too much protein??

LadyLoriAnn
LadyLoriAnn Posts: 41
edited November 9 in Success Stories
Ok, I have started the body by Vi 90 day challenge, (Im not selling anything) I needed to learn ealthier food choices, any way As you can see on my log, I log everything I conume, my log calls for me to have 1410 calories, I can barely get there truth is I havent hit 1000 yet this week however always go over in protein. Keep in mind I'm the woman who ate once a day right after work, usually mcdonalds! then sat on my couch eating ruffles, so Im not thinking my body can go into starvation mode lol Bottom line...is the extra protein hurting me? any elp is greatly appreciated! :)
«1

Replies

  • cmriverside
    cmriverside Posts: 34,454 Member
    You need to eat more.

    The protein setting here is low, by a lot of peoples' estimation.

    Use that protein setting as a MINIMUM. Not max.

    Eat more.
  • supersourbubble
    supersourbubble Posts: 103
    MFP has our protein set really low. you can customize it for how you'd like it. As long as you're pretty healthy overall and no kidney issues, i would say being over in protein is ok. I myself try to eat over 100g of protein a day, and stay below 149g on carbs.

    hope that helps!
  • Canadien
    Canadien Posts: 122 Member
    I'm no expert or anything, but I don't think it'll have any significant negative effect on your body. I go over my protein almost every single day (sometimes by a LOT) but that's actually my goal. Protein is the key to building muscle. :)
  • Blair66
    Blair66 Posts: 4
    my doctor said to track protein intake by meal. you dont want more than 24g of protein per meal. he said that our bodies can't process more than that...and any more would eventually hurt your kidneys.
  • rpantusa
    rpantusa Posts: 267 Member
    no MFP sets your protein intake kind of low anyways, I always go over on protein, and i am still loosing just fine. good luck on your journey! :wink:
  • George1567
    George1567 Posts: 107
    1 gram per pound of lean boady mass is very common. The MFP settings are based on the goverment standard, 2000 calorie diet 55% carbs, 15% protein, 30% fat. Many will say that 15% is too low for active/athletic lifestyles. Without a number I of how much your eating it is just a guess to say, but I doubt you are getting too much in 1000 calorie intake.
  • LadyLoriAnn
    LadyLoriAnn Posts: 41
    I really am eating, can you see my log? (not sure if you can) I have a health shake for 2 meals, yogurt or hard boiled egg for snacks and a good meal, trust me i have been sooo full! i do at least 10 sit ups, and walk with weights. this is a uge change for me!
  • DecemberNick
    DecemberNick Posts: 64 Member
    Having extra protein or fat or carbs isn't really bad of and by themselves. Your overall caloric intake versus how many calories you're burning will ultimately decide whether you'll be losing weight or not. That's the simplest way to look at it.

    Depending on your size, less than a 1000 calories a day is borderline unhealthy. Generally, going below 1200 calories a day is a bad idea and may not peel off the weight as fast if you ate a bit more and encouraged your metabolism to get out of starvation mode. It doesn't matter what you weigh, if you're not eating enough, your body will lock up the fat stores. Think of your metabolism like a candle. If you eat a lot, it's not worried about saving food, the candle burns bright. If you stop eating, it has no idea when the next meal will come, the candle barely lights the room. Like it or not, eating encourages your body to burn faster.
  • LadyLoriAnn
    LadyLoriAnn Posts: 41
    and as u can see the "H" on my keyboard sticks sorry, and thanks everyone for your replies!
  • AnarchoGen
    AnarchoGen Posts: 400 Member
    my doctor said to track protein intake by meal. you dont want more than 24g of protein per meal. he said that our bodies can't process more than that...and any more would eventually hurt your kidneys.

    Very interesting, I wonder if this goes the same for athletes who consume those 30g per serving protein shakes though :-/
  • LadyLoriAnn
    LadyLoriAnn Posts: 41
    im 48, 185.00 andd 5 7
  • dollipop
    dollipop Posts: 379 Member
    Your diary isn't public hun.
  • LadyLoriAnn
    LadyLoriAnn Posts: 41
    ty
  • cstein71
    cstein71 Posts: 38 Member
    my workout instructor told me today based on my excercize (5 days a week) I should be eating about 110 grams of protein for my weight (159). that seems like alot and mostly never could get there but I also am always over the MFP amount. 1000 calories is very low and you can put yourself in starvation mode where your body will burn muscle before fat. Not what you want.
  • AlsDonkBoxSquat
    AlsDonkBoxSquat Posts: 6,128 Member
    You're not eating enough calories, 1000 per day gross isn't enough especially if you're exercising, it just isn't. If you're having metabolism issues this is why. I aim for 140 g of protein on days when I don't exercise, today my adjusted protein was a little over 170. Also, just because you're brain says full doesn't mean your body is nourished or replenished, it may very well just mean that you trained yourself to under eat and think it's okay.

    Edit: I'm 34, 133.5 pounds.
  • jenlb99
    jenlb99 Posts: 213 Member
    I'm sure you CAN consume too much protein, but I assure you, you're not. Aim for over 100g; MFP's set number is WAY too low, in my opinion.
  • FitLink
    FitLink Posts: 1,317 Member
    Ok, I have started the body by Vi 90 day challenge, (Im not selling anything) I needed to learn ealthier food choices, any way As you can see on my log, I log everything I conume, my log calls for me to have 1410 calories, I can barely get there truth is I havent hit 1000 yet this week however always go over in protein. Keep in mind I'm the woman who ate once a day right after work, usually mcdonalds! then sat on my couch eating ruffles, so Im not thinking my body can go into starvation mode lol Bottom line...is the extra protein hurting me? any elp is greatly appreciated! :)

    Upon what do you base the idea that your body "can't" go into starvation mode? That you ate badly before? Because that just makes it MORE likely. If you're eating less than 1000 calories a day consistently, that's exactly what is happening. I wouldn't worry about the extra protein--my doctor adamantly insists I need more protein than MFP defaults to--I simply manually adjusted the percentages to the ones she prefers, which increased the protein and decreased the carbohydrates by a bit.
  • RogerF765
    RogerF765 Posts: 113
    I found this info on the bodybuilding.com website for how much protien you should be eating. Maybe it will help.

    Lifestyle/Training Goal Daily Protein Needs

    Bodybuilding 1.0 - 1.6g/lb bodyweight
    Endurance 0.7 - 0.9g/lb bodyweight
    Power & Speed 0.9 - 1.1g/lb bodyweight
    Trauma Recovery 0.9 - 1.4g/lb bodyweight
    Dieting 0.35 - 1.0g/lb bodyweight
    Stressed 0.45 - 0.7g/lb bodyweight

    http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/bbprotein.htm
  • r1ghtpath
    r1ghtpath Posts: 701 Member
    may i ask, how do you get that much protein? the 140-170g? i'm supposed to be up there too, and i just cannot do it. i would love some advice or examples if you don't mind sharing!!!
    thanks!

    You're not eating enough calories, 1000 per day gross isn't enough especially if you're exercising, it just isn't. If you're having metabolism issues this is why. I aim for 140 g of protein on days when I don't exercise, today my adjusted protein was a little over 170. Also, just because you're brain says full doesn't mean your body is nourished or replenished, it may very well just mean that you trained yourself to under eat and think it's okay.

    Edit: I'm 34, 133.5 pounds.
  • LadyLoriAnn
    LadyLoriAnn Posts: 41
    Well I did base it on eating badly before, looks like i get another snack of yogurt! ty
  • RogerF765
    RogerF765 Posts: 113
    I eat a lot of tofu based stuff and a lot of nuts. Pumkin seeds are really high in protien, 15g per 1/4 cup but they are also high in calories too. I'm always over my MFP protien goal but nowhere near where the protien calculator I linked to says I should be at so I just try to get around 25g every meal.
  • Blair66
    Blair66 Posts: 4
    yeah, i was wondering that myself. it makes since that you would need more if you work out a lot.
  • bigbeardiver
    bigbeardiver Posts: 154 Member
    I believe the calculators are based on LEAN body weight as well not your total body weight. The average is 1.0-1.5 g/per lb for muscle building. I'm 245 but 170 Lean, yes 65 lbs of fat! So my target would be 170-255 grams per day. Roughly divided by 5 meals a day so 34-55 per meal.
  • ppaz512
    ppaz512 Posts: 5
    Too much protein does turn into fat if you arn't exercing. My sister has lost 19 lbs on the challenge since new years this year! Good luck!
  • tgzerozone
    tgzerozone Posts: 160
    may i ask, how do you get that much protein? the 140-170g? i'm supposed to be up there too, and i just cannot do it. i would love some advice or examples if you don't mind sharing!!!
    thanks!

    Try using a whey protein supplement if you cannot eat that much. Remember to just see it as a supplement though, real food is best. I am on bulking regime eating 3500 to 4000 calories a day with about 350 - 400 g of protein. Not easy without supplements.

    I eat 40/40/10 of Protein, carbs, fat.
  • hedgiie
    hedgiie Posts: 1,226 Member
    You need to eat more.

    The protein setting here is low, by a lot of peoples' estimation.

    Use that protein setting as a MINIMUM. Not max.

    Eat more.
    exactly, mine is about 70g but actually consuming up to 200g but that's all good
  • srhula
    srhula Posts: 25 Member
    I have had gastric bypass and am required to eat at least 85 g of protein a day. My doctor said that our bodies can only process around 26g at a time and anything over that is just disposed of by the body. You aren't eating enough calories though, especially if you are working out. I'd shoot for at least 1200 a day.
  • 2012asv
    2012asv Posts: 702 Member
    Having extra protein or fat or carbs isn't really bad of and by themselves. Your overall caloric intake versus how many calories you're burning will ultimately decide whether you'll be losing weight or not. That's the simplest way to look at it.

    Depending on your size, less than a 1000 calories a day is borderline unhealthy. Generally, going below 1200 calories a day is a bad idea and may not peel off the weight as fast if you ate a bit more and encouraged your metabolism to get out of starvation mode. It doesn't matter what you weigh, if you're not eating enough, your body will lock up the fat stores. Think of your metabolism like a candle. If you eat a lot, it's not worried about saving food, the candle burns bright. If you stop eating, it has no idea when the next meal will come, the candle barely lights the room. Like it or not, eating encourages your body to burn faster.

    Thank you, that is VERY helpful.
  • tmlandis
    tmlandis Posts: 39 Member
    Yep, what they all said. I try to do about 20g per meal, 5-6 times a day. I'm about your same size. I started a year ago with the Body for Life program. If you are exercising a lot you need the protein to help rebuild your muscles. That being said, you can customize your MFP so that it won't go into the red. I set mine on 30% protein.
  • midwifekelley2350
    midwifekelley2350 Posts: 337 Member
    my doctor said to track protein intake by meal. you dont want more than 24g of protein per meal. he said that our bodies can't process more than that...and any more would eventually hurt your kidneys.

    Very interesting, I wonder if this goes the same for athletes who consume those 30g per serving protein shakes though :-/

    this info is pretty dated
This discussion has been closed.

Categories

Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!