Strength training for women help
elviraluvzu
Posts: 33 Member
Ok, so before i would breastfeed (partially) for about 4-5times a day so of course i was told that my food intake was suppose to be 2000-2400. Of course i would eat the proper nutrition for me and my baby. Funny thing is that i would strength train 3 days a week for 20min, and the other 3 days a week intervals for 20min. If i had the time, i would take a good brisk walk at the park or dance till id sweat for like 30min. Ok, so about 2 weeks ago i went to the doc for a normal checkup, I couldn't believe that I WEIGHED THE SAME since i gave birth 8 months ago. I was frustrated and sad to see that all my nutrition, my exercises were a waste of time! (i felt it that way) And now, i read blogs, saying that both strength training and cardio along with proper nutrition help you loose weight. But how is it that strength training helps you loose weight when isn't that what bodybuilders use to GAIN MUSCLE? sorry im just new to this strength training dilemmas. Since i stopped breastfeeding (work reasons) my calorie intake are now at the 1600-1700 so now i do 30 min of cardio, plus 15 min of intervals(3 days a week) so i have completely eliminated my strength training. My question is.....how can i loose weight with strength training without getting bulky?
0
Replies
-
The training doesn't make them gain mass. The large amount of food they eat does.0
-
You may be the same weight but measure and take pictures, strength training has helped me lose inches and sizes even when pounds weren't falling off like I wanted. Keep it up and it will happen! I plateaued as soon as I eased off strength training and now I'm back to it and am dropping weight/size again.0
-
actually yes, my husband says i look "slimmer" but when i go to the doc, "oh...you gotta loose weight" I told him, well how do i loose it, he just gives me the same feedback, just do 30min cardio and some strength training" but id really would like to see that scale nudge at least 10lbs hahaha...I know they say not to rely on a weight scale but a lil feedback wont hurt me lol. Oh and many people are actually suggesting me to skip strength training...to not even consider lifting weights or it will get me bulky or not loose weight.0
-
(First, sorry if this sound's kind of weird and rambling... it's late and I'm about falling asleep, lol.)
I wouldn't necessarily be too cautious about strength training. Unless you are taking supplements and doing higher weight/lower reps, you in all likely-hood aren't going to "bulk up" but rather gain lean muscle which will actually work to increase your metabolism because muscle basically requires more calories to function. Look at pictures of "cross-fit" women and even though they train pretty hard, they are typically not what most people would think are "bulky" in terms of muscle.0 -
actually yes, my husband says i look "slimmer" but when i go to the doc, "oh...you gotta loose weight" I told him, well how do i loose it, he just gives me the same feedback, just do 30min cardio and some strength training" but id really would like to see that scale nudge at least 10lbs hahaha...I know they say not to rely on a weight scale but a lil feedback wont hurt me lol. Oh and many people are actually suggesting me to skip strength training...to not even consider lifting weights or it will get me bulky or not loose weight.
And no offense to your doc, but "30 minutes of cardio and some strength training", while good advise is somewhat old-school thinking. As far as exercising a trainer would likely give you better advise. If your hubby says you look slimmer, you're doing great! Don't put too much stock in the scale. The fit of your clothes, photos taken every couple of weeks/month let you see how you are actually progressing. If you weigh yourself every day it can get very frustrating as you see little fluctuations in either direction, or no progress at all. LOL ok G'nite0 -
I do 50/50 strength and cardio. And it was the only time I finally lost weight. First of all, you are raising your heart rate and burning fat even when you are working with weights......it's just NOT strength. Second, you want to melt off the fat and have something good some tone under there, right? You're not going to get bulky unless you are weight training for hours a day. For moms like us, adding weights in can be helpful.
Also, for what it's worth, my personal opinion is that the "oh you only need to work out 30 minutes a day" mantra is kind of deceptive. If you want to see results, it's not really as easy as going for a 30 minute walk a few times a week, you know? Cutting calories and increasing output is how it works.0 -
to Diveryanfitne-- Well now that you mention, my clothes(especially my pants) do feel a more snug that before. What does amaze me is that the doctors scale hasnt budge in over 8 months. could this be due to the calorie intake while breastfeeding? The thing is i want to get into shape by my sons 1st birthday in july and i dont expect a miracle to happen overnight but i do want some results haha..would the calorie intake that im eating now, 1500-1600 healthy of course, plus lets say 3 days weight training alternating with 3 days of cardio intervals would finally help me loose those mama lbs?0
-
You weigh the same because you are taking in about the same amount of calories you put out. Your body burns more calories when breastfeeding, but the math is still the same...........calories in needs to be less than calories out in order to lose weight.0
-
IveLanded
You weigh the same because you are taking in about the same amount of calories you put out. Your body burns more calories when breastfeeding, but the math is still the same...........calories in needs to be less than calories out in order to lose weight.
Wow that really cleared out ALOT of what i had in my mind. Most people would tell me that since breastfeeding burns calories, or that the fat just melted off, well i guess i waited 8 months to melt off and so far nothing lol. So now that ive stopped breastfeeding (due to work my calories are now set back to my normal self, with weight lifting plus some cardio, would that aid in my weight loss (finally lol)0 -
the past is the past, so i wouldnt think about how many calories you were eating while you were breastfeeding. start thinking in the now, i cant see your food diary to give suggestions, perhaps you could change it to public. what are your goal settings at? ie is it the recommended loose 1lb per week? also how many calories are you eating compared with target? it is important to eat most of your calories and exercise calories if you can. check out your bmr (which is the amount of calories you use per day with staying in bed all day). you need to be eating at least this much otherwise u'll go into starvation mode. as for exercise i would combine cardio with strength, this combined with a good diet you should loose. what cardio are you doing now and at what intensity?0
-
Well, right now i eat as much healthy as i can, only upgrapding it now to 1500 and sometimes i get to eat more when i excersice more..sometimes upto 1800. I just found out that my BMR is 1484. So i eat more than that to stay off the starvation mode. And i checked out my target goal is the recommended to loose 1lb per week. The cardio that i do now is take a 30min brisk walk or dance (depending on the outside weather) and my cardio intervals of either squats, jumping jacks, etc.. for about 15-20min0
-
thats great that you are eating healthy. i see you have been a member since december and no weightloss yet tracked. i would suggest upping your calories, you could change ur settings to loose 1/2lb per week which may give you an extra 200-300cals. by doing so it is providing your body with more fuel for your daily activities. remember that 1484 is how many cals you would burn if you lay in bed all day obviously you are running around after a little one so it is important to have enough nutrician to do so.
also for exercise try and mix it up. go that little bit further on your walk, perhaps even try jog a little. remember to give yourself rest days. hope this helps0 -
Strength training is important to gain muscle and increase your body's energy expenditure. Burning more energy even when you are at rest. Definitely helps weight loss and tones your body, giving you a better shape. Women don't bulk up easily because of low levels of testosterone.0
-
actually yes, my husband says i look "slimmer" but when i go to the doc, "oh...you gotta loose weight" I told him, well how do i loose it, he just gives me the same feedback, just do 30min cardio and some strength training" but id really would like to see that scale nudge at least 10lbs hahaha...I know they say not to rely on a weight scale but a lil feedback wont hurt me lol. Oh and many people are actually suggesting me to skip strength training...to not even consider lifting weights or it will get me bulky or not loose weight.
And no offense to your doc, but "30 minutes of cardio and some strength training", while good advise is somewhat old-school thinking. As far as exercising a trainer would likely give you better advise. If your hubby says you look slimmer, you're doing great! Don't put too much stock in the scale. The fit of your clothes, photos taken every couple of weeks/month let you see how you are actually progressing. If you weigh yourself every day it can get very frustrating as you see little fluctuations in either direction, or no progress at all. LOL ok G'nite
I dont really weigh my self often but id would like to see some lbs dropped once in a while lol. I started lifting weights like 4 months ago and nothing...I would wonder if changed my caloric intake (im not bfding anymore) would that and my 3 day training and my 3 day cardio interval-alternating- be enough to see my weight drop now?0 -
thats great that you are eating healthy. i see you have been a member since december and no weightloss yet tracked. i would suggest upping your calories, you could change ur settings to loose 1/2lb per week which may give you an extra 200-300cals. by doing so it is providing your body with more fuel for your daily activities. remember that 1484 is how many cals you would burn if you lay in bed all day obviously you are running around after a little one so it is important to have enough nutrician to do so.
also for exercise try and mix it up. go that little bit further on your walk, perhaps even try jog a little. remember to give yourself rest days. hope this helps
Well thats how it automatically gave me a number to keep my nutrition on at 1500(but more if i excersice more). Yeah, i guess im one of those types that dont loose the weight while bf(being my first child)0 -
I know you aren't breastfeeding now, but in case you have another baby or someone else who is reading this can benefit, here is my take...
You do burn more calories when you are breastfeeding but it doesn't mean you can just eat whatever you want. The weight "melts off" in the sense that if you are eating less calories than you use, you will lose weight. Same as when you aren't breastfeeding. If you were basing your caloric intake on 2000 calories plus 400-500 for breastfeeding then you were most likely eating too much (without knowing more about factors that would affect your BMR like weight, etc). I would guess that the 2000 calories a day would be what is recommended to maintain weight and then add on the breastfeeding calories.
What I have read is that when breastfeeding you should not under around 1800 calories. MFP has me set at 1200 calories as my daily goal, but I add 500 for breastfeeding. If I am still hungry I will eat a bit more, but many days I am not at 1700 and am not hungry with that. I feel like I am eating healthy and not starving myself, so I am not concerned about not meeting 1800 all the time, but will be aware of what my body is telling me.
That being said, you need to figure out what your BMR is. There are sites that can give you that info and how to adjust for weight loss. MFP was pretty accurate for me compared to what I found on other sites so you could always stick with the number they give you for daily calorie goals and go from there. Just remember that breastfeeding or not, in order to lose weight you need to have a calorie deficit, which means that you are taking in less than you are burning.
I'm still in the process of figuring out what my ideal workout should look like, but I do know that lifting weights helps to build muscle and therefore helps to increase your metabolism. You can do some circuit training that mixes cardio with strength training and those are really good workouts (30 day shred, to name one).
I would be cautious about eating your exercise calories. IMO, MFP gives higher numbers than what is correct so you could do yourself a disservice by eating 500 extra calories if you are actually only burning 200. Unless you are doing very strenuous, long workouts, I would try eating at the level that MFP gives you for a few weeks then adjust according to your activity level.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions