We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Are you Big Boned Or Overweight

Liseii01
Liseii01 Posts: 20 Member
edited November 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
So seriously?

How can you tell if you're "big boned" or "overweight" I can do the finger (or measuring tape) around the wrist measurement, but won't my wrist size change as I lose weight?
«1

Replies

  • dreamy885
    dreamy885 Posts: 18
    More importantly, has anyone ever seen a fat skeleton??
  • hapoo100
    hapoo100 Posts: 926 Member
    I just read this. Overweight tends to create big bones.

    http://sciencebasedlife.wordpress.com/2011/03/23/are-the-overweight-really-big-boned/
  • Liseii01
    Liseii01 Posts: 20 Member
    no, but I'd be interested in seeing that, also if you have a bridge I can buy let me know =)
  • chicky89
    chicky89 Posts: 254 Member
    Ive always thought I was big boned.... but possibly because I always thought I could never be thin, so "i must be big boned"
  • junyr
    junyr Posts: 416 Member
    Bones don't jiggle.
  • EatClenTrenHard
    EatClenTrenHard Posts: 339 Member
    hhKKy.jpg
  • GinaJDarling
    GinaJDarling Posts: 16 Member
    More importantly, has anyone ever seen a fat skeleton??

    Very True!! Your bones can be larger than others but large bones will not give you a double chin, stomach rolls, or a muffin top lol I am over weight along with big bones, My hands are huge and long like a mans and so are my feet and I also have big features but I also know I need to loose more weight!
  • GinaJDarling
    GinaJDarling Posts: 16 Member
    hhKKy.jpg
    Perfect example!
  • Aerohead21
    Aerohead21 Posts: 333 Member
    I don't think the weight has much if anything due to bone size. I do think people of the very same height ca vary in musculature and bone length. It may be that you carry muscle differently than others. For example I have two brothers: one is stocky and heavy in the shoulders and chest. The other is lean and long like a runner's build. The way their bodies put on muscle was different.

    Just my speculation, anyway. I don't actually know for sure.
  • tmassy
    tmassy Posts: 21
    More importantly, has anyone ever seen a fat skeleton??

    hehehe^^^^
  • lovinmysoldier
    lovinmysoldier Posts: 156 Member
    You can measure the width of you elbow. That's supposed to tell you if you have a small, medium or large frame. You'll have to look up the actual measurements for which is which.
  • dreamy885
    dreamy885 Posts: 18
    "The initial findings of this study show that having big bones does not make you fat, being fat gives you big bones."

    ^from that website posted, in case anyone didn't check it out.
  • Sapporo
    Sapporo Posts: 693 Member
    Yeah... I'm big boned, like Cartman! :)
  • Aerohead21
    Aerohead21 Posts: 333 Member
    And fat too :) I wasn't going there but since someone put the xray pics up :) It explains my big booty and my friend's larger chest :)
  • RonSwanson66
    RonSwanson66 Posts: 1,150 Member
    Bones don't jiggle.
  • Blessedmommy_2x
    Blessedmommy_2x Posts: 419 Member
    More importantly, has anyone ever seen a fat skeleton??

    TRUE!
  • lovinmysoldier
    lovinmysoldier Posts: 156 Member
    hhKKy.jpg

    Very interesting. Point made but will say that the left is male, right is female. Notice how compressed her diaphragm is, granted his is a closer X-ray but you can definitely tell that his lungs have do much more room!
  • djkshdfd
    djkshdfd Posts: 443 Member
    You can have a larger frame which you can find out by measuring your elbow width. Google it.

    But you can get pretty thin with a large frame. I am a larger frame, at the low end of my BMI and I still need to lose. So I don't think larger frames are a good reason to be overweight.
  • CoderGal
    CoderGal Posts: 6,800 Member
    My doctor told me I had big bones (he seemed to be surprised and impressed by this). I was 90 pounds at the time. I laugh when people say they're not over weight, they just have big bones.
  • PammyKY
    PammyKY Posts: 129
    In my opinion there is no such thing as being big boned. Yeah everyone kept telling me that is why I was built the way I was. Let's be honest I am not big boned I am just simply overweight. I guess they were trying to make excuses for me but as they say on the Biggest Loser this is a year of NO EXCUSES.
  • LaMujerMasBonitaDelMundo
    LaMujerMasBonitaDelMundo Posts: 3,634 Member
    That's just one of the many excuses of some overweight people (I was also guilty of this before) & even if your bones are "big" it will only be slightly bigger & there won't be much difference on the weight. I read somewhere that our bones only weigh 2kgs. & if you're larger framed, its just a slight 5-6 lbs. heavier.

    First I thought I was big boned but when I was measured at the gym, they told me I'm only a medium framed based on many factors. One thing they did, they instructed me to wrap my wrist with my thumb & middle finger & my fingers just touched. On the finger test, if your thumb overlaps your middle finger then you are small boned, if it touch then you are medium boned & when fingers do not touch then you're large framed or "big boned". However being like that isn't an excuse for being overweight.
  • bobie1978
    bobie1978 Posts: 204 Member
    hmmmm you can have a big bones I'm short 5ft 2 and do have big bones for my height.. (of course i'm overweight at the moment) But when I was at my smallest.. still had a big bones (110lbs) Which is a healthy weight for my height.
  • SMoRZ3
    SMoRZ3 Posts: 6 Member
    I'm husky, or at least thats what my pants say! ;)
  • KeriA
    KeriA Posts: 3,367 Member
    I am small boned, and know it.
  • joybell32
    joybell32 Posts: 252 Member
    im gonna have to say both! :grumble:
  • pornstarzombie
    pornstarzombie Posts: 297
    I don't care what someone wants to tell me, but when my wrist measurements are almost 8" [and there is NO FAT on my wrist, as I am not overweight and have "bony" wrists] and my elbow width is what it is...I have a large frame. Notice I'm not saying "big boned" and using it just as an excuse to be overweight. I'm also 6', however my friend who is 6' has a very small frame, her wrist only measures 6" and I forgot what her elbow width was but it was smaller than mine.
  • hapoo100
    hapoo100 Posts: 926 Member
    I'm husky, or at least thats what my pants say! ;)

    HAHA as a kid I had husky pants and I thought it meant tough like the dog. Then I got older and realized what meant...wasnt a good day
  • jworb
    jworb Posts: 146 Member
    you can use this site to calculate your frame size... it's helpful, since I've always thought I had a large frame but according to this I have a medium frame, so now I may change up my weight goals.

    http://www.healthstatus.com/calculate/fsz

    good luck!
  • Bikini27
    Bikini27 Posts: 1,290 Member
    I always thought I was big boned because that's what they call big girls. Now that I'm losing weight, my wrists are tiny and dainty. Turns out I was just fat.

    Big boned, sadly, is just another way of saying big. :/
  • Allic1971
    Allic1971 Posts: 145 Member
    looking at frame size, I have a large frame.... which is true, when I was 16 my friend and I used to be in the same size clothes uk12 but I weighed 28lbs more than her, and from the photo's we look the same.....
This discussion has been closed.

Categories