Am I skinny fat?

2»

Replies

  • miss_missa07
    miss_missa07 Posts: 170
    AHHHH I love skinny fat people! My buddy Josh is "skinny fat" and I keep telling him to get off his butt and lift weights, strength train, etc. He keeps telling me he's just so thin and I'm like, "Yeah.... but you're skinny fat, Bromigo." He's pudgy for a tiny dude. So yeah, it happens.

    Hahaha, Bromigo. Best ever.
  • DaniJeanine
    DaniJeanine Posts: 473 Member
    Sigh. I think all of us skinny girls who aren't hard as a rock feel "skinny fat" from time to time. In reality, I think there's a lot of factors that come into play. First of all--you could just have some loose skin from prior weight loss or pregnancy that keeps the skin from looking tight. Me for example--my stomach is as tight as it's gonna get without a cosmetic procedure because I have some loose skin from the weight loss.
    Also, like everyone is saying--weights make a huge impact on looking tight, not just skinny. I'd recommend doing a full body circuit twice a week *in addition* to your cardio routine. Cardio is not just for weigh loss....it's extremely good for your heart and overall health. Everyone should do cardio...no matter how much they weigh
  • christibam
    christibam Posts: 478 Member


    Hahaha, Bromigo. Best ever.

    Bromigo, Broseph, Brotatoe, Dudebro, Brochick, etc. I love bromantically derived browords lmao
  • dmpizza
    dmpizza Posts: 3,321 Member
    Its muscle that is missing.
  • ssforcey
    ssforcey Posts: 92 Member
    What she said.


    Edited to say - I would STOP all cardio immediately (you don't need to lose any weight) and start a heavy lifting program 3-4 times a week.
  • ChitownFoodie
    ChitownFoodie Posts: 1,562 Member
    I am personally skinny fat. I weigh 95 pounds but I jiggle. When I weighed 102, I was toned and nothing jiggled, even the little squish on my tummy didn't move much. So it's an unfortunate truth that the scale doesn't really matter.
  • andrejjorje
    andrejjorje Posts: 497 Member
    No way to know exactly without pictures and BF measurements taken correctly.
  • megjeg
    megjeg Posts: 18
    I would say that first muscle weighs more than fat so if they look more lean its becuase they have more muscle and thats why they weigh more. I saw on the Drs that there are women who eat really bad and don't exercise and thier bodies make them think they are fat but they are physically skinny. And there was a women who is bigger. and she is in awesome physical shpe. So I guess im going to guess and say yes you may be.. but hey your working out now so good luck ;)

    Hmm.. Makes sense.. And unfortunately sounds like me prior to the last months. I really didn't take care of my body and used to get into starving- binging cycles, so I can understand why I'm in this strange situation.
  • gleechick609
    gleechick609 Posts: 544 Member
    start lifting weights, heavy weights. "New rules of lifting for women" google it... buy the book!

    I second this!
  • megjeg
    megjeg Posts: 18

    Edit: I want to follow the mantra: Skinny girls look good in clothes; fit girls look good naked

    Love it! Also, hopefully, in bikinis :)
  • megjeg
    megjeg Posts: 18
    Sigh. I think all of us skinny girls who aren't hard as a rock feel "skinny fat" from time to time. In reality, I think there's a lot of factors that come into play. First of all--you could just have some loose skin from prior weight loss or pregnancy that keeps the skin from looking tight. Me for example--my stomach is as tight as it's gonna get without a cosmetic procedure because I have some loose skin from the weight loss.
    Also, like everyone is saying--weights make a huge impact on looking tight, not just skinny. I'd recommend doing a full body circuit twice a week *in addition* to your cardio routine. Cardio is not just for weigh loss....it's extremely good for your heart and overall health. Everyone should do cardio...no matter how much they weigh

    I don't think that's the case with me, since my highest weight was 112 lbs. I only wanted to lose weight since I was under the misconception that weighing less would equate to me being less wobbly, but as I've now found, that's far from true. Will keep up some cardio, but am definitely going to look into lifting.
  • _Bob_
    _Bob_ Posts: 1,487 Member
    My wife was the same, started at a size 5 at 110 and out of shape. After some weight training and lots of dedication she just bought some size 3 jeans and loves her new shape. again she has always been a smaller girl so her journey was just about getting in shape and being stronger. but she's a little more curvy now too with the added muscle weight, she's up to 120.
  • nutandbutter
    nutandbutter Posts: 447
    Concentrate on compound lifts (squat, deadlift, bench press, overhead press, rows, and lat pulldow/pullups), heavy enough you can only do 8-10 reps, 3 sets. Several really good routines: Starting Strength, Stronglifts 5x5, New Rules of Lifting. This is a good link to see body fat percentages (at the end, she shows muscular vs skinny fat):
    http://www.leighpeele.com/body-fat-pictures-and-percentages
  • DaniJeanine
    DaniJeanine Posts: 473 Member
    Sigh. I think all of us skinny girls who aren't hard as a rock feel "skinny fat" from time to time. In reality, I think there's a lot of factors that come into play. First of all--you could just have some loose skin from prior weight loss or pregnancy that keeps the skin from looking tight. Me for example--my stomach is as tight as it's gonna get without a cosmetic procedure because I have some loose skin from the weight loss.
    Also, like everyone is saying--weights make a huge impact on looking tight, not just skinny. I'd recommend doing a full body circuit twice a week *in addition* to your cardio routine. Cardio is not just for weigh loss....it's extremely good for your heart and overall health. Everyone should do cardio...no matter how much they weigh

    I don't think that's the case with me, since my highest weight was 112 lbs. I only wanted to lose weight since I was under the misconception that weighing less would equate to me being less wobbly, but as I've now found, that's far from true. Will keep up some cardio, but am definitely going to look into lifting.

    Ohhhh I see. Sounds like you just need to tone up then...maybe consider a personal trainer once a week for a little while. I did that for 3 months once and not only did I get into great shape, but I had a whole slew of weight training exercises that I still use. I also know that CrossFit is the ultimate weight lifting program, but it's intense to say the least
  • shells2963
    shells2963 Posts: 35 Member
    My only response to heavy lifting.... is don't go too heavy because once you stop and you will stop that muscle will go to fat. I am speaking from experience. A good balance of weights and cardio is great. Doing something to the Curves circuit and working the machines hard and fast every other day will build the muscles and help to get you a leaner, more fit look. Don't forget to stretch when you are done exercising because that will help elongate your muscles and keep them more pliable.:wink:
  • kmorris246
    kmorris246 Posts: 312 Member
    So haopy to wear everyone mentioning "The New Rules of Lifting for Women"! I just downloaded this to my Kindle this morning. Now, to follow this program- do you need a gym membership? If not, what kind of equipment do you need for home workouts?
  • megjeg
    megjeg Posts: 18
    Concentrate on compound lifts (squat, deadlift, bench press, overhead press, rows, and lat pulldow/pullups), heavy enough you can only do 8-10 reps, 3 sets. Several really good routines: Starting Strength, Stronglifts 5x5, New Rules of Lifting. This is a good link to see body fat percentages (at the end, she shows muscular vs skinny fat):
    http://www.leighpeele.com/body-fat-pictures-and-percentages

    Brilliant link!
  • megjeg
    megjeg Posts: 18
    Sigh. I think all of us skinny girls who aren't hard as a rock feel "skinny fat" from time to time. In reality, I think there's a lot of factors that come into play. First of all--you could just have some loose skin from prior weight loss or pregnancy that keeps the skin from looking tight. Me for example--my stomach is as tight as it's gonna get without a cosmetic procedure because I have some loose skin from the weight loss.
    Also, like everyone is saying--weights make a huge impact on looking tight, not just skinny. I'd recommend doing a full body circuit twice a week *in addition* to your cardio routine. Cardio is not just for weigh loss....it's extremely good for your heart and overall health. Everyone should do cardio...no matter how much they weigh

    I don't think that's the case with me, since my highest weight was 112 lbs. I only wanted to lose weight since I was under the misconception that weighing less would equate to me being less wobbly, but as I've now found, that's far from true. Will keep up some cardio, but am definitely going to look into lifting.

    Ohhhh I see. Sounds like you just need to tone up then...maybe consider a personal trainer once a week for a little while. I did that for 3 months once and not only did I get into great shape, but I had a whole slew of weight training exercises that I still use. I also know that CrossFit is the ultimate weight lifting program, but it's intense to say the least

    Thanks for the advice :).. Will check it out!
  • megjeg
    megjeg Posts: 18
    So haopy to wear everyone mentioning "The New Rules of Lifting for Women"! I just downloaded this to my Kindle this morning. Now, to follow this program- do you need a gym membership? If not, what kind of equipment do you need for home workouts?

    I'm totally getting this!
  • Smuterella
    Smuterella Posts: 1,623 Member
    My only response to heavy lifting.... is don't go too heavy because once you stop and you will stop that muscle will go to fat. I am speaking from experience. A good balance of weights and cardio is great. Doing something to the Curves circuit and working the machines hard and fast every other day will build the muscles and help to get you a leaner, more fit look. Don't forget to stretch when you are done exercising because that will help elongate your muscles and keep them more pliable.:wink:

    what a load of nonsense - firstly - not everyone will stop - your experience is not other people's experience - and secondly you cannot elongate muscles - you can only make them bigger or smaller.
  • rjbrowne
    rjbrowne Posts: 28
    I know the feeling! I'm 5'2", 100lbs. At around 105, I was bony and uncomfortable. I started doing Jillian Michaels and Jackie dvds and put my calories to maintenance. I did lose a little more weight, but I'm solid and not bony like before. I'm toned and feel a lot better in my body. That's what worked for me. I'm tempted to start lifting more, but for right now, this has given me the results I'm looking for. Best of luck!
  • mes1119
    mes1119 Posts: 1,082 Member
    Sounds like it. I'm 5'3" but 30 pounds heavier and I wear a size 2 (0 on good days). Granted I'm built for a girl my size so I'm the opposite of your problem. Back when I was 17 I lost about 30 pounds and got down to 105. I had to wear children's clothing because I was so small-MOSTLY because I was a swimmer, so I was very bulky. Muscle is awesome. I have to reevaluate my goal weight because I would lose all of my muscle and have 0% body fat to be as skinny as you
This discussion has been closed.

Categories