Wheatabix ...doesnt fill me up!
ravihira1892
Posts: 149 Member
Ok so in the mornings i typically have
2 sticks of Wheatabix
200ml skimmed milk
25g whey protein
15ml Aloe Vera juice
Spirulina tablets
Multi-vitamin tablet
1000mg omega 3 tablet
Now this all comes to 324 kcals, 4g fat, 39g carbs & 33g protein.
I eat my breakfast around 7.30am and by 10:30am my stomach is just rumbling so much, why is this?? I end up having to eat a banana or some almonds or just something! Shouldn't my meal last me till atleast lunch time? Am i burning it off that quickly? someone kindly explain!
2 sticks of Wheatabix
200ml skimmed milk
25g whey protein
15ml Aloe Vera juice
Spirulina tablets
Multi-vitamin tablet
1000mg omega 3 tablet
Now this all comes to 324 kcals, 4g fat, 39g carbs & 33g protein.
I eat my breakfast around 7.30am and by 10:30am my stomach is just rumbling so much, why is this?? I end up having to eat a banana or some almonds or just something! Shouldn't my meal last me till atleast lunch time? Am i burning it off that quickly? someone kindly explain!
0
Replies
-
Lots of people find that cereal doesn't fill them up for very long. Try adding some protein from real sources into your breakfast - yoghurt, eggs, cheese, lean meats.0
-
I'm always hungry mid-morning so I eat mid-morning. Simple!0
-
cereal never fills me up!
They claim they do. But I think it usually fills you up until your mid morning snack!!
Eggs and soldiers always fill me till dinner time0 -
I find I am the same with cereal sometimes. Well I used to have Coco Pops, but I tried Ready Brek today for the first time with Sweetener and a banana sliced. The banana was quite high in sugar and I had to start using the Semi-Skimmed Milk until it's gone then I can go back to Skimmed Milk. Overall it was 315 calories, 61g carbs, 28g sugar, 5g fiber, 14g protein, and 9g of fat.
I actually don't feel too hungry, I felt a little empty about half an hour ago, but I had some water just in case. Will probably have a few snack a jacks to tide me over till lunch.
Anyway, when I did have Coco Pops for breakfast, I would usually have a Banana and even that didn't fill me up at all. I was craving anything pretty bad.
If I have an Omelette with Baked Beans (Reduced Sugar and Salt) I feel fuller for a lot longer and don't usually go mad on snacks in between breakfast and lunch. Will usually grab a homemade banana oatmeal cookie.
I've been trying to find a few ways to reduce my carb and sugar intake lately and I had a look at my breakfast this morning and I am going to get rid of the banana and replace it with some berries (raspberries, blueberries, blackberries, etc). I had a look at them and they are way lower in carbs and sugar. After I have used the Semi Skimmed Milk I will go back to Skimmed Milk and that will help reduce my sugar intake.
I think the best thing to have I would say is have eggs if you are having an early breakfast, I would consider 7:30am quite early for breakfast, especially if you are going to wait till 12pm or 1pm for lunch. That's almost 5 hours till lunch. So try an omelette or something that looks like it will fill you up because when you look at cereal it really doesn't look like it will fill you up for the amount that's in the bowl. My omelette's usually fill half of the plate then I have a quarter of the tin of baked beans so my plate is pretty much full and it's really low in calories, carbs and sugar, but high in protein and fiber.
For later breakfasts, like say around 9am to 10am have some cereal, some fruit with natural fat free yoghurt. I've never tried the natural yoghurts before, but you could stick some low sugar and low carb fruits in there to mix up the taste I guess. Then a few hours later you have your lunch instead of waiting like 5 hours for it lol.0 -
Guys I use to do Whetabix - useless fly's weight food
Now I eat quaker oats
Trust me 50-100 grams with everything <--- no more hunger0 -
I eat my breakfast around 7.30am and by 10:30am my stomach is just rumbling so much, why is this?? I end up having to eat a banana or some almonds or just something! Shouldn't my meal last me till atleast lunch time? Am i burning it off that quickly? someone kindly explain!
3 hours later i would definately be hungry regardless of what i had for breakfast - Having a banana is great.
I have a mixture of oats, fruits, nuts and soya yogurt then a snack 2- 3 hours later - it's all good as long as it's healthy :happy:0 -
Plus the Whetabix is not very interesting, regarding it's nutritive property.
I think it's interesting for a snack, maybe a pre-wo, or after a cardio session. But if you are a "breakfast" type, I wouldn' count on that in order to start the day. Or that could do it if you eat like the whole container. Try oatmelas0 -
Porridge - its the only way!!
0 -
I have given up on eating cereal, they never fill me up, and I find it’s just empty calories.
My favourite is porridge, I find this fills me up the best.
But regardless, if I ate at 7.30 I would be starving by 10.00.
I eat at 9am and by 10.30 I’m having a snack. You want to eat every 2-4 hours to keep your metabolism going and not end up starving.0 -
Guys I use to do Whetabix - useless fly's weight food
Now I eat quaker oats
Trust me 50-100 grams with everything <--- no more hunger
is that oats with milk or water?
When i was bulking i used to have instant oats, milk, whey protein & mixed berries in my shake but even then i used to be hungry at 10:30 at the latest 11am! I thought when bulking you should eat every 2-3 hours and when loosing weight its not?
P.S how many grams of oats do you use? also what type of milk?0 -
I haven't eaten Weetabix for years, does it still taste like cardboard? LOL
At 300 cal your breakfast may be a little light, you could add some fruit or berries (1/2 cup frozen blueberries is only 40 cal) to fill you up a bit more and maybe a bit more protein or just have a healthy snack if you're hungry mid-morning.0 -
I love my weet bix (not sure if there is a difference to wheatabix). Every morning I have 2 with 1/4 cup of musli on top and half a banana (saving the other half for a snack inbetween meals). The musli is low GI, so it helps a lot. I do need to eat again at 10am, but this is only natural. Your body functions better with more smaller meals throughout the day. I find a cup of grapes at 10 gets me through until I have lunch at 12:30. I also make sure I have drunk 1L of water by midday. If I am still hungry, because I have been a little more active, I always have some nuts on the side to nibble on.
Hope this helps.0 -
I find whatever i eat in a morning i'm still hungry by 10. Be it omellete, weetabix or porridge. Nothing seems to make me last any longer.0
-
I find that after I pile on about 250g of sugar, as required to make Weetabix taste like real food, then I'm so hyper I forget about being hungry.0
-
is that oats with milk or water?
When i was bulking i used to have instant oats, milk, whey protein & mixed berries in my shake but even then i used to be hungry at 10:30 at the latest 11am! I thought when bulking you should eat every 2-3 hours and when loosing weight its not?
P.S how many grams of oats do you use? also what type of milk?
It doesn't matter how often you eat when you're bulking or cutting, as long as your calorie total ends up for the day where you want it.
When I have oats, I always have with milk (semi skimmed) - On a bulk I would try and have ~100g oats, which is VERY filling. On a cut, around 60-70g.0 -
I used to have the same issue with weetabix so no longer eat them anymore. I now have 2 finn crips rye breads, 1 banana and a fruit tea which comes to about 140-145kcals. The other thing I do is to eat my breakfast slightly later than normal, say around 9:30-10; I'm lucky enough to be able to do that in my office without a problem.
It's trying to find that balance isn't it!? Eating bacon, mushrooms, eggs, that sort of thing is great but actually fill me up too much in the morning and I end up skipping lunch.0 -
Why would Weetabix fill anyone up?
Try having bacon and eggs, or a omlette with plenty of veg.
Try and get nutrition instead of empty calorie manufactured junk.0 -
Try adding All-Bran, works for me0
-
i think its normal , your bodys burning and using the energy , id say having a fruit mid morning is the right thing to do to keep your metablolism running as it should do. so dont worry.0
-
No matter what I have for breakfast I'm hungry 3 hours later... Even if I have 600 calories of oats, fruit, eggs and meat. So I eat 3 hours later!0
-
Ok so I in fact I was wrong - whetabix have the same values as quaker oats - I just checked. I was quite convinced oats had more fibers that Whetabix.
Regarding your breakfast - there are things to know :
#1 - If you are not hungry in the morning, skip the breakfast. Have it when you are really hungry
#2 - The feeling of being hunger is controller by an hormon called "Ghrelin". This one adapats to your feeding habits. If you maintain meals at fixed hour, you'll be hunger when the time comes. Good news is, the hormons adapt. If you constantly skip a meal, the first week you'll be hungry, then lately less.
#3- Forget the whole timing, think in tern of total calories : You need (assuming yout goals are good) to eat a certain amount. The timing doesn't matter AT ALL. So if you are hungry in the beginning of the day - never in the end : prepare yourselves cabbage breaksfasts (eat 1000 calories if you want), and just don't eat in the end of the day
#4- Now here is what I call a pretty solid breakfast (I myself don't eat anymore in the morning, I'm on IF)
: 80 grams of Quaker Oats
: 50 grams of SEMI-skimmed milk
: 15 grams or strawberry coulis
: 20 grams of nuts OR 2 tbsp of ground almonds
Next to that :
: 150 grams of 20% greek yogurt
: 10 grams of coca powder
A high-fiber fruit (a nice red apple for instance)
I let you check the total cals - but basically I'd say 650-700 calories (60% carbs, 30% fat, 10% proteins)
#5- Through my endless mistakes I've learned that wanting to track always the lowest caloric food is useless, since in the end of the week you'd end with a bigger exceed
#6- I've purposely included a 20% and not a 0% yogurt. It is more dense and contains more proteins
#7- Try that and let me know how it went
#8- Remember the hormonal response - meaning the first days you'd still be hunger, eaven if you have a royal feast. by forcing yourself the first day, the level of ghrelin should remain low in that time window0 -
Put the savage breakfast in the microwave, during 3 minutes, oatmeals will be hot, it's even more delicious mmmmmmmm
The glycemic index increases when oatmeals are hotter, meaning you could have an bigger insulin response (You would slightly feel it after 2,5 - 3 hours), but it's no biggie at all0 -
I have the same breakfast most every morning. It is not a traditional breakfast, but it can keep me going at least until lunch if not well after.
1 cup full fat cottage cheese
1/2 cup beans (black, kidney, etc. - it does not matter)
Cal: 322 Carbs: 25g Fiber: 8g Fat: 11g Protein: 35g
If you want a traditional breakfast, then this is not for you. I wanted something easy to prepare ahead of time that I could travel with and had over 30g of protein.0 -
I agree Weetabix isnt filling despite its claims.
I always have porridge, made with Soy milk and a tablespoon of Linseed (Flaxseed).
Filling, slow release energy, low cal, and the linseed is full of omega 3 and helps digestion.
Add some berries or banana to mix it up.
Also, I defenitely agree with previous poster- you should eat if you are starving...I usually have breakfast about 7am and then have a piece of fruit or a few nuts at 10.30am ish. Most successful slim people who maintain their weight (rather than yo yo) state that they do it by managing their hunger. They eat small meals every 3-4 hours so they never get so hungry that they over eat- they keep their energy levels stable.
Also....drink lots. If you think the hunger is emotional not physical then when youre hungry wait ten minutes (distract yourself with a chore) and if you still feel hungry then have your snack....just keep it healthy.0 -
I must be odd then... 3 weetabix and 150ml of skimmed milk at 7am. No lunch yet but quite hungry. (its now 12.30).0
-
I agree Weetabix isnt filling despite its claims.
I always have porridge, made with Soy milk and a tablespoon of Linseed (Flaxseed).
Filling, slow release energy, low cal, and the linseed is full of omega 3 and helps digestion.
Add some berries or banana to mix it up.
Also, I defenitely agree with previous poster- you should eat if you are starving...I usually have breakfast about 7am and then have a piece of fruit or a few nuts at 10.30am ish. Most successful slim people who maintain their weight (rather than yo yo) state that they do it by managing their hunger. They eat small meals every 3-4 hours so they never get so hungry that they over eat- they keep their energy levels stable.
Also....drink lots. If you think the hunger is emotional not physical then when youre hungry wait ten minutes (distract yourself with a chore) and if you still feel hungry then have your snack....just keep it healthy.
Wrong :-)
It's the so-called "metabolic fire" that doesn't exist. I tried the whole 6 meals. Now I've two meals, works better, and you don't end up bringing 45 tupperwares at work.
In fact there is also a psycological sphere in that : Eating more meals means smaller ones (eg : Kitten plates), there is a high chance that the proportions leave you with the feeling of having eating nothing (trust me I've been there ahaha), and I was always waiting for the next tiny meal to come --> unavoidable binges
Rather, 2 or 3 meals, or just one, but hell-sized 1- physically fills you 2- brings the satiety0 -
Maybe to each their own but I use the 3-4hours rule and have lost 3 stone and dont feel hungry or cravings.
Its also what I have read in most of the research I have read. I have tried it, found it successful and so shared my findings.
If 2 meals works for you then obviously you should continue with that.
As for tupperware...can't say it bothers me...I just remind myself of my old clothes and the money bringing preprepared food over convenience shopping and that works! :happy:0 -
Guys I use to do Whetabix - useless fly's weight food
Now I eat quaker oats
Trust me 50-100 grams with everything <--- no more hunger
I agree! I use steel cut oats and cook it with frozen fruits and nuts... its got stick to yer ribs goodness!!!0 -
I was reffering to the meals one needs to eat every 3 or 4 hours, to maintain high energy levels (the so-called metabolic fire). This is wrong :drinker:
What is right, it's the fact that it does work for you ;-)0 -
English Muffin with peanutbutter....keeps me nice and full!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions