Paula Deen & Diabetes. Thoughts?

2»

Replies

  • Seriously people, no one told you to watch her show or cook her food.... it's sad she has diabetes but its her business, everyone with a brain know eating unhealthy foods will have bad consequences. So she didn't run out and announce she had diabetes the minute she found out... is it really our business anyways? If you like her cooking good for you, if you dont like it good for you too, if you hate her good for you if you love her good for you. Its really none of our business what goes on in her personal life so we shouldn't be so mean about it.
  • Ely82010
    Ely82010 Posts: 1,998 Member
    question what type of diabetes does she have???


    Type 2. Adult onset. As far as I know, type 1 diabetes is congenital. You can't develop it later in life (correct me if I'm wrong).

    you can get type 1 any time. and type 1 is so not congenital

    its a autoimmune disease.


    Hmmm. I wonder why type 2 is referred to as "adult onset" diabetes? I knew type one was autoimmune, I just didn't realize you could get it as an adult. I think children are typically diagnosed with it more frequently than adults. Thanks, though, I did not know. :)



    Type one is an autoimmune disease but also considered inherited since people need to inherit risks factors from both parents. Congenital refers at what happens at the time of birth (not in the genes)

    ! Congenital = present at birth
    ! Inherited = heritable trait that may or
    may not be present at birt


    I think that the following information will help all of us to understand the difference between both type of diabetes (frommthe diabetes Association)

    Type 1 Diabetes

    Definition: Insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (type 1) is an inflammatory autoimmune disease of the pancreas, resulting in a lack of insulin.

    Description: Insulin is produced in the pancreas by beta cells of the islets of Langerhans. The main source of energy for all cells and especially for brain cells is glucose. Insulin is necessary for glucose to get into cells and be used for energy production. After eating, the glucose level in blood rises, which leads to insulin being released from the pancreas. In a person with IMDM, beta cells of Langerhans are damaged by autoimmune inflammation, leading to an insufficiency of insulin. The glucose level in blood rises and cells do not have enough energy for metabolism.

    In most cases of type 1 diabetes, people need to inherit risk factors from both parents. We think these factors must be more common in whites because whites have the highest rate of type 1 diabetes. Because most people who are at risk do not get diabetes, researchers want to find out what the environmental triggers are.

    In many people, the development of type 1 diabetes seems to take many years. In experiments that followed relatives of people with type 1 diabetes, researchers found that most of those who later got diabetes had certain autoantibodies in their blood for years before.

    (Antibodies are proteins that destroy bacteria or viruses. Autoantibodies are antibodies 'gone bad,' which attack the body's own tissues.)

    Type 1 diabetes is a disorder of the human immune system that makes it difficult for the body to produce insulin. Without insulin, the body cannot convert sugar from food into nutrients for cells. Excess sugar builds up in the blood stream and may eventually cause severe damage to organs and premature death.

    Type 1 diabetes is a disease which can strike children and adults suddenly and requires supplemental insulin along with carefully regimented diet and exercise to manage properly.

    Type 1 diabetes is generally diagnosed in children, teenagers, or young adults. Scientists do not yet know exactly what causes type 1 diabetes but believe that autoimmune, genetic, and environmental factors are involved.

    Type 2 Diabetes (non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus)

    Much of the food we eat is turned into sugar in the blood for our bodies to use for energy. A hormone produced by the pancreas called insulin helps sugar in our blood get into the cells of our bodies. If your body doesn’t make enough insulin or if the insulin doesn’t work the way it should, blood sugar can’t get into your cells and instead stays in your blood, raising your blood sugar level.

    Type 2 diabetes has a stronger link to family history and lineage than type 1, although it too depends on environmental factors. Studies of twins have shown that genetics play a very strong role in the development of type 2 diabetes. Lifestyle also influences the development of type 2 diabetes. Obesity tends to run in families, and families tend to have similar eating and exercise habits.

    If you have a family history of type 2 diabetes, it may be difficult to figure out whether your diabetes is due to lifestyle factors or genetic susceptibility. Most likely it is due to both. However, don’t lose heart. Studies show that it is possible to delay or prevent type 2 diabetes by exercising and losing weight
  • karenmi
    karenmi Posts: 242 Member
    I like her personality so I was a bit surprised by her dishonesty. I saw her on Dr. Oz a few months back and he was asking to test her blood sugar because he was concerned about diabetes....she could have come clean then, but did not.

    But I still find her interesting and hope that she changes her lifestyle so she can live a long time. Sadly many people diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes do not; my Mom was diagnosed at age 69 and a co-worker at age 60, and watching them struggle with the disease is a real eye-opener for me. It's amazing to me how little my Mom, who was a nurse for over 40 years, know about food & how to eat healthy. I feel very bad for them but my Mom's diagnosis inspired me to lose 50 lbs so something good came of it!
  • Seriously people, no one told you to watch her show or cook her food.... it's sad she has diabetes but its her business, everyone with a brain know eating unhealthy foods will have bad consequences. So she didn't run out and announce she had diabetes the minute she found out... is it really our business anyways? If you like her cooking good for you, if you dont like it good for you too, if you hate her good for you if you love her good for you. Its really none of our business what goes on in her personal life so we shouldn't be so mean about it.

    NOW I WELCOME ALL THE RUDE TURDS THAT WILL CALL ME NAMES FOR SAYING WHAT I HAVE SAID IN THIS POST... GO FOR IT I DON'T GIVE A FLYING FART K :)

    This is pretty much exactly how I feel. Yes, she is a public figure, but is it really anyones business outside of her family members?? Its comon sence to know that eating all the food she shows in her show, day in and day out, is NOT healthy for you. Will it 100% cause diabetes? Probably not 100% but theres a darn good chance of it! We as people have to take responcibility for ourselves, and not sit here, and say "Shes a horrible person for not coming out asap!" Though you've watched her for years on tv, shes not a relative, and its really none of your business.

    Now the fact that shes coming out due to the fact that she is the new face for a diabetes drug kinda puts a new spin on it though - Thoughts???
  • I think she epitomizes America: I'll eat whatever I want, have a sedentary lifestyle, get diagnosed w/ a disease caused by poor lifestyle, and take a pill to remedy the situation. Sadly, things are backwards. Instead of preventing disease in the first place, which would save a lot of money, we want the quick fix that ultimately has greater costs for individuals and society as a whole.
  • I like her personality so I was a bit surprised by her dishonesty. I saw her on Dr. Oz a few months back and he was asking to test her blood sugar because he was concerned about diabetes....she could have come clean then, but did not.

    *****But I still find her interesting and hope that she changes her lifestyle so she can live a long time.***** Sadly many people diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes do not; my Mom was diagnosed at age 69 and a co-worker at age 60, and watching them struggle with the disease is a real eye-opener for me. It's amazing to me how little my Mom, who was a nurse for over 40 years, know about food & how to eat healthy. I feel very bad for them but my Mom's diagnosis inspired me to lose 50 lbs so something good came of it!


    She could still do the same show she has done for years - High fat and sugar and all - And be healthy. Just because she takes a bite of the deep fried chocolate butter shes giving you a recipe for, doesn't mean that shes not eating a carrot between takes. Just a thought.
  • cheeksv
    cheeksv Posts: 521 Member
    Just becasue she has diabetes (to me) does not mean she only has to share recipes that help her condition. She could make some of her recipes healthier but, most of what she shares are family recipes or ones she has always made and I happen to love them. It is not who she is it is what she has. I just made a pumpkin loaf from a cook book of hers last night and made it healthier , it is individual choice of how we eat and what we eat. She has every right to do things her way and if anyone says " Paula Deen gave me diabetes" or " Caused me to be unhealthy" they are right up there with the people who say " Mc donalds made me fat"
  • mochaphobic
    mochaphobic Posts: 92 Member
    I am pre-diabetic and was really not surprised that she is diabetic. But what I wonder about is what changes has she made, besides not drinking sweet tea, to bring her bs numbers down into the safe range. I can almost understand why other chefs might be upset ~ she doesn't appear to have changed her cooking style at all. However, she has stated that people for years have asked for her to make healthier versions of her foods. I hope that this is the push she needs to do that. By the way, not coming out for a couple years isn't surprising to me either. People can be mad about it but it takes courage to admit that you aren't perfect, that you have an invisible disease. While it really isn't anyone's business but her own, I think that owning it publicly and withstanding the lashback from the announcement will only serve to make her a stronger and better person.
  • tialynn1
    tialynn1 Posts: 884 Member
    I believe really that it isn't anyones business people's health just because they are in the public eye. But, that saying, I wish she would make it a teaching moment on how to cook healthier.
    The way some people have reacted to this news, Paula Deen is NOT the reason why so many people are overweight in this country. She did not force you to cook everything she does the way she does it. There is ways to make things that she makes and make it heealthier such as when she fries something, bake instead.
    Type 2 is more common in adults. But, an adult still can develop type 1, because my Dad was diagnosed with type 1 when he was 24 years old. He died when I was 12 years old. But, I can still remember him being rushed to hospital for diabetic shock.
  • dovesgate
    dovesgate Posts: 894 Member
    I think it is asinine to expect anyone to share their medical history and/or treatment with the world. It is none of our collective business.

    Who knows, maybe she gets her insulin for free by being the spokesperson. If my husband could get his blood pressure medication for free by shilling for the company we'd be all over that, millions in the bank or not. It would still be no one else's business if my husband was attempting to fix his problem through diet and exercise or if he was relying on a pill.
  • Kelwalks4
    Kelwalks4 Posts: 56 Member
    The thing that concerns me is that she does NOT want to alter her diet, but would rather take a prescription. BTW, EVERY drug has side affects. This is a dangerous lifestyle choice. High blood pressure? Eat all the salt you want, just take a pill. Cholesterol too high? Eat what you want, sit on the couch and take a pill. It goes on and on.

    This story reminds me of a woman I met, dying of emphysema... on oxygen, and still smoking a pack a day. She had to remove the oxygen/nose apparatus because canned oxygen is flammable. It spoke to me how strong her addiction to nicotine was. Paula is obviously in denial that she has a problem, or just doesn't want to give it up. It is her choice, but a very unhealthy one.

    I hope her son's show is a hit and influences her to make changes.
  • StevLL
    StevLL Posts: 921 Member
    Really for those that slam her, why? My guess would be she couldn't come out because she had contracts with food companies that probably prohibited that for some term of her contract as it could prove detrimental to her power of endorsement. Hopefully if we are on here, we all are able to make the choice to eat super rich food all the time or not. Butter is not the enemy, neither is fat, neither is sugar, nor any other goodie she cooks with. The consistent consumption of uncensored quanities is what does us all in. (unless we have a genetic issue or a disease which contributes)

    Gotta tell ya her gooey butter cream cake is amazing, but I ate it once and that was all it took for me to go "good but worth 380 calories in my new lifestyle". Nope!

    Give her a break and hope she finds the same support and motivation to change like we have found. I would hope nobody would wish her ill, just because she is an incredible cook and celebrated Chef. Personally I prefer Guy Fiero and Bobby Flay as my guides and trust me their stuff is not much healthier.

    Hopefully I don't get too many haters, but whats happened to our society where we are so quick to diss on our fellow beings. Where's the love folks?

    I was diagnoised pre-diabetic jan 3rd last year 7.5AC1. Last month no longer and 5.0AC1 and I eat butter everyday, we gave up the fake stuff when we started getting healthy.
  • Kelwalks4
    Kelwalks4 Posts: 56 Member
    I wish Paula Deen all the best. I would keep my personal life to myself too.

    But, once SHE came out, she invited the public into her business. She got paid for it, and will deal with the consequences. I would rather she became open with it because of a sponsor opportunity then if someone else came out with it. If someone else had "outed" her, then I would be yelling to leave her the heck alone.
  • sunkisses
    sunkisses Posts: 2,365 Member
    Ask Paula Deen what she thinks about my thyroid condition. :wink:
  • christine24t
    christine24t Posts: 6,063 Member
    I understand it's her private health, but I think she should've came out with it sooner, and stressed how you can indulge every once in a while with one of her meals, but you should eat healthier.
  • brittanyjeanxo
    brittanyjeanxo Posts: 1,831 Member
    Seriously people, no one told you to watch her show or cook her food.... it's sad she has diabetes but its her business, everyone with a brain know eating unhealthy foods will have bad consequences. So she didn't run out and announce she had diabetes the minute she found out... is it really our business anyways? If you like her cooking good for you, if you dont like it good for you too, if you hate her good for you if you love her good for you. Its really none of our business what goes on in her personal life so we shouldn't be so mean about it.

    NOW I WELCOME ALL THE RUDE TURDS THAT WILL CALL ME NAMES FOR SAYING WHAT I HAVE SAID IN THIS POST... GO FOR IT I DON'T GIVE A FLYING FART K :)

    No one told you to reply to this thread, don't know why you're getting so butthurt about it.
  • Ask Paula Deen what she thinks about my thyroid condition. :wink:

    Why? Do you think she gave you a thyriod condition???
  • reneepugh
    reneepugh Posts: 522 Member
    I always thought paula deene was an asshat. I haven't changed my opinion - she's an asshat mother from a long line of asshats in asshat -ville . I don't like her, her food or one single thing she stands for
    Want my opinion of sarah palin?

    Hilarious!
  • I knew her food was clogging my arteries.... I could almost hear them slamming shut whenever I made something of hers.
  • sunkisses
    sunkisses Posts: 2,365 Member
    Ask Paula Deen what she thinks about my thyroid condition. :wink:

    Why? Do you think she gave you a thyriod condition???

    oh man...
  • Ask Paula Deen what she thinks about my thyroid condition. :wink:

    Why? Do you think she gave you a thyriod condition???

    oh man...


    Ok, so can you explain your comment... 'cause I'm just not gettin it.... :frown:
  • Aerohead21
    Aerohead21 Posts: 333 Member
    Not trying to ne rude here, but if people want to offer their opinions that ultimately are a judgement of someone or a disease/disorder they have, the least one could do is a little research on the disease/disorder first. Again, no offense, but some of he opinions on here prove just how close-minded and stereotypical people can be.

    Having grown up with diabetes in my family and having it gestationally myself, there is no one factor that causes or contributes to having or "getting" diabetes. Diet and exercise help, but it helps with many issues so to suggest her diet and exercise is the cause of her diabetes is absurd. Also, there are people with type II diabetes that have to take medicine because diet and exercise alone doesn't do enough so her promoting the use of medication doesn't mean she is copping out of changing her lifestyle. In addition, the food she promotes has nothing to do with the food you and I eat. What we choose to eat is a choice we make that ultimately is our responsibility. It is unfair to blame anyone for the decisions we make simply because they promoted it.
  • HeatherChapa
    HeatherChapa Posts: 15 Member
    People shouldn't be mad that's her life and she's older and she is over weight so it's going to happen and well most chefs are sometimes over weight. They do eat everything they cook so, It was bound to happen and besides at least she's trying to change her ways and knows that she is now. I saw it on the show last week I think it was. It happens to older people all the time, we all need to try hard to take care of our bodies & It is a hard process for anyone. Besides sometimes it runs in the family and their is nothing you can do. I know skinny people that have & their not just over weight.
  • I saw her interview with Al Roker on the Today Show. I do think she is being somewhat disingenuous. She kept repeating how she has never said that she eats that way every day but I think to the average food show viewer, they probably read her cookbooks like the Bible, faithfully trying out each recipe. I think she is backtracking and since she has known for 3 years of her condition, she had an obligation to lighten up her recipes for her viewers. It almost appears as though she purposely mislead people who were loyal to her way of cooking and deliberately kept them in the dark. I think there will be backlash to her brand over this.
  • HeatherChapa
    HeatherChapa Posts: 15 Member
    :)
  • brittanyjeanxo
    brittanyjeanxo Posts: 1,831 Member
    horse.jpg
  • MaryB2
    MaryB2 Posts: 331 Member
    Seriously people, no one told you to watch her show or cook her food.... it's sad she has diabetes but its her business, everyone with a brain know eating unhealthy foods will have bad consequences. So she didn't run out and announce she had diabetes the minute she found out... is it really our business anyways? If you like her cooking good for you, if you dont like it good for you too, if you hate her good for you if you love her good for you. Its really none of our business what goes on in her personal life so we shouldn't be so mean about it.

    NOW I WELCOME ALL THE RUDE TURDS THAT WILL CALL ME NAMES FOR SAYING WHAT I HAVE SAID IN THIS POST... GO FOR IT I DON'T GIVE A FLYING FART K :)

    No one told you to reply to this thread, don't know why you're getting so butthurt about it.

    This coming from someone that asked a question earlier then deleted the whole post when you didn't like the responses. Why did you get all butthurt about what people said? Currygirl had as much right to reply to this thread as anyone else.
  • noneya2010
    noneya2010 Posts: 446 Member
    question what type of diabetes does she have???


    Type 2. Adult onset. As far as I know, type 1 diabetes is congenital. You can't develop it later in life (correct me if I'm wrong).

    you can get type 1 any time. and type 1 is so not congenital

    its a autoimmune disease.


    Hmmm. I wonder why type 2 is referred to as "adult onset" diabetes? I knew type one was autoimmune, I just didn't realize you could get it as an adult. I think children are typically diagnosed with it more frequently than adults. Thanks, though, I did not know. :)

    Type 1 is an autoimmune disorder where the body does not make insulin. It is also referred to as juvenile diabetes. Back in the days, the average age of diagnosis was 30 whereas people had alot of damage at the time of diagnosis. With technology and education, people are diagnosed much, much younger. My son was diagnosed with Type 1 at 14 months of age -- just a baby! he was seen by some of the top pediatric endocrinologists in the country and at that time was one of the youngest patients his dr. had ever seen! Sadly, many babies are now being diagnosed.

    Diabetes Type II runs rampant in my family. My grandmother and 17 of her siblings were all diabetics!! Many of their offspring also have rampant Type I and Type II diabetes. My son has participated in several research studies through the years, as has my other child who is not a diabetic. Genetically, some are more prone to getting diabetes.

    Many Type II diabetics are being diagnosed due to diet/weight issues and in many cases it is reversable. My brother was a Type II and lost a lot of weight and is now not considered a Type II diabetic anymore.

    To say that Paula Dean is diabetic because of butter or her love of cooking is totally b.s. We dont' know her family history or background. Hopefully she will get it under control because diabetes is nothing to mess around with -- Type I or Type II.
This discussion has been closed.