. It helps me to wake up from my boring job
3. It's easy because it only takes 10 minutes away from my day
4. A 10 minute walk generally doesn't work up enough sweat to require changing clothes and showering which consumes more time during the day.
Pick a long scenic route that you can walk in one lap instead of a shorter multiple lap walk. Multiple laps are monotonous.
Myfitnesspal plus my ten minute daily walk has enabled me to lose 29 pounds from November 2 (232 lbs) to January 20 (203 lbs).0 -
I think if your body can handle it- go for it. I started jogging at 270ish lbs!!!! I used the Couch to 5K program to get myself to a point where I could have the endurance to run a 5K. Now I've done multiple races, even a 10K. I still weight right around 199 lbs and I have no issues with it! I think it all depends on your fitness level and if you have knees that can handle it! (I run around 10 miles a week give or take, I hate the treadmill.....more in the summer because I can run outdoors) Good luck- and check out c25k- its a great way to build endurance! 0
-
I trained and ran a half marathon at 300lbs. Just start slow, stretch properly and listen to your body.0
-
There are alot of great ideas out there about easing into running. I too am over 200 lbs and use to run in my younger years. I really enjoy the benefits that come from running and I'm anxious to get back into it. I love the suggestion to jog for 20-30 seconds and walk for a minute. Great suggestions. Keep them coming.0
-
I am 6'0" and now 254 pounds. I used to run often before I gained weight, and I've now started back. As others have recommended, the C25K program is great. I've downloaded it on my phone, and you can go at your own pace and repeat weeks if necessary. If you're having pains, I would also recommend getting your endurance up by either walking, stationary bike, or using the elliptical machine since it is easier on the knees. My gym has Zumba and other classes, and that is what I used to get my endurance up enough to run again. Running is one of the best ways to lose body fat, but you do need to listen to your body and make adjustments. I have high arches; therefore, I had to put arch support inserts in my shoes to mitigate shin splints.0
-
This is the best advice on the post, I am 245 and when I first started jogging I got pain but this is because before I had been lazy and fat and my body wasn't used to exercise, I get pain when I have gone to the gym as well but it's because we need to build up stamina and strength. You can't just go from being a couch potato on a bad diet to thinking "Right I'm on MFP, now lets do a 5 mile run" It doesn't work like that.:laugh:talk to your doctor, get a GOOD pair of running shoes (Asics are #1 in running world magazine and most blogs that I pulled up)..and stretch really well before and after running. That makes a huge difference.0 -
You so asked a good question and it looks like you are getting alot of good anwsers I weight the same as you and I run on the treadmill. I have been reading runner's magazines for a while now and they say the same thing. Start out very slow walk to warm up and then jog for a bit until your lungs start to feel it, then start to walk again and then just build yourself up to a 1 mile jog! But this happens over a long peroid of time. i would not just start running right away. But your weight has NOTHING to do with running. But be smart about it start out slow and listen to your body. you will probably have sore muscules but the pain that comes with injures surpasses sore muscules. remember that cross training is great to do with running. Hey if the guys on the biggest loser can do it, I can do it that is the way i look at it....=D I love running and started running when I weight 250. And no one could tell me I can't
Feel free to add me as a friend!0 -
I actually started jogging when I was 248 LBS , bad knees from a car accident and being an asthmatic to boot.. Im down to 208 and run an average of 2 miles nightly . My advice is this ..Start slow and set realistic goals.. your not going to be able to run several miles right out of the gate.. Set a consistent amount of time you want to be on the treadmill (like 30 mins at first) and try what I call a "2 and 2" pace at first .. Walk 2 minutes at 3+ MPH and then go into a light jog like 4+mph for 2 minutes , drop back to the walk for 2 minutes and then up to the jog for 2 minutes.. Keep going back and forth like that for the duration of time your on the treadmill and allow enough time to cool down for at least 10 minutes afterwards. Once you get to the point (and you WILL ) where the 4 MPH isnt a "challenge" any more .. bump up the speed to 5MPH and keep the cycle of 2 and 2 and then do it again at 6 MPH. Once you get to the point where you can do 2 and 2 at 6 MPH with less effort .. Change your focus to distance more than time.. Walk for a .25 mile to warm up and then jog (at least 5+ mph) for .25 mile drop back to a walk for a .25 mile and then jog for a .25 mile... do this for a while untill you feel comfortable and then walk for a .25 mile and jog for a half mile back to a walk. Eventually keep working up by 1/4 mile increments till you can run a mile + without effort..
kinda wordy I know.. but what worked for me0 -
start off walking and then add a light jog and then attempt to run once your weight is under control and your heart is stronger.0
-
As many people have already said, just start slowly. Also your stride is important. You want a short stride length with a mid foot landing. You want to avoid heel striking as that is like putting on the brakes and is very jarring to your knees and entire body. Warm up by moving(walking) and stretch AFTER. Never stretch cold muscles.
And again.....GO SLOWLY!0 -
I am about 250lbs. The ONLY way I can jog is on a treadmill because it gives and does hurt my knees like it would on the road.0
-
I think if your body can handle it- go for it. I started jogging at 270ish lbs!!!! I used the Couch to 5K program to get myself to a point where I could have the endurance to run a 5K. Now I've done multiple races, even a 10K. I still weight right around 199 lbs and I have no issues with it! I think it all depends on your fitness level and if you have knees that can handle it! (I run around 10 miles a week give or take, I hate the treadmill.....more in the summer because I can run outdoors) Good luck- and check out c25k- its a great way to build endurance!
thats inspiration right there, seeing your profile picture Id never of believed you weighed 270lbs, well done, epic! :-) you look awesome0 -
I'm 306 and have started c25k! Though I dunt know if you can call what I do running...0
-
Might try to get shoes fitted. It helped my knee issues and now Im back to running 25 miles a week.0
-
As many people have already said, just start slowly. Also your stride is important. You want a short stride length with a mid foot landing. You want to avoid heel striking as that is like putting on the brakes and is very jarring to your knees and entire body. Warm up by moving(walking) and stretch AFTER. Never stretch cold muscles.
And again.....GO SLOWLY!
Five pages of comments and this is the first time someone's mentioned form? I hope I missed previous ones, because next to shoes, this is the biggest factor in non-muscle pain for runners, especially when running on concrete.
Read up on how the foot is designed to absorb the impact of running to understand why mid-foot strike is so important and ALWAYS be mindful of your form.
As for not being able to describe your pain, I recommend sitting down the next time it hurts and really concentrate on how it hurts. Does it hurt when you move it? Does the pain seem to come from inside the joint, or is it the muscles around it? What does the pain feel like (grinding, pulling, pinching, etc)?
Until you can answer those questions, no one can really tell you whether you're going to do damage to your knees, or if it's just muscle soreness from a good workout.0 -
I want to echo what someone said above: read Chi Running. It's a book about running form by an ultra-marathoner. Most runners (regardless of weight) get injured every year. Most of those injuries are the result of poor form, not the impact. Be careful of fancy shoes (definitely get some nice running shoes, but be careful that their comfort doesn't allow you to run with poor form).
I've run hundreds of miles in the past few years with no significant injuries (a couple of minor muscle tweaks, but no joint issues) and I had knee surgery a few years ago. I was over 200 when I started back running 2 years ago. Don't stretch too much beforehand, but loosen up and warm up A LOT. Stretch heavily afterward, particularly your IT band if you're having knee issues. Work on your form first, then add distance when you feel good about your form, then think about speeding up a little. I would start out mostly walking and only run for as far as you can while maintaining proper form. The most important thing is relaxation. Also, don't let your heel hit the ground first. Land on your mid-foot. And remember, the knee is only designed to move in two dimensions.0 -
My starting weight was 223 I started at the track running the straights and walking the curves me knees would hurt a lot so I did other cardio along with the running I would only run like once or twice a week over time they stopped hurting and now I run all the time0
-
I was 256 when I started. No excuses....just run. Or start out walking. but MOVE IT!!! If you are looking for excuses, don't expect results. RUnning is a fabulous way to lose weight (I'm down 80 pounds).0
-
I think if your body can handle it- go for it. I started jogging at 270ish lbs!!!! I used the Couch to 5K program to get myself to a point where I could have the endurance to run a 5K. Now I've done multiple races, even a 10K. I still weight right around 199 lbs and I have no issues with it! I think it all depends on your fitness level and if you have knees that can handle it! (I run around 10 miles a week give or take, I hate the treadmill.....more in the summer because I can run outdoors) Good luck- and check out c25k- its a great way to build endurance!
thats inspiration right there, seeing your profile picture Id never of believed you weighed 270lbs, well done, epic! :-) you look awesome Thanks! I started this journey at nearly 332 lbs!!! Almost 2 years later, here I am still plugging away! Thank you for your kind words! 0 -
I started at around 200 with C25K. What I've learned is to also do some strength training along with your running, it will protect you from injury (well, it protects me NOW from my knees crapping out on me, so this is just my experience not science or proof or the Word of God).0
-
http://www.drdavidgeier.com/is-running-bad-for-your-knees/
A medical journal has said that running is not bad for your knees. It actually could help your joints.
Not being a medical Dr, I am only offering anecdotal evidence from my past medical experiences.
You knee pain is probably from too much too soon. Start off slow, and get a good pair of shoes. If your knee hurts all the time, especially when it is bent, I would go see a Dr to rule out tendinitis.
All that being said, you need a cardio workout you love and can stick with. If you don't like walking/jogging, then you won't do it consistently, and it won't be of any benefit to you. Find something you love.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions