We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Opinion on elliptical trainers?

mistercarbon
mistercarbon Posts: 2
edited November 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
I hear a lot of contradicting opinions on ellipticals... I have a hard time working out and so far the elliptical is the only thing working form me! What are your opinions, though? I am very new to working out.

Replies

  • Kim28dav
    Kim28dav Posts: 50
    I like them but they bother my back a little so I started using the Arc Trainer which is simliar but works your legs in a different motion and doesn't seem to bother my back. And I sweat alot and burn a lot more calories. I would do what works for you tho.
  • brandyosu
    brandyosu Posts: 257 Member
    I don't have a scientific or experienced opinion, but I say keep doing whatever it is that is going to get you up and moving. Doing something is better than doing nothing!

    From a personal perspective, I'm trying to start running but right now it hurts my knees and back too much. But I can do the elliptical just fine - I do it for an hour and I can guarantee that I definitely work up a sweat! I'm hoping that once I've lost a little more and strengthened up the muscles in my legs/back and especially around my knees that I can run pain free (I'm also strength training to accomplish that goal).
  • Kempossible
    Kempossible Posts: 158 Member
    I actually went to an exercise physiologist today. I asked her what she considered one of the best machines in the gym for cardio. She said the ellipitical machine. I personally prefer the treadclimber before meeting with her. But now I will be using the ellipitical.

    Good luck on your weight loss journey!
  • arc918
    arc918 Posts: 2,037 Member
    I think it is really easy to go through the motions on it and not get a good workout.

    If you set the resistance high and steep, and really work hard you can get a good workout.
  • Whodatgirl77
    Whodatgirl77 Posts: 238 Member
    Personally I just find them to be incredibly boring. My preference is to be outside but I know that's tough at times for those in colder climates.
  • thefuzz1290
    thefuzz1290 Posts: 777 Member
    They're a little easier on my shins, feet, and knees. I'm a heavy runner (working on it) and it puts a lot of stress on my body. Like one other poster stated, if you work hard and up the resistance, you can get a good workout.
  • Trophyyf
    Trophyyf Posts: 218 Member
    I la la love the elliptical if it was a man I would be having a affair!! I bought one because it is the one machine I love so much!! I can burn 100 calories in 5mins running and the highest resistance at a incline. It can make a short workout a good work out.
  • t_rog
    t_rog Posts: 363 Member
    i LOVE it! it's what i work out on 90% of the time. easy on the body, and i can burn 600 calories/hour on it.
  • kp1439
    kp1439 Posts: 343 Member
    that is what i have so that pretty much only thing for me besides running and walking. before when i was over weight it was very hard for me to use it but since i been walking and running and eating healthy its much better. quit smoking helped me a lot also. so all i will say is good luck and you can do it . lets get healthy.
  • aippolito1
    aippolito1 Posts: 4,894 Member
    It's great for beginners ... I had to move on to a similar type of machine, but the cross ramp has a different angle and the resistance works better for multiple parts of my legs, so I find it better than the elliptical - for me. I started with the elliptical, but I've gotten to the point where 5 minutes on it and my feet are numb and then hurting, so I can't even physically be on one.

    I say it's great... go fast with low resistance, or go moderately fast with a little bit of resistance to really get a good burn. Try backwards as well. Works different muscles!
  • ChrisStoney
    ChrisStoney Posts: 479 Member
    I lost about 50 pounds doing treadmill only.. I have recently tried the elliptical and love it. A good machine- gym quality is over $2000 reconditioned and about $5000 brand new.. I know because I wanted to buy one for my garage- the same as the gym has... I guess I will pay $14/month and go to the gym, LOL

    I like it because it moves to work different areas of your legs and arms, my pulse stays up around 150, it is non-impact, yet challenging, I am a good daydreamer, so I don't think it is boring. I had tried a cheaper model prior, and hated it. I use row machine, treadmill and the elliptical for cardio now.
  • VinaAnderson
    VinaAnderson Posts: 104
    The elliptical works for me. I raise the incline and tension throughout my workout, switch from forward to backward motions and I never use the hand rails. I let me legs do all the work. After an hour I'm sweating like crazy. Some people prefer it over treadmills or running because it's low impact. I am currently focusing on jogging so I miss the elliptical sometimes because running sucks.
  • jadedone
    jadedone Posts: 2,446 Member
    I like them but they bother my back a little so I started using the Arc Trainer which is simliar but works your legs in a different motion and doesn't seem to bother my back. And I sweat alot and burn a lot more calories. I would do what works for you tho.

    Love the arctrainer. Wish my gym had one. :(
  • msthing21777
    msthing21777 Posts: 1
    I do those same machines. How much on each of them do you go for?
This discussion has been closed.

Categories