How does one exercise a broken body?
OliveJuice1984
Posts: 45
My junior year of high school (11 years ago) my knees started cracking when I would go upstairs. It became enough of a problem that I had it checked out. My doctor was pretty shocked by what he saw and long story short I had to have knee surgery. I've had one done but it didn't help the pain so I never got the other knee done. ( I should mention that the cause of this is my very wide hip structure and not due to an injury.)
I know that my weight has a lot to do with the pain in my knees whenever I exercise but that's only half the problem. The other half is that my knee caps aren't aligned correctly and because of this I have damaged cartilage and my knee caps grinde against bone. When people hear my knees pop they cringe. I seriously sound like someone is popping bubble wrap.
To make matters worse last year I was diagnosed with Ulnar Tunnel Syndrome that makes some of the simplest tasks painful and if I do too much I can't even carry a gallon of milk.
So my question to you is, how do I work out? I know I can use an elliptical for low impact cardio but the thought of squats, jumping jacks, weights where my knees or wrists must be used actually scares me. I understand that pain is gain but this kind of pain isn't the right kind of pain. Does anyone have any suggestions? Much appreciated!
I know that my weight has a lot to do with the pain in my knees whenever I exercise but that's only half the problem. The other half is that my knee caps aren't aligned correctly and because of this I have damaged cartilage and my knee caps grinde against bone. When people hear my knees pop they cringe. I seriously sound like someone is popping bubble wrap.
To make matters worse last year I was diagnosed with Ulnar Tunnel Syndrome that makes some of the simplest tasks painful and if I do too much I can't even carry a gallon of milk.
So my question to you is, how do I work out? I know I can use an elliptical for low impact cardio but the thought of squats, jumping jacks, weights where my knees or wrists must be used actually scares me. I understand that pain is gain but this kind of pain isn't the right kind of pain. Does anyone have any suggestions? Much appreciated!
0
Replies
-
I wouldn't put the cart before the horse. You think your weight plays a part (however large or small it may be) in some of your issues. I would say that, like you said, elliptical would be a good choice. Let's worry about getting exercise in (and elliptical is very good!) before we worry about doing squats, etc. Take one thing at a time.0
-
Are you able to swim without much pain? Another option is adjusting your diet so you can shed some pounds before worrying about cardio and such.0
-
Are you able to swim?0
-
Swimming/Aqua fit classes....i have a trillion injuries right now and that seems to do well with me.
I also bought a few of Leslie Sansone's 'walk at home' videos. They're great low impact. You can do them with or without weights.0 -
Ouch! I'm sorry you're having those problems. How about biking? The elliptical is lower impact than running, but it's still weight bearing, and biking might be easier on your knees.0
-
Swimming is virtually non-impact but can be pretty high cardio so if you have access to a pool that might work well for you. Only thing that might be an issue for you would be the action of your knees as you kick but it might not be a problem given that your weight is supported by the water?0
-
Excellent suggests so far. I would also suggest you talk to a physical therapist. They can lead you in the right direction.0
-
Leslie Sansone's 'walk at home' videos <---- this!0
-
Swimming is a great option. Elliptical machine, boxing for cardio to get your heart rate up. Simulated jumping jacks from a seated position to get your heart rate up. Stationary bike which is low weight bearing. Diet is 80% of it in my opinion, so start there & as you lose the exercise may get easier. Good luck! You can do this!0
-
Walk.. do some kempo punching and sit ups and leg lifts using a ball to support your back.. don't forget simple pilates moves that don't include high intensity on your knees.. I have tailbone issues and knee ones and I started with that and was able to work up too jogging.. Do you take joint supplements regularly?0
-
Swimming, and also water walking classes. My Mom's physical therapist had her doing water walking / water aerobics after knee surgery.0
-
i was also going to suggest swimming or some other water based exercise program, so since that's already been said .... i would also suggest going to your doctor and seeing if you can't get a referral to a really good physical therapist who might be able to help you strengthen your body without causing injury or pain for you.
good luck!0 -
Stationary bike.
After my knee surgery it was all I was allowed at first.
Then they had me on some sorta of leg press where I gradually built up to my body weight.
Then it was lots of squats and lunges and balancey stuff. By building up the muscles around your knee, the pain will actually reduce.
Took me six months of hard work post-op to be allowed to do things like run and skip rope & jump.
Take your time and do it right. I recommend seeing a professional to give you a plan.0 -
A Physiotherapist if available would be able to help you figure out how to strenthen the muscles around your injuries - helps with the pain as well:) As well, they may be able to help you figure out the best exercises for your specific injuries.0
-
Both my knees are bone on bone from arthritis and previous injuries. I have a Gazelle. It doesn't work you out hard but it gets my HR up and is ok on the knees. People on MFP make fun of it but they are usually young very fit people that can handle the Insanity and such. I also use Wii Fit games. I've lost almost 30 lbs and it has really helped my knees. Good luck. When it comes to injuries pain is NOT gain.0
-
See a Sports Medicince doctor. They know a lot about what sports out stress on what parts of the body.
They will be able to look at your injury(s) and tell you what can help or hurt.0 -
Do what you can and get the weight off. Remember losing weight is about diet not exercise. Also, it would be advisable to see a sports medicine doctor, things change a lot in that field over the years, and a good physiotherapist who has your current medical work-up. This is not something that I would want to suggest things on lest it causes additional harm.0
-
how about yoga? you can build a little strength while being nice to your body. even i can do it and i have arthritis in my both of my ankles (not to mention lots of hardware) good luck0
-
I don't have easy access to a swimming pool so that's not really an option and I don't take joint supplements though I have thought about it. But the rest are great suggestions! I'm going to look for that "walk at home" thing for sure.
Thank you for those that mentioned just losing some weight first with healthy eating. I'm doing that right now but felt like I HAD to work out else I wasn't doing it right. I did have a goal that by the end of May that I would start working out regardless of how much weight I lost and I am getting a little more active though that seems to be the hardest part for me so far. I'm just happy at this point that the changes I've made to my eating habits have been great and I've actually enjoyed it.
I hadn't really thought of going to see a physical therapist and would have to check with my health insurance but that's not a bad idea at all!
Thanks again!0 -
Carefully! I agree that some pain is not a good thing and not just to be worked through. It is meant to be a warning! This is tricky but I think you have a handle on it already: if being heavy is tough on your joints, then go for the elliptical and swimming until you are lighter. There is no rule that says you must do squats/ jumping jacks etc. right from the start. I'm trying this myself (have hyperflexible joints and began my weight loss journey with much pain and the despairing feeling that things would only get worse) The weight lost so far has made a huge difference to pain levels. It isn't difficult to stay motivated to exercise when it becomes pain relief! I'm starting to look at doing different things -and have no problem with endurance/stamina as I like to 'fight'... but will be very cautious until I'm sure my frame can take it.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions