Am I in for a rude awakening? *Running*
lml1042
Posts: 121
I'm a fairly new runner, started in later November of last year. I couldn't run 1/4 mile then and now I'm up to about 5.5 miles per day (my long run days). I'm currently training for a 10k in May. I have only run on the treadmill so far.I do plan to run outdoors when it warms up a bit, but every time I try it's either pouring or we're having strong winds. Anyway, everyone keeps telling me that running outdoors is so much harder and I'm getting a little nervous. I run at 5.7-6.0 mph at a 2% incline on the treadmill right now, I try to mimic outdoor running with the incline. I've heard so many different things about running outside vs. running on a treadmill but I don't know what to believe. I've heard that a 1.5 incline mimics outside, I heard that my speed with significantly decrease when I start running outside, I've heard that for every 4 miles I run on the treadmill, I'm really only running 2 outside. I'm just confused!
What can I expect? Is it really that much harder?
What can I expect? Is it really that much harder?
0
Replies
-
It's a little different but not really any harder. Since you are using a 2% incline on the treadmill you'll be fine when you move outside.0
-
I actually find running outside easier b/c I don't get bored..I can go farther without wondering when I can stop. I am slow as crap, so IDK about the speed difference for 'normal' people, but I find that I'm pretty consistent wherever I run.
I would suggest running outside in the wind/rain sometimes just so you know how it feels b/c you never know what will happen on race day. If you know the race course elevation, you can try to mimic it with the incline on the treadmill just to make sure you know what hills do for you endurance/speed wise. My May race has one super huge hill so I make sure I crank up the treadmill incline occasionally so that I'm not completely dead after the race's hill.
overall, I think you'll be fine if you're at 5.5 now & your 10k isnt until may. have fun!0 -
I don't think anything on the treadmill really mimics outside. I run different outside - much more free and faster. I like running outside and prefer it. I wouldn't say it's harder - it's different. It's harder for me on the treadmill because for me it's such a bore unless something really interesting to me is on TV which is extremely rare. My music helps, but still a yawn, love being outside. Try it!0
-
It will take you a while to adjust but you'll be fine in a few weeks. Although once I got used to running outside I find the treadmill next to impossible. I hate it. Now I run outside no matter how cold it is.0
-
I agree with everything that everyone has said. I don't run much on the TM, but I can't say that it seems harder or easier - just different, like another person said. Also (like another person talked about), unless your 10k course is super flat, you'll want to get used to some uphills and downhills, which aren't a big deal, but just something you'll want to try out some before the race so you'll know what to expect.
It might also be helpful to run outside in different weather conditions because you never know what race day will bring. In a way, you can think of it as part of the training - training yourself to figure out how to run in different conditions (what clothes you'll wear in different temps, how you'll deal with winds, sun, rain, or whatever).
Have fun and have a great race!0 -
Just from personal experience, I find maintaining pace outdoors a lot harder than the treadmill. The motorized treadmill is forcing me to move, outdoors its all me.0
-
Agree with the masses here. I hate the treadmill and really never use it. I will run outside as long as it is above freezing. I get bored to death on the treadmill and it hurts my knees more as well.
If you can run 5.5 miles, you can run 6.2 in your sleep. Don't sweat it.0 -
They are just scaring you for no reason. I do find it easier on the treadmill, however my neighborhood has 103ft elevation change from one end to the other. Where ever they are hosing your 10k will be predominately flat with no hills. You're already miles ahead of me when it comes to how far you can run in one sitting, just keep up your good work, you'll do absolutely fine.0
-
Agree with the above, I trained for a marathon last year and did a lot of my mid-week 'shorter' runs on the treadmill just to make sure I had time to get into work, but then did my longer runs outside at the weekend.
I found myself doing more and more of my mid-week runs outside as I was getting bored inside after I discovered the fun of getting soaked and freezing but still having a massive grin on my face!
I'd say it would be worth trying some outside running as part of your training as the treadmill is a little more cushioned/stable so when I first ran outside I did notice the adjustments your ankles make when you land can take a bit of getting used to (I had an ankle niggle anyway so just made it flare up to start with, soon settled).
Well worth being prepared for race day so you don't get any surprises. Good luck with the training!0 -
I'm with everyone else. Running outside is definitely a change from running exclusively on the TM. Make sure you get in a good amount of time pounding some pavement.
The incline thing is kind of controversial. Some say it replicates outdoor running, some say it's just a myth. Either way, it isn't as good as running outside (or as fun). If your race is on pavement, run on the pavement when you can. But i'd start with 3ish miles and see how it goes before you tackle 5.
Plus, running outside in the rain/wind/cold makes you feel ridiculously Bad A**!0 -
The best way to ease your mind is to just go outside and run. Their is no guarantee that on race day the weather conditions will be a perfect 60 degrees and sunny.0
-
It's different for sure, but for me it's much easier to run outside. I find myself "fighting" the treadmill trying to find the right speed. I naturally speed up and slow down during my runs and of course this is much easier to do when you are not being guided by a moving belt. I'm just trying to build my way up to running longer distances but I can go much further outside. For me it's easier to have visual cues or goals than time goals on the treadmill. AND race day is even more different...the adrenaline takes over and somehow you can run more/faster than you ever did in training. You'll be fine!0
-
i could have written your post a year ago.
i finally got the courage to run outside....and I've never looked back. physically it seems the same to me but mentally it is SO SO SO much easier. No boredom!
fear not....you will love it!0 -
I think that MENTALLY it is harder to run on a treadmill. I ran on a treadmill for about 3 months before I ventured outdoors. I will NEVER step foot on a treadmill again. I just can't anymore. It's so much more inviting to run outdoors, see the sights, hear the sounds, feel the breeze and feel like you're actually MOVING somewhere. I wouldn't say it's "harder" with the inclines and the winds etc. The experience itself makes up for anything that might be slightly more difficult than running on a treadmill.0
-
I'm weird but I love my treadmill! I live in a very HOT, HUMID, RAINY area and sometimes my only free time to run is in the middle of the day or in the middle of the storm... so if I didn't have this thing there are many days when I probably wouldn't train!
I think since you are setting the incline you will be fine. I trained for my last half-marathon probably 60% of the time on my treadmill due to weather -- it rained for about two months solid during my training cycle! -- and I finished the race pretty much exactly as I expected.
Like many said, the excitement and adrenaline of race conditions will carry you through the whole thing, possibly faster than you imagined
I live at sea level, though, lol, so if you live at a high elevation YMMV.0 -
I don't know what to believe.
Start running outside and find out for yourself. There's no rule that says race day weather will be perfect. It might be windy and rainy that day too.0 -
Just from personal experience, I find maintaining pace outdoors a lot harder than the treadmill. The motorized treadmill is forcing me to move, outdoors its all me.
This is true, but so is the opposite. Based on terrian your outside pace will not stay a constant X.0 miles per hour, a little slower for an uphill, a little faster for a downhill and you can make those minute adjustments outside. Sometimes being forced into a constant pace may be a bad thing.
I run on the treadmill because I HAVE to. I dont like it, I find it harder than outside, but I can run faster on the treadmill than outside, but I sweat more on the treadmill and feel miserable when i finish.0 -
I'm not very fast nor am I a great (good) runner but here's how it works for me. Due to weather and timing I spend most of my time in teh gym (I won't run outdoors in the dark or extreme weather), I've been running four miles with mixed terrain once a week out doors and I seem to overall go faster outside. When I am on the treadmill I do 1-2 interval walk 4.0 and am working my running up to 5.7 (at this time). I actually think this is helping me run better outdoors. I've been doing actual (outdoor, at a highschool stadium) stairs every other week since Jan. I really want to run at 8 mph outdoors, and I'd like to be able to do a half marathon by the end of the year at that pace (possible, I don't know). I know if I don't have my music on I am super, super slow, I need distraction.
Last year when I started running I remember running to school to pick up my girls and another mom comes up to me and says, 'Hey, I saw you walking to school today. (and she was actually trying to be encouraging)" I was pretty sad because I thought I was working my but off and I was sweaty, and red-faced to boot. lol0 -
I think running outside is easier than running on the treadmill. Often when I need to work on speed I'll go to the tread mill and when I want to run longer distances I'll go outside. It's way less boring outside. They both have their place though.0
-
You should also run outside to practice having adults/children/pets in your way. On race day, it's hard to run in a straight line as you'll be passing people and people could be stopping in front of you. You could sign up for a 5k just to get used to the feeling.0
-
Outdoor running is typically a bit slower on pace but not always. Its different. But in my opinion, running outdoors is way better. I find it more enjoyable, I can push myself more, I don't get bored, its way less repetitious. I feel like its a better workout outdoors and you don't have the treadmill belt and friction working against you. I run on the treadmill, but I despise it. haha0
-
It's different. Your body will feel outdoor runs a little bit more. It's a little harder on your body, but you are doing a good job simulated it with the incline.0
-
Thanks everyone! My 10k is on a boardwalk, so it's flat. I'm hoping to get out this weekend and try running the boardwalk. Hoping to break the treadmill habit, but with 2 kids and a husband who works long hours, I struggle to find the time to get outside. I don't have a double jogging stroller so I can't take the kiddos with me unfortunately. Going to do my best though...no excuses.0
-
I live in Michigan and I am currently training for a May 10K. With that being said, I tend to train during the winter (snowy/icy) months on a treadmill and squeeze in outdoor runs whenever the weather permits. I run on a treadmill anywhere from a 1% to 2% incline. I don't see much of a difference between running on a treadmill vs. outdoors, physically. However, mentally, outdoors is SO much better. I love my outdoors runs during the winter months (probably because they are so scarce). Good luck on your race!0
-
I find that I can run at a faster pace on the treadmill but I far prefer to run outdoors. And best of all is trail running! And as for weather, that is one of the joys of running outdoors. I love running in the cooler temps and running in light rain is fine, though I avoid thunderstorms for safety purposes. As many have said, get out and try it, you'll probably love it and avoid the dreadmill from now on.0
-
I agree that it's not particularly different in terms of effort. My wife runs like a metronome...her pace never varies outside. Me...I'm up and down in pace according to how I'm feeling, terrain, etc. I find on the treadmill that the constant pace is a bother because it doesn't allow me to vary. As well, although my tm has a fan, I struggle with heat. Outside at this time of year, it's way better for me. I like running in the rain for this reason. Good luck on the 10k!0
-
umm. i run 40 miles a week, and I've been running for over 5 years.
I will tell you that the difference is not that big. For me personally I can run the exact same, if not better outside.
I know people who can run 7 on the treadmill, but they can barely break 11 min mile running outside (for a long distance)
I started on the tredmill, and I moved to outside. At the point when I moved to outside running I could run 6 miles easily under an hour on the tredmill, but I couldn't run without stopping outside for over 3 miles.... However, it only took me a month to get used to the outdoor conditions.
Once I stayed outside, I was able to improve WAY more than I ever could on the treadmill. I can now run 6 miles in under 45:30 outside! (it was only 10 months ago when I was running 6 miles in an hour on the treadmill).
JUST GET OUTSIDEEE!
but, the treadmill isn't that bad. But the hills will kill you, i promise you!0 -
It will take you a while to adjust but you'll be fine in a few weeks. Although once I got used to running outside I find the treadmill next to impossible. I hate it. Now I run outside no matter how cold it is.
^ This, and this:Plus, running outside in the rain/wind/cold makes you feel ridiculously Bad A**!0 -
all im going to say, is get out and get running, iv been running now for 7 months, all outside. When i started to get cold i tried out the treadmill and didnt like it, so iv stuck through Sub freezing temperatures, snow, blizzards, rain, wind and a little bit of sun lol It makes running interesting and gives it that extra dimention to treadmill running, not to mention the sceanary changes, and the thing you get to see when your out and about, and being chased by little dogs down the road (dont get that on the treadmill LOL)
Is it harder? no idea, but i know for me, getting outdoors and running is more than just exercise, its an experience0 -
I went through the same thing last year, training for a 5K. I started on the treadmill and was really freaking out about going outside. At first I found it practically impossible outside until I got fitted for new shoes and realized I was wearing a half size too big. The shoes made all the difference.
I would much rather run outside, it's much more interesting and since it's a bit chilly out most days I recover faster than on the treadmill. But remember to pick up your feet! I tripped over the sidewalk yesterday and went down on my knees and one hand, scraped and bruised up my knees. It was on a very busy street at lunch time so I was a bit embarrassed too. $h!t happens, I got up and kept running, but I was glad I had sunglasses on so I could believe nobody saw me... lol
ETA: one of my most fun outdoor runs was last summer in the pouring rain, it was awesome, I felt invincible and incredibly athletic.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions