We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Is weight just a number?

rkwestfall
rkwestfall Posts: 37 Member
edited September 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
Ok so I have to admit that I didnt sick to my diet this past weekend. I had some adult beverages...so maybe im wondering if it is water weight?

But all in all I feel lighter and smaller around the waist but my scale says I have a gained a few lbs!!!:explode:

I am wondering if I should stop weighing myself, but I cant!! Im a total almost daily weigher...

Any advice?
And I might change my weigh in days to a wed or fri cuz... weighing in on a mon after the weekend is not making me very encouraged!:sad:

Thanx!

Replies

  • BrenNew
    BrenNew Posts: 3,420 Member
    I fully believe in weighing in only once a week. But, you'll find plenty of people at MFP who believe otherwise. Guess it'll have to be YOUR choice in the long run! :smile:
  • Simplicity
    Simplicity Posts: 383 Member
    weight is such a number.
    if i have had a bad day i don;t weigh myself the next day to save getting annoyed at the scales. if i have a good day i get on and off them all day till i dissapear its like countdown.
    when i drink (booze), the next day i am instantly pounds lighter thanks to good old dehydration.
    but you can drink and drink and drink (water) and put on weight even though it is all water.

    i weight myself now everyday
    then i wrote my self a little program that i use to monitor weight on the pc that automatically adds up each weight from the day and divides it by 7 for my weekly aerage that way i know if its beer or if its food or whatever it is i know if i have had a good week or bad.

    my weight can fluctuate 2 -3 pounds a day and even more if alcohol is involved. i aim for when i wak but working shifts it hard. especially when your goals are in sight this really thrws it around.

    my best and i think honest figures come when i haven;t had a sinlgle alcoholic drink and i have followed the diet strictly for two days and my last meal was finished at 6pm the night before i weight in. no doubt then i will see good results its just hard to put it all in to practise all the time.
    Ben
    man what a load of rambling lol
  • rkwestfall
    rkwestfall Posts: 37 Member
    Thanks Ben!

    I totally hear what ur saying!

    I guess its just disappointing to watch my ticker go back to 0 lbs lost!:ohwell:
  • dbg1
    dbg1 Posts: 208
    Daily can be rewarding and sad. A girlfriend of mine got very frustrated doing the daily weigh in thing. I asked what her goal was - lose 2lbs a week. SO I told her to weigh her self friday am - before any weekend damage could be done. It worked for her.

    I also agree with Benjamumover. Until you rehyrate you will feel lighter. :drinker: If you know you were bad, then expect alot more weight. Say 10lbs. Then you won't feel so bad when you see the damage.

    Also, I weigh myself at the gym - shoes and all. THis way I know I am actually lighter naked - and that makes me feel even better. Its all mental. Just know you WILL MAKE IT!:happy:
  • jljohnson
    jljohnson Posts: 719 Member
    Your exercise can also impact this. I went for MONTHS without losing a single pound, and even fluctuating up a little on some days. However, I also took measurements, and noticed that by adding some strength training, I still lost inches, and actually went down another size. Weight really is just a number, and it's really size and body fat % that count, at least in my book.
  • Simplicity
    Simplicity Posts: 383 Member
    Thanks Ben!

    I totally hear what ur saying!

    I guess its just disappointing to watch my ticker go back to 0 lbs lost!:ohwell:

    tell me about it i keep wanting to post on here that im down to my last ten pounds then i go out for the night and it all seems a week away again. it ahs put me off booze this website. i stop having one or two during the week now. and weekedns have been all about the kareoke instead of all about the porcelain. i drink subrounds of coke and water now but i still feel the enjoyment. you can;t quit everything that would be well miserable innit!
  • i used to be a daily weigher. then i decided to get rid of the scale. so now i can only weigh myself once a week when we go to my father-in-laws house for dinner. i know it's not the "ideal time" to weigh yourself, but it at least gives me some kinda idea at how i'm doing.
  • Jennplus2
    Jennplus2 Posts: 984 Member
    When I weigh myself everyday it helps me get the average. I can change up to 4 lbs in a week! So for the people who only weigh once a week, make sure it is on a light day, lol. For me the light day is Thursday. I workout all week and eat right, but Monday OMG I want to throw the scale out the window! The weekend is a hole of fun but bad food choices for me. Vaca next week-AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH that is like ten days of weekend! I will be bringing my DVD's and walking everyday (I hope :embarassed:)
  • fm1304
    fm1304 Posts: 31 Member
    someone please help us all scale addicts.. its like a compulsive disorder!! :sad:

    i've tried to limit myself too.. strange part is.. even when ive gained a few pounds.. my clothes dont fit all that bad.. i mean i can feel the difference but its not THAT bad.. and then i get on the scale.. and its the worst thing i can do.. demotivates the hell out of me..

    and the funniest? i dont feel 'really' bad.. i mean its far worse after i know my weight..

    am i making any sense? :cry:
  • I have had this same question. I have been eating clean and working out HARD for 3 weeks now. The scale had shown no changes, and I was so frustrated. I felt smaller. I felt more toned. My pants were getting baggy. Even the measurements I took were showing some small losses (but small!) But I just knew the composition of my body was changing. Instead of feeling flab under my skin, I was feeling nice hard muscles.

    This week I found my answer. I went to a gathering where I saw all of my coworkers after being on Summer Vacation for a month and MANY approached me and wanted to know what I had been doing because I looked so great. They really noticed my shrinking and toned body and one even said that I was her inspiratoin !:happy: Then today I weighed in and I am down 3 pounds from last week, and my measurements really shrunk!

    My advice for you is to just be patient! Keep doing what you are doing. It is working! It took me 4 weeks before I saw numeric results. But all this time, my body has been changing dramatically, and I am feeling healthier and stronger than ever. Just give it time!
  • jljohnson
    jljohnson Posts: 719 Member
    Also, I'm a daily weigher too. I feel like I have a better grip on things that way. I also don't let a pound or 2 or 3 bug me, unless they stick around for more than a few days.
  • photoman67
    photoman67 Posts: 116 Member
    I like to weigh in everyday also. That way, if I gain, I know not to do what I did the day before. Does that make sense?
  • 2catowner
    2catowner Posts: 94
    Ok so I have to admit that I didnt sick to my diet this past weekend. I had some adult beverages...so maybe im wondering if it is water weight?

    But all in all I feel lighter and smaller around the waist but my scale says I have a gained a few lbs!!!:explode:

    I am wondering if I should stop weighing myself, but I cant!! Im a total almost daily weigher...

    Any advice?
    And I might change my weigh in days to a wed or fri cuz... weighing in on a mon after the weekend is not making me very encouraged!:sad:

    Thanx!

    I know how you feel, I tend to over indulge in these type beverages on the weekend as well.... I have switched to weighing on Fridays -- HOWEVER, I am getting ready to go on vacation this week and I am sure the diet will be blown to bits after this vacation.... sigh.... I think the idea you had of weighing on Wed and Fri sounds reasonable. I think after adult beverages I tend to retain water weight also!!
  • rkwestfall
    rkwestfall Posts: 37 Member
    Thank you for all of your inputs....I feel better that Im not the only one!! lol.

    I am switch my weigh in days to Fri am! and i need to really do my measurements asap!

    I am doing more weight training this time around so i really should me documenting my measurements!

    :flowerforyou:
This discussion has been closed.